Kenneth Clark's Civilisation 09_ The Pursuit of Happiness

Honor Art
11 followers
Oct 28, 2024
For over a century, the disorderly aftermath of the Reformation,
followed by the dreary, interminable horrors of the Thirty Years' War,
had kept them from playing a part in the history of civilization.
Then, peace, stability, the natural strength of the land,
and a peculiar social organization,
allowed them to add to the sum of European experience two shining achievements.
One in music, the other in architecture.
Of course, the music is far more important to us.
The writing and painting of the 18th century make one think
that the emotional life had somehow dried up.
Well, of course it hadn't.
It had been transferred to music.
From Bach to Mozart, music expressed
the deepest thoughts and feelings of the time,
just as painting had done in the early 16th century.
This program is primarily about music.
And some of the qualities of 18th century music,
its melodious flow, its complex symmetry,
its decorative invention, are reflected in its architecture.
You know, it's only quite recently that people have noticed
what a brilliant, inventive, and altogether enchanting,
style of architecture flourished for almost 50 years
in 18th century Germany and Austria.
Serious-minded historians used to call it shallow or corrupt.
Well, the founders of the American Constitution,
who were far from frivolous,
thought fit to mention the pursuit of happiness as a proper aim for mankind.
And if ever this aim has been given visible form,
it's in rococo architecture,
the pursuit of happiness and the pursuit of love.
But before we plunge into the buoyant sea of rococo,
I must say a word about the austere ideal that preceded it, classicism.
For 60 years, France had dominated Europe.
And this had meant a rigidly centralized,
authoritarian government and a classic style.
French classicism produced magnificent architecture.
This is the architecture of a great metropolitan culture.
And it is expressive of an ideal.
Not an ideal that appeals to me, but an ideal nonetheless.
Grandeur achieved through the authoritarian state.
I find that this French classical architecture has a certain inhumanity.
It was the work not of craftsmen,
but of wonderfully gifted civil servants.
But because it reflects so clearly a grand comprehensive system,
it is done with superb conviction.
French classicism was eminently not exportable.
But the high baroque of Rome, especially that of Borromini,
was exactly what the north of Europe needed for a variety of reasons.
For one thing, it was elastic and adaptable.
So the architectural language
which northern Europe became articulate in the 18th century
was that of Borromini, the second great master of Italian baroque.
Borromini came from a land of stone carvers,
the Italian lakes that form a boundary with Switzerland.
And his style could fit into the craftsman tradition of the Germanic north,
a tradition serving a social order that was absolutely the reverse
of the centralised bureaucracy of France.
It's true, of course, many of the German princes
thought they would like to imitate Versailles.
But the formative element in German art and German music didn't lie there,
but in the multiplicity of regions and towns and abbeys
all competing for their architects and choirmasters,
but also relying on the talents of their local organists and plasterers.
The creators of the German baroque, the Assams and the Zimmermanns,
were families of craftsmen.
Zimmermanns are German for a carpenter.
The finest buildings we should look at are not palaces,
but local pilgrimage churches deep in the country
like the Pfiatzenheiligen behind me, the Fourteen Saints.
And, come to think of it, the Bachs were a family of local musical craftsmen,
out of which there suddenly emerged
one of the great geniuses of Western Europe, Johann Sebastian.
They had crossed paths in the evening,
they shared their clothes,
and threw their lust for it
into what would be fulfilled,
I said, through the prophets.
They shared my clothes among themselves,
and threw their lust for my clothes.
And the sound of Bach's music reminds me
of a curious fact that people don't always remember
when they talk about the 18th century,
that the great art of the time was religious art.
The thought was anti-religious,
the way of life ostentatiously profane.
We are right to call the first half of the 18th century
the age of reason.
But in the arts, what did this emancipated rationalism produce?
One adorable painter, Watteau,
some nice domestic architecture,
some pretty furniture,
but nothing to set beside the Matthew Passion
or the pilgrimage churches and abbeys of Bavaria and Franconia.
They crossed paths in the evening,
they shared their clothes,
and threw their lust for it
into what would be fulfilled,
I said, through the prophets.
They shared my clothes among themselves,
and threw their lust for my clothes.
and threw their lust for it
into what would be fulfilled,
I said, through the prophets.
There was a musician in Germany
that went back to the Reformation.
Luther had been a fine musician.
He wrote music and sang
with, surprisingly enough,
a sweet tenor voice.
And although the Lutheran reform
prohibited many of the arts
that civilized our impulses,
it encouraged church music.
In small Dutch and German towns,
the choir and the organ
became the only means
through which men could enter
the world of spiritualized emotion.
This organ in the great church at Haarlem
was played on by Handel
and by Mozart
at the age of ten.
When the Calvinists,
in their still more resolute purification
of the Christian right,
prohibited organs
and destroyed them,
they caused more distress
than had ever been caused
by the destruction of images.
Organs have played a variable role
in European civilization.
In the 19th century,
they were symbols of newly won affluence,
like billiard tables.
But in the 17th and 18th centuries,
they were expressions of municipal pride
and independence.
They were the work of the best local craftsmen,
and organists were respected members
of the community.
Bourgeois democracy,
which had provided a background
to Dutch painting in the 17th century,
became partly responsible
for German music.
And it was a society
more earnest and more participating
than the Dutch connoisseurs had been.
This provincial society
was the background of Bach.
His universal genius
rose out of the high plateau
of competitive musical life
in the Protestant cities
of northern Germany.
One can even say that it rose out of a family
that had been professional musicians
for a hundred years,
so that in certain districts,
the very word Bach meant a musician.
And his life was that
of a conscientious,
somewhat obstinate,
provincial organist and choirmaster.
But he was universal.
A great musical critic
said of him,
he is a spectator of all musical time
and existence,
to whom it is not of the smallest importance
whether a thing be new or old,
so long as it is true.
And we once more find
that we can illustrate
Bach's music by contemporary building.
This church behind me,
the pilgrimage church
of the Ferdinand Heiligen,
was built by an architect
who was only two years younger than Bach.
He was called Balthasar Neumann,
and although his name isn't well known
in the English-speaking world,
I think he was certainly
one of the greatest architects
of the 18th century.
Unlike the other builders of German Baroque,
he was not primarily a carver or plasterer,
but an engineer.
He made his name as a master
of town planning and fortifications.
And inside his buildings,
just as when we are listening to Bach,
we are conscious
of a complex plan
worked out like the most
intricate mathematical problem.
And, when occasion demanded it,
he made use of ornaments
as lavish and fanciful
as that of the most
embellished Bavarian plasterer.
The sheer happiness,
the almost childlike joy
of Bach's Christmas Oratorio
is made visible
by all these happy cherubs
and benevolent saints.
Balthasar Neumann was fortunate
in that the painted decorations
of his finest interiors
are not the work of amiable
local ceiling painters,
but of the greatest decorator
of the age, the Venetian
Giambattista Tiepolo.
Here's his masterpiece,
the ceiling of the staircase
in the Bishop's Palace at Würzburg,
known as the Residenz.
And there, in fact,
in the corner,
is Tiepolo's self-portrait,
the man with the yellow scarf,
with his son, Gian Domenico,
also a very good painter,
looking over his shoulder.
Then, as you move along to the middle,
here, this very grand,
military-looking man
is the architect himself,
Balthasar Neumann,
looking at the great master
of fortifications.
The Residenz doesn't seem
quite our idea
of a bishop's residence,
being, in fact, about three times
the size of Buckingham Palace
and incomparably more splendid.
And one can't help speculating
on the tithes and taxes
that the peasants of Franconia
had to pay in order that their
episcopal master should do himself so well.
But one must admit
that many of these rulers
of small German principalities,
dukes, electors, bishops, or whatever,
were, in fact, remarkably cultivated
and intelligent men.
Their competitive ambitions
benefited architecture and music
in a way that the democratic obscurity
of the Hanoverians in England did not.
The Schoenborn family,
one of whom was responsible
for the Residenz at Würzburg,
were really great patrons
whose names should be remembered
with the Medici.
I felt some scruples
in comparing the music of Bach
with the Baroque interiors.
No such hesitations prevent me
from invoking on this splendid staircase
the name of George Frederick Handel.
You know, great men
have a curious way of appearing
in complementary pairs.
This has happened so often in history
that I don't think it can have been invented
by some symmetrically-minded historian,
but must represent some need
to keep human faculties in balance.
However that may be,
there's no doubt
that the two great musicians
of the early 18th century,
Bach and Handel,
fall into this pattern
of contrasting
and complementary personalities.
They were born in the same year, 1685.
They both went blind
from copying musical scores,
and both were operated on
unsuccessfully by the same surgeon.
But otherwise,
they were opposites.
In contrast to Bach's
timeless universality,
Handel was completely of his age.
Instead of Bach's frugal,
industrious career as an organist
with numerous children,
Handel made and lost several fortunes
as an impresario.
This amiable statue of him
was erected by the grateful proprietors
of an amusement park,
Vauxhall, in which his music
had been one of the attractions.
There he sits in unbuttoned mood,
one shoe off and one shoe on,
not caring how much
he snitched other people's music
as long as he produced
something effective.
In his youth, he must have been charming
because when he went to Rome
as an unknown young virtuoso,
he was immediately taken up
by society, and cardinals
wrote libretti for him to set to music.
And there are remains
of remarkable good looks in his head.
Later in life,
when Handel had settled in England
and entered the world of operatic production,
he became less anxious
to please.
In his alleys, traditionally,
this is said to have held
one of his leading ladies out of the window
and threatened to drop her
if she didn't sing in tune.
He remained faithful throughout his life
to the Italian Baroque style.
In consequence, his music
goes well with the decorations of Tiepolo,
which even have the pseudo-romantic
subjects of his operas.
One can look with pleasure
at the marvellous Tiepolo ceiling
on the staircase at Würzburg
with Handel's Music in One's Ears.
The extraordinary thing is
that this composer of flowing,
florid airs and rousing choruses,
when he turned from opera to oratorio,
which was, in fact,
a kind of sacred opera,
wrote great religious music.
Saul, Samson, Israel and Egypt
not only contain wonderful
melodic and polyphonic inventions,
but show an understanding
of the depths of the human spirit.
As for the Messiah,
it's like Michelangelo's
creation of Adam,
one of those rare works
that appeal immediately to everyone.
And yet it is indisputably
a masterpiece of the highest order.
that is my flesh,
see God,
shall I see God?
Yes, however often I hear it,
it brings tears to my eyes.
In passages like that,
Handel is beyond classification.
Still, one may reasonably call him
a Baroque composer.
Now, Baroque first came into being
as religious architecture
and expressed the emotional aspirations
of the Catholic Church.
Rococo was to some extent
a Parisian invention
and provocatively secular.
It was, superficially at any rate,
a reaction against
the heavy classicism of Versailles.
Instead of the static
orders of antiquity,
it drew inspiration from lateral objects
in which the line wandered freely
without symmetry,
shells, flowers, seaweed, vines,
especially if they wandered
in a double curve.
Rococo was a reaction
against the academic style,
but it wasn't negative.
It represented a real gain
in sensibility.
It achieved a new freedom
of association and captured
new and more delicate shades
of feeling.
All this is expressed
through the work of one exquisite artist,
Watteau.
He was born in 1684,
the year before Bach and Handel,
in the Flemish town of Valenciennes,
and he derived his technique
from Rubens.
But instead of a hearty
Flemish acceptance of life,
Watteau, who was a consumptive,
discovered something in himself
that had hardly ever been seen
in art before,
a feeling of the transitoriness
and thus the seriousness
of pleasure.
He had brilliant gifts.
He could draw with the style
and precision of a Renaissance artist,
and he used his skill to record his rapture
at the sight of beautiful girls.
What dreams of beauty they are!
These exquisite people should be.
But in the very temple
of delight veiled melancholy
hath her sovereign shrine
those seen of none,
save him whose strenuous tongue
can burst joy's grape
against his pallid thigh.
No one had a finer pallid than Watteau.
He can taste
every delicate flavour
in this open-air dance
where glances suddenly meet.
And he's depicted himself
not as one of the dancers,
but as the bagpipe player,
animating the scene
with his humble, melancholy instrument.
He was, his friend Caylus said,
tender,
and perhaps something of a shepherd.
And in this elegant company
that he watched so discerningly,
he remained the odd man out.
And Gilles, the simpleton,
whose tall, white figure
rises in isolation
from his fellow comedians,
is a sort of idealised self-portrait.
Tender, simple,
and yet capable of love
and of delicate intuitions.
Watteau came on the scene
at an incredibly early date
in the 18th century.
His masterpiece,
The Departure from Cytheria,
was painted in 1712
when Louis XIV was still alive.
And yet it has the likeness
and sharpness of a Mozart opera,
also the sense of human drama.
The new sensibility
of which Watteau was the prophet
showed itself most of all
in a more delicate understanding
of the relations between men and women.
Sentiment.
The words got into trouble, as words do.
But it was, in its day,
a civilising word.
Sterne, in his
Sentimental Journey,
that somewhat discredited work of Rococo prose,
tells a fable about a town
of Abdera, which was
the vilest town in all Thrace.
What with poisons,
conspiracies and assassinations,
libels, pass grenades and tumults,
there was no going there by day.
It was worse by night.
Till, hearing a play of Euripides,
the people were struck by a speech of Perseus.
O Cupid,
Prince of Gods and Men.
Every man almost spoke
pure iambics next day,
and talked of nothing but Perseus,
his pathetic address.
O Cupid,
Prince of Gods and Men.
Every street of Abdera, in every house,
O Cupid,
Cupid, in every mouth,
like the natural notes of some sweet melody,
which drop from it
whether it will or no.
Nothing but Cupid,
Cupid, Prince of Gods
and Men.
The fire caught, and the whole city,
like the heart of one man,
opened itself to love.
No pharmacologist could sell
one grain of helibor,
not a single armourer had a heart
to forge one instrument of death.
Friendship and virtue met
together and kissed each other in the street.
The golden age
returned, and hung over
the town of Abdera.
Next to love,
Watteau cared most about music,
of which, his friends tell us,
he had a most delicate ear.
Nearly all his scenes
are enacted to the sound of music.
In this, he shows himself
as part of a tradition going back
to the Venetians, of whom Pater said
that they painted the musical
intervals of our existence
when life itself is conceived
as a kind of listening.
Here at Watteau,
we are in the world of poetry,
not only on account of the grace
of the figures,
but because the facts have been
translated into the most
exquisite paint.
Watteau's colour has a
shimmering, iridescent quality
which makes one think immediately
of musical analogies.
Watteau died in 1721,
the same age as Raphael,
and by that date,
the Rococo style was just beginning
to affect decoration and architecture.
Ten years later,
it had spread all over Europe,
producing a style as international
as the early 15th-century Gothic.
Rococo even spread to England,
although the native good sense
of a fox-hunting society
prevented its more extravagant flights.
I suppose that most of the plaster work,
like most of the opera singing,
was done by foreigners.
But a group of English craftsmen
designed and executed the decorations
in this music room
from Norfolk House,
which is only a little less elegant
than its Parisian counterpart.
It's extraordinary how a true
international style controls
the shape of everything.
It's an absolute compulsion
which overrides convenience
or what we used to call functionalism.
It makes everything dance to the same tune.
aspired to the condition of music.
I don't suppose he thought
of extending this famous dictum
to applied art,
but it is true of the finest Rococo design.
The rhythms, the assonances, the texture
have the effect of music
and are echoed in the music
of the next 50 years.
Is that Haydn or Mozart?
Well, I happen to know that it's Haydn.
One can't always be sure.
And yet, the two great musicians
of the second half of the 18th century
were very different characters,
and the difference comes through in their music.
Haydn, who was 20 years older than Mozart,
was born in Croatia,
the son of a wheelwright,
and was fundamentally a peaceful,
spacious, soil-conscious man.
He said that he wrote his music
in order that the weary and worn
or the men burdened with affairs
might enjoy a few minutes
of solace and refreshment.
And I think of this saying
as I approach
the Bavarian pilgrimage church of Avice.
It belongs to the countryside.
In fact, from a distance,
it might almost be
the hall of a rustic manor.
But enter it,
and the most incredible richness
appears before your eyes.
In these Rococo churches,
the faithful are persuaded
not by fear, but by joy.
They're a foretaste of paradise.
Sometimes, I admit,
rather more like the Mohammedan paradise
of the senses
than the disembodied paradise
of Christianity.
Oh, Cupid, Cupid,
prince of gods and men.
Well, it's always been difficult,
even for the saints,
to represent spiritual love
without having recourse
to the symbols of physical love.
Creation is the most mysterious
of all God's acts.
And it is Haydn's creation
that comes to my mind
as I contemplate
the rustic delights
of the brothers Zimmermann.
we should have made such a cult
of Rococo music
when the Rococo style as a whole
runs so strongly counter
to our convictions.
You see, many of the most
beautiful Rococo buildings
of the 18th century
were built simply to give pleasure
by people who believed
that pleasure was important
and worth taking trouble about
and could be given
some of the quality of art.
And we managed to destroy
a good many of them during the war,
including the Palace of Sanssouci
at Potsdam and the Zwinger at Dresden.
As I've said,
it may be difficult to define civilization,
but it isn't so difficult
to recognize barbarism.
But by chance,
we didn't hit the pleasure pavilions
at Nymphenburg,
which is a suburb of Munich.
Munich itself we pretty well laid flat.
They were built
for the elector Max Immanuel
by his court dwarf named Cuvillier,
who happened to be
an architectural genius.
Despite his French name,
he came from Flanders.
This behind me is the most famous
of them, I suppose,
the Immanuelburg.
The exterior is quite simple.
The interior, a riot,
or rather a ballet
of beautifully designed ornament.
These rooms are the ultimate
in rococo decoration.
And one might say
that they bridge the gap
between Watteau and Mozart.
And yet to pronounce
the name of Mozart
in the Immanuelburg
is dangerous,
because it gives color
a very pretty color
to the notion that Mozart
was merely a rococo composer.
Fifty years ago,
this was what most people
thought about him.
The notion was supported
by horrible little plaster busts,
which made him look
a perfect 18th century dummy.
I bought one of these busts
when I was at school.
But when I first heard
the G Minor Quartet,
I realized that it couldn't
possibly have been written
by the smooth, white character
on my mantelpiece,
and I threw the bust
into the waste paper basket.
I afterwards discovered
the Portrait by Lange,
which, although no masterpiece,
does convey the single-mindedness
of genius.
Of course, a lot of Mozart's music
is in the current 18th century style.
He was so much at home
in this golden age of music,
so completely master of its forms,
that he didn't feel it necessary
to destroy them.
Indeed, he loved the clarity
and the precision
and the mathematical perfections
of the late 18th century style.
I love the story of Mozart
sitting at table,
absentmindedly folding and refolding
and refolding his napkin
into more and more elaborate patterns
as fresh musical ideas
passed through his mind.
But of course, this formal perfection
was used to express
two characteristics
which were very far
from the Rococo style.
One of them was that peculiar
kind of melancholy,
a melancholy amounting
almost to panic,
which so often haunts
the isolation of genius,
and Mozart felt it quite young.
And the other characteristic
was almost the opposite,
a passionate interest
in human beings
and in the drama of human relationships.
How often in Mozart's orchestral pieces,
concertos, quartets, symphonies,
we find ourselves
participating in a drama
or dialogue.
Of course, this feeling
reaches its natural conclusion
in opera.
Opera, next to Gothic architecture,
is one of the oddest inventions
of Western man.
It couldn't have been foreseen
by any logical process.
Dr. Johnson's much-quoted saying,
which, as far as I can make out,
he never said,
an extravagant and irrational
entertainment is perfectly correct.
And at first it seems surprising
that it should have been brought to perfection
in the age of reason.
But just as the greatest art
of the early 18th century was religious art,
so the greatest artistic creation
of the Rococo
is completely irrational.
Of course, opera
had been invented
in the 17th century
and made into a form of art
by the prophetic genius of Monteverdi.
It came to the north
from Catholic Italy
and it flourished
in the Catholic capitals,
Vienna, Munich, Prague.
Indignant Protestants
used to say
that Rococo churches
were like opera houses.
Quite true,
only it was the other way around.
As you can see,
this enchanting opera house
in Munich,
built by the dwarf architect
Cuvillier,
is exactly like a Rococo church.
One can almost say
that opera houses came in
when churches went out.
And they expressed so completely
the views of this new profane religion
that for a hundred years
all opera houses
continued to be built in Rococo style
long after that style
had gone out of fashion.
And in Catholic countries,
not only in Europe,
but in South America,
they were often the best
and largest buildings in the town.
As Don Giovanni
assaults Donna Anna,
her father,
the Commendatore,
comes down the stairs.
What on earth has given opera
its prestige in Western civilization?
A prestige that has
outlasted so many
different fashions and ways of thought.
Why are people prepared
to sit silently for three hours
listening to a performance
of which they don't understand a word?
Why do
quite small towns
all over Germany and Italy
still devote a large portion of their budgets
to this irrational entertainment?
Partly, of course,
because it's the spray of skill
like a football match.
But chiefly, I think,
because it is irrational.
What is too silly to be said
may be sound.
Well, yes.
But what is too subtle to be said
or too deeply felt
or too revealing
or too mysterious,
these things can also be sung
and only be sung.
No wonder that the music
is rather complicated
because even today
our feelings about Don Giovanni
are far from simple.
He's the most ambiguous
of hero-villains.
The pursuit of happiness
and the pursuit of love,
which had once seemed so simple
and life-giving,
have become complex and destructive.
And his refusal
to repent, which makes him heroic,
belongs
to another phase of civilization.
It's time for the war!
