Kenneth Clark's Civilisation 05: The Hero as Artist

Lost Treasures
16 followers
1 Video View·Oct 27, 2024
The scene has changed from Florence to Rome. From the city of hard heads, sharp wits, light feet,
graceful movement, to a city of weight. A city that is like a huge compost heap of human hopes
and ambitions. A wilderness of imperial splendor, despoiled of its ornament, almost indecipherable.
Only one bronze emperor, Marcus Aurelius, who was above ground in the sunshine
throughout the centuries. And as you see, the scale has changed. This is part of the courtyard
of the Vatican, at the end of which the architect Bramante has built a sun trap known as the
Belvedere, from which the pope could enjoy a view of the ancient city. And it's in the form of a
niche. But instead of being designed to hold a life-size statue, as it would have been 50 years
earlier, it is enormous. In fact, it has always been known as Il Nicchione, the monster niche.
It's the outward invisible sign of a great change that overcame the civilization of the Renaissance
in about the year 1500. This is no longer a world of free and active men, but a world of giants and
heroes. A world of giants. This bronze pine cone, and it really is a big pine cone, came from that
earlier world of giants antiquity. It was supposed to have been the point at which the chariots
turned in their races around the Hippodrome. And since in that Hippodrome many Christian martyrs
were put to death, it was here that the Christian church elected to make its headquarters. Huge,
cloudy concepts compared to the sharp focus of Florence. But in Rome, they weren't so cloudy
after all, because the huge buildings of antiquity were there. Very much more of them than we have
today. Even after three centuries in which they were used as quarries, and in which our sense of
scale has expanded, they still are surprisingly big. In the Middle Ages, men had been crushed by
this gigantic scale. They said that these buildings must have been the work of demons, or at best they
treated them simply as natural phenomena, like mountains, and built their huts in them, as who
should take advantage of a ravine or sheltering escarpment. Rome was a city of cowherds and stray
goats, in which nothing was built except a few fortified towers from which the ancient families
carried out their pointless and interminable feuds. Literally interminable, because they're still
quarreling today. But by 1500, the Romans had come to realize that these mountainous ruins had been
built by men. The lively, intelligent individuals who created the Renaissance, bursting with vitality
and confidence, they weren't in the mood to be crushed by antiquity. They meant to absorb it,
to equal it, to master it. They were going to produce their own race of giants and heroes.
The scene has changed to Rome also for political reasons. After years of exile and adversity,
the sovereign pontiff has returned to his seat of temporal power. Temporal power that meant so
much to the popes of the 16th century, but of course are completely abandoned today.
Now the pope is solely a religious leader.
In what is commonly described as the decadence of the papacy, the popes were unusually able men,
who used their international contacts, their great civil service, their increasing wealth,
in the interests of civilization. And even Sixtus IV, who was as brutal and cunning as he looks,
founded the Vatican library and made the great humanist Platina its first prefect. And here we
see for the first time the splendid head of the young cardinal, who more than any man was destined
to give the high Renaissance its heroic direction, Giuliano della Rovere. What a lion he looks
compared to the donkeys of the papal secretariat. And when he became Julius II, he was able,
by magnanimity and strength of will, to inspire and bully three men of genius, Bramante,
Michelangelo, and Raphael. This program is about a few individuals of genius, and two of them,
Michelangelo and Raphael, were, to some extent, the creation of Julius. Without him, Michelangelo
would not have painted the Sistine Ceiling, nor would Raphael have decorated the papal apartments.
And so we should have been without two of the greatest visible expressions of spiritual power
and humanist philosophy. Well, this splendidly over life-sized character conceived a project
so audacious, so extravagant, that to this day, the very thought of it makes me feel slightly
jumpy. He decided to pull down old St. Peter's. It was one of the largest and most ancient churches
in the world, certainly the most venerable, because it stood on the place where St. Peter
was supposed to have been martyred. Julius decided to put it down, and put in its place something
even larger and more splendid. In his thoughts for the new building, he was influenced by two
Renaissance ideals. It must be based on perfect forms, the square and the circle. It must be on
a scale that surpassed even the grandiose ruins of antiquity. And he called on Bramante to provide
a plan. He didn't get very far with it. You know, great movements in the arts, like revolutions,
don't last more than about 15 years. After that, the flame dies down. People prefer
a cosier glow. Julius II was pope for only 10 years. St. Peter's wasn't completed till
almost a century after his death. But the first step in this visible alliance between Christianity
and antiquity was taken when Julius decided to pull down the old basilica and rebuild it
in rivalry with the enormous remains of Roman architecture. In the 15th century,
Greco-Roman sculpture had become a shining, almost inaccessible model to the more adventurous
artists. And collectors had begun to compete for fine examples. The greatest prize in the
papal collection was the Apollo of the Belvedere, an ideal of godlike beauty.
But for some time, these discoveries didn't influence their mental picture of antiquity.
As they read the ancient authors with passionate attention, they wrote to each other in Latin.
But although their minds were full of antique literature, their imaginations remained entirely
Gothic. When the average painter set out to depict a scene of ancient history or legend,
as in this picture of the rape of Helen, he did so in the costume of his own time with
dainty fantastical movements which show not the slightest consciousness
of the physical weight and the flowing rhythms of antiquity. Well, these are not ancient Greeks,
but 15th century Florentines. And the funny thing is that the humanists who took such trouble about
the text of an author like Lippi accepted a picture like this of the death of Julius Caesar
as a correct representation of the event. And as long as there was this rather comical discrepancy
between the written word and the image, antiquity couldn't exert its humanizing power on the
imagination. I suppose that the first occasion in which the dream of antiquity is given a more or
less accurate visible form is the series of decorations representing the triumph of Caesar
done for the court of Mantua by Mantegna in about 1480.
It's a piece of romantic archaeology. Mantegna has rummaged passionately in the ruins of ancient
Roman towns to find evidence for the shape of every vase or of a Roman trumpet. But he has
subordinated all his antiquarian knowledge to a superb feeling for the drive and discipline of
Rome. I said that the gigantic and the heroic spirit of the High Renaissance belongs to Rome,
and it's true. But there was a sort of prelude in Florence. The Medici, who had been the rulers of
Florence for the last 60 years, had been kicked out in 1494, and the Florentines had established
a republic. They made speeches full of the noble puritanical sentiments which pre-Marxist
revolutionaries used to dig up out of Plutarch and Livy. And to symbolize their convictions,
they re-erected two statues by Donatello, the Lion of the Republic, called the Marzocco,
and Judith, the Tyrant Slayer, two figures belonging to an earlier period of Florentine
liberty. And the city fathers also commissioned various works of art on heroic or patriotic themes,
and one of them was a gigantic figure of David, the free, pure-hearted youth who had killed the
giant of corruption. And the commission was given to an alarming young man who had just returned
from Rome to his native city, Michelangelo. Only 25 years separate this marble hero from the dapper
little figure which had been the last word in Medician elegance, the David of Verrocchio, and you
see there really has been a turning point of the human spirit. The Verrocchio is light, nimble,
smiling, and clothed. The Michelangelo, this is the original, the one you saw on the piazza was a copy,
the Michelangelo is vast, defiant, nude. It's rather the same progression that we'll see again
in music between Mozart's Figaro and Beethoven's Fidelio. What a man. Everyone who met Michelangelo
recognized that he had an unequal power of mind and skill of hand. Even as a boy, his spiritual energy
terrified people. Personally, I believe that this small figure which he carved in Bologna when he was under 20
is a self-portrait, and it shows that he'd ever changed, except that he grew sadder like the rest
of us. It has the indignant singleness of purpose that alarms ordinary accommodating citizens,
and in a way his art never changed. This relief of a battle is certainly one of his earliest works,
and already one sees the same expressive poses that reappear on the Sistine ceiling,
even in the Last Judgment. It's inspired by a Greco-Roman relief. Antique art was always to
Michelangelo a kind of quarry from which he dug out his ideas of form, but of course it's still
rather a rough version of antiquity, and when he went to Rome he was able to make much more
finished versions of antique sculpture, some that were actually passed off as originals.
This one even achieved some of the unpleasant smoothness of a Roman copy, but when he returned
to Florence he was able to charge this worn-out style with his own vigour and potency. Seen by
itself, the David's body might be some unusually taut and vivid work of antiquity. It's only when
we come to the head that we're aware of a spiritual force that the ancient world had never known.
I suppose that this quality, which I've called heroic, isn't a part of most people's idea of
civilization. It involves a contempt for convenience and a sacrifice of all those
pleasures that contribute to what we usually call civilized life. It's the enemy of happiness,
and yet we recognize that to despise material obstacles and even to defy the blind forces of
fate is man's supreme achievement, and after all we see that he's expressed this by the body no
less than by the head, by this living cage of ribs, by those tense architectural muscles of
the pelvis, above all by this huge Florentine hand so far from the antique tradition of ideal beauty.
And since, in the end, civilization depends on man extending his powers of mind and spirit to
the utmost, we must reckon the appearance of Michelangelo's David as one of the great events
in the history of Western man. And this brings us back to Rome and to the terrible Pope. In fact,
I'm sitting in the papal garden in the Vatican. Julius II wasn't only ambitious for the Catholic
Church, he was ambitious for Julius II, and in his new temple he planned to erect the most
grandiose tomb of any ruler since the time of Hadrian. It was a staggering example of superbia,
what we call megalomania, and Michelangelo at that time wasn't without the same characteristic.
I didn't go into the question of why the tomb was never built. There was a quarrel. Heroes don't
easily tolerate the company of other heroes, nor does it matter to us what the tomb was going to
look like. All that matters is that some of the figures made for it survive, and they are something
new to the European spirit, something that neither antiquity nor the great civilizations of India and
China had ever dreamt of. As a matter of fact, the two most finished of them were derived from
antiques, but Michelangelo has given them a complex in their life that was almost unknown in antiquity,
and he has made them convey their emotional conflicts by the action of their bodies.
They're conceived as captives, bound captives, one of them struggling to be free from what?
From mortality, from the weight of his muscle-bound body, derived as we know from a Roman figure of a
boxer, and the other sensuously resigned, half in love with easeful death. Michelangelo had in mind
a Greek figure of the dying son of Niobe. These two are carved in the round, but the others,
assuming they were part of the same set, are unfinished. Their bodies emerge from the marble
with the kind of premonitory rumbling that one gets in the Ninth Symphony, and then sink back
into it. To some extent, the rough marble is like shadow in a Rembrandt, a means of concentrating on
the parts that are felt most intensely, but it also seems to imprison the figures. In fact,
they're always known as the prisoners, although there's no sign of bonds or shackles.
As with the finished captives, one feels that they express Michelangelo's deepest preoccupation,
the struggle of the soul to free itself from matter. I'm standing in the Sistine Chapel,
and above my head is one of the greatest works of man, Michelangelo's ceiling. People sometimes
wonder why the Italian Renaissance didn't make more of a contribution to philosophy.
The answer is that the most profound thought at the time wasn't expressed in language, but in
painting, just as in the early 18th century, it was expressed through music. And of this truism,
the chief example is Michelangelo's ceiling. We owe it to Julius II. Ever since Michelangelo's
earliest biography, the Pope has been blamed for diverting his energies from the tomb, on which
he'd set his heart, and putting him to work on the paintings of the Sistine ceiling. It was even said
to be a plot devised by his enemies. Well, I think it was a stroke of inspiration. The original
project of the tomb included almost 40 marble figures, over life-size. How could Michelangelo
ever have done it? It's true that he carved marble faster than any mason, but even with his heroic
energy, the tomb would have taken him 20 years, during which time his mind was changing and
developing. And the very fact that, in the ceiling, he decided to depict scenes, not simply to
concentrate on single figures, allowed him a range of experience, which would hardly have been
possible in the more concentrated medium of sculpture. Look at this woman holding her child
in front of her, and these piled-up men looking across the flooded landscape. And this wretched
woman lying there in misery, abandoned. All these show a human side of Michelangelo,
which will scarcely appear again. A ceiling also allowed him to express his thoughts
about the divine player. But were they his thoughts? You know, in most philosophical
paintings of the Renaissance, the ideas were suggested by poets and theologians.
But in one of Michelangelo's letters, he says that the Pope had told him to paint what he liked.
So, I suppose, that the subject of the ceiling was largely his own idea. And perhaps this is
one of the reasons why it's so difficult to interpret. It's an extremely complex work.
Viewed from the ground, there's an acute physical difficulty in concentrating long enough to relate
the scenes and the individual figures to each other. Some scenes are clear, the contrast between
the confident sensual twist of Eve's body before the fall, and the huddled desperate animal after.
As for the general scheme, I think at least one thing is certain. The Sistine ceiling
passionately asserts the unity of man's body, mind, and spirit. You can admire the ceiling
from the point of view of the body, as 19th century critics used to do, who looked first
at the so-called athletes. Or from the point of view of the mind, as one does when one looks at
those great embodiments of intellectual energy, the prophets and civils. But when one looks at
the sequence of stories from Genesis, I think one feels that Michelangelo was chiefly concerned
with the spirit. As narrative, they begin with the creation and end with the drunkenness of Noah.
But Michelangelo compels us to read them in reverse order, and indeed they were painted
in the reverse order. Over our head as we enter the chapel is the figure of Noah, where the body
has taken complete possession. At the other end, over the altar, is the Almighty dividing light
from darkness, in which the body has been completely transformed into a symbol of the spirit,
and even the head, with its two evident human associations, has become indistinct.
In between these scenes comes the central episode, the creation of man. It's one of those rare works
which are both supremely great and wholly accessible, even to those who don't normally
respond to works of art. Its meaning is clear and impressive at first sight, and yet the longer
one knows it, the deeper it strikes. Man, with a body of unprecedented splendor, is reclining on
the ground in the pose of all those river gods and wine gods of the ancient world who belonged
to the earth and did not aspire to leave it. He stretches out his hand so that it almost touches
the hand of God, and an electric charge seems to pass between their fingers. Out of this glorious
physical specimen, God has created a human soul. Behind the Almighty and the crook of his arm is
the figure of Eve, already in the creator's thoughts, and already one feels a potential
source of trouble. It's possible, I think, to interpret the whole of the Sistine ceiling as a
poem on the subject of creation, that god-like gift which so much occupies the thoughts of a
naissance man. After God has brought Adam to life come those scenes of the Almighty in the act of
creation, which form a sort of crescendo. The movement accelerates from one scene to the next.
First of all, God dividing the waters from the earth, and the spirit of God moved upon the face
of the waters. I don't know why these words give one such a feeling of peace, but they do.
And Michelangelo has conveyed it by a tranquil movement, a gesture of benediction. In the next
scene, the creation of the sun and moon, he doesn't bless or evoke but commands, as if dealing with
these fiery elements required all his authority and speed. And to the left, he swishes off the
scene to create the planets. Finally, we're back at the separation of light and darkness.
Of the rare attempts of finite man to set down an image of infinite energy, this seems to be the
most convincing. One might even say the most realistic, because photographs of the formation
of stellar nuclei show very much the same swirling movement. Michelangelo's power of prophetic
insight gives one the feeling that he belongs to every epoch, most of all perhaps to the epoch of
the great romantics, of which we are still the almost bankrupt heirs. It's the quality that
distinguishes him most sharply from his brilliant rival, the second hero of this program, Raphael.
Raphael was above all a man of his age. Even in his early work, still painted in the clear
self-contained style of the 15th century, he's begun to absorb and harmonize all that was being
felt or thought by the finest spirits of his time. He is the supreme harmonizer. That's why he's out
of favor today. One couldn't write a bestseller about Raphael. I suppose one must allow that,
as works of art. Raphael's frescoes aren't all that easy to enjoy. Even in the 18th century,
when Raphael stood at the summit of an established Olympus, Sir Joshua Reynolds warned young artists
not to be disappointed by their first visit to the stance, but to go on looking and looking
till finally they understood the restrained but perfectly balanced language in which he
expresses his ideas. I've tried to follow his advice over the last 40 years, and I promise you
it's been worth the effort. Raphael came from Urbino, where his father was called painter,
and it's reasonable to suppose that he was introduced to the papal service by his compatriot
Bramante, who was not only the architect of the new St Peter's, but seems to have been on relatively
intimate terms with Julius II. At the time, Raphael was 27. He'd only once tried his hand
at mural painting. He'd shown no evidence at all that he could cope pictorially with great ideas,
and yet Julius had the insight to commission this young man to decorate the library and study,
which was to be the center of the pope's life, where he was to meditate on theology, decide on
action. The decorations must in some sense project and harmonize his thoughts. No doubt Raphael had
much of his boyhood in Urbino, in the Paris library, where paintings of poets and philosophers
and theologians were placed above the shelves containing their books, and when he came in time
to decorate what in effect was a branch of the papal library, he determined to carry the same
idea further. He would not only portray the figures whose books were in the shelves below,
he would relate them to each other and to the whole discipline in which they formed a part.
He must have had advice from the learned cultivated men who made up about a third
of the papal curia, but that sublime company wasn't assembled by a committee.
It represents human reason. It's always known as the school of Athens, and on the opposite wall
is divine reason, known for some reason as the disputa. On the subsidiary wall, the window wall,
is poetic inspiration, Apollo and the Muses, known as the Parnassus. Everything in the groups is
thought out. For example, of the two central figures in the school of Athens, Plato, the idealist,
is on the left, and he points upwards to divine inspiration, and beyond him to the left are the
philosophers who appeal to intuition and to the emotions. We recognize Socrates, but many of the
We can be certain only that these noble human beings are passionately engaged in a search for
truth. To the right is Aristotle, the man of good sense, holding out a moderating hand,
and beside him are the representatives of rational activities, logic, grammar, and geometry.
Curiously enough, Rapha has put his own portrait in this group, next to a bearded philosopher who
seems to be an ideal portrait of Leonardo da Vinci, perhaps intended to represent Pythagoras,
and below them is a group of beautiful young men looking over the shoulder of a bald-headed
geometer, Euclid, I suppose. He is certainly a portrait of Bramante, and it's fitting that he
should be there because the noble piece of architecture in which these representatives
of human reason are assembled must, I think, represent Bramante's dream of the new Saint
Peter's. Rapha himself was later to become an architect, and a very fine architect, but in 1510
he couldn't possibly have conceived a building like this, one of the most life-enhancing effects
of space in art. It may have been designed by Bramante, but Rapha has made it his own.
Like all great artists, he was a borrower, but he absorbed his borrowings more than most.
One has a vague feeling that these figures are inspired by Hellenistic sculpture. I suppose
that's one of the things that makes him distasteful to us, but every figure in this picture is pure
Rapha, or every figure but one. This morose philosopher does not occur in the drawing,
the full-size drawing for the fresco which by a miracle has survived. We can see where he comes
from, the Sistine Ceiling. Michelangelo wouldn't let anyone in there while he was at work,
but Bramante had the key, and one day when Michelangelo was away, he took Rapha in with him.
Who cares? The great artist takes what he needs. While human reason is rooted to the earth,
divine wisdom floats in the sky above the heads of those philosophers, theologians, and church
fathers who have tried to interpret it. For all these figures, Raphael made studies which are
models of the academic style of drawing. He even made nude studies of whole groups that get the
underlying structure solid and real enough. How Michelangelesque that left-hand figure is.
Then other studies of the flow of drapery, but when he came to the final design, all these ideas
are enriched and developed. The seekers after revealed truth are arranged the same regard for
their relations with each other, and with the philosophic scheme of the whole room, that exists
in the school of Athens, insofar as civilization consists in grasping imaginatively all that's best
the thought of a time. These walls represent a summit of civilization. We feel Rapha had more
often allowed himself this vein of sensuous poetry, which in its way is quite as civilizing
as his intellectual abstractions. Michelangelo took no interest in the opposite sex. Leonardo
thought of women solely as reproductive mechanisms, but Raphael loved the girls as much as any Venetian.
Soon after this portrait was painted, Julius II died, and his successor, Leo X,
doesn't look at all like a hero. I suppose Rapha tried to make this portrait as flattering as
possible, but what a contrast to the old warrior. Rapha remained on in the papal service and was
asked to do everything from the rebuilding of St. Peter's to the decoration of a very pagan
bathroom for Cardinal Bibiana. Of course he couldn't do it all himself. For such a project
as the Lodge of the Vatican, one must imagine him making dozens of slight sketches, handing them
out right and left to his brilliant young pupils, really young, Giulio Romano was only 16.
Someone said of Courbet that he produced pictures of an apple tree produces apples.
The same is true of Rapha, except that his apples were fruits of the imagination,
and sometimes achieved such grace and finality that they stamped themselves with the European
mind for 300 years. However, one of the commissions of this period had a more questionable influence.
This was a series of designs for the tapestries which were to be hung in the Sistine Chapel.
With the thought of Michelangelo's ceiling above them, Raphael took a lot of trouble about them,
and of course they are masterpieces. Masterpieces of composition in the tradition of the early
Florentines, masterpieces of elevated imagination. But their very nobility was dangerous.
They're concerned with the lives of the apostles Peter and Paul. Well, St. Peter was a poor
fisherman. Raphael has made him and all his companions uniformly handsome and noble.
Where can one find more impressive human types than in the group of apostles who listened to
Christ's charge, feed my sheep? It may be good for us to leave our daily chores and move in high
company for a short time, but this convention by which the events in biblical or secular history
could be enacted only by magnificent physical specimens, handsome and well-groomed, went on for
too long. Till the middle of the 19th century, in fact. Only a very few artists, perhaps only
Caravaggio and Rembrandt in the first rank, were independent enough to stand against it.
And I think that the convention, which was an element in the so-called grand manner,
became a deadening influence on the European mind. It deadened our sense of truth, even our sense of
responsibility, and led, as we see in modern art, to a hideous reaction. In the autumn of 1513, soon
after the death of Julius, there arrived in the Belvedere, almost exactly where I am now, one more
giant, Leonardo da Vinci. Historians used to speak of him as a typical Renaissance man, a kind of
Well, that's a mistake. In fact, he belongs to no epoch. He fits into no category, and the more you
know about him, the more utterly mysterious he becomes. Of course, he had certain Renaissance
characteristics. He loved beauty and graceful movement. He shared, or even anticipated, the
megalomania of the early 16th century. The horse that he modeled as a memorial to Francesco Sforza
was with 26 feet high. He made schemes for diverting the River Arno that even modern
technology couldn't accomplish. And then, of course, he had, to a supreme degree, the gift of his time
for recording and condensing whatever took his eye. But all these gifts were dominated by one
ruling passion, which was not a Renaissance characteristic, curiosity. He was the most
relentlessly curious man in history. Everything he saw made him ask why and how, particularly
and he's left his answers in thousands of sheets of paper and scores of notebooks. I've got in my
hands the facsimile of one of these, manuscript B. It deals with practical problems. Mill wheels,
toothed wheels, ratchets, architecture, a tower for the Ducal Palace in Milan, the Castello Sforzesco,
a church in the style of his friend Bramante. Leonardo was obsessed with the idea of putting
a round dome onto a square base and a stable for the Duke of Milan's famous horses. Very grand
stable, the hayloft above, the feeding bars on either side, and a drainage system down the middle.
And then the other aspect of Leonardo's mind is interest in theoretical and mathematical problems.
This you see in a manuscript called manuscript A, where he's studying the light falling,
action of light falling on a sphere, and the interruption of light forming this continuous
modeling. It looks abstract enough, but in fact it was the theoretical study of light falling on a
sphere that enabled Leonardo to achieve the incredibly precise, scientifically precise,
continuous modeling of the head of the Mona Lisa. You can see from these manuscripts that
Leonardo's curiosity was matched by an indefatigable energy. He's never satisfied
with a single answer. He goes on asking the same question again and again, worrying it,
restating it, countering imaginary antagonists, till the reader is absolutely worn out.
Fortunately, he also left answers in the form of drawings, which are, or appear to be,
easier to take in. One can enjoy them for the way in which his eye grasps each form,
and his hands set it down with a unifying rhythm. But one mustn't forget that they are all,
or nearly all, answers to questions. How does one stream of water deflect another?
What is the cause of whirlpools? How are rocks formed? What is the reason for stratification?
How do storm clouds build up? How do trees mass together? How does a twig support its load of
acorns? How do blackberries mass on a branch? Why do the leaves of a star of Bethlehem resemble
the movement of water? What is the structure of a bird's wing? How does a bird fly?
Of all these questions, the ones he asks most insistently concern man. Not the man
of Alberti's invocation with wit, reason, and memory like an immortal god, but man as a mechanism.
How does he digest? How does the heart pump blood? How does a child live in the womb?
How does he speak? Is it by using his throat muscles or his tongue? And finally, why does he
die of old age? Leonardo discovered a centenarian in a hospital in Florence and waited gleefully
for his demise in order to examine his veins. Every question demanded dissection, and every
dissection was drawn with marvelous precision. And at the end, what does he find? That man,
although remarkable as a mechanism, is not at all like an immortal god. He's not only cruel
and superstitious, but feeble. If Michelangelo's defiance of fate was heroic, there is something
almost more magnificent in the way that Leonardo, that great hero of the intellect, confronts the
inexplicable, ungovernable forces of nature. And it was in Rome, in the very year that Raphael was
celebrating the godlike human intellect, that Leonardo used his scientific knowledge of the
movement of water to express his feelings of human insignificance. The painstaking way in which he
depicts these disasters shows a strange mixture of relish and tragic indignation. On the one hand,
he's the patient observer of hydrodynamics. On the other hand, he is King Lear defying the deluge.
Low winds, uncrack your cheeks. Rage and blow, you cataracts and hurricanes.
Spout till you won't drench our steeples. Drown the cocks. We are used to catastrophes. We see them
every day on film and television. They contribute to our pessimism. But coming from a perfectly
endowed man of the Renaissance, these extraordinary drawings of the world destroyed by flood
are prophetic. The golden moment was almost over. But while it lasted, man achieved a stature that
he's hardly ever achieved before or since. Because to the humanist virtues of intelligence was added
the quality of heroic will. For a few years it seemed that there was nothing which the human
mind couldn't master and harmonize.
