Underappreciated Historical Weapons: War Darts & Fletched Javelins

RANGED Weapons
5 followers
174 Video Views·Oct 26, 2024
A series exploring underappreciated and lesser-known historical weapons that truly existed. In this episode, we examine the War Dart, also known as the Fletched Javelin—a lightweight, aerodynamic projectile designed for speed and accuracy. How was it used in battle, and why has it been largely forgotten? Watch to find out!
Greetings, I'm Shad, and welcome back to Underappreciated Historical Weapons,
and in this episode we'll be looking at war darts, also known as war javelins.
This is one of the things I love about Underappreciated Historical Weapons,
because there are so many weapons that people, when you think, when you see them,
you're like, what, this really was a real historical weapon?
Because look, it's basically a giant arrow.
Yeah, you know, arrow, bow and arrow, ramp it up in size, okay?
Something you hold, something you throw, yeah, that's what we're talking about.
Now, as to the terminology, well, there doesn't seem to be an official distinction for it,
which is why I was like, war dart or javelin.
People really haven't decided definitively what to call it,
because a dart is something you throw that has kind of fletching and, you know, a metal point,
and so ramp that up in size, like a warfare equivalent of it, well, it would be a war dart.
But in contrast to that definition, a javelin is, you know, a long shaft,
like spear or object, that you throw.
And war javelins, war darts, they're thrown.
It just has fletching and a pointy tip to make it more applicable and useful
and effective in combat.
Hence, war javelin.
So, you pick what word you want to use.
I'm probably going to be jumping between the two definitions,
because I haven't even decided what to be.
Darts, javelins, war, yeah, that, okay?
It's interestingly hard to find a lot of information on war darts,
because they're very obscure in the modern kind of view of the medieval period.
That doesn't mean they were obscure in the past, rather quite the contrary,
but we'll get to that.
But because information is so hard to find in it,
I really need to give a shout out to Todd of Toddstuff,
who has made two excellent videos on this very subject.
Now, I'm going to be kind of deconstructing the logic behind a war dart,
try and figure out where, you know, it originated from,
how it was developed,
and also share a bit of information how they use and stuff like that.
But Todd has actually made one and demonstrates its use,
and he also explores the use of a throwing string in application to war darts
and how it fits in in historical context.
Great videos.
And Toddstuff, he is like an experimental archaeologist, all right?
He is recreating medieval weapons as historically accurate as he can,
and he just makes some awesome stuff,
and he has some really great videos.
So, shout out to him.
Go check him out.
Link in the description to his channel.
Now, let's deconstruct the kind of logic behind the war dart.
Bring it all the way back, okay?
And then we're gonna move down and return to where we would logically reach.
What is the war dart?
So, to begin with, in combat, all right,
being able to dispatch your enemy, your foe, at a distance
is always more advantageous than having to get in too close,
meaning melee, right?
Because if you're in melee and they're using melee weapons,
that means you can be hit back.
But if you're out of their range,
and then you can dispatch them from a distance and keep yourself safe,
that's always the more preferred option,
which means ranged weapons, all right?
Ranged weapons are great.
Okay, so in its most basic idea,
what is the most basic ranged weapon that you could really think of,
pick up, and use?
It's basically a thrown rock, okay?
Pick up a rock and throw it.
But we humans, we're very industrious,
strange little creatures,
and so if we think of this logic,
what's a way to make this work better?
In regards to throwing rocks,
well, we did develop a tool that, you know,
enhanced our ability to throw rocks quite effectively,
and it was the sling.
Slings are actually fairly prominent and rather deadly
in the ancient and classical periods,
but the problem with a sling, they throw rocks.
And the problem with rocks is that
they have a decently large surface area
for the type of thing that we're considering here, weapons,
and if they hit thick clothing, they won't do much damage.
And so something pointy,
where it goes to a really fine point where all the damage in force
is, you know, on that tiny surface area point,
which increases penetration,
and that means hitting vital organs,
which means much higher chance of incapacitating
and killing your opponents.
So pointy things, good!
Okay, what's the easiest pointy thing we can find?
A pointy stick!
And there we go, the spear.
But can we throw a spear?
Well, we can,
but there are other ways in which we can enhance this idea
of a long pointy thing.
For instance, developing a tool
which converts our biomechanical energy
into mechanical energy
that can apply the same force
that we kind of put into this mechanical duvidacky thing,
which transfers into the arrow,
duvidacky thing,
that's, you know, a very technical term,
you've got to remember that,
transfer the energy into the long pointy thing
and then bang!
And so we develop an arrow, arrow,
they're kind of small, they're kind of thin,
but there's a problem with bow and arrows,
which kind of has existed for the entire existence of this weapon.
And it's that you need to use two hands to use them,
including crossbows,
even small crossbows,
when you're loading a one-hand shot,
to reload, two hands.
And why is this a problem?
Well, it nullifies a vitally important weapon tool
that has been used in historical combat
for a very long time, right?
We're still using them today.
Oh yeah, you know what I'm talking about.
Shields.
So it's a bit of give and take.
You'll be a bit more vulnerable
if you're using this bow and arrow.
You get good range,
they're phenomenally effective,
but you can't use a shield, all right?
And so what if you need a shield,
you're not necessarily a dedicated ranged combatant,
so you have a shield, you have a weapon,
but you want the advantage of having a ranged weapon
just in case.
So that means you need a ranged weapon
that you can use in one hand.
And so slings, yes, kind of.
It's possible to reload the one hand,
but again, rocks, okay?
Something pointy, something more deadly,
they can use in one hand.
So we come back to the spear thing.
Spears can be thrown,
but they're not necessarily optimized for being thrown
if your intention was to use them as a melee weapon,
because some of the big advantages
that a spear offers over other weapons is reach.
So you want it decently long.
And then you also want it to be able to survive
some pretty, you know, abusive use,
especially if they're clinging up
against armor weapons of the opponent.
So you need the shaft decently thick and robust,
which actually makes it less effective
as a thrown weapon,
because the heavier it is,
the less it has in range.
And in terms of length,
well, you're throwing the weapon for reach,
so you don't need the additional reach
on the spear itself to get additional range
because you're throwing it.
So, and adding additional weight
just increases the weight problem,
which means a spear, long pointy stick,
which is optimized for being thrown
is something a bit thinner
in terms of its cross-section circumference.
Okay, we're looking at a smaller kind of circle
and also shorter.
And this type of spear
is what is historically understood as a javelin.
And javelins, of course,
were used very prominently in the classical period.
And what type of warriors generally use javelins?
People use shields as well.
Okay, shield, one-handed throwing weapon.
All right, javelin, it works.
And this is why the use of the javelin
was still concurrent
around the times when bows and arrows were being used
because it is a ranged weapon
that you can use
while using your shield at the same time.
It's a one-handed ranged weapon.
And in regards to reloading,
you don't need a second hand
if you have one, you know,
available strapped onto your back
or on a loop or something like that.
You throw it, you can pull it out,
and then you're good to throw again.
And it can also double
as a fairly effective melee weapon as well.
Not as effective as like a full-blown war spear
or something like a war spear.
That's, you know, an anachronistic term.
You know what I mean.
But still, it's a long enough pointy thing
that you can poke your enemies with
with more deadly, you know, intentions.
And so what I'm trying to describe here
is a situation in which
the utility and function of a javelin
is actually superior to that of a bow.
It's not a superior ranged weapon,
mainly because of its range,
but for the transition between
ranged combat to melee combat,
it is a profoundly more effective weapon
because you can do both with it
and even if you throw all your javelins,
you still would have another hand
to protect yourself
in which you can quickly draw your main weapon,
whether that's a sword or anything else.
And so with this logic explored
and understood a bit better,
it really does make more sense
for a dedicated melee soldier
to have a couple of ranged thrown weapons
on his person as backup
to be able to throw at an enemy
who's charging him.
And then the engagement before his life
is even put at real risk.
But this doesn't mean that
the only situation in which a javelin
or javelin-like weapon
would be useful is if you had a shield.
Not at all.
There is a lot of utility and usefulness
in having a ranged weapon
in which you can use it
without needing an additional tool
for it to be effective.
In regards to a bow and arrow
or a crossbow,
if the crossbow or bow breaks,
your arrows or bolts
become rather useless on their own.
With javelins,
you don't need anything else
apart from yourself
to employ them effectively in combat,
which also makes them a viable
and effective choice
in a combat situation,
even when other ranged weapons
like bows and arrows are available.
So then, why did they disappear?
Why did this logic disappear?
Well, the answer is, of course,
it didn't.
Javelins didn't so much disappear
from the historical battlefield
as much as they evolved
or got a significant
and rather cool upgrade.
Now, the upgrades are, of course,
fletching at the back
and something a bit more substantial
at the tip.
Why would you want those things?
They seem fairly evident,
but I am going to break it down
and go through it.
When you throw a javelin,
okay, there is actually a chance
that if you, you know,
get your throw, you know,
is a bit wonky,
you know, you didn't do a good job,
that the tip will fall, you know,
fall away from the point
that you're aiming at
and it can actually flip
or move around.
And if you ever throw a javelin,
and, you know, of course I have.
When I first did,
I remember way back in high school,
we were doing javelin Olympics
and all that stuff.
I was amazed at how difficult it was
to get the tip to stay on point.
Okay, you would throw the javelin
and kind of land back first
and flip or go over
and stuff like that.
And it took a little bit of coordination
to actually throw it in the right way
that it would fly true.
Of course, the simple
and evident way to fix this
is to add fletching on the back.
Okay, if you try and throw
one of these things,
like a javelin with fletching,
even if you do a really bad throw,
it's going to solve correct
and fly straight.
And a steel or iron head on this thing,
well, of course,
just increases its lethality.
So that's the weapon.
That's kind of the deconstructed
logical progression
to reach its development.
Now let's have a look at
how they fit into history,
because whenever, you know,
movies, video games, TV shows,
even role playing games
are depicting the medieval period,
I have not once seen
this kind of weapon.
Yet from artistic record,
it is surprising.
I was shocked at how many,
you know, artistic depictions
there are showcasing these weapons.
They were very, very common
in the medieval period.
So common, in fact,
that the war dart or javelin
really should be considered
in the classical catalog
of medieval weapons.
You got sword, you got axe,
you got maces, you got war hammers,
you got pole arms.
Well, add in war darts
and war javelins.
They belong in this same group.
What were they used for?
Funny question this, OK?
Because there are some direct
indications from artistic record,
but a lack of evidence,
meaning a lack of evidence
being used in any other situation
isn't evidence
to the contrary conclusion.
OK, well, it doesn't mean
that we can leap
to that contrary conclusion
that, well, these are clearly
used in these other areas
where we don't really
have evidence for,
but we don't have evidence
excluding it.
And so in those realms,
I feel we can just use
logical analysis
to try and figure out,
well, you know, that probably
would be effective
in these other areas.
Well, what are the areas
in which the medieval artwork
shows these weapons being used?
Hunting, naval warfare
and sieges by the look of it.
Obviously, one of the weaknesses
of these weapons is range.
Their range is only as far
as you can throw them,
and so a good bow will outshoot you.
But their damage potential,
because of their, you know,
size would be fairly significant.
Just by looking at them,
they don't seem like
they'd be particularly effective
against armored opponents.
Of course, the type of,
I was going to say arrowhead,
it's not really arrowhead,
so spearhead,
javelin head, dart head thing
would determine how effective it is
against different types of armors.
If you have kind of like,
you know, a bodkin type head on it,
much more effective against armor.
But it seems to be that
the more common head
for these war darts,
as shown in the medieval artwork and stuff,
is something a bit broader, OK?
Indeed, like a broadhead.
And those are the type of heads
you use on arrows
and things similar to it
against animals, for one,
and lightly armored opponents,
because once that thing
gets in and hits internal organs,
it's going to be cutting
and doing more slicing
and stuff like that,
doing more damage,
harder to heal from.
And, you know,
it would be interesting to see
how effective it would be
against a properly made gambeson.
Now, I don't think that
were the only realms
these weapons could have
only been used in history.
I think, you know,
there could be many things
like straight on battlefield.
We do have artistic pictures
of them being used,
what looks to be on battlefields as well.
Were they ever used
as a melee kind of weapon substitute
in the same vein that
javelins can be used
as a melee weapon substitute,
because, you know,
they're substantial enough.
Some of them, they do seem
kind of like this one
in the hunting one.
They seem fairly close,
not like they're just coming up
and skewering them.
So these weapons could be
kind of also used
as small like spears.
They're pretty cool,
and they were far,
far more common
than many people realize.
This is a classic medieval weapon.
So guys, role playing games,
you know, if you're ever
writing for TVs, movies
or whatnot, stuff like that,
you know, video game developers,
if you're there.
War javelins, these are prominent.
So it seems like if you want
to accurately depict
medieval combat and warfare,
war javelins need to be a must.
OK, I'm not saying that
they were more prominent
than swords or something like that.
Swords, very, very common.
Bows and arrows, I think,
were probably more common
than war javelins.
But in terms of how common
other weapons like maces,
OK, they were not nearly
as common as other weapons
because they were a more
specialized type of weapon.
But that's the same vein
as these war javelins.
A bit more specialized,
a bit more, you know,
focused in for specific uses,
but definitely present
and known of being very common
in the medieval period.
So there you go, guys.
This has been war javelins,
underappreciated historic weapons.
Thank you for watching.
I hope you've enjoyed.
And of course,
I hope to see you next time.
So until then, farewell.
