We compared Captain America's Shield to HISTORICAL shields, the results were interesting...

Eternal Shield
2 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 26, 2024
Hey, Dollface. How you going?
You know, I'm actually a little jealous of you.
You don't actually need to shave your head very often.
I know they talk about the fact that, like,
um, that we should probably get on to cleaning him up every now and again.
I mean, if you take a look, it's fairly damaged.
I wasn't talking to the doll.
We don't go crazy here.
It's fine. What are you doing?
What are you doing?
It sounded like you needed a friend.
So, you're giving me the official Shadiversity plushie,
which, link in the description, these things are amazingly cute.
And you can talk to them.
Because this guy will listen to me.
Won't you, Shad?
Greetings!
I'm Shad, and, hey, how are you, Tyranth, Nate?
We're doing good today, Shad.
You're doing good?
How are you doing?
I feel a little different.
You are, do you?
Wow, you look tall.
Yeah, you're looking pretty short today, buddy.
You're looking soft.
Did you condition your hair recently or something?
Well, you know, new conditioner.
Oh, look, alright, that's beside the point.
We got shields.
We do.
We do. We have Captain America's shield today.
And we're going to be giving this a little bit of a testing treatment.
What do you think, Shad?
I think it's going to be awesome.
In fact, I want to show you something.
So, pass the shield here.
You don't even stand up straight by yourself.
You want the shield?
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Look, pass the shield here.
Okay.
Ow!
I hurt my pancreas.
Shad, buddy, I think we need the big version of you.
Yeah.
So, yeah, get over here.
Bastard.
Ah, back to normal.
That was existential.
Were you going to say ecstasy then, Shad?
No, I was trying to say existential.
Right.
So, we have a Captain America shield here.
Yes, this is a steel one as well.
So, we can do some stuff with it.
Do you want to shoot it?
Do you want to throw it?
Do you want to hit it with a sword?
Do you want to do, well...
Yes.
Okay, yes.
So, now that we have this pretty cool prop, I believe you made it.
Yeah, kind of, yeah.
Kind of.
Yeah.
Well, if you want to see how this was modified and put together,
you can check out Tyrone's new channel, Screen Tested.
Yep.
And he had some fun with it.
But now he's also provided it to us here at Shadiversity.
Now, I want to bring up one thing.
It's actually really good that I did that because it exposed some flaws
in my original modifications.
So, I've tried to make it a little bit more...
Stronger?
So, it doesn't hurt you as much.
Yeah, because it definitely looks like, well, from that angle,
but even from this angle...
We don't need to show the other angle.
We can just show this side.
It looks like you had fun with it.
So, there are a couple of core functions that I would say
that Captain America does with his shield.
First off, he uses it as a shield, but he also uses it for shield bashing.
So, it can be offensive.
It's a weapon, which I have an old video discussing this as a weapon.
Interesting thoughts on it.
Okay.
Then, lastly, it's a projectile.
That's where I have some thoughts on.
Now, this is not vibranium.
Yes.
And we understand that Captain America's real shield, if it exists in real life,
defies the laws of physics and would be better thrown.
So, throwing the shield, no problem.
Getting it to do, like, rebounds off things and come back.
That's where we get into, like, okay, not reality.
There is something we can test, right?
Even though it's not vibranium or anything like that,
we can test if this general shape of shield can be thrown well.
Does it lend itself to being a somewhat effective thrown object?
Do you mean, like, compared to, say, a historical version?
Yes.
A shield?
Yes, because there are some—
Now, I think a heated shield, we'll test, we'll see.
But we also have some round shields.
We do.
Yeah, I brought a few of them along.
That might actually throw better than the Captain America-style shield.
Now, if we were to name this shield historically, it would be called a rotella.
Yes.
It could definitely be classified as a rotella.
It's about the right size, shape, it's lenticular.
It's got the framing.
Yep.
And it's metal.
Rotellas are classically metal.
And so, yeah, this does fall into kind of a historical category of shield.
Okay, that makes sense.
Doesn't mean that it will throw well.
Well, I've actually modified the design a little bit here
because, first off, this was just steel.
Now, that's kind of good and bad
because steel is stronger than something like an alloy.
We know this.
However, it means that it has a bit of flex to it.
Technically, steel is an alloy.
Actually.
So, I've added some reinforcement here.
I've also modified the design a little bit so we can actually throw it
because on something like a regular shield,
you'd have something like straps where it's not really supposed to come off.
Once you put your arm in, your arm is meant to stay in.
There are shields that have center grips,
and we've brought a few of them, so we'll give them a test as well.
Now, I also want to shoot some arrows at it.
I also want to hit it with some swords.
I want to destroy this thing, basically.
All right, then.
I need this one.
I need this one for training, so maybe not those.
We're going to hit it with most things
and then get a finish off with the actual destructive weapon.
Yep.
Yeah.
You know what we're talking about.
I just fixed that.
I think it'll hold up.
Let's get started.
I can fix a good heart.
The Bechtor Corbin, baby.
So, we should probably say that these are going to be heavier
than the real historical ones.
Yes, I was going to say that.
They're reenactment grade.
They're designed to be a little more heavy,
a little more heavy duty, and last a bit longer.
I mean, actual Viking shields even had a taper
from the inside to the outside.
They found this on, like, historical replicas.
All right, we got zero.
So, this one weighs...
Error.
Which means it's like...
This scale doesn't go, actually, that high, so...
So, it's over five kilos.
That was one and a half.
That's over five kilos.
Let's try this one.
I can't actually see anything, so...
3.1.
3.1?
Yep.
And then the little buckler, little I-33.
2.2.
And then for the heater...
2.7.
Yep, 2.7.
And this one is over five at least.
Yep.
Because it maxed out at 4.9.
You're holding it upside down.
Dragon's at the bottom!
All right, why don't we get to some throwing?
Let's see what we can do with these.
All right, Tyron, how do I throw this beast of yours?
Okay, because we don't want user error and then blame me for it.
Which I'll... It's going to be...
What we'll do is you grab...
You want to hook this under your arm.
So, this is... If you were using it like a shield, you want to hook it like that.
But when you're throwing it, you want to hook it underneath.
Underneath.
Because as soon as you start moving...
Yeah, yeah, it's going to come out.
And you say just throw it like this and let go.
And let go when you get about there.
That feels very counterintuitive.
Well, it's made this way so that it doesn't get caught and hurt you and do all that sort of stuff.
There are so many pointy things on this.
There is.
All right, ready?
I'm just going to go for it.
I'm Captain America.
That actually sounded pretty nice.
Yes.
Yeah, okay.
See, my thumb got caught then.
It hurts, yes.
It's painful, yes.
That's not good.
I didn't say it was good.
Get my nail back.
It hurts a little bit.
A little?
User error.
So, first thing I should say is it feels really weird to hold a shield in your primary hand.
Like, this is not the way these things are meant to be held.
I feel like this way.
Well, it generates enough force to bend steel.
I mean, that's a thing.
Soft, mild steel.
It still generates enough force to bend steel.
It's hard to aim.
It is.
Off camera, Tyranth went, ah.
So, Tyranth has been sitting off to the side thinking like, look at these guys.
Throwing it is so easy.
You guys were very close.
If you don't nail this first try.
Hold on.
I don't have to nail it.
Oh, now it's worried.
Whatever.
Let's do this.
A little bit off.
That's alright.
Second shot.
Alright, you got him.
You got him.
Sorry, what?
You did get him.
Oh, I did, yes.
Have you got him?
How many tries?
That was two.
No, I'm counting all the ones that you've practiced before.
None.
Look out, Tyranth.
How easy is it to dodge a shield when it actually is about to hit?
We're going to do that.
We're going to do more of this.
But that's going to be for exclusive content.
So, if you want to see us dodging shields, become a supporter.
And so, channel memberships, Patreon, Subscribestar or Player, you get access to that exclusive content.
And we're going to be throwing shields at each other.
Closer.
Closer, but it didn't frisbee.
You're still very close, though.
Which seems crazy.
Boom!
It's crazy.
Boom!
Headshot!
That's the most depressing death we've ever had on Parmesan.
It's just like, I hate working here.
Where's this range, Mark?
So, I have found that the most effective distance is about this far away.
This is good.
However, for novices, beginners, which one would you call yourself?
Get!
That was poop!
It didn't have as much lift as before.
No, because it's...
Because there, on the side.
It's easier to throw it that way.
It's just worse.
Oh, I do not like that.
That's just ripping at your...
Fingers.
Yep.
I really can't get a grip on that thing.
So close!
Wasn't that weird?
Admittedly, my throwing technique design here is not that good.
I am willing to admit this.
It's poop.
However, the aim with it is pretty good.
Legitimately.
See, just like that.
That's great!
Just like that.
Such great aim!
Legitimate aim.
Legitimate.
That actually was the worst throw of the day so far.
Genuinely, though, I will admit this on camera.
I will admit this.
I have a little bit of trauma.
Trauma's not the right word.
I'm hesitant to throw it because my hand just healed from the last time I did this.
And it hurts.
So, I don't want to throw it anymore.
I don't want to throw it anymore because I don't like the design of the handle.
How about we go to some historical versions and we give that a shot?
I like this idea.
Let's do that.
Let's prevent some more injuries.
A couple of things.
That was the worst throw of the day, but it has given us some feedback on damage.
Oh yeah, it does heaps of damage.
Let's have a look at the tree.
That's why I did it.
Josh!
That's a double oof.
Look at that.
That's a double chunk.
That's a broken face.
No, no, no.
That is a chunk that leads in and it is split off.
So, something hit on both sides.
How do you get a double slice?
So, with these historical ones, I...
Demi-historical.
Okay, Demi.
Yeah, I'm a little dubious.
I think that one will do alright.
If you're going to throw this from the center grip, it's going to be really hard to get it spinning.
And so, I'm going to try it though.
Yeah, so none of these are meant to be thrown.
So, for one, like we said at the start of the video, my arm is trapped for all intents and purposes here.
With something like that, to try to spin it, you're going to crack at your wrist to do it.
However, this one has a good grip here.
Yeah, it's a nice thick handle on there.
It's not meant to be a handle, but we're going to have to throw these a little unconventionally.
And for people who don't know, we have buckler, heater, and round.
Yeah, Viking round.
Viking round.
But they weren't unique to the Vikings.
That's true.
I'm just going to throw it.
Ready?
I had to hit it.
You hit him.
I hit him.
I wouldn't want to...
It didn't frisbee, but it still traveled through the air.
That's actually not bad.
So, one of the problems is that if you're using this, you'd have a weapon in your other hand.
And so, you couldn't really double...
So, I've got my old shield here.
Look, the boss has even fallen out.
But it's much lighter.
And closer to what a historical one would weigh like.
So, just to see how this throws.
That hit the plastic.
Ow, ow, ow, ow, ow.
Held up.
You know, so, Boromir's not...
You hit him in the ghoulies.
Yeah, alright.
This actually has cloth lacquered and glued over top.
So, it has the actual somewhat analogous historical reinforcing behind it.
And so, even though it's really thin, it's pretty solid.
We'll see how long it holds up.
Well, I don't want to be the one...
I already broke a very important Chadversity weapon at one stage.
So, I'm going to stick to my own things in case I break them.
And my OG gambeson.
We asked your wife.
Yeah.
And she said yes.
I'm like, I'll use the geese shirt.
Okay, okay.
We have a new worst thrower.
Oh, no, no, no, no, no.
My throw landed this far away and got caught on the geese strap.
He aimed and went over there.
What do you mean get caught on the g-string?
Geese.
Geese strap.
The strap.
Not the g-strap.
Dirty guy.
Is that wearing a g-string?
There is nothing...
Australians wearing thongs is traditional.
That's actually very true.
Oh, wow.
That is hard to throw.
You missed.
Not by that much.
For the record, that was even further left than mine in the barrel.
It was, yes.
I don't like it.
Give me another shield.
It's getting worse.
So, you guys are throwing it like this?
Yeah.
Yeah, that works.
Well, I was pretending it was another bald chap that I know.
And I was just throwing the shield to him.
All right.
I'll just throw this one.
Same.
Not that way.
Yeah, just double hand frisbee.
That did some damage.
Man, I sound like the...
What's his name?
The flex shield guy.
Where did it hit?
It hit this shield.
Is that it there? Wow.
That flies pretty nice.
Like, I would not want to get hit by that because it has that steel edge around it and it's very thin.
But, not bad at all.
All right.
So, round historically-ish shields, they can be thrown.
So, you want to throw a triangular frisbee.
All right.
Which is a half aerofoil.
And points if you're going to hit there with the point.
So, how?
How?
I'm going to try multiple ways.
I'm sure you will.
Good luck.
I'm going to...
I think I'm going to...
That away.
And a spin.
So, first spin.
Ready?
Boom!
Rah!
Boom!
You all right?
All right.
That actually...
That was all right.
Cool.
The air just, like, pushed it down.
Yeah, yeah.
I could tell, actually.
Exactly what you said.
No, seriously.
Rah!
Spinning works better.
Boom!
That was in the neck.
That's nice.
My aim is getting better, too.
He did beat you in the thrown dagger, though.
Technically.
But I also beat you, so...
You remember when Nate beat you in the thrown dagger?
Yeah, I remember it.
But I'm not trying to beat him.
That was out of Boromir's neck, by the way.
He'll be all right.
You took a chunk out of his neck.
Yeah, that time when Nate beat you with the dagger.
That was when we did that video.
Yeah, yeah.
When Nate beat you.
Yep, yep.
But I beat you, Shad.
And that's what matters.
At the end of the day, that's all that matters.
Nate really does like that G strap thing.
Yeah, he loves that.
Straps.
He keeps saying it.
Yeah.
Did you slap his own ass with that shield?
I did.
I did just slap my own ass with the shield.
It, like, flopped over.
Your overhead thing...
Yeah, give it a go.
I feel like it might work from this range.
That sucks.
All righty, it's my turn.
Now, I don't know what Nate's talking about with all these G-string, G-strip, whatever.
I'm just going to throw it like, you know, a normal person.
Like a man.
We have a new worst shot of the day, people.
That was a bad shot.
I can admit when it was a bad throw.
That was a bad throw.
However, that was very repeatable and it didn't hurt my hands at all.
I was just holding on to this little strap here.
Let me try again.
I'm going to need space.
Space.
We need space, Shad.
Nate, can you collect him, please?
Check him.
See what he's doing.
He must be doing something wrong, because I didn't have that issue.
It's because of the 45 degree angle he's holding.
Okay, so what I did there was I compensated, moved over to the side, and threw over there.
And then hit him in the groin.
So...
Tyron.
Yes.
Are you saying you're experienced in compensating?
You were having some trouble with this, Shad.
Yes.
Keep in mind, he's like...
One, two, two and a half, three metres away.
Are you going to do this one?
Oh, you're doing a long shot.
Good throw.
Are we going to try this little one next?
Yep.
That's cute, I like it.
It's my pokey shield.
Did you make this one?
Yeah, I made all three of these.
Wow, that's really good.
He doesn't give compliments.
It's like a kid with their art project, I don't know.
I know!
Get out of here.
This one, in theory, we should just be able to frisbee.
Just...
In theory, yes.
Yeah, in theory.
Shut up.
Are you upset because that one doesn't have a G-strap string?
It has no geese strap.
Geese, geese.
It's not like geese quack quack, but say it like that, you'll be fine.
It's not a thong.
Oh.
Hey!
Hey, good shot!
Even Bomi agrees.
Yeah, look!
This is one I have the most hope for.
And I feel like when I say that, I'm just jinxing myself.
But let's just see what happens.
So I'll do like a cap throw first.
He's going to get this one bad.
I can hear you, I can hear you.
I actually tried to keep it soft, so I wasn't trying to throw you off then.
But I knew he was going to get that wrong because he's bad at that type of throw.
Yeah, that throw's better.
I think the backhander one.
Better, yeah.
But I'm not into frisbees.
I am, I love frisbees.
I'm not surprised somehow.
What's wrong with frisbees?
You are an anime dub kind of guy.
And a frisbee kind of guy.
I am a frisbee guy, watch this.
Every time you start to trash talk in moments like this, it's just because I'm practicing.
You saw what happened with the heater shield.
Right, yes.
I'll admit, freely, I was bad at it.
I'll even step further back.
Watch this.
But keep in mind that you say that you're an avid frisbee fan or whatever.
I am.
Your average frisbee enjoyer.
Yeah, so that means technically you've had practice with frisbees.
I've never used a frisbee in my life.
Really?
No.
Never?
No.
You poor deprived child.
I can't say things because they'll get demonetized.
I'm sure that there are starved orphans in North Korea that have used frisbees and you haven't.
A frisbee's a c***.
No you didn't.
How dare you.
It frisbee well.
It does have the same shape as your head though.
Boom.
Maybe I'm good at frisbee.
Should give it a go.
Nah.
So that one is easier to aim.
Easier to throw.
But it doesn't have as much power as the other ones because it's small.
Hey tyrant.
Yeah.
You hit him.
I did.
Thank you.
So why don't we move on to actually destroying the shields now.
Yeah.
Conclusions.
Shield.
We're not destroying all of these.
However, if you want to see like one of these more historical, you know, historical ones
destroyed, I theoretically do have one that we could do.
So maybe leave a comment.
Question though.
Did the Captain America shield throw better than the other shields?
No, not really.
I like, uh, in actual fact, the surprising one for me was the heater shield.
That was surprising to you?
That it was surprisingly effective.
I was surprised at how much I hit the target.
Yeah.
Yes.
But I feel like you had, you had to have.
Weren't you surprised at how much?
Oh yeah.
I forgot.
Didn't we do archery last week?
I nailed that, you know, that boulders gate thing.
I did too.
If we want to bring up past glories, things that are in the past.
I loosened it for him.
We have a Captain America shield and clearly because it's a one-to-one analog made out
of our brain and everything.
Captain America.
You know what he hasn't like defended against, which I think is proof that, um, is avoiding
it because no, no arrows.
Oh, I thought you were going to say us.
Okay.
Well that, that as well.
Is there nowhere where he has to deflect an arrow with like.
Not in the movies.
Not that I've seen.
I mean, why do you think he wants Hawkeye on his team and not to fight against him?
So vibranium is weak to arrows.
I think that's, we're going to prove it.
Let's test it.
Vibranium.
Fatal weakness.
You're right.
It is.
Fatal weakness of not hitting the target.
That deflected.
That's interesting.
Let's try to.
Oh, that was dead center.
Let's have a, let's have a look.
Oh, that punctured.
Did we?
Bang.
Nice shot.
Thank you.
Yeah.
And I was drawing it.
The full length.
As far as well, as much as I have the strength for today, let's say, uh, I mean, didn't go
through it.
Well, it went through, but not through.
It's enough of a shot that like the tip of the tip got through, but it didn't actually
manage to push the whole thing in.
I'm surprised the arrow didn't snap.
I feel like that even could have been braced right up against your arm.
So we also hit there.
It got through a tiny bit.
I think that would have been fine.
Like you would have, it's not going to hurt you if you're behind this.
Like look, that doesn't go through the rings of the armor.
Not that Cap wears armor, but.
So I guess, I guess vibranium isn't, isn't that bad.
Steel.
We should mention in case you don't know, this bow is 110 pound draw weight.
I'm probably only drawing it to a hundred today because I'm not feeling too energetic, but
it's a, it's a war bow.
It's hard on the fingies.
I decided not to wear gloves because I'm an idiot.
That was a mistake.
Well, well, well, if it isn't the consequences of my own actions.
Broken arrow.
I was expecting that to happen on the other ones.
Interesting.
So I think like all of these ain't going to kill you.
But this one here, because it doesn't deflect, it puts all that force.
Put everything in.
Yeah.
So it's getting deeper here.
And that one I was specifically drawing, you know, putting power into it.
And so you can see the results.
This has the deepest, biggest hole that we've been able to put in the shield.
Deepest penetration.
Deepest penetration so far.
Why don't you penetrate it, Nate?
You mean miss?
This is kind of strong evidence about who's, who's, who's drawing the bow further back.
Really?
Because this one, this goes straight here.
However, here I just.
I don't know.
Look at that.
Oh, Nate's shooting.
We better get out of here.
Have I ever mentioned how long and respected I feel?
Yep.
Amazing.
Truly is.
A usable weight.
Yeah, this is a good shot.
Shield.
I can literally hear crickets.
Hey.
The shield might not return, but the arrow does.
Let's do it.
You want to go first?
Yeah.
I'll go spike.
I'm doing hammer.
Okay.
I feel like it did more than what the arrow did.
I think it did more than the arrow.
I don't think it got through though.
Ah, that's it there.
No, that's it.
No, that's your arrow.
Oh, okay.
So that's it.
So it didn't.
It did.
It did about as much as the arrow.
Yeah.
About as much as the arrow.
And that was like a moderate amount of force.
That wasn't superhuman by any means, but.
We'll have to check the slow-mo, but I actually think you hit an arrow hole.
I think there was a little, a smaller hole there.
You might be right.
That's weird you being right at this.
It's hammer time.
No, it's not.
I've got to get out of the way first.
All right.
Are we ready?
I heard some crap.
Yeah.
I mean, you probably have a broken arm.
Yeah.
Look at that.
Now, one of the positives of this shield is that you can just grab a hammer and put it
back into place.
Is that why it works with Thor?
Yeah.
Right.
You can see the indent right there.
Really, Shad?
Where was it again?
Corner of the hammer?
I do.
Right there.
Thank you, Shad.
Anytime, sorry.
You can tell those days where they've been like extra convenient because there's just
salt.
Let's go again.
That was fun.
Holy crap.
Look at how far that went in.
That is...
Come on, come around and have a look at this.
Look at this.
Oh, man.
Beck to frigging Corbin, man.
So.
Yeah.
What do we think?
Do we think he survived those?
I mean, look at that one.
Oh, just as a note, that there, the one that went the deepest because it was the first
one, went through both of the cross braces on the back.
Oh, yeah.
It broke that one.
So we have found the weakness.
The limitations of vibranium.
And clearly it's the back to Corbin.
I mean, have you.
So.
So just to add caveat to that, the back to Corbin is the limitation of most things.
Yeah.
The weakness of a lot of types of armor.
But like, seriously, have we seen Captain America's shield in the movies block a back
to Corbin?
No, we haven't.
We have not.
That's true.
And that's why.
That's exactly it.
So this was fun.
It can frisbee.
It can.
It's definitely.
It's got.
It goes fast now.
It's got speed holes.
But other medieval shields actually frisbee.
Not just as well.
Even a bit.
There's nothing unique about this shield.
I would say the heater shield.
I disagree.
Just give me a shield to hold on to my arm.
Make sure I'm not against a Beck.
Hang on.
Are you saying it's a skill issue?
I am not talking about skill issues when it comes to any form of ranged combat.
Let me stay in martial range.
I'm good.
So, hey, if you want to see us throwing shields at each other, remember to become a supporter
because we're going to throw shields at each other or get your hands on a Shatterversity
plushie.
They're available for a short time and they're just so cute.
Link in the description.
Thanks for watching, guys.
Cheers.
