Exploring the Future of Occupational Safety Research

CDC
258 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 25, 2024
October 2024 Foresight Friday @ NIOSH webinar: This presentation describes a forward-facing strategic foresight project that proactively investigated the long-term future of occupational safety research. Analysis of evidence-based scenarios identified opportunities for strategic action to enhance and advance safety research methods, innovation, systems thinking, networking, and scientific ethics as we move into the future.
For more information on Strategic Foresight at NIOSH: https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/strategic-foresight/php/about/index.html
This video can also be viewed at
https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/video/lo-res/ORI/ORI_FF_Oct_11_2024_LoRes.mp4
welcome to foresite Friday at Nash my
name is Nicole Edwards and I was the
office of research integration at
Nash we are very excited to have our
colleagues Sarah felner and Jessica stri
with us today to review the methods and
results from a recent strategic
foresight exercise that Nash conducted
to explore the future of Occupational
Safety Research Sarah is Professor in
the department of environmental and
occupational health and director of the
Southwest Center For Occupational and
environmental health at the University
of Texas Health Science Center at the
Houston School Public Health she has had
over 35 years of experience in
occupational safety and health research
training and service in the US and
internationally her recent work focused
on developing strategies and tools to
anticipate the occupational health
challenges in the future of work and
explore the new need for an expanded
Focus for occupational safety and health
through a Futures oriented approach to
planning and
action Jessica serves as deputy director
for the
Nash office of research research
integration as part of this role she
leads the nias Strategic foresight
initiative a Futures focused service
that seeks to explore how unfolding
changes may impact near Mid and
long-term approaches to occupational
safety and health
Jessica has co-authored a number of
Publications and presentations examining
safety and health related challenges and
opportunities for workers today and in
the
future Sarah and Jessica thank you for
being with us today and now I will turn
things over to Sarah thank you and good
morning everyone it's a real pleasure
for me to be presenting alongside Dr
Jessica strip and we're glad to be here
with you today to tell you about Na's
recent exploration into the future of
Occupational Safety
Research I had the privilege of working
on this project with Jessica and other
colleagues while I was the associate
director for research integration at
Nash we'd like to start today by
acknowledging our naos colleagues who
devoted their time and expertise to the
success of this project that we'll be
sharing with you today and we're very
grateful for their
contributions there are also a few
additional groups who we'd like to
recognize first the six volunteers from
the naos division of Safety Research who
gave their time and expert perspectives
to help us establish a present day view
of Safety
Research also the 27 confidential
individuals who participated as subject
matter expert
interviewees many of whom also
contributed to helping us craft
scenarios in a one-day
workshop and finally Dr Andy Hines and
Miss Nikki Obert from the University of
Houston's foresight program who Prov
provided consultation and support
throughout the project we want to start
today by exploring the future of
Occupational Safety Research and looking
at the project Genesis and the benefits
of foresight as a method of inquiry as
we all know naos was established under
the occupational safety and health Act
of 1970 with a mandate to assure so far
as possible every working person in the
nation safe and healthful working
conditions and to preserve our human
resources to meet this charge nios
maintains a robust and thriving
portfolio of Occupational Safety
Research that seeks to identify reduce
and prevent work rated injuries and
deaths across the US Labor
Force for many years the portfolio has
consisted of basic ideologic
surveillance intervention translation
and implementation research to address a
variety of known occupational
hazards including chemical hazards such
as solvents paints and toxic dust
biological hazards including viruses and
bacteria physical hazards such as
confined spaces extreme temperatures
noise and vibrations and psychosocial
hazards including the organization of
work work hours and work rated violence
in recent years nios has focused some of
its resources on explor exploring the
future of work and the changes that it
suggests for occupational safety and
health we've gained important insights
into the changes that are happening all
around us and having an impact on what
it means to work who engages in work and
where work can be
performed changes can be seen in such
areas as technology demands for new
skills and changing job Arrangements
which suggest hazards in the future of
work may be quite different than they
are today the potential for uncertainty
and ambiguity with the com within the
complex systems that are impacted by
those changes raised important questions
about how responsive Occupational Safety
Research might be conducted in the
future and what topics that research
might
explore it was with this challenge in
mind that Nash designed its exploration
into the future of Occupational Safety
Research through our work work we sought
to better understand possible changes
that may impact the future of work and
the hazards and risks it
brings reflect on our current
preparedness to address or respond to
those changes and then generate options
that might contribute to a robust
resilient and thriving approach to
Occupational Safety Research because we
were focusing on future Readiness we
structured our inquiry as a strategic
foresight invest
investigation strategic foresight is a
Futures oriented approach that can help
enhance the way we think about and plan
for the future the practice of foresight
involves identifying assessing and
monitoring signals of potential future
change the insights that we gain from
these signals can help both individuals
and
organizations Better understand prepare
for and influence the UN predictable
future applying a foresight approach can
also help overcome three cognitive
biases that may otherwise limit how we
think about what's possible for the
future forite relies heavily on signals
of change coming from outside our own
organization which we must actively seek
out the process of gathering evidence to
gain an outside in view of the future
can help combat availability bias or the
tendency to consider only recent or
easily accessible information when
making
decisions it can also improve active
interference capacity which allows us to
seek out information and continuously
update our beliefs and behaviors to
minimize uncertainty and optimize
outcomes foresight is also largely a
scenario-based practice going through
the process of creating evidence-based
stories about what the future could Poss
possibly entail can help reduce
confirmation bias or the tendency to
seek evidence that aligns with our
existing beliefs and
theories by considering more than what
we think we know will happen in the
future we can minimize
surprise and finally foresight
encourages us to think about long-term
future States and then back into plans
that can begin
today this future back approach to
planning can help fight against status
quo bias or our tendency to maintain
current States because that's what's
comfortable and that can help facilitate
organizational and individual growth and
evolution n has published a foresight
framework for occupational safety and
health to help researchers and
practitioners engage in the practice of
strategic
foresight this framework is a safety and
health specific adaptation of the
framework foresight created by the
University of Houston
it provides a clear step-by-step row map
of a six stages foresight process in
which you frame the domain central
question or issue of
Interest scan collect data related to
strong and weak signals of potential
change related to The
Domain and develop future alternative
scenario
stories vision the implications issues
risks challenges and opportunities
associated with each
scenario design and Implement responsive
strategies and
actions and continuously monitor for new
signals of change as new signals are
located they're used as inputs for
future foresight efforts and now Jessica
will describe how we applied the
foresight framework to complete the naos
Safety Research foresight project or
srfp for short
Jessica thanks Sarah so the activities
of the srfp really focused on the first
four stages of the foresight framework
we started at the beginning of the
process by intentionally framing the
project and we identified the domain of
interest for the project as occupational
safety then to bound our exploration of
that topic we went through a series of
brainstorming and discussion exercises
to identify the key topics that are
specifically critical to the future of
Safety
Research the final list of topics
included Partnerships regulations the
Workforce Technology and work-related
hazards and
risks and recognizing that our Safety
Research will not be conducted in a
vacuum we situated those Key Safety
Research topics within a broader set of
contextual steep factors the social
technological environmental economic and
political factors that will have a broad
impact on how the future unfolds we then
developed a list of key words that were
related to each of the five key
occupational safety topics and those
five main steep factors and used those
keywords to help us gather and make
sense of information in the remaining
project activities once that domain was
set we completed a current assessment of
Occupational Safety Research as it
exists in functions today um with
support from our experts in the Nash
division of Safety Research who were
recognized at the beginning of this
presentation we summarized relevant
conditions key interest groups and major
occupational safety Milestones from the
past 50
years the current conditions included
factors that are both internal and
external to our agency that influence
the way we approach Safety Research the
key interest groups included
organizations that have a vested
interest in Occupational Safety Research
findings and the recent history captured
a number of events since the passing of
the ash act in 1970 that established
Nash and among those events were the
establishment of many surveillance
programs and other significant
initiatives that have contributed to our
Safety Research
capacity so this current assess exercise
wasn't intended to provide a
comprehensive or systematic review of
Occupational Safety but instead it
really helped establish a baseline
descriptive characterization that shed
light on the current state of
Occupational Safety
Research and so with that current
assessment complete and having that in
mind as sort of present day operations
we started searching for information on
how the future of Occupational Safety
Research might be different from today
and we used a two-pronged approach to
collect our evidence so the first was a
systematic scan or review of online
resources we used the key words that we
developed from our domain map um and a
team of six scanners searched the
peer-reviewed literature and other
information sources like books
government and research reports trade
Publications magazines newspapers
newsletters um blogs and then other
opinion pieces too to look for signals
of the forces that might shape the
future of Occupational Safety
Research um two months of that scanning
on those variety of
resources um for just a few minutes a
week um collectively probably no more
than around an hour per week returned
177 unique scanning
hits and in parallel we also conducted a
series of 27 one-on-one interviews with
18 Federal and nine non-federal
employees
these individuals are all respected
scientists and thought leaders in areas
that are relevant to occupational safety
including industry sectors like mining
Agriculture and
construction um and also safety topics
like diversity equity and inclusion
traumatic injury Motor Vehicle Safety
and Robotics um and those interviews
were Guided by a set of predetermined
questions that were designed to focus on
major successes and shortcomings in
Occupational Safety Research and the
trends decisions and obstacles that we
should consider when we're preparing for
the future of research in the
occupational safety space the scanning
hits and interview transcripts were
analyzed using traditional qualitative
research methods for both thematic and
content
analysis and the key themes that emerged
served as the basis for developing six
drivers of change or key factors that
might shape the future of research and
occupational
safety to prepare those for use in the
foresight process each of the drivers of
change was stated as a key uncertainty
question or important question about the
future for which there is currently no
clear
answer the possible responses for each
uncertainty question were then defined
along a singular Continuum with
polarized
anchors so we had a driver for example
of technological advancement and the key
question we identified in that area was
do technological advancements bring more
Ben benefits and Solutions or more
hazards to the workplace with the answer
to that question falling somewhere along
a Continuum that's defined by the
extremes of exclusively more benefits or
exclusively more hazards um recognizing
that the actualized future that we'll
experience will fall somewhere within
the Continuum not necessarily at one of
those
extremes and then with safety and health
integration just as another example of a
driver um we framed the key point in
that area
um with the question will there be
widespread acceptance for holistic
approaches to integrate occupational
safety and health or will the field
remain loyal to traditional approaches
to occupational safety with the answer
to that question falling somewhere along
a Continuum that's defined by the
extremes of a completely holistic
approach to uh only staying with our
traditional
approaches so we used those six key
uncertainty questions as the building
blocks to construct scenarios or stories
that describe possible futures for
Safety Research 21 of our 27 expert
interviewees joined us in a virtual
participatory Workshop to help flesh out
those
scenarios and there are different
methods from the strategic planning um
and strategic foresight um body of
literature that you can use as a
blueprint for building scenarios but for
this project we used what's called a 2
by two Matrix method and so in this
method you identify the two most
critical uncertainty questions for your
domain and use those to define the axes
of a 2 by two Matrix in then in which
you construct your
scenarios so during our Workshop the
experts who are with us quickly
identified the uncertainties related to
technology advancements and safety and
health integration as the most important
and uncertain for the future of
Occupational Safety Research and then
assigned those arbitrarily um as the X
and Y AIS of our Matrix so there's not
really a a specific reason why one is
the X and one is the Y just each needs
to be assigned to an axis so you can see
we have um our technological
advancements as our x-axis here with
more hazards and more benefits defining
those poles and then the integration of
safety and health as our y AIS um
ranging in possibilities from
exclusively traditional approaches to
exclusively holistic
approaches and then we broke into small
groups while we were in the workshop to
discuss how the remaining uncertainties
might play out in the four quadrants
that we've now built with this Matrix
and so at the end of the workshop the
full group of experts reconvened to
debrief share insights and identify the
implications that these four scenarios
hold for Safety Research after the
workshop um our core project team worked
with the notes and recordings and
consulted with the University of Houston
to refine the scenario stories and the
implications that we derived the final
stories are each around 500 Words um so
for the sake of time today we'll just
share a brief summary of each of the
scenarios so you have a feel for what
those four Futures kind of looked like
so in the upper right quadrant of the
Matrix we have a future called
technological utopianism um this is a
future in which more holistic approach
to safety and health greatly reduces
work-related injury and illness while
technological advancements improve
workplace safety data access and
collaboration opportunities so in some
way this is sort of a a best case
scenario um in the lower left quadrant
sort of the the polar opposite if you
will of that we have a scenario called
ineffectual occupational safety and
health this is a future in which
technology fails to improve the safety
of work processes across Industries and
the use of traditional and siloed
approaches to occupational safety and
health result in increased injury rates
and greater Occupational Health
disparities so in some ways this is sort
of a worst case scenario right where
Tech has brought more hazards and we're
staying with traditional sort of siloed
feeling approaches to our safety and
health
research then in between those we have
our other um quadrants of The Matrix so
in the lower right we have limited
utility this is a future in which
occupational safety and health remains
rooted in Tradition and fails to
innovate which stunts our capacity to
proactively identify and address the
unintended psychosocial and
socioeconomic risks that accompany the
positive safety benefits that are
afforded by new work rated
Technologies and then in the upper left
quadrant we have unintended consequences
a future in which emerging Technologies
and strong Partnerships with industry
leaders have enhanced surveillance
capabilities and data access but have
also brought new concerns around dual
use of occupational safety and health
research so we considered input from the
individual and group analysis of each of
those four scenarios to identify key
considerations for Occupational Safety
Research collectively the considerations
related to building collaborations um
generating and translating safety
related evidence enhancing
Communications exploring emerging
Technologies as a key safety priority
utilizing new types of data addressing
barriers to safety progress safeguarding
the misuse of research findings and
supporting diversity equity and
inclusion in the Occupational Safety
Research Workforce so then we took this
list of considerations and envisioned
the potential implications that they
suggest for the future of Occupational
Safety
research the extracted implications
coales around five major topics these
topics represent five main areas where
strategic action that starts today might
help us position Occupational Safety
Research for resilience and thriving in
an uncertain
future first we have enhancing
occupational safety research methods and
approaches amplifying the occupational
safety toolbox might include considering
new types of research and surveillance
expanding implement ation science and
pilot testing new risk prevention
strategies next we have building
capacity to conduct Innovative
Occupational Safety
Research improving um Occupational
Safety Research abilities to engage in
Leading Edge knowledge generation might
involve increasing representation of the
social and Behavioral Sciences in
occupational safety research projects
investing in Advanced Training for
research data analysts and stat
Ians and providing all Safety Research
staff with foundational knowledge and
work rated Technologies and their safety
risks hazards and benefits next we have
implementing systems thinking in
Occupational Safety Research um the
principles of systems thinking or
ecological modeling of research um
issues that we might address in the
occupational safety space might help us
look more closely at the complexities
around occupational safety systems-based
approaches might be incorporated into
Occupational Safety Research by
designing activities that identify and
address not only the challenges um but
also the benefits associated with new
Safety
Solutions considering Health Equity
investigating facilitators and barriers
to decision-making and exploring the
external factors that influence change
at the individual
organizational industrial and societal
levels and then we have networking and
connect
um occupational safety researchers might
consider collaborating with public
health to address safety issues since
there is sort of a natural um natural
linkage there um we might also build and
maintain um not only new Partnerships
but also um our existing Partnerships so
thinking about how to bolster those um
particularly in the areas of emerging
Technologies and then identify Salient
opportunities to strengthen public trust
in the occupational safety community
community and finally um we have
preventing the misuse of science so the
Occupational Safety and Health Community
as a whole can work together to
determine whether policies that are
related to dual use research are being
appropriately applied to protect workers
against the misuse of Science and
leverage skilled communication
strategies to prevent the misapplication
of published occupational research
findings working through the Strategic
foresight process really helped us
develop a series of long-term Visions
for occupation Safety Research in the
form of the scenarios and those are
intended to help inform priority setting
and the design of strategic planning
efforts that can start today so with
this project the insights that we gained
through scanning for evidence helped us
construct those scenarios or stories
about that far-term future and then
assessing these scenarios broadened our
consideration of challenges and
opportunities for the Safety Research
Arena working with those far-term future
Stories We then ident identified areas
where strategic action is needed to
reshape and transition our current
practices and build new capabilities to
reinforce the strength and resilience of
Occupational Safety Research as we move
into the future we encourage
organizations to use these areas for
Action to inform strategic decision and
planning efforts in both the present and
near-term future um they might help us
make choices for example on how and
where to invest and align our resources
and capabilities so that we're moving
the Safety Research field forward in
preferred directions but integrating
foresight exercises like this one into
organizational thinking and decision
making allows for the development of
Futures informed strategies and plans um
and this can help bolster organizational
preparedness Advantage Innovation and
performance and this will be especially
important as we move into the uncertain
future of work and seek to conduct
research that helps us proactively
understand and address new challenges
and Hazards for work and working
people so in terms of our prepared
remarks we'll leave you today with the
list of resources that we consulted when
creating this presentation and working
through the project and the event you'd
like to learn more about foresight um
and we want to let you know that the
Nash office of research integration
welcomes your feedback and questions on
our work um not only today but in the
future as well and we welcome email
Communications from fellow futurists and
those who'd like to learn more about our
growing activity in the foresight
space uh and so with that thank you very
much for your time and attention and I
will turn things back to
Nicole um thank you both Sarah and
Jessica for walking us through the
Strategic foresight process that nios
used to explore the future of
Occupational Safety Research we welcome
anyone interest in learning more about
Nash's work to advance the role of
foresight in O research and practice to
visit the Strategic foresight at Nash
webpage at its new URL the link will
also be dropped in the chat
