[Sous-titres disponibles en Français] Peu après 18 heures le 4 août, une explosion a dévasté le port de Beyrouth, tuant plus de 200 personnes et en blessant plus de 6 500 autres. Forensic Architecture a été invité par le journal en ligne égyptien Mada Masr à examiner les informations disponibles en source ouverte, y compris des vidéos, des photographies et des documents, permettant de fournir une chronologie et une modélisation 3D précises des événements.
shortly after 6 pm on august the 4th
an explosion ripped through the port of
beirut it killed more than 200 people
wounded over 6500 and destroyed large
parts of the city
forensic architecture was invited by
madam mass to examine open source
information
including videos photographs and
documents
to provide a timeline and a precise 3d
model
to help investigate the events of august
the 4th
the model is available via this link
the first photograph of the warehouse on
fire was uploaded to twitter at 5 54 pm
we carefully geo-located this photograph
by identifying the key buildings and
calculated the camera's cone of vision
in this image we identified the location
of the source of the smoke plume
at the northeast corner of warehouse 12.
smoke plumes
are continuously transforming and have a
unique shape at every moment
we modeled the plume at this crucial
stage to help synchronize other videos
without a timestamp
a video shot around the same time from
one of the balconies of the residential
tower
building shows the same source of fire
clearly
on the same side of the warehouse the
shape of the plume
and the heat source suggests that the
fire had evolved
another video starting at 5 58 pm
from the nearby st george hospital
provides 10 minutes of uninterrupted
footage of the warehouse
within two minutes the smoke thickens
and its color changes to a darker shade
according to gareth collett a un
explosives analyst we consulted
this suggests that the material burning
inside the warehouse has changed
at 6 07 pm a new intense heat source
appears on the other
north western side of the warehouse here
followed by a different larger plume
the sparks that follow suggest the
presence of small explosive charges
such as fireworks
35 seconds later at 608 pm
a large spherical plume appears above
the center of the warehouse
according to the explosives analyst the
symmetrical shape of the sphere
suggests that it's a single point
explosion originating in one particular
place
within the warehouse and it's possible
that as little as half
of the 2750 sacks of ammonium nitrate
stored inside
detonated we use the shape of the two
plumes from these explosions as metadata
to synchronize the remaining footage
this video taken from further back
provides an uninterrupted view of the
events that followed
within the span of nine seconds the
spherical plume projected high into the
atmosphere
several tons of particulates thick in
the air and a red coloured plume
755 meters high rose over the warehouse
we have thus identified four types of
smoke plumes
emanating from different parts of the
warehouse within the space of these 14
minutes
the first plume at 5 54 pm
emanates from the northeast corner of
the warehouse
second plume at 6 pm is from the same
source point
but has a darker colour
the third plume appears on the northwest
side of the warehouse
at 607 pm
the final plume is developed from a
spherical explosion
located at the center of the warehouse
at 608 pm
each of these smoke plumes with their
distinct shape and colour
provide indications as to the
arrangement of goods in the warehouse
the way the fire developed and the
layout of what was stored inside
a close-up examination helps in
understanding the evolution of fire
inside the warehouse early footage
shows smoke leaking out of every opening
including the windows
and the ceiling vents from this point
at about 5 56 pm the temperature inside
the warehouse started rising rapidly
the smoke is visible as it changes color
to a darker shade
in this footage from the east side
we stabilized the footage to reveal the
full extent of the warehouse
the sounds of fireworks starts being
heard at approximately 5 59 pm
it shows that many windows and doors are
shut
according to the expert confinement
creates hot spots
areas of high temperature in which
ammonium nitrate can get close to its
combustion point
as reported by media outlets the fire
brigade arrived approximately four
minutes after an initial call was made
to the station
at 5 54 pm in this footage
taken by the fire brigade on their
arrival to the scene the sound of
fireworks continues to be heard
the 2750 tons of ammonium nitrate
were unloaded to this hangar in october
2014
and as early as december of that year
various port and customs officials
warned of the dangers posed by its
storage
many subsequent warnings were issued
in february 2015 for example a chemical
forensics expert
commissioned by the lebanese courts to
report on the state of the stored
ammonium nitrate
described that 70 of the sacs were torn
open
their content spilling out and some of
the crystals had darkened
leaked images from february 2020
indicate that the storage conditions had
not improved
the sacs were still torn open and their
contents were still spilling out
the bay numbers visible in the ceiling
allowed us to locate these bags
in bay 9 and 10. the images
show the presence of a container and a
stack of wooden pallets
another video taken on december 18th
released by news outlet al jadeed shows
the state of ammonium nitrate bags
stored at bay 6
and surrounding door 9. stacked ammonium
nitrate bags are blocking the entrance
here we can see the numbers for base 4
and 5.
on the right of the videographer between
door 9 and 10
a white colored wall is visible
suggesting the presence of a small
service room
together these videos and images allowed
us to map a total of 243 bags of
ammonium nitrate in the space
given the location of the source of the
spherical plume here at bay eight
the remaining two thousand five hundred
and seven bags of ammonium nitrate
should have been stored here occupying
almost two thousand meters squared of
space
but given the haphazard way the visible
bags are stored
the space the entire stockpile occupied
was likely larger
news reports suggest that in addition to
the ammonium nitrate
the warehouse also stored 23 tons of
fireworks
50 tons of ammonium phosphate 5 tons of
tea and coffee
5 rolls of slow burning detonating cord
and 1 000 car tyres
each of these materials burns
differently
the combustion of tyres for example
produces a dark and thick plume
according to the explosives expert it
could correspond to the dark plume
we had located on the north east corner
of the warehouse
so we placed the tyres roughly here
the expert also told us that the white
plume that appeared on the northwest of
the warehouse
corresponds to the ignition of fireworks
we therefore place the fireworks
roughly in this corner
from an engineering perspective this is
the spatial layout of a makeshift bomb
on the scale of a warehouse awaiting
detonation
according to gareth collett ammonium
nitrate is extremely difficult to
detonate by fire alone
however when confined and contaminated
this can lead to catastrophic detonation
it is sensitized by the presence of even
the smallest quantity of additives
and hence should be separated we
reviewed international standards for the
storage of ammonium nitrate
internationally accepted benchmarks
include british regulations
according to british standards stacks of
ammonium nitrate
must be limited to 300 tons
and each stack must be at least one
meter away from walls
and other stacks
australian standards are more stringent
bags must be arranged in 500 ton stacks
but should be stored 890 meters away
from the closest residential buildings
using their equation to calculate safe
distances
we can determine that a 2750 stack of
ammonium nitrate
should have been stored 1570 meters away
from the closest residential building
nasa's damage map illustrates the
extents of the blast
all these regulations prohibit the
storage of combustible
or explosive materials such as tyres or
fireworks
in proximity to ammonium nitrate
this fact highlights the substantial and
sustained state negligence
which led to the formulation of a
makeshift bomb
around 1 000 of the survivors and
victims families
have called for an independent
investigation and public access to all
relevant documents
as the search for political and economic
accountability
for the explosion of august the fourth
continues forensic architecture madam
mass are making the model
the geolocated videos and the source
material used in the research
publicly available via this link
you