National Debt and You; Critical Race Theory in Classrooms; ‘Roe v. Wade’ Movie | The Nation Speaks

The Nation Speaks
200 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
today on the nation speaks the
ballooning
national debt the spending spree
continues
why should the average american care
critical race theory is being taught at
all levels of education
what you need to know about it a new
film is out
roe v wade it's guaranteed to teach you
things you never knew
about the landmark 1973 decision
and america q a we ask people across the
country
how much effort they think the
government should be making to ensure
each vote represents one citizen and we
ask
how far back can you trace your family
history
hello and welcome to the nation speaks
i'm your host cindy drew care
most americans probably don't spend much
time thinking about the national debt
it's a lot of big numbers that frankly
most of us can't wrap our heads around
in the last 12 months under two
administrations
five spending bills average out to
nearly 2.4 trillion dollars a piece
does sound big but again no idea what a
trillion dollars looks like and
no idea how much revenue the government
brings in to offset that spending
there's a terrific website called
usdetclock.org
that is quite helpful it shows the debt
increasing in real time
it's over 28 trillion dollars
and that breaks down to over 85 000
for every american citizen or nearly a
quarter of a million dollars
for every taxpayer those numbers are
high
but still hard to know what they really
mean so we've invited two guests to help
us sort that out
our first will shed light on all of that
spending
and if it's truly well spent or not and
our second guest will answer the
question of why americans should care
about the debt at all
joining us now is adam anjievsky he's
the ceo and founder of the nonprofit
openthebooks.com adam thank you for
joining us
before we get right into things i wonder
if you could just quickly start by
telling us the mission of
openthebooks.com because frankly it's
kind of an unbelievable
endeavor our mission at openthebooks.com
is to capture and post online every dime
taxed and spent at every level of
government across the whole country
so to that end last year we actually
filed 40 000
freedom of information act requests it
was the most in american history
we successfully captured six trillion
dollars
of federal state and local spending
across the country
wow okay that's remarkable um so there's
been
a lot of spending in the last 12 13
months
under the trump administration we had
the 2.2 trillion dollar cares act in
march 2020 then in may
3 trillion dollar heroes act then
december 2020 there was a 2.3 trillion
dollar spending bill
and not even a hundred days in office
the biden administration has
a 1.9 trillion america rescue plan
and a 2.5 trillion infrastructure plan
these are a lot of big numbers and all
of these bills were like hundreds
thousands of pages long
does anyone know what's in these
spending bills
well even members of congress when they
take the vote they don't know what's
actually
in these bills if you recall the cares
act that was a year ago that was a
two trillion dollar coronavirus aid bill
and different versions of that bill were
still being dropped
while the united states senate was
debating that bill
if you recall just a couple of months
ago in december at the end of
2020 there was a 600
page bill dropped two hours before the
vote
and even aoc said that this is like
hostage taking this is not
representative government so at
openthebooks.com
we rolled out a petition campaign called
read the bill
and we've got over 10 000 people
organically that have come to our
website to sign that petition
it calls for a 72-hour time out to read
the bill
and i'll submit to you that we don't
have a representative republic
if our representatives don't have time
to simply
read the bill so you have been reading
the bills and digging into
what they actually mean can you give us
some examples of what you consider
you know egregious waste or just missed
you know allocated funds that have been
in some of these recent bills
absolutely so just a month ago when joe
biden's 1.9
trillion dollar american quote unquote
rescue act passed congress
on a party-line vote not one single
republican voted for that bill
joe biden signed it we actually read it
and on page
305 we found a new
perk for federal workers that if your
child's school is
is not full-time so it could even be
hybrid
a federal worker could be paid to stay
home fourteen hundred dollars
per week for fifteen weeks that's
twenty one thousand dollars on this new
perk and its expense of a new fund was
set up at the treasury department
that fund is going to be filled with 570
million dollars
to fund that perk oh
so i i looked into some things that
you've been
you know that are on your website you've
been saying there are some pretty
astounding figures for how many people
work for the federal government and the
kind of
wages and bonuses that they're paid can
you give us a sense of that
so the number one most highly
compensated federal
employee out of 4.3 million of them
is dr anthony fauci we actually found
this in our data in january we made
national news fauci earned
more than the president united states he
made 434
000 last year and since 2015 he's up a
hundred grand
on a pay hike if you're a
federal employee and if you're there for
just three years
incredibly you get 43 days of paid time
off now that's not every single week a
four day work work week but it's
nearly every week of the year you can
take a four day work week because you
get
so much paid time off we estimate that
that
small perk at the federal level cost the
taxpayers every single year
more than 20 billion dollars because
when you have people taking this much
time off you need to hire more
employees your head counts have to go up
that's very expensive
if you're saying that there's
overspending in government at every
level
and look for far too long republicans in
congress
joined democrats to drain the u.s
treasury from the left
the president submitted tremendous
budgets that cut the size scope and
power of the federal government over to
congress
and republicans caved even when they
were in the majority of both
chambers the house and the senate they
cave to democratic pressure
to put massive spending bills with
trillion dollar budget deficits during
boom times so i think republicans have
been
culpable in this overspending as well as
democrats but now obviously the biden
administration's
putting the overspending on steroids so
and do you think the overspending is
just
you know spending more than the coffers
have on worthy things or
do i i know you look at you know waste
and corruption and
you know improper mistaken payments so
where do you think
the cuts could come from how do you
think we could be more efficient
so biden's bills to date have been just
wishlists
for the progressive left and i'll give
you some examples
so they are just funding all their
constituencies their political power
groups
you know teachers unions for instance
k-12 education higher education
let's walk through k-12 education during
the pandemic
year of 2020 congress threw 80 billion
dollars on a bipartisan basis at k-12
schools
it was so much money those schools
couldn't even spend 10 billion dollars
of it
but in the partisan american rescue act
that just passed 30 days ago
the 1.9 trillion dollar bill
in one fell swoop there was 128 billion
dollars for k-12 schools
now joe biden has come out with his
quote infrastructure bill
there's another 100 billion dollars for
k-12
schools they're just flooding the zone
okay i mean here's another example
higher education the ivy league they
don't need taxpayer help
they have 140 billion dollars in their
collective endowment the eight schools
of the ivy league
and in the american rescue act they're
getting 168 million dollars
worth of coronavirus bailout
so let me ask you about something else
uh earmarking
um that is something that was uh done
away with in
2011 uh because you know can easily lead
to corruption and did lead to corruption
people went to jail over it
and i understand that that's come back
or coming back can you
explain that to us well bringing back
earmarks is the equivalent of
bringing back the swine flu it is the
currency of corruption
in congress our former the late
uh honorary chairman of openthebooks.com
was the legendary
u.s senator from oklahoma dr tom coburn
and this was one of coburn's signature
achievements he spearheaded the ban on
earmarks
and they got that in place about 10
years ago in 2011
and they ran it so hard that even barack
obama in his state of the union speech
that year
twice said he would veto any bill to
come across his desk if it contained
earmarks
and now the modern democratic party they
proposed to bring it back
and unfortunately in a secret vote a
couple of weeks ago
in the house the republicans on a 102
to 84 vote they voted to join the
democrats
on their proposal to bring back earmarks
and it's not a small number it's 4 350
of these anchors
that total 13 billion dollars a year
in spending so if you could just explain
to us how do we remarks work
so it's the old style log rolling
smoke-filled back room where you buy
off a legislator for his vote on your
big spending bill so you can spend more
taxpayer money
by getting him on board with a perk with
a project
in his district it's bacon is back on
the table
it is called bringing home the bacon on
these bills
so here's an example of actually it in
practice how it worked
in 2005 denny hastert the republican
speaker of the house at the time he had
purchased a piece of farm ground two
years earlier
and in 2005 put an ear mark
in a spending bill that put a a brand
new highway
through his piece of farm ground four
months after that earmark
passed the earmark was 207 million
dollars for that highway
he was able to sell that farm ground and
make millions
so what do you think is the best way
overall to make the government more
accountable and transparent to reduce
some of this
misspent funds well transparency
first step it's very simple and it's
probably a hundred percent issue
with the american people and that is to
simply read the bill
so we have that petition up at
openthebooks.com we've helped turn that
into senate legislation
so the u.s senator from florida rick
scott he actually has a bill now
called read the bill in the united
states senate it's a great bill
it would require that 72 hour time out
to read it to post it online so people
politicians the press the pundits
can comb through it give it transparency
and here's the other component of that
bill
and this is very important it would
require that every single united states
senator
sign an affidavit that they actually
read the bill
excellent all right thank you so much
for joining us today adam
thank you thank you for your interest in
our work
our next guest is a man who is
intimately familiar with the federal
budget
he served as director of the office of
management and budget for over three
years in the trump administration
director mick mulvaney director mulvaney
thank you so much for joining us
the growing debt is apparently one of
the few bipartisan
issues both parties seem to be quite
capable in this regard
and clearly with voters increasing
spending is a bigger crowd pleaser than
cutting spending
but the big question is should the
average american
care about the nation's ballooning debt
and
basically how does it impact them
directly but before i'd like you to
answer that i want to
ask you to start by giving us some
historical perspective on the size of
the current national debt
sure um and thanks for having me a
couple different questions there
it's simply not been this large since
world war ii
uh and there's a lot of folks who say
that what we've just been through with
covet was as bad as world war ii
no it's not it's terrible what we're
going through it doesn't even close to
what was happening in world war ii and
what the government did people forget
the government took over almost
all of the economy during world war ii
they rationed all the material for the
war they took
over all of the much of the production
of the wartime
the things needed in wartime so that the
comparisons are not
it's night and day um the opening point
though was
was one of the good ones that needs to
be made again and again which is this is
not
a republican versus democrat topic
you do not get 30 trillion dollars in
debt which is roughly where we are at
this point
by one party spending money in the other
party not doing it if you look at when
the debt
started to take off it started to take
off in the early 1980s
when ronald reagan was president and
that's when both parties figured out
that republicans could have more defense
spending and more tax cuts
and and democrats could have more social
welfare
and no one would get unelected everybody
would be happy everybody would keep
their job
in fact to this day i don't think
there's a single person who has ever
lost his or her job
in elected office in washington dc
because they spent too much or borrowed
too much
washington is littered with people who
lost their jobs because they cut
spending or cut funding or discontinued
a program
but no one loses their job over more
spending
and politicians know this and the one
thing politicians really like is
is staying in politics and continuing to
be re-elected so
at the end of the day yeah it's they are
simply reacting to what the voters
want which is more spending that's
extraordinarily dangerous your point is
is very well made in that it does
impact or at least it will impact
ordinary americans in the future
the best example i can give right now is
that at roughly 30 trillion dollars and
i know it's not there yet but the math
is a lot easier
if interest rates go to 3 on that debt
that's 900 billion
a year in interest payments alone
um and what that means is that we'll be
more money than we
spend on defense so unless we want to
continuing to not just borrow money but
borrowing more and
more money sooner or later those
interest payments do take a chunk out of
what we want to spend our money on and
that's when the rubber hits the road
in one of the many ways the rubber hits
the road for ordinary americans
so a lot of these numbers are kind of
they're just so big and nebulous for
most americans talk about 30 trillion
900 billion
how do you think it will impact actual
americans
in the pocketbook and what they're able
to do or not do can you bring it home at
all
yeah the numbers are quite fascinating
the democrats recently took a
i think an infrastructure bill from 2.1
trillion to 2.3 trillion
and that sounds like a really small
amount it's 200 billion dollars put that
in perspective
um last year we ran the department of
homeland security for 50 billion dollars
i think we
ran the department of housing and urban
development for about the same so that
simple
change that rounding error from 2.1
trillion to 2.3 train was four
times what we spent this year on the
department uh department of homeland
security
what it means to ordinary americans is
they crowded out
things that they want to buy will be
more expensive
taxes will go up so they have less money
to buy the money that they have in their
pockets will
be worth less the easiest thing to
explain the easiest thing to explain
is inflation which many folks who are
younger than i am have
have forgotten inflation was a real
um thing and it was a real problem back
in the late 1970s and 1980s
when you had to pay interest on a house
on a mortgage
someplace between 12 and 16 percent
think about that right now my kids are
looking at you know maybe buying their
first house a few down the
years down the road and they're
complaining that rates are are below are
you know
are between three and a half and four
percent it used to be you paid 12 14
maybe 16 percent to
to borrow uh to buy a house imagine what
that does to your ability to own a home
ability to buy a home ability to save
money
very very difficult to do inflation is
part and parcel of what you get when you
get this
rapid spending inflation is roughly
defined but accurately defined as too
much money
chasing too few goods and when we print
all of this money
just print it out of nowhere make it up
and don't have
a commensurate increase in the goods and
services
for that money to buy you get higher
prices you get inflation
and you get damage to the middle class
in a very very real way that i don't
think nearly enough people are talking
about
okay that that helps bring it home i
want to go back to something you were
talking about earlier
um about incentives in the government to
reduce waste or reduce
you know duplicate payments or
unnecessary payments is there any
incentive
in the government to do that it sounded
like from what you said earlier
not really but are there levers that can
be pulled
oh sure there's leaders to be pulled but
there's no incentive to do so
that not none whatsoever because keep in
mind what would happen
um i'll give you a great example back
when i was in congress
and i joke with my colleagues now who
are still in congress especially the
incoming freshmen who've only been in
the job now about i guess three or four
months
that we re we receive an allowance to
run our offices in washington dc and our
offices back in the district let's say
that budget was a million dollars for a
year well the first year i was in
congress
um we didn't spend all of that i think
we we we saved we came in under budget
about two hundred and fifty thousand
dollars two hundred thousand let's call
for sake of discussion
and we thought that that money would go
back to the taxpayers the taxpayer given
us a million dollars to run our offices
in washington and back in south carolina
we didn't spend all that million where
there's two hundred thousand dollars
and we gave it back um to congress
because we thought it would go to the
treasury and thus to the taxpayers and
it didn't it got spent someplace else
more specifically by the way
by the speaker of the house the time was
john boehner now it's nancy pelosi
so money doesn't get saved in washington
it simply gets spent and if you don't
spend it on project a
it absolutely will get spent on project
b the government
is set up to spend money and it is set
up to spend
more money one year over the next and it
is not set up in any fashion
way shape or form to save money so
what would you prescribe we have about
two minutes left what would you do
if you wanted to reduce this kind of
runaway spending or waste or whatever
what would you prescribe
yeah the only thing that's gonna work i
used to say you need to educate voters
and so forth but it's really hard
most voters don't don't really get down
deep into these issues and that's fine
they have more important things to do
with their lives that's why they elect
people to go off to washington for them
so educating voters to to penalize
people who borrow too much money is just
too attenuated here's the simple answer
to your question a balanced
budget amendment and one of the other
reasons that i think in addition to the
economics of
of a balanced budget amendment the
things that i think is really good about
it i've just started thinking about this
recently when i compare
federal government to state government
state governments
work they're bipartisan people seem to
get along
things get done roads get built bridges
gets built etcetera schools get run
maybe not well not as well as they can
but certainly better than washington
that's because in almost every state in
this union
democrats republicans have to work
together to balance the budget those
statewide balanced budget amendments
make the men and women work together and
i think
everybody thinks that we need more of
that in washington d.c so in addition to
helping
economics i think the balanced budget
amendment would actually help politics
as well
does everybody in washington dc think
that would help it seems like there's
not that many fiscal conservatives
nobody agrees with that they all want to
spend the democrats don't agree with it
because when they're in charge they want
to spend the money and the republicans
don't agree with it because where charge
we want to spend money that's the dirty
little secret
there's probably a true handful of real
fiscal conservatives in washington dc
are most of the republicans
probably but that doesn't mean the
republican party is a fiscally
conservative
party again you don't get this much in
debt
uh by having one party spend money in
the other party complaining about it you
walk
hand in hand down the road to 30
trillion dollars
so no the dirty little secret in
washington dc is that
almost everybody likes spending money
because it's it's more
fun to be santa that it is to be the
grinch so no
the balanced budget amendment is not
something that's going to be supported
in washington dc it's something that's
have to come from
the grassroots and come from the states
uh and be forced upon washington against
its will
all right thank you so much director
mulvaney thank you for joining us today
thank you coming up next how critical
race theory is changing what our kids
are learning
but first here's america q a where we
ask people across the country
how much ever they think the government
should put in to ensuring each vote
represents one citizen
i think that that all people who are
registered
in the united states to vote should have
the ability to vote
in a timely manner efforts should be a
hundred percent you should be a thousand
percent offered
well absolutely you need um ids
one vote one person a lot because you
should be an american citizen like i
said before checks and balances to make
sure that
there is no fraudulent voting i think
everybody who's an american should have
an absolute right to vote
say that i trust the voting process as
is
it's been a stable voting process and a
legal right as we had already mentioned
every vote is important voting is a
sacred right
however as you did say the constitution
does say that citizens
are the ones who should vote i think
making sure that we have a proper system
in place checks and balances to make
sure
socials line up to make sure just
numbers in general line up that's very
very important
i think a lot of energy should go into
that because if we have illegals voting
then that's not the actual citizens of
the united states
not right sure i think there's a better
way than handling all the uh
you know interactive votes and all that
i think as much as it takes
i think we're a country of laws i think
we're a country that
we don't want to disenfranchise any
voter
any legal voter but anytime there's a
fraudulent vote or an illegal vote
that offsets a legal vote unless they're
showing identification
i mean that is the law i think at this
time there's a lot of effort that needs
to be put into a lot of different
directions
and that the most important thing that
we need to do is
make sure that everyone is safe i feel
like it should be a lot of effort put
forth in that
like like i said we have a democracy and
everybody has a right to vote
probably maintain the effort that has
been given thus far
i think over time people are seeing that
their input does matter i think they've
seen what happens when they don't do
anything
i work for the polls you have to show id
that you're who are you you are and
i've been doing it for five years and
never seen one person
try to vote twice i've heard of it but
i've never seen it
i just think uh election is very uh it's
sacred
it's a right and we should make sure
that it's valid
our government is supposed to give us
every person is entitled to
their vote and how they vote um
i do believe that things are a shame
right now
you have to have id one person one vote
with id
there's growing attention these days on
something called critical race theory
or you might have heard about it as
anti-racism training
the social justice movement diversity
equity and inclusion or even
culturally responsive teaching most
recently in illinois
critical race theories roots go back to
1960s but it
formally came onto the scene in 1989 at
the first annual workshop on critical
race theory
gradually and then suddenly it's come to
inform what students are being taught at
virtually every level of education
and with that has come some growing
backlash against it
to delve into these issues we have two
guests with us today
dr peter wood the president of the
national association of scholars
and the author of a new book 1620 a
critical response to the
1619 project and dr lindsey burke
director
of the center for education policy at
the heritage foundation
welcome to you both as i
mentioned in the intro critical race
theory is now
informing curricula in schools and
colleges across the country
and i think there's two aspects to it
that are important for people to
understand and one is the
content that's actually being taught and
the other
is the the theory that's actually
changing the
pedagogical approaches and evaluation
standards that are now being used
um dr wood perhaps you can start us off
by just explaining
how critical race theory sees the world
what what is it
critical race theory sees the world as a
matter of power
and hierarchy that is the powerful
people attempt to
impose their will on everybody else by
controlling the language that we use
choosing what
cultural benchmarks are legitimate what
books can be read
and by promoting that world view through
the artifacts of civilization
uh they become able to manipulate people
so critical race theory looks at the
world as basically a conspiracy
run by the wealthy and powerful and
especially the white
to impose their will on everyone else
and
it is meant to be a a weapon
to undo that kind of control that
hegemony as they call it
by calling into question uh everything
in the culture that supports this form
of white supremacy
so critical race theory is a a
weapon of war essentially cultural war
it's a continuation of what we used to
call the culture wars
by new means ones that call into
question
the entire curriculum as we have known
it for the last several hundred years
of what we teach in our schools in every
subject
including some that one might not think
are
actually weapons of any sort such as
teaching mathematics
is suddenly one of the areas of
contestability so i can see how all of
this clearly
started in the university setting but
now um
it's in the schools in the k to 12
schools perhaps
dr burke could you give us some examples
of how that's actually being implemented
this
how the theory is being implemented
right and it really is
critical theory and all of its
derivations
critical pedagogy critical race theory
really
is derived from marxism at its at its
essence
and so now we're seeing as dr wood
mentioned uh this theory make its way
from universities university-based
colleges of education in particular
down to the k-12 classroom and so we see
it manifest itself
in efforts like california's new
ethnic studies curriculum which is the
first statewide ethnic studies
curriculum in the country the california
state board of education
just unanimously approved it about two
weeks ago
and if you read through the model
curriculum
all of the frameworks are online it
really is like sitting through
a graduate seminar on critical race
theory
the education officials in california
who
are charged with determining what
students will learn in that state
and mind you this is a state in which
just three and ten
eighth graders can read proficiently
they have determined
that what is imperative in this moment
instead is learning about
systems of power and identity politics
and so if you read through the model
curriculum in california you'll
you'll see it is clear that students are
taught
neo-marxist theories of
intersectionality
sorting students into multiple
categories according to race and gender
and sexual orientation in class
you know it really is i think preparing
them for what is ultimately in
california
a mandatory ethnic studies course that
all students
in the california state university
system now are required to take
as a result of legislation that was
signed into law last year
can you give me one quick small example
of how you know someone in elementary
school might be taught this
what activity would they be doing well
if you if you read through
these frameworks you'll see students
will learn to
one of the quotes from the frameworks is
critique empire building in history and
its relationship to white supremacy
racism and other forms of power and
oppression
children throughout their k-12 school
years will
quote challenge racist bigoted
discriminatory
imperialist colonial beliefs and
practices on multiple levels
so it goes on and on and hits those
themes over and over again throughout
the grade levels
so i know both of you believe that this
is harmful you're doing work to
fight against it can you explain why dr
wood you feel this is
harmful well yes
ultimately this is an effort to
tear down our national self-confidence
and
change our regime from one in which we
uphold the ideals of individual striving
regardless of our race or ethnicity to
one in which we are to see everything
as a interplay of oppressive groups and
oppressed groups fighting back
it's a terrible way to try to encourage
our nation to solve its problems instead
of working together this calls us to
be divided to be divided either into
people who feel
their lives are defined by grievance and
those who feel their lives are defined
by
uh guilt or penitence but that is
no way for our republic to govern itself
people don't naturally fall into those
categories they have to be taught that
and that's why this contest is being
fought in our schools
young children have no basis at all to
challenge the authority of their
teachers the teachers coming out of
teachers colleges
trained in cultural marxism don't even
realize what they're missing
so of course they present to these young
students
a world view that the students will take
with them for the rest of their lives
i think it's a very dangerous situation
right i was thinking about that because
it used to be that
you know education was about you know
pursuit of truth and knowledge and
you know debating both sides was
encouraged
but with the critical race theory it
seems like there is one correct way to
think and the teacher is going to tell
you about that
so um dr burke if you're uh in teachers
college and you don't subscribe to these
views what happens to you
yeah that's a really tough position to
be in quite frankly because we know that
colleges of education that they are
really steeped in these theories
i just conducted a report with rick hess
over at the american enterprise
institute and we actually
analyzed the research agendas of faculty
at
colleges of education across the country
at the top producing
colleges of education in terms of the
number of teachers they produce every
year
along with the most prestigious colleges
of education across the country we
looked at over 3 000
faculty pages and really delved into
their research
areas of interest and what we found is
that this is one of the driving
pursuits that these faculties have at
the top ranked schools
of education across the country nearly
half of faculty
characterized diversity and race as
their
research interest area and 25
of those faculty categorize it as their
primary area of study
now that in and of itself isn't a bad
thing to pursue a study
of race and diversity of course but when
we consider how this is being applied
and how critical theory is the lens
through which most of these faculty are
examining this
that's when it really starts to raise
some questions and so we
did do a deeper dive into their
areas of study and found that about a
third of professors
who focus on race and diversity describe
their work
through the tenets of critical theory
interesting and dr wood there's
obviously you know if something new is
being taught in school something isn't
being taught
and i know civics and yeah civics
education is one of those areas doctor
would that's something you're
particularly interested in and
especially
uh countering the 16 19 project can you
tell us about your your book
1620 is a response to the new york
times's
1619 project which is essentially the
claim that america
was founded in 1619 with the arrival of
slaves in the colony of uh jamestown
virginia
and ever since then we've been a
slaveocracy in every
major development in american history
such as the american revolution
was fought in order to advance the cause
of slavery
most of these claims are rejected out of
hand by knowledgeable historians but the
new york times has stuck with them
that would be one thing but the new york
times partnered with the pulitzer center
to roll this out as a curriculum and
has proudly placed it in thousands of
american classrooms whole school
districts like chicago and buffalo
washington dc have adopted this so
what amounts to a completely fictitious
history of america is being taught at
every great level now
the times broke this down into lesson
plans it made them available for free
it gives fellowships to teachers who
want to become more deeply immersed in
this
new mythology and what is it replacing
well it's replacing basic american
history you don't learn much about
george washington other than that he
owns slaves you think that
abraham lincoln instigated the civil war
in order to exile blacks from the north
american continent
we learned that american prosperity our
whole capitalist system
derives from plantation slavery and so
on that's what the 1619 project teaches
it is displacing the teaching of
american history and certainly the
teaching of civics
civics requires us to have some
understanding of the american founding
why we had a declaration of independence
and what it said
what's in the constitution and the bill
of rights and the federalist papers
why we have elections why we have juries
our whole system of government depends
on some basic knowledge
of civics that is being shoved aside in
a lot of ways
among the things that goes in its place
is the 1619 project
but that's not all there are these new
radicalized forms of civics called
action civics
that aim to turn young children into
political activists aligned with a
progressive agenda
so instead of learning about the
american founding you learn how to
protest you learn how to
write to your congressman and repeat
whatever your teacher has told you is
the facts of the matter
um that's what we face right now it's uh
between critical race theory 1619
project the obliteration of traditional
history and the erasure of civics
uh we're faced with a school system that
is
100 dedicated to producing
in the next generation of people who
just don't have real
understanding of what america is and
what it can be
so dr burke why do you think this is
happening
in this cultural moment
well i think it's in part a function of
the fact that you do as i said earlier
have colleges of education that
are really steeped in these theories and
these of course are
the primary production avenues for
new teachers most teachers who enter the
k-12 classroom
do so through their colleges of
education and so
i think that's a big part of the puzzle
and a good reason why
at the state level policymakers need to
offer
alternatives to teachers prospective
teachers who
want to enter the profession that do not
require them to go through
a traditional college of education in
order to enter the classroom
do not require them to uh be uh
to go through colleges that are really
pushing this ideology of critical theory
and critical pedagogy so that is one key
to moving away from this moment that
we're in is to actually
offer alternatives uh in to getting into
the classroom and then at the same time
state policy makers really should
consider
allowing content that is taught in
public schools and in fact requiring
content
to be transparent to parents and to
taxpayers
this is something that sounds so obvious
on the surface and many people might
think that
they already have access to the content
that is taught
in the k-12 classroom but often it is
very difficult to determine
what your child's school is teaching to
get access to the textbooks that they're
using
and so public school officials really
should make those
k-12 curricular materials available to
parents and taxpayers on requests and
then
of course provide families options
provide them with an immediate exit pass
out of a school that's not the right fit
for them by
creating school choice options in the
states i think that's a combination
right now
alternative teacher certification
transparency around school curriculum
and school choice
that combination is currently lacking
and i think that's a big part of the
reason why
we're seeing some of this left-leaning
curriculum really make its way into the
k-12 classroom so
moving in a direction that empowers
family gives them
more information about the content that
is taught in schools and gives them an
exit pass
is really going to be key to pushing
back on this all right so we're going to
have to wrap up dr wood do you have any
other
thoughts on solutions to the current
predicament
well i i do think that those states that
are willing to should do their best to
outlaw the critical race theory and the
1619 project
they are defective goods it's bad
pedagogy it's bad
content um it's one thing to have
ideas debated among people who are
capable of
understanding both sides of an argument
that's something very different to
impose an ideology on children who are
in no position at all to dispute it
all right thank you both so much for
joining us today i really appreciate
your time
thank you thank you
coming up next there's a new film out
about the landmark supreme court
decision
roe v wade we'll talk to his director
and star
but first here's america q a where we
find out how far back people can trace
their family history
probably i think i think it was like
1890 around there
i haven't looked into it but i would say
probably like like three generations
back
my dad's explained a lot of things and
like he's told me how like most of like
my
past family has been like in the army
and stuff back in colombia i think
three three generations we came from
italy i have no idea interesting you say
that because my wife is standing over
there
she tells me all the time that's
something we should look into all around
like a
200 years in new york new york and
puerto rico
just up to my parents i really
rarely remember my grandparents i'm out
of my mom's
from germany my dad is from west
virginia
that's as far as i know probably
the early 1800s i can trace my family
history back to
four generations and my
great-grandparents
all came either from england or ireland
or germany
so probably back probably several
generations four or five when they
arrived in canada
both my parents are canadian and then
came over
there my my parents parents came over to
the united states
so before that we traced them back to
the original starts
in canada which is pretty far back oh i
know cherokee
i know my last name is french
great-grandparents in 1985
when i was 17 years old i ran away from
my country
because it was a company during that
time after the
you know about killing field right
that's my country
yeah after the killing field and
vietnamese take over
i only see my grandma only my
grandfather he passed away before i go
and so
i know it's from germany some somewhere
in germany that's all i know
my uncle and aunt live there right now
you know my great grandfather building
dan lawson he had a
first old house across the creek
and he getting some age on him and the
house was getting bad
he built this house and
at that time he owned a thousand acres
from rich mountain to the top smokey
mountain
what's really funny is my dad's parents
have a picture at this
cabin so now with that picture my
parents got their honeymoon picture at
this cabin
and then i did and my brother did as
well
in 1973 the supreme court decided roe v
wade protecting a pregnant woman's
liberty to choose to have an abortion
without excessive government restriction
the case gave birth to the pro-choice
and the pro-life movements as we know
them today
that much is widely known but what's
lesser known is the backstory behind the
landmark decision
a new film aims to fill that gap we're
very happy to have with us nick loeb
the writer director producer and star of
roe v wade the movie
that came out on april 2nd nick thank
you so much for joining
us now you play the main character and
narrator dr bernard nathanson
i wonder if you could start off by
telling us a little bit about dr
nathanson
and particularly why you decided to
center the film around him
yeah so um dr bernard nathanson was the
biggest abortionist in american history
uh he in his clinics oversaw about 70
000 abortions
he was one of the founders of uh narrow
the national association to repeal
abortion laws and work hand in hand with
planned parenthood
to get abortion legalized through roe v
wade
uh later in his life he converted uh and
became pro-life when he realized through
new sonogram technology
um he was killing human beings and the
reason we wanted to use bernard to tell
the story
one he was instrumental in getting ro
pass and you know i like to say
you know funny a lot everyone's like
well how come you didn't use roe or wade
um well people don't realize that jane
roe or henry wade really had nothing to
do with the case at all
um uh jane rowe who was norma mccorvey
essentially was a
a character uh woman looking for an
abortion
uh that planned parenthood and narow
signed up for the case so they could
legalize abortion and literally never
spoke to her again
she didn't even find out what happened
in the case she found out through the
media not even through her own lawyers
and so we wanted to find people who are
instrumental in the case and because i
wanted to tell
the movie from both sides of the story
um or both sides of the argument i
should say you know a lot of people are
pro-choice from dealer pro-life
bernard who was so instrumental was on
both sides
of it he was started off becoming being
pro-choice and converting her pro-life
so
i thought it was very interesting to
tell it from his point of view
especially since he was so instrumental
and a doctor
interesting and i know you weren't
always
pro life yourself did you identify with
him
as a character yeah i mean of course so
i you know i
you know i grew up in um i'm 45
i grew up in the northeast and so well i
was taught when a woman gets pregnant
it's just a clump of cells and there's
no real baby there until it kicks
and so i had a few abortions in my 20s
uh and it really wasn't until my 30s
when when technology became
more accessible you could hear a baby's
heartbeat through a sonogram
on the internet or you could see babies
sucking their thumbs in the womb
in the first trimester and you realize
oh my god it's a baby
it's not a clump of cells and and
abortion really is the ending of the
life of a human being and through that
i ended up converting and becoming
becoming pro-life
um and but i think a lot of a lot of
people my generation
uh who grew up like i did still don't
understand there's a real human being
there that have been manipulated and
lied to for so long
um that i think that's where the
struggle lies
and um did you expect that viewers would
be familiar with dr
nathanson's story i.e you didn't okay
not at all i mean
you know the the the funny thing is i
mean
you know i making this movie and then
promoting the movie
very much you talk to a lot of people
who are in the pro-life community
and everybody in the pro-life community
knows who dr bernard nathanson is and
they
they give interviews and they talk and
like well they talk is about
everybody should know who he is but the
majority of people
in america are not involved in the
abortion movement
right 99 of americans uh
do not volunteer for planned parenthood
or the national right to life
and so very few people americans really
know who dr bernard is i mean the only
thing he was really truly famous for and
known for
was making a documentary called the
silent scream which
people may remember is where he
performed an abortion under a sonogram
but no really the general public has no
idea who
bernard nathanson was and i think i
think it's an interesting story
to tell since he was the biggest
abortionist in american history
i was aware of the silent screen but i
had no idea that was him until you know
the very end of the film and i was like
oh
wow okay that changes a lot of things
yeah i learned so much
in this film and everybody of course has
heard of roe v wade but
you know the back story is you know
quite unknown i would say to most people
how much did you know about the story
before you made the film
zero i mean i i like to say roe v wade
is
is the court case everyone has heard of
but nobody knows anything about
including me and and i you know i
assumed that nobody had made the movie
on the most famous court case in
american history because
maybe it was just a boring courtroom
drama uh but when
i started reading and learning about it
i was fascinated you know
it almost came across like an oliver
stone
conspiracy movie like jfk and so i
thought it was you know
from a hollywood perception i thought it
would you know be also entertaining
as well and at least in informative and
interesting and
finally people will learn what is roe v
wade
another interesting character in the
film is dr mildred jefferson so she was
the the first african-american woman to
graduate from
harvard medical school and she played a
big part in this whole story and
is also quite unknown what did you learn
about her
you know i i think it's sad that
women in america who tend to break the
glass ceiling or african americans who
break down
barriers are revered they're talked
about
movies holidays and no one's ever heard
of dr mildred jefferson
she was the first black woman to
graduate harvard medical school she
really was a pioneer in the medical
profession and broke down
barriers from women's and blacks during
that period of time
and no one's ever heard of her or talks
about her
and the reason in my opinion the reason
it is because she became the second
president of the national right to life
she became
very instrumental in the pro-life
movement that was uh really what she
took on i mean if she was a volunteer
for
now the national organization of women
everybody would have heard of her but
because she was
so vigilant in her fight for life i i
think people just didn't want
to to recognize her um and her whole
point for fighting for life was she
believed that
abortion was the number one killer of
her own race of african americans in
this country
um and and her fight was to stop that
from happening
right um so you know it's no
secret that hollywood isn't uh pro
pro-life
or very friendly towards generally
conservative ideas
how much you know how many obstacles did
you
encounter in trying to make this film
fun this film get this film out
i mean the funding is always difficult
from independent film perspective and i
think we took on a lot
interesting different issues i mean i
that happened
i think what's funny um
now is more challenging than ever is the
distribution of the filming we released
the movie
last week on friday on all platforms
and just the way some of the platforms
have been having it's just it's really
funny
uh you know the first day amazon
you had to have a link you couldn't even
search for it you search for one come up
but you could click on have a link you
could get to it then i went on a fox and
i complained about that and
magically it was up an hour later but
then they buried it
he couldn't find it they put it into the
romance section finally
rose to number one on the road man
section
itunes actually the romance section of
itunes which has now pushed it onto new
and noteworthy but
in amazon you know amazon uh you've got
itunes and google play voodoo they're
all like the first page
you know amazon's buried in the back
you've got like comcast
uh and directv where you if you don't
actually
type in the actual name correctly and
you can't even find it
um and it's it's just it's just blatant
uh censorship and it's sad i mean i just
don't
see let people you know there's liberal
movies there's conservative movies
you know where divided country let
people make their own decision it's it's
a pg-13 movie it's not even our
like romance apparently
um we have to wrap up but i just want to
ask you one more thing um
because i know a lot of research went
into this film and
you know you're trying to make it as
accurate as possible there's a lot of
things in there they'll be surprising
so you've got the you know fact check
yourselves on your website
what one of the things that super
surprised me was the fake pulls and fake
stats
that um were were put out there that
your character put out there
um to help have people support an
abortion stance
can you speak very briefly to that or
maybe something else that surprised you
in your research that you put in the
film
yeah you know i mean literally you know
they there were statistics thrown around
i mean they they came up and said you
know
um a million women every year are having
illegal abortions and 10 000 are dying
in back alleys
and they literally just completely made
it like
invented fabricated uh told it to the
press and the press just ran with it
back then and back then
there was nobody to cross-check it
wasn't like we have social media today
to see if that's even accurate or not
and so the press ran with it i mean in
the movie we actually
you know they run through all the
stories they leaked i mean he goes
through he i
i leak stories in newsweek and time and
you know in 19 you know
68 and 69 in these months and every time
we mention a month that they leaked a
story in at a certain magazine
you can actually go to the archives and
check that magazine
and there's a story there we use the
actual uh
the exact dates the exact months of
the stories they planted
i guess it's quite useful that you had
dr nathanson being a um a whistleblower
on himself
ultimately yeah well that was uh yes
that was very helpful in writing
uh making the movie all right well thank
you so much for
joining us today we really appreciate
hearing about roe v wade the movie
well thank you so much for having me
that's all for today's show thank you so
much for watching the nation speaks
join us every saturday 11 a.m to noon
eastern and from all of us here
have a great week
