#Business September's existing home sales report released Wednesday showed sales dropped to 3.84 million units, falling short of the 3.88 million estimated and marking a 14-year low. EY senior economist Lydia Boussour and Charles Schwab chief global investment strategist Jeffrey Kleintop join Catalysts to discuss the broader economic implications. Boussour emphasizes that the report indicates ongoing downward pressure from higher interest rates on the housing market. She notes that US housing affordability remains "depressed" and is hovering around its lowest levels since the 1980s, characterizing the current housing market as "frozen." Looking ahead to the Federal Reserve's potential easing cycle, Boussour projects optimism: "As we move into 2025, we do expect to see some of that pressure easing on the housing market, so we do expect to see a gradual recovery." She adds that the broader economy continues to move at a "solid pace." Addressing the ongoing impact of rates on markets, Kleintop points to currently high market valuations, noting that sustained elevated rates put downward pressure on these valuations. He cautions that this environment, combined with slowing economic growth, could "see a beginning of a downtrend in earnings growth" and lead to moderating stock market gains.
Here to break down the latest economic data
and what it means for the U.S. economy,
we've got Lydia Boussor, EY's Senior Economist,
and to help put this into context
from a global perspective, we've got Jeffrey Kleintop.
He is Charles Schwab's Chief Global Investment Strategist.
Lydia, I want to start with you here
because existing home sales coming in at 3.84 million,
falling 1% to a 14-year low here.
That feels very significant to me.
What is your reaction?
Yeah, I mean, I think the data really shows
that we continue to see some downward pressure
from higher interest rates on the housing market.
Housing activity remains under pressure.
When we look at the overall picture,
we still have a depressed housing affordability in the U.S.
It's still hovering around its lowest level since the 1980s.
So we continue to see, you know,
essentially a housing market that's frozen
and where elevated interest rates
and that restrictive policy stance
is putting downward pressure on activity.
Lydia, how big of a risk do you see this being
to future economic growth?
Yeah, I mean, we have the Federal Reserve
that has started to lower interest rates.
So as we move into 2025,
we do expect to see some of that pressure easing
on the housing market.
So we do expect to see a gradual recovery.
But overall, when we look at the economic picture,
we continue to see an economy
that's moving at a fairly solid pace.
If you look at economic growth in the third quarter,
we're looking at growth above 3% for the U.S. economy.
We're also looking at a consumer that's still standing,
even if it is doing so more cautiously,
especially for lower income households.
I think it's important to stress
that we have this bifurcated consumer
when it comes to the U.S.
And overall inflation continues
to move in the right direction.
So I think the economy overall remains on solid footing.
Yeah, it's also interesting noting
that median home prices rose 3% from last year.
Certainly bad news when you think about the Fed's path
forward and the relationship of interest rates
to home prices.
But Jeffrey, I wanna bring you into the conversation here.
Just in terms of how the macro environment
has been impacting particularly fixed income
over the course of the last week,
we're still seeing that rise in yields,
the tenure at over 4.2%.
How long do you think equities can withstand
that kind of upward momentum?
Well, we'll have to see what we hear this week
and next week from an earnings perspective
to see how that can be sustained.
Valuations are very high.
And of course we know when longer term rates rise,
that puts downward pressure on valuations.
And U.S. equities are pressing on a fairly robust outlook
for earnings growth next year.
Analysts are looking for double digit growth.
The problem with that is that we're actually seeing
economic growth slow.
I'm not looking for a recession in the U.S. next year,
but we are seeing GDP growth slow.
According to the IMF estimates came out yesterday
from 2.8% this year to 2.2% GDP growth next year.
And the PMI, which is a really interesting indicator
of what's going on with earnings.
Usually it leads earnings by about three months
in its trend.
The U.S. PMI in manufacturing is showing signs of weakening.
Even as analysts have been rising estimates higher,
we've been seeing economic outlook
from those same business leaders revised downward.
So I think it'll be interesting as we go through
this earning season with very few upward revisions
to estimates as we've, as over the last few weeks,
if we see a beginning of a downtrend in earnings growth
tied to this somewhat softer outlook,
that could undermine stock market's gains.
This year we've already seen some weakness this week
that could extend into next week as well.
So what does that tell us about the potential levels
that we could see for yields then
if that were in fact to be the case?
Well, they could come down a little bit.
We think that this probably,
the time to extend duration is, you know,
probably passed at this point.
Maybe yields stabilize a little bit here.
I think where we might see rates come down
more dramatically is outside the U.S.
You know, we just had 15 minutes ago,
a 50 basis point rate cut from the Bank of Canada
as the economy slows there
and inflation's coming down rapidly.
In fact, inflation's coming down much more rapidly
outside the U.S. than inside the U.S.
I think you could see more downside to yields
both in the short and longer term outside the U.S.
which could really benefit valuations
where they're still relatively low
and that could benefit international performance
here in the fourth quarter.
Lydia, I'm curious how all of this ties into
both your thoughts on the next Fed meeting
and just the amount of growth that we do continue to see
in the U.S. despite some of that kind of bifurcated consumer
that you mentioned.
Given that we do keep seeing strong data
in the face of that,
do you think that we could potentially get a no-cut
Yeah, that's not our base case.
If you look at the overall economic backdrop,
we're also in the camp that, you know,
economic activity overall is softening
and that as we look into 2025,
we should continue to see that gradual
and gentle slowdown in activity.
For consumer, we are seeing more prudence
on the part of consumer,
but businesses are also being more cautious
with their spending.
So from, you know, a risk management perspective,
when you think about the Fed,
going into the November meeting and the end of the year,
we still have a label market that has softened
and that is back into balance.
So you're no longer seeing that upward pressure on inflation.
And at the same time, we have inflation
that continues to move in the right direction.
So I do think that there is still a solid case
for the Fed to move away from that restrictive policy stance.
And so we're expecting to see a 25 basis point rate cut
at both the November and December meeting.
And as we head into 2025,
we do expect to see that continued cooldown in activity
carrying over into next year.
And we do see growth, you know, at around 1.9% next year.
And that would come down from about, you know,
2.7% expected this year for US growth.
Jeffrey, how does that compare to your expectations?
Well, you know, I think as we take a look at interest rates,
you know, central banks seem to be on a path
for easing pretty much at every meeting
of European Central Bank, Bank of Canada, the US Fed.
I think that's old news now.
I think it's time for investors to pivot
to a focus on fiscal policy.
Of course, that involves taxes and spending.
And of course, we've got a US election coming up,
so that could be up in the air.
But I think what's interesting
is that we are starting to see a shift
towards tighter fiscal policy.
At the same time,
central banks are committed to easing monetary policy.
And when those two move in opposite directions,
the outcome is not all that certain.
Generally, it can mean a drag on earnings growth,
even if it lifts valuations.
We're seeing big economies like Germany, France, Italy,
China, all pursuing tighter fiscal policies,
intentionally or unintentionally this year and next year
to rein in their budgets to meet targets.
And that could result in a drag on GDP,
a drag on earnings growth.
At the same time, monetary policy is trying to boost it.
So there'll be a bit of a tug of war
between monetary and fiscal policy next year,
something we didn't see in 2023, 2022, or 2021,
where they were in sync.
Jeffrey Kleintop, Lydia Boussort,
thank you so much to both of you
for kicking off the hour with us here.