Can You Win At Chess If You're Untalented?

Chess Master
75 followers
Exactly.
And I would also say that Hikaru, although at times I felt like he...
Doesn't care.
Has lost his motivation and will to win.
So recently Dubov made a very interesting comment on one of the podcasts that he's been on recently
and it was targeted at you. Let's see what he had to say and your reaction to it.
So the goal is basically to become at least of the same level as Magnus in terms of chest strength.
No, no, not Magnus, of course, but like Fabi, let's say.
Fabi actually in that sense, Fabi is a very, very inspiring example because for me,
like I really hope Fabi, if you will watch this, like that's what I think and it's actually like,
I mean it as a compliment.
I seriously think that Fabi is probably like in terms of the natural gift.
Fabi is like one of, I don't know, like he's arguably the least talented player of the whole
like top, I don't know, 20, 30.
At least for me.
And it's very inspiring because with Magnus, I mean, sometimes you see those
like moments of genius and you can say to yourself, okay, like, I don't know how he,
I mean, like I cannot do this.
I can work a lot still.
No, no, I mean, of course it's a 25 minute video, so like I don't want to pause it too
much at the start, but here's what I'm going to be honest and here's what's really important to
note.
What's really important to note when you look at a topic like this is what is the criteria that
you're basing everything off of?
So in my opinion, what Dubov is basing this off of is Dubov is basically, he's basically
saying that natural talent, at least as my perception is about blitz and rapid chess
specifically.
And the value of your actual talent is showcased much more in rapid and blitz than in
classical chess.
So that's what I think Dubov's criteria is.
You have to understand what the criteria or the basis is for making such statements.
And my perception is Dubov is talking specifically about blitz and rapid chess.
And because you have to move quickly, it showcases pure talent versus hard work.
That's what I think he's trying to say.
But let's, let's see, let's see how Fabiano perceives it, because I assume that's what
Fabiano is going to say too.
At least that's my perception.
At least, you know, and it's not going to change.
Yes, and actually you're right.
Actually, as someone in chat says, you're right.
When he's saying about no talent, very, very clearly it's saying that when you have to
play with no preparation, you show up and you have to find good moves with very little
time.
And so that's what I think Dubov is effectively basing it off of.
There are just things that he feels and you cannot do much about it.
But with Fabi, like, I don't think there is like a single thing like chess thing that
Fabi can do and like many, many other players cannot.
I don't think it exists.
It's very much about the winner's mentality.
It's about his routine, openings, a lot of work, tremendous amounts of work.
So basically what he says, it's that you're putting in absolutely tremendous amounts of
work.
You're the least talented, naturally gifted player in the top 20, which I think is complete
bogus.
But I mean, this is this is the problem with the whole thing.
Like I said, I mean, the big problem with the whole thing ultimately is that when you
look at this, it's like it's like a compliment, but it's also an insult at the same time.
That's the problem.
And again, without like a basic criteria, like because here's an example, I could put
it the other way.
I could say, I think classical chess is the best example of how good you are, because
I could say, well, look at classical.
You have to work very hard.
You have to do great opening preparation.
You have to have great calculation.
You have to be able to think for a long time, but also play with very little time on the
clock.
So like the problem with this whole thing or this whole argument, I'm sure Fabian, I
assume he's going to say something along these lines is like the criteria.
There's no hard set criteria.
So without explaining what your criteria is like, it's very, it's like it's hard.
You can't be objective.
And that's the big problem that I have with this is because you could, you could say anything.
I mean, if you want to talk about rapid and blitz, you could buy that metric.
Yes.
I think Dubov is not wrong.
Fabiano's results in rapid and blitz chess are much worse than say myself, Magnus or
Ali Reza.
But on the other hand, you can say like hard work and having to do a lot of opening preparation
is a massive talent in it, massive talent in and of itself.
So it's like, that's really the problem is like, it's not, it's not really an objective
take.
And I think Dubov probably should have clarified.
I think with a lot of things in chess without a clear, without a specific clarification
or specific criteria of what you're basing it off of, it doesn't really work very well.
But that's the problem.
He literally was St. Louis rapid and blitz last year.
Yes.
But the thing is in the world rapid and blitz, he's never done very well.
He's not, he's not been close.
Um, he's, I, have you ever gotten a metal even?
I don't think he's even gotten a metal and rapid in the world rapid and blitz, but, but
that's the problem.
That's the problem is like you, unless you're going to say, look, I base this off of rapid
and blitz period.
That's it.
Then it's just, it's just like, it's crazy.
It's just crazy.
So, uh, he got a metal and rapid two years ago.
It was probably the year that I didn't play.
I'm guessing.
Um, so that's probably why I was unaware of it, but, but at any rate, yeah, it's just,
it's, it's really, I mean, I, I personally, the way that I look at it is I think hard
work is definitely a thing.
Um, and I, I think trying to say that's not a talent.
I mean, cause also, you know what else I could say?
I could also say, look at, um, you know, why is the Fabiano comes up with better ideas
than like do Bob?
Or why, why, why is that?
I mean, everybody, everybody is the same engines.
Everybody's using the same stuff.
Why does Fabiano come up with better ideas?
Like that is a talent in and of itself.
I mean, is it not?
Even if he's not doing the work specifically as his team, like the team or him, whatever
it might be, like everybody should be able to find the same ideas.
Everybody has the same equipment.
Everybody, everybody's got like, you've got access to the exact same engines.
Everybody's got stockfish, Lila, Komodo torch, everything else.
Like everyone's got access to the same stuff.
So like, again, why isn't everyone else coming up with it?
So you can make an argument.
That's a talent too.
On the other hand, I think Dubai is basically saying that, you know, engines have, have
I mean, my take is to do, I was saying engines have ruined the game.
There's no creativity.
It's just, you, you plug in the moves and that's that.
But there are holes even, even in that, even in that, that, that argument too.
So I really just like, I don't, I mean, I know what do Bob's trying to say, but I don't
really agree with it because I think it really is diminishing how important hard work and
opening preparation really are because you can't get very good without putting in a lot
of time, no matter who you are.
I want to see your reaction to that.
Well, okay.
So first of all, I do Bob says that he doesn't mean it as like a criticism or insult, which
I think is true.
And he means it as a compliment, which again, I'm, I'm certainly not taking this as a personal
thing.
So I don't see it as either an insult or compliment.
He says it's a compliment.
Some people would.
Yeah.
I mean, the problem with statement is it's both.
It can be a compliment.
It can be an insult.
You don't really know.
So Fabian is not wrong with what he says here at all.
I mean, it's like, it's both.
I'm contradicting my own statement.
What do you mean?
How am I contradicting my own statement?
What are you talking about?
I don't, I don't know exactly what you're saying.
I'd see this as, as a bit of an insult.
Um, someone say it really depends on your perspective of what you would call a natural
gift and what you would call hard work and which is more valuable to, it's going to be
very individual thing.
The thing which I, I never really understood is like when we say natural talent, I don't
really know what this means.
Yep.
Also true.
When, when we talk about someone's level.
Yeah.
Because Fabiano is probably going to say, it's like, you say natural talent, but like,
for example, if Fabiano never, like if I didn't study chess with computers and study
openings, natural talent basically means how good are you without any other resource?
So by that match, by that metric, Paul Morphy is easily, easily the greatest chess player
to have ever played chess.
Not even close.
Cause he had no computers.
He had very basic books.
He had to learn everything on the fly.
But as we know, in modern day chess, if you don't have, if you don't use any resources,
you're not going to be good no matter how naturally talented you are.
You're just, you're just not going to be good.
You're, you're just not going to be good at all.
That's, that's the reality.
So that, that's why I think Fabiano is about to say this.
We understand we go by rating and foreign victories, accomplishments, and so on.
And there's like objective criteria, right?
You know, you, uh, Hikaru is this rating?
Magnus is this rating?
And then we can measure people by their results.
When we speak about talent, it's not something that's really quantifiable.
Exactly.
Yep.
So this is, it's going to be a very subjective thing.
And usually I think we use it as a helpful metric, a subjective metric, but still a helpful
one to determine if like a young player is very promising.
So you, you, you talk to, or you work with, let's say an eight year old player.
And of course they're not very strong yet, but you can see, or you can try to, to gauge,
uh, how strong they will be in the future.
And we call that like natural gift, right?
I think it's, I think it's just instincts, right?
Instincts.
Um, understanding of where to place natural understanding of where to place the pieces.
And I mean, my, my personal take, by the way, is all this is nonsense.
I think it's a, it's a complete package.
Like, I mean, trying to say that someone's terrible or, you know, this, that, or the
other thing matters more matters less.
Uh, I mean, I think at the end of the day, it's all nonsense.
It's just a complete package.
I don't think you can really quantify it in any way and say, so-and-so is better than
so-and-so.
Like, yes, you can say Magnus, Magnus, myself, and Ali Reza were clearly the three best blitz
players by rating, but I don't think that has any, I mean, you can't say that's natural
talent.
It's a combination of hard work, playing many games online, for example, or playing
many games over the board and blitz.
Like it's not, it's just not, it's just not really the same thing.
Um, so I, I think it's all kind of silly.
This generally comes at an early age and you can kind of understand where that player
is going to go based on that.
I think this is what he's hinting at.
Okay.
But again, it's like natural, natural feel for where to put the pieces.
I mean, we don't really, we speak about this for, um, for determining if like a young player
will get very, very strong, but of course top players all have natural feeling of where
to put the pieces.
And, and of course, yeah, it may vary, but then there's also other aspects of chess,
like calculation ability, tactical awareness, which I think is one of my weaker sides.
Like, and I think that's one of the strongest sides.
And also one of Magnus' strongest sides is like just quick tactical awareness.
Tactical awareness, really?
Yeah.
But there's like a million factors in chess, like my...
But I mean, but, but Magnus also just happens to have good awareness, period.
Like, I'll give you another example of good awareness.
Like, like a good example of awareness is, um, uh, a good example of awareness is that
Magnus in Blitz games are moments where he knows to stop and think for like 20 seconds.
And that is like an innate ability that he has that no one else has.
Like he can sense it, even if it's tactical or positional, he can sense when something's
wrong and he'll be able to stop and think for 20 seconds.
Like he did it against me in title Tuesday, actually.
Uh, there was a critical moment in this last title Tuesday, round 11, where we played,
and he just slowed down and thought for 20 seconds and he moved the wrong rook, but he
still could sense it.
He could sense that there was something there in the position.
And that is like, that, for example, is something that I would say is just like, no one else
possesses that ability.
No one else possesses that ability to just like feel it.
Like it's just that innate ability, um, to feel the position.
So Magnus definitely has some things more than anybody else, but, but overall, um, I
mean, Fabiano is completely right here.
This is all very, very subjective.
Um, is probably one of my stronger sides.
And in the past, it's been more of a stronger side.
Like now it's, it's changed a bit, but in the past, I think that was, I was, uh, in
terms of like ability to accurately and thoroughly calculate a position.
Um, I was maybe, maybe the best, um, or equal best.
And now I don't think that's really the case anymore because chess has changed and players
have changed and I've also changed, but, but we're again, we're now, now we're talking
about, uh, different things in chess, not about talent, but about skills, right?
When we say talent.
I'm trying, I think, I think Icarus trying to be moderate, but this Dubov guy was very
unlikable.
I mean, basically my, I'm sure we're going to hear more about this, but my take is it
feels like Dubov salty.
It feels like Dubov is very much a purist towards chess.
And he feels like the better you are without computer engines and programs, like the better
you actually are, like, you know, the more natural ability to play a position that's
like equal on move 10 versus like getting some massive advantage with some insane preparation,
for example.
But it's like, it feels very much like he's salty.
Cause he's as pure as where he, like, he hates the chess to become this game where people
can prepare so, so deeply.
But on the other hand, the problem with that take is that he can do it too.
He has access to the exact same resources.
That's the problem with the whole take is that like anybody can do it.
So why can't you do it too?
Um, that, that's really the problem that that's really the problem.
Like, why can't you, why can't Dubov study 12 hours a day as well?
I mean, that's the thing, you know, Fabiano can do it.
Why can't Dubov do it as well?
There's, there's no, there's nothing saying that Dubov can't study 12 hours a day.
So like, just saying.
What does it mean?
It's like someone who, who is completely raw and someone who's completely raw is someone
who hasn't been exposed to a chess.
So we're talking about young players.
So again, we're talking about, um, what metric can we use to determine if a young player
will become very good.
But when we're talking about 30 year old plus players, like I'm me, Magnus, Hikaru, and
so on, I don't really know what, what talent means.
Like you have ratings and you have accomplishments, which determines skill.
And we don't really know what went into the skill.
Like how, how did you get that skill?
Yeah.
And I think this is something that, uh, Gary also mentioned when he was on our podcast,
he mentioned the fact that, um, the work that you're putting in the routine that you
are setting up for yourself and the work that you're willing to do should be a part of the
talent should be a part of the talent discussion.
Yeah, of course.
I agree.
Being able to work hard is first of all, uh, essential and it is also a, an ability in
itself.
You could call it a talent if you want, but it's also one that pretty much everyone at
the top possesses.
There's not a single player.
I'll just get like the top 30 list or the 2700 list.
And especially if we look at the top 10, but if we look at anyone over 2700, there's not
a single player who has not devoted enormous amounts of work.
Now there are players who have worked more or less than others.
And it's hard to measure that because we don't know, right.
We don't have insight into everyone's work.
Also though, also as Fabian was saying here, the other thing that's very difficult about
this is when he talks about like top 30, what, what, what even does work mean for someone
studying 12 hours a day can be the way they get very good for another player playing 12
for another player playing 12 hours of blitz online can help them improve.
So like, even this is very, very subjective because like no, no two people are the exact
same in terms of how they learn or how they get very good.
I mean, that, that's really actually the problem.
It's all so subjective that there's nothing that you can really say about this.
Um, and like, I would just use myself an example.
If I weren't streaming and I were actually a pro chess player for me past a certain number
of hours, if I'm studying more than say five hours a day, the information is just going
to go right out of one ear.
It's going to go in one ear out the other ear.
Like my mind, I will not be able to remember stuff if I study more than five hours a day.
But for example, there might be other players who can study 10 hours a day and they will
actually remember everything that they're looking at.
So it's again, very, very subjective.
No two people are the same.
There's no one box that you can fit everybody in.
And that's why the whole thing is, it's just like, I mean, I get what Dubov is saying,
but I find it kind of, uh, I find it kind of, it, it just, it rubs me the wrong way.
It really does.
For some watching car streams as part of the work to get good.
Obviously, obviously everybody's got a different routine.
It's no different than like education for, that's one of the hardest things in education
these days is that you try to standardize like test taking, for example, or things along
these lines.
And for one per for one kid, it works phenomenally well following a straightforward routine for
taking tests for another kid.
They don't learn the same way.
They struggle very, very heavily, um, with, with, with test taking.
So it's like, that's, that's why the whole thing is, it's just kind of silly to me, but
let's keep going.
And their work ethic.
Um, if we're talking about like Magnus, he maybe has worked the most just because he's
played so many world championship matches and, and to, to prepare for a very clear goal
like that, you essentially get a bunch of people together and then you work all day
for weeks at a time.
And I'm, you know, that because we've done this right for, for big goals like the campus
or the world championship match that I've played, but he's played five world championship
matches.
So he's, he's done that absolutely dedicated work more than, uh, other people at the top,
uh, except for maybe Vishy who has, uh, like from my understanding has, has one of the
best work ethics.
And, um, and I, I, I'm, I'm not speaking from experience with him, but I've heard from
people who've worked with him, like Rustam Kazanjanovic that basically his work ethic
is unparalleled.
But especially when you have a clear goal, like a world championship match, it's very
easy to motivate yourself for that type of work.
While if your goal is, let's say to win some open tournament, it's a lot less motivating.
And I think this is part of why you have achieved such longevity at the top, because
outside of the candidates outside of the world championship match that you've trained for,
you also putting enormous amounts of work every single day.
And I think this is something that he's touching upon as well.
The mentality, the winner's mentality.
Um, actually, what do you think he means when he says, um, you possess a certain winner's
mentality that allows you to stay at the top compared to everybody else in the top 20 that
might, you know, I don't even know what this means myself, by the way, winners.
I don't even know what Dubov is saying here.
Well, so again, now it's, it's another sort of vague term, which means something to Dubov
that may mean something different to me, right?
When, when I hear of like winner's mentality, and I think also people will disagree about
who has like more winner's mentality or who has less, because this is again, quite a subjective
sort of thing.
Um, I would say this is very subjective too, because I'll give you an example.
Everyone would say that Magnus has the best winner's mentality, but that's just because
Magnus happens to win the most.
If Magnus weren't winning the most, I don't think he would say he has the best winner's
mentality.
He just happens to win the most.
So we, so we sort of associate Magnus with that.
Um, so like, again, this is one of those things that like, you know, it's just, it doesn't
really work because if Magnus were, if Magnus were losing a bunch of important games, we
would not be saying he's got the best winner's mentality, but everybody in the chess world
would say Magnus has the best winner's mentality, but it's just because he happens to win the
most.
Magnus hates losing the most.
Maybe, maybe, but I mean, still like, I don't even know where this is going.
I'm starting to lose my train of thought too.
Is that like when you approach a game or when you approach a tournament, you basically
think I'm here to win it.
And you kind of think you're the main character in a sense, right?
Not that, not that like you, you are a second party to someone else, but that you're the
one who, uh, who's there to win.
And then you're just facing an obstacle, which again, I, I think I do possess that
to a great extent.
That's, that would be my interpretation of it.
Uh, but again, if you look at the top, I think like from players that I've played against,
obviously Magnus has that in about the greatest, uh, quantity that you can imagine.
And I would also say that Hikaru, although at times I felt like he doesn't care, has
lost his motivation and will to win.
Um, but generally speaking, yeah, he, he does view himself as like the guy to go and win.
Right.
Yes.
Uh, and from the young players, like who catch.
This is actually really funny to hear Fabiano say, this is actually really funny to hear
Fabiano say, because, uh, because, but he, he sort of like, he says both, he says like,
he says sometimes I want to win.
And then it's sometimes I don't care, which is, it's interesting to, it's interesting
to see, hear Fabiano say that he's, he's basically saying that I have a mix.
He's saying that like, I don't care, but I do care.
Basically.
So it's interesting.
And Notre back.
Although I don't know them too well, it's very evident that Gukash does possess this
and that Notre back does possess this.
I would agree with Notre back for sure.
With Ali Ali residents, a bit less clear again, because I don't know.
It's, it's like, I'm not in someone's head.
Right.
So you can, you can maybe read too much into someone's.
No, no, Fabio.
I would actually, I agree with pretty much everything Fabiano has said, though.
I would say like with Notre back and Gukash, you definitely feel that, um, with, uh, with
all the residents, it's very, it's very confusing because sometimes you feel like he's completely
there and he's like, he's in it to win it.
And then sometimes you feel like he's just showing up.
Like it's, it's very Ali Reza out of all the top players.
He's the one that it's really the hardest to, to sort of read or understand, which I
think Fabiano is about to say.
Uh, and to someone without knowing really how they are, who they are, if you don't know
them, uh, them quite well, but okay.
With Ali residents clear that still, he's, he's like trying to win every tournament he's
playing.
So you, again, who, who at the top does not have this, this, um, will to win this sort
of winner's mentality, if you want to call it that.
Yeah.
Winner's mentality, killer's instinct.
I mean, I think, I think, yeah, you could say winner's mentality, killer instinct, as
Christian just says, you could say like a will to win.
Like, I mean, all you can use 20 different ways to say the same thing.
Basically, I guess some people would call it, there's different names for it.
I would assume.
Anyway, I think this is, this probably sums up, um, Wesley, you know, actually, actually
I would agree that you guys are right.
That when you talk, when you get beyond the top 10, it's not clear, but like you talk
about Dominguez or you talk about a Wesley.
I mean, I would agree that those are guys who do not possess it anymore.
Dominguez is just a little bit too old.
I mean, he's too old.
He's like 42 years old.
But Wesley So is definitely someone where you feel like he's showing up.
He wants to win his one or two games, collect his paycheck and go home.
He is definitely someone who I would say, I don't think possesses anywhere near as much
of the winner's mentality.
He's very happy to win his one, two games, make a bunch of draws and go home with his,
with his big check.
Um, so, so yeah, now someone's probably gonna make a video out of drama that, oh, oh my
God.
Like I said that, I said, I said that Wesley So doesn't have a winner's mentality.
He's not talented.
He's a terrible chess player and everything else, but let's keep going.
You know, I, I just want to say, like, I, I understand his opinion.
I'll just like finish up quickly.
Like I understand more or less what he's going for, but I feel like this is a issue of kind
of, uh, vague language, which maybe means something to him that it means something different
to someone else.
And it doesn't really, it's not a very accurate metric.
Um, so when he says like someone is the most or the least talented in, in, you know, chess
among the top 50 or top 30 or whatever, then I don't exactly know what that means.
And I think that if he tried to start ranking people by their talent, he would realize that,
that it starts to become a bit meaningless.
Like maybe he would put Magnus at number one and nobody would, uh, would argue and maybe
he'd put Ali Reza at number two.
But then like, besides some things that maybe people would agree on.
Yeah, because see, here's the problem.
I mean, basically the only way that he can do this, I mean, Fabian is not saying this
specifically.
It doesn't seem like, but is that Dubov basically saying blitz is what matters the most because
you have to play quickly with limited time, no opening prep, none of this stuff, blah,
blah, blah.
And that that's basically what Dubov is ranking it off of.
But again, that's very, very subjective trying to say that blitz with, with no prep is better
because again, natural talent is not a thing.
There would be like very little agreement at some point.
It's going to, I'm going to end up repeating myself too if I say this 20 times.
Uh, or Wesley So.
Jan Nepomniachtchi or Noderbeck, I'll just start.
It's you, you can't like, how, how do you say this?
How do you determine this?
Unless you turn it off at blitz.
It's something which doesn't mean, it doesn't have a clear meaning for me.
I think it's quite subjective and it's based on everybody's interpretation.
Now to illustrate, uh, his point kind of, uh, give him the benefit of the doubt.
We should, um, go into an analysis of one of your games that you play today against
Vincent Keimer division three semifinals.
Oh, you're right.
I think that's it.
Is it just going to turn to a recap?
Oh, it's just going to turn to a recap.
Okay.
So yeah, I mean, I think again, like, uh, in terms, in terms of, of what Dubov is saying,
I mean, he, he, he should come out and just say like, I'm talking about blitz that I consider
blitz to be the purest form of natural talent.
That's, that's what I would say is I think that ultimately, uh, if Dubov just says that,
then we can, it can be much clearer.
There's no, there's more to the interview besides a game recap.
No, it's just a game recap, right?
No, no, it's just a game recap.
That's what it looks like.
Um, I mean, I, I agree.
I agree with Fabiano from the standpoint that, I mean, like, so for example, Dubov frames
it as like, I consider blitz to be like the pure hallmark of who's the best at chess.
Then by that metric, that's Dubov's opinion.
And I would, I mean, probably I, I mostly would agree with Dubov that if you consider
blitz to be the most important thing that yes, Fabiano is not as talented as say Magnus
or Ali Reza or myself.
Um, but blitz is just one form of the game.
I mean, it's one form of the game.
Like you can't suddenly say classical chess doesn't matter.
Like you can't, you can't really make that argument, but I think, I think if Dubov were
to like say that, like then at least it's a lot clearer.
It's not vague the way that it's vague.
Um, and I, and I think that's probably what, that's probably what, what Dubov means is
my guess.
Um, no, but I'm watching the Fabiano react.
I'm not talking about the, this is not the Dubov react.
Um, I think Dubov is a much better blitz player than Fabiano.
I think Dubov is extremely dangerous, extremely creative.
Dubov, however, is also nowhere near as consistent, which is another big part of chess.
Fabiano won't, Fabiano might not shine as brightly as Dubov.
He might not have as many flashy games and blitz, whereas Dubov will have some incredible
masterpieces, but Fabiano is going to be much more consistent overall.
So, so that, that's what I would say.
