Do Personalised Diets Work? - The Zoe App Results - Dr James Gill
The Zoe app has frankly been a revelation, giving the idea of democratising personalised diet medicine, but advertised results are one thing, what do the scientists say?
Now the Zoe approach has been challenged in a randomised control trial in Nature - so what did they study show?
00:00 - How Calories Affect People Differently 01:02 - Why Personalized Nutrition Is Important 01:57 - Insights from the Personalized Diet Study 03:56 - Benefits of Tailored Nutritional Plans 05:00 - Final Thoughts on Personalized Nutrition
we know there's a good deal more to
weight loss and good diet than just
calorie control but that message has
been very difficult to convey and it
seems almost counterintuitive if not
unfair that one person can eat a
particular food with no significant
detriment to their weight and yet
another would have to exert caution with
that particular food and portion size
frankly from a physics perspective the
concept that all calories are not
created equal almost doesn't seem to
make sense but what we have to
appreciate is how an individual's body
interacts with those calories will
differ from one person to the next in
exactly the same way that one person
might naturally have a greater muscle
mass and thus benefit from the strengths
which comes from there another person
might lack that same level of absolute
power but may have a higher level of
endurance so we appreciate our bodies
are different similar with regard to
diet we need to recognize that also
means different fuels will affect us in
different ways there's a new study in
nature medicine with the weighty title
of the effects of personalized nutrition
programs on cardi metabolic Health a
randomized control trial which can
essentially be reframed as does the
personalized diet from the zoak work
Professor Tim Spectre the co-creator of
the zap has been at the Forefront of
democratizing this idea of personalized
nutrition which frankly has been the
sort of Revolution that's been needed in
the public rather than the academic and
clinical nutrition space for the last 30
years it was the sort of thing that we
were talking about when I was at
University 20 years ago the approach to
our personalized diet is becoming
increasingly relevant due to the excess
of processed food which is contributing
to the makeup of the modern diet and the
effect on how that processed food
affects our physiology and our
relationships with food however it's one
thing to have a good hypothesis as the
zc does or bit supported by a strong
scientific rationale it's quite
something else to have that hypothesis
supported by randomized control trial
validating their approach this seems to
be something that has been confirmed
today via this nature medicine article
looking at personalized dietary advice
in the nature article they compared
standard dietary advice against a
personalized dietary program largely
because the study was funded by Zoe but
the results clearly demonstrate a
positive Improvement in a group of fats
called triglycerides additionally they
saw improvements in body weight and a
metric of uh diabetes the
hba1c they also saw diet quality and the
gut microbiome improve all of these are
significant to improving our future
health outcomes especially as we've seen
in the study that 2.3% of body weight
was lost over 18 weeks I mean most
people will be very happy with that as
an outcome now it's vital to highlight
that this study does not suggest Gest
the personalized diet plan is a miracle
intervention several other health
markers they looked at blood pressure
glucose levels insulin levels and other
proteins did not change however there
were also no Adverse Events and there's
no medications being prescribed these
have got to be positive wins and you
know guided diet changes have to be
considered sucess for the patient and
the teams doing these interventions
based upon this outcome obviously there
are many co-founding factors in a study
like this not least as mentioned this
study was funded by the Zoe team which
is a huge Mark of bias an equally
important one is the issue of
intervention bias whereby having this
personalized approach means that active
participation alone is more likely to
promote change in the study group
compared to the controll group who
essentially were given a leaflet with
standard advice however I think it's
important that we highlight the end
point here
that the patients in the personalized
nutritional group overall had improved
health and improved Health surrogate
measures so I would argue that
regardless the intervention is of value
here not least as it moves away from the
negative approach and a calorie
restriction which is the core of many
diet interventions we have at the minute
frankly I personally view this study as
a stronger outcome that the NHS should
look towards this personalized approach
with dietary advice and other aspects of
medicine but particularly with regard to
dietary advice rather than that one size
fits all we currently have a health
emergency in the UK 26% of the
population are classified as obese 38%
of the population are considered
overweight we do already have targeted
inter interventions with regard to
diabetic programs specifically Desmond
referrals for oral early diabetes and
those do have positive outcomes for
patients but to quote and often deployed
Public Health quote you know this study
again I know it's funded by Zoe but the
outcomes we really should be looking at
allocating funds to stop people falling
in the river in the first place rather
than spending money to pulling them out
so I'm not saying go and by the Zoe app
that's not what I'm saying at all what I
am saying is look at the way they have
approached look at the whole idea of
personalized nutrition talk to your GP
ask what it is that you need to change
on a personal level rather than just
generic diet advice and if that means
asking for a double appointment so you
can take the time to have that
conversation then do so as a doctor I
want to help my patients and I want to
be able to take the time to help them
because actually I'll save time in the
longer term with regard to improving
their health hous scems so if you want
to have a look at the study I'll put it
in the links down below um if you want
to have a look at the Zoe app I'm not
going to put a link there because this
is not a sponsor post or anything like
that um but have a look what their
outcomes are with that in mind take care
and I hope this has been useful cheerio