Kenneth Clark's Civilisation 03: Romance and Reality

Lost Treasures
16 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 26, 2024
I'm in the Gothic world, the world of chivalry, courtesy and romance.
A world in which serious things were done with a sense of play,
where even war and theology could become a sort of game,
and when architecture reached a point of extravagance unequaled in history.
After all the great unifying convictions of the 12th century,
high Gothic art can look fantastic and luxurious, what Marxists call conspicuous waste.
And yet, these centuries produced some of the greatest spirits in the whole history of man,
amongst them Saint Francis of Assisi and Dante.
Behind all the fantasies of Gothic imagination,
there remained, on two different planes, a sharp sense of reality.
Medieval man could see things very clearly,
but he believed that these appearances should be considered
as nothing more than symbols or tokens of an ideal order,
which was the only true reality.
The fantasy strikes us first.
A charming example is this series of tapestries known as the Lady with the Unicorn,
one of the last and most seductive examples of the Gothic spirit.
It is poetical, fanciful, and profane.
Its ostensible subject is the four senses,
but its real subject is the power of love,
which can enlist and subdue all the forces of nature,
including these two emblems of lust and ferocity,
the unicorn and the lion.
They kneel before this embodiment of chastity,
and even hold up the corners of her tent.
These fierce beasts have become, in the heraldic sense, her supporters.
And all round this allegorical scene
is what the scholastic medieval philosophers used to call
nature-nurturing, natura naturans.
Birds, trees, flowers, leaves galore,
and those rather obvious symbols of nature-nurturing, rabbits.
There is even nature domesticated, sitting on a cushion.
What an image of worldly happiness at its most refined.
What the French call the douceur de vive,
which is often confused with civilization.
We've come a long way from the powerful convictions
that induced knights and ladies to draw carts of stone up the hill
for the building of Chartres Cathedral.
And yet, the notion of ideal love
and the irresistible power of gentleness and beauty,
which is emblematically conveyed by the homage of these fierce beasts,
can be traced back for three centuries,
and we may even begin to look for it in the north portal of Chartres.
This portal, the north portal,
was decorated about the year 1220,
and it seems to have been commissioned
by that formidable lady Blanche of Castile,
the mother of Saint Louis.
And perhaps for that reason,
or perhaps simply because it was dedicated to Virgin Mary,
many of the figures are of women,
and several of the stories on the arches
concern Old Testament heroines.
And at the corner is one of the first
consciously graceful women in Western art.
Only a very few years before,
women were thought of as like this,
and those were the women
who accompanied the Norsemen to Iceland.
Now, look at this embodiment of chastity,
lifting her mantle, raising her hand,
turning her head with rhythms of self-conscious refinement
that would have become mannered,
but here are genuinely modest.
In fact, she represents a saint called Saint Modesta,
which he might be Dante's Beatrice.
Of the two or three faculties
that have been added to the European mind
since the civilization of Greece and Rome,
none seems to me stranger and more inexplicable
than the sentiment of ideal or costly love.
It was entirely unknown in antiquity.
Passion, yes.
Desire, yes, of course.
Steady affection, yes.
But this state of utter subjection
to the will of some almost unapproachable woman,
this belief that no sacrifice was too great,
that a whole lifetime might properly be spent in paying court,
to a disdainful lady,
or suffering on her behalf.
This would have seemed to the Romans or to the Vikings
not only absurd, but unbelievable.
And yet, for hundreds of years, it passed unquestioned.
It inspired a vast literature,
from Cretien de Troyes to Sherry,
most of which I find completely unreadable.
And even up to 1945,
we still retained a number of chivalrous gestures.
We raised our hats to ladies
and let them pass first through doors,
and in America, push in their seats at table.
We still subscribed to the fantasy
that they were chaste and pure beings
in whose presence we couldn't tell certain stories
or pronounce certain words.
Well, that's all over now.
But it had a long run,
and there was much to be said for it.
How did it begin?
The truth is that nobody knows.
Most people think that, like the pointed arch,
it came from the East,
that pilgrims and crusaders found in the Muslim world
a tradition of Persian literature
in which women were the subject
of extravagant compliment and devotion.
I don't know enough about Persian literature
to say this is true,
but I do think that the crusade
had another less direct influence
on the concept of costly love.
The lady of a castle must always have had
a peculiar position,
cooped up with so many unoccupied young men
who couldn't spend all their time fighting.
And when the lord was away for a year or two,
the lady was left in charge.
She took on his functions
and received the kind of homage
that was accepted in a feudal society.
And the wandering knight who visited her
did so with the mixture of deference and hope
that one gets in the Troubadour poems.
In support of this theory
is the subject of the siege of the castle of love,
which appears on mirror cases and caskets
and other domestic objects of the 14th century.
I ought perhaps to add
that the idea of marriage
doesn't come into the question at all.
Medieval marriages were entirely a matter of property.
Well, as everybody knows,
marriage without love means love without marriage.
And then I suppose one must admit
that the cult of the Virgin
had something to do with it.
In this context, it sounds rather blasphemous.
But the fact remains
that one often hardly knows
if a medieval love lyric
is addressed to the poet's mistress
or to the Virgin Mary.
The greatest of all writings about ideal love,
Dante's Vita nuova,
The New Life,
is a quasi-religious work.
And in the end, it is Beatrice
who introduces Dante to paradise.
So for all these reasons,
I think one can associate
the cult of ideal love
with the ravishing beauty and delicacy
that one finds in the Madonna's
of the late 13th century.
Costly love was not only the subject of lyrics,
but of long, very long stories
in prose and verse.
And this reminds me of something else
that the Gothic centuries added
to the European consciousness,
that cluster of ideas and sentiments
which were not just about love,
One can't really say that romance
was a Gothic invention.
I suppose that, as the word suggests,
it was Romanesque
and grew up in those
southern districts of France
where the memories of Roman civilization
had not been quite obliterated
when they were overlaid
by the more fantastic imagery
of the Saracens.
But the chivalrous romance
of the Gothic time,
from Crete and Detroit
in the 13th century
to Mallory in the 15th,
with their allegories
and personifications,
their endless journeys
and night-long vigils,
their spells and mysteries,
had a special appeal
to the medieval mind.
For 200 years,
the Roman de la Rose
was probably the most read book in Europe,
except for Boethius and the Bible.
Well, it's not much read today,
except in all the past examinations.
But of course,
the effect of these romances
on 19th century literature
was decisive,
whether as a quarry
or as an imaginative escape,
especially in England.
The Eve of St Agnes,
the Belle dame sans merci,
the Idols of the King,
are to say nothing of that
crucial masterpiece
of the late 19th century
Wagner's Tristan and Isolde.
One can't say that Gothic romance
hasn't played a part
in our experience,
if only a second hand.
The summit of court civilization
was reached in the late 14th century
in France,
under the patronage
of the Duke de Berry.
He built a series of fabulous
filigree castles,
of which the painter de Lambourg
has left us an apparently
accurate record.
He filled them with jewels
and jeweled contraptions,
paintings and tapestries.
This warlike scene
is only a tapestry.
The Duke wasn't fond of war.
The Duke's artists have given us
a vivid account of his court.
Here he is giving a grand dinner
to celebrate the new year.
There are no ladies present,
which is curious,
because the Duke,
who was an amiably
self-indulgent man,
is reported to have said
But we can see
some of his famous collection
of 1,500 dogs,
which is too many,
even for me.
They seem to have had
the run of the table.
Behind him is his chamberlain
saying to some bashful suitor,
Approche! Approche!
And his courtiers,
including a cardinal,
are raising their hands
in astonishment
at such condescension.
The castles,
pictures,
tapestries
have vanished with the dogs.
But a few of the treasures remain.
This gold cup is one
which seems to have been
owned by the Duke
and one of the few objects
from which one can still
catch the flavour
of this fanciful,
luxurious world.
And this,
nominally a reliquary,
but actually an extravagant
but charming toy.
It's supposed to have held
a thorn from Christ's crown
at the crucifixion.
There were many patrons
of art and collectors
at that time,
but the Duke was peculiar
in that the arts
were his whole life.
And to pay for his collections,
he taxed his subjects mercilessly
and they probably wouldn't have
agreed with this miniature
where Saint Peter seems
to be admitting him to heaven
without the usual formalities.
It was a colder world for peasants.
The manuscripts illustrate
another capacity of the human mind
which had grown up
in the preceding century,
the delighted observation
of natural objects,
leaves and flowers,
animals and birds.
Birds were a medieval obsession.
They're the subject of one
of the earliest medieval sketchbooks
and they fill the borders
of manuscripts.
If you'd asked a 14th century cleric
to account for all these birds,
he would probably have said
that they represented souls
because they can fly up to God.
But this doesn't really explain
why artists drew them
with such obsessive accuracy
and I think the reason is
that they have become symbols of freedom.
Under feudalism,
men and animals were tied to the land.
Very few people could move about,
only artists and birds.
They were cheerful, hopeful,
impudent and mobile.
And in addition,
had the kind of markings
that fitted in with medieval heraldry.
The Duke's earliest manuscripts
had shown an isolating
and symbolising approach to nature.
But in the middle of his career,
he discovered an artist
or a group of artists
called the Lambour,
who by some stroke of original genius
saw nature as we see it,
as part of a complete visual experience.
No doubt much of their work's been lost,
but one book remains,
The Very Rich Hours,
which is one of the miracles
of art history.
Here are men and women
cultivating the fields,
harrowing,
sowing,
the scarecrow in the background,
haymaking and harvesting,
and suddenly we realise
that all this had been going on
in the same places,
more or less unchanged,
all through the dark ages.
And went on the same way,
right up to the last war.
In the foreground,
a party of nobles out hawking,
indulged in a little mild courtship,
so called because it was only in courts
that one had time
for these agreeable preliminaries,
instead of getting down to business immediately.
Then, in May,
everyone puts on crowns of leaves
and goes out riding.
What a dream.
No society has ever been more elegant,
more debonair,
more dainty.
Those French and Burgundian courts
were the model of fashion and good manners
all over Europe.
Many people,
when you mention to them
the word civilisation,
think of something like this.
Well, it isn't to be sneezed at.
But it isn't enough
to keep a civilisation alive.
Because it depends on a small, static society
that never looks outside or beyond.
And we know from many, many years
that such societies become petrified,
anxious only to hold on
to their own social order.
The great, indeed the unique,
merit of European civilisation
has been that it has never ceased to develop.
Even the idea of courtesy
could take on an unexpected form.
In the years
when the north portal of Chartres
was being decorated,
a rich young dandy
named Francesco Bernardone
suffered a change of heart.
He was, and always remained,
the most courteous of men.
He was deeply influenced
by French ideas of chivalry.
And one day,
when he had fitted himself up
in his best clothes
in preparation for some chivalrous campaign,
he met a poor gentleman
whose needs seemed to be greater than his own
and gave him his cloak.
That night he dreamed
that he should rebuild the celestial city.
Later, he gave away his possessions
so liberally
that his father,
who was a rich businessman
in the Italian town of Assisi,
decided to disown him.
Whereupon Francesco
took off his remaining clothes
and said that he would possess nothing,
absolutely nothing.
The Bishop of Assisi hid his nakedness
and afterwards gave him a cloak
and Francesco went off into the woods
singing a French song.
The next three years
he spent in abject poverty
looking after lepers
who were very much in evidence
in the Middle Ages
and rebuilding with his own hands
abandoned churches.
In all his actions
he took the words of the Gospels literally
and he translated them
into the language of chivalric poetry.
He said that he had taken poverty for his lady
and when he achieved
some still more drastic act of self-denial
he said that it was to do her a courtesy.
It was partly because he saw
that wealth corrupts
and is the cause of war
but partly because he felt
that it was discourteous
to be in the company
of anyone poorer than oneself.
I have so far illustrated
the story of St Francis
by the work of the Sienese painter Sassetta
because although he painted so much later
the chivalric Gothic tradition
lingered on in Siena
as nowhere else in Italy
and gave to Sassetta's sprightly images
a lyric even of visionary quality
more Franciscan
than the ponderous images of Giotto.
But I must now change to Giotto
not only because he lived 150 years earlier
than Sassetta
that's to say much nearer
the time of St Francis
but because he was chosen
to decorate the great church
where I'm now standing
the church of St Francis
built very shortly after his death.
How many of these frescoes
are really by Giotto's
is an open question.
Modern English scholars
have taken it into their heads
to say that Giotto
practically never went to Assisi at all.
Italian scholars think
that he painted nearly all of them.
I'm inclined to think
that Giotto was one of those artists
like Raphael
who attached much more importance
to invention than to execution.
He was quite prepared
to let his pupils
there must have been a small army of pupils
carry out his ideas.
The ones here above my head
I'm pretty sure he painted himself
because they have all his weight
and dramatic power.
Where he seems to me to fall short
is in his actual image of the saint.
It's too grave and commanding.
It has none of that
sprightliness almost
that sense of joy
which St Francis valued
almost as much as courtesy itself.
Incidentally, we don't know
what St Francis looked like.
The best known early painting
is attributed to Cimabue.
It looks quite convincing
but I'm afraid that it's entirely repainted
and only shows us
what the 19th century thought
St Francis ought to have looked like.
From the first
everyone recognized that St Francis
was a religious genius.
The greatest I believe
that Europe has ever produced.
Although he was only a layman
the Pope gave him permission
to found an order here at Assisi.
St Francis died in 1226
at the age of 43
worn out by his austerities.
On his deathbed
he had asked forgiveness
of poor brother Donkey, my body
for the hardships he had made it suffer.
He'd seen his order
go from a group of humble companions
and become a great institution
a power in church politics.
And at a certain point
he had quite naturally
and simply relinquished control.
He knew that he was no administrator.
Within two years
only two years of his death
he was canonized
and his companions
began to build this great church
to his memory.
A masterpiece of Gothic architecture
also an incredible piece of engineering.
Two churches
one on top of the other
a huge monastery
all built on arcades
and of such hard stone
that it's almost impossible to believe
that it's original 13th century work.
I think it must have been built
by a castle architect.
It was decorated
by all the chief Italian painters
of the 13th and 14th centuries
from Cimabue onwards
so that it has become
the richest and most evocative church in Italy.
A strange memorial to the little poor man
whose favorite saying was
foxes have holes
and the birds of the air have nests
but the son of man hath not where to lay his head.
But of course
Saint Francis's cult of poverty
couldn't survive him.
It didn't even last his lifetime.
It was officially rejected by the church
because the church had already become
part of the international banking system
that originated in the 13th century
and those of Saint Francis's disciples
who clung to his doctrine of poverty
called fraticelli
were denounced as heretics
and burnt at the stake.
And for 700 years
capitalism has continued to grow
to its present monstrous proportions.
It may seem that Saint Francis
has had no influence at all
because even those humane reformers
of the 19th century
who sometimes invoked him
didn't wish to exalt or sanctify poverty
but to abolish it.
And yet his belief
that in order to free the spirit
we must shed our earthly possessions
is the belief of all great
that all great religions have in common
east and west
almost without exception.
And by enacting their truth
with such simplicity and grace
he made it a part of the European consciousness
an idea to which
however impossible it may be in practice
the finest spirits will always return.
And by freeing himself
from the pull of possessions
Saint Francis achieved a state of mind
which has been of great value to us.
I mean his belief in the unity of creation
and the possibility of universal love.
It was only because he possessed nothing
that Saint Francis could feel sincerely
a brotherhood of all created things
not only living creatures like brother pig
but brother fire and sister wind.
This philosophy inspired his hymn
to the unity of creation
known as the canticle of the sun
and it's expressed with irresistible naivety
in a collection of legends
known as the fioretti
the little flowers.
Not many people can make their way
through the polemics of Abelard
or the definitions of Saint Thomas Aquinas
but everyone can enjoy these holy folk tales
which after all may not be completely untrue.
They are in contemporary jargon
amongst the first examples of popular communication
to any rate since the Sermon on the Mount.
And they tell us for instance
how Saint Francis persuaded a fierce wolf
that terrified the people of Gubbio
to make a pact by which
in return for regular meals
he will leave the citizens alone.
Give me your paw, said Saint Francis
and the wolf gave his paw.
Most famous of all of course
is the Sermon to the Birds
those creatures which as I've said
seemed to the gothic mind singularly privileged.
Seven centuries haven't impaired
the naive duty of that episode.
Saint Francis is a figure of the pure gothic time
the age of crusades and castles and the great cathedrals.
Although he put it to strange and marvellous uses
he belonged to the age of chivalry.
Well however much one loves that world
I think it remains for us infinitely strange and remote.
It's as enchanting, as luminous, as transcendental
as the stained glass that is its glory
and in the ordinary meaning of the word as unreal.
But already during the lifetime of Saint Francis
another word was growing up
which for better or worse is the ancestor of our own.
The word of trade, of banking, of cities
full of hard-headed men
whom Amy Knife was to grow rich
without ceasing to be respectable.
Cities, citizen, civilian, civic, civic life
I suppose that all this
ought to have a direct bearing on
what we mean by civilisation.
Behind me is the town hall of Siena
looking very much as it did in the 14th century.
In fact the city architect told me
that the population is too less
than it was in the 13th century.
Historians sometimes maintain
that civilisation began in these Italian republics
of the 14th century.
Well, civilisation as I understand it
can be created in a monastery or a court
just as well as in a city, perhaps rather better.
But all the same the social and economic system
that grew up in the 13th century had a point.
It was a manageable human unit
and as opposed to the system,
if you can call it a system, of chivalry
it was realistic.
And the proof is that it has survived.
Of course Siena remained to some extent medieval
compared with Florence.
Their industrial and banking conditions
at the time of Dante
were surprisingly similar to those
that exist in Lombard Street today
except that a double entry wasn't invented
in the 14th century in Genoa, I believe.
Of course the Italian republics
weren't in the least democratic
as those pre-Marxist innocents
the liberal historians used to think they were.
Exploitation was in the hands of a few powerful families
who managed to operate within the framework
of a guild system
in which the workers had no say at all.
The Italian merchant of the 14th century
isn't a sympathetic figure,
less so really than that old reprobate Jean de Berry.
The stories of Florentine thrift
are like the stories that Jews used to tell about each other.
But, and here the parallel with Lombard Street
is not so close,
the new merchant classes
as patrons of the art of their own time
were at least as intelligent as the aristocracy.
And just as their economic system
was capable of an expansion
that has lasted till today,
so the painting they commissioned
had a kind of solid reality
that was to be the dominant aim of art
up to the time of Cézanne.
The first and in some ways
the greatest painter of this new reality
was Giotto.
This is one of Giotto's frescoes
in the Arena Chapel in Padua.
And as I look at it,
I realize that to anyone
whose eye has been conditioned by realism
as it has existed in European art
from the Renaissance to the Cubists,
this will not look very realistic.
Perhaps no more so than Gothic tapestry.
But this much is clear.
Instead of a decorative jumble,
it concentrates on a few simple,
solid-looking forms arranged in space.
Giotto had more than any artist before him
the ability to make his figures look solid.
He manages to simplify them
into large, comprehensible, apprehensible shapes,
and it gives one a profound satisfaction
to feel that one can grasp his figures so completely.
He needs to make his figures more vividly credible
because he wishes us to feel more intensely
the human drama in which they are involved.
Once we have, so to say, learned Giotto's language,
we can recognize him
as one of the greatest masters of painted drama
that has ever lived.
How did Giotto evolve this very personal
and original style?
When he was a young man,
he was born in Tuscany in about 1265,
Florentine painting was really only
a less polished form of Byzantine painting.
It was flat, flowing, linear,
based on traditional concepts
which had changed very little for 500 years.
For Giotto to break away from it
and evolve this solid, space-conscious style
was one of those feats of original creation
that have occurred only two or three times
in the history of art.
When such drastic changes do take place,
one can usually find certain points of departure,
models, predecessors, but not with Giotto.
We know absolutely nothing about him
till the year 1305,
when he decorated a small, plain building in Padua
known as the Arena Chapel
and made it, to anyone who cares for painting,
one of the holy places of the world.
It was commissioned by a moneylender
named Enrico Scrovegni,
whose father had actually been imprisoned for usually,
that is to say,
for charging an extortionate rate of interest
because moderate rates of interest
were unofficially countenanced.
And it's one of the first instances
of the new rich commissioning works of art
as a kind of atonement,
a practice that has benefited the world
almost as much as vanity and self-indulgence.
Here he is,
perhaps the earliest painted portrait
that is obviously a genuine likeness,
presenting a model of his chapel to three angels
and, for that reason,
placed among the blessed in the last judgment.
Giotto is the supreme dramatist of human life
in all its diversity.
He can depict a scene like this,
Marriage at Cana,
which is almost Chaucerian.
Behind the pots stands the pot-bellied host
who tastes with astonishment
the wine that has been created out of water.
But Giotto is greatest
when the human drama is greatest,
as in the scene of the betrayal of the Garden of Gethsemane.
What a marvellous invention
that Judas should put his cloak round our Lord.
Everything,
heads,
gestures,
the explosive pattern of the spears,
is a crescendo of feeling,
tension and violence.
But he can also achieve
the lyrical beauty of the Virgin's wedding procession,
the tenderness of the Noli mi tangere
with its marvellously subtle relationship
between the figures.
And finally,
the lamentation over Christ's dead body.
It's a masterpiece of pictorial construction,
a sort of model for high academic painting
for 500 years.
But this technical aspect is soon forgotten.
Look at the gestures
and the heads of the mourning women.
They need no words from me.
Although I think that Giotto
was one of the supreme painters of the world,
he has equals.
But in the year of his birth,
and in the same district,
was born a man who is unequalled,
the greatest philosophical poet
that has ever lived, Dante.
Since they were contemporaries and compatriots,
one feels that it should be possible
to illustrate Dante by Giotto.
They seem to have known each other
and Giotto may have painted Dante's portrait.
In fact,
their imaginations moved on very different planes.
Giotto was above all interested in humanity.
He sympathised with human beings
and his figures,
by their very solidity,
remain on earth.
Well, of course,
there is humanity in Dante.
He lived in the thick of Florentine politics
and all the characters he had pitied
or hated or admired
appear in his poem.
Not only as representatives of good and evil,
but with the vividness of real people.
But Giotto lacked Dante's philosophic power
and moral indignation.
That heroic contempt for baseness
that was to come again in Michelangelo.
Above all,
that vision of a heavenly order
and the intellectual power
to make it comprehensible.
In a way,
the poet and the painter
stand at the junction of two worlds.
Giotto belonged to the new world
of solid realities.
The world created by the bankers
and merchants for whom he worked.
Dante,
as has often been observed,
belonged to the earlier Gothic world,
to the world of St. Thomas Aquinas
and the great cathedrals.
One isn't as close to Dante
in the Arena Chapel
as one is here
in the Romanesque baptistry at Pisa.
The pulpit by Niccolò Pisano
was executed five years
before Dante was born.
And yet it has all his sense of horror,
even some of the elements of the grotesque
that come into the Inferno,
combined with much
that is derived from antiquity.
And it has the same keen eye
for truthful details,
although, of course,
we can no longer believe
in these rather ridiculous monsters.
Niccolò's son, Giovanni,
about 15 years older than Dante and Giotto,
and deeply influenced
by the Gothic art of the North,
seems to me perfectly
to reflect the Dantesque spirit.
Giovanni Pisano was one
of the great tragic dramatists of sculpture.
The pulpits he carved at Pisa
and at nearby Pistoia
depict a terrible world.
Here is the grief-filled suffering
of the Massacre of the Innocents.
But Giovanni Pisano's feeling
of tragic indignation
was only one side of Dante.
In the second half of his great poem,
from the middle of the Purgatorio onwards,
there are moments of disembodied bliss
to which no artist of the time did justice.
Nor were the painters of the 14th century
ready to reflect Dante's feeling for light.
Like all the heroes of this series,
Dante thought of light
as a symbol of civilized life.
And in his poem,
he describes accurately
and economically
light in all its varying effects.
The light of dawn,
light on the sea,
light on leaves in spring.
But all these beautiful descriptions,
which are the part of Dante
that we like best,
are only similes.
They are introduced by the words,
as when.
They are intended to illustrate
and make comprehensible
to our earthbound senses
the vision of divine order
and heavenly beauty.
