My Owner Hates Me :: Let's Play OOTP 25 :: Ep. 6 (2025 Second Half)

Baseball Channel
134 followers
Comments are disabled for this video.
Draft day. Because we didn't sign our first round pick last year, we get two first round picks.
We will pick 5th and 13th. We did not make it into the lottery. The lottery was the Pirates,
White Sox, Nationals, and Royals. And the Pirates will be picking first. And I think that's, what,
third time in five years or something like that? All right, it's time for us to pick. The first
four picks in the draft, three of them were high schoolers. One of them was Ethan Holliday. He goes
number one overall. Brady Abel, is he, is he related to Dino? I feel like there's just so
many, like, baseball families nowadays. Ethan Petri, this is a guy I was looking at,
but he is off the board. And Seth Hernandez, a high school hurler. So I find myself in a similar
situation as last year. The top rated player according to potential, this is for my scout,
is Cruz Schoolcraft. But I don't really like his ratings that much, like a 45 control potential
for a high school starter. That carries some reliever risk for me, even though his stuff is
pretty nasty and his movement is pretty nasty. I don't know, I'm not going to go after him,
even though his demand is only two million. The best player available to me is Coy James,
who would probably be a alright shortstop, but better at second base, most likely. This is the
best player, but his demand is nine and a half million. You'll remember what happened last year,
and it's not totally clear to me what happened last year, like, you know, how to manipulate the
draft budget or whatever, it's still the same budget. The way I think I understand it now is I
have five million to go over slot, if that makes sense. But yeah, I just, I messed up the negotiations
last time. And the thing about this pick is, you know, you can't get a comp pick again. You can
only do it once. This is already a comp pick that I'm using now to pick fifth. And so the safest
player, even though I don't think he's as good, is the college bat, Devin Taylor, a left fielder
with some good power and eye potential. And his expectation for his bonus is just slot money. So
what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna pick Devin Taylor now, and if Coy James is still around at 13,
I'll pick him, knowing that I don't necessarily have to sign him, I can get the comp pick back.
But I don't, I'm not sure if he'll last at 13. I'm pretty confident he won't. But Devin Taylor,
safe pick, college bat, draft player. Alright, this is how the rest of the draft has gone. We
are picking again at 13. And luckily for us, Coy James is still around. I'm gonna look at some of
the pictures real quick, but I'm probably gonna end up picking Coy James here. Yeah, I'm gonna
go Coy James here with the knowledge that this pick we can get back, because this is not a comp
pick. This is a pick we could get back as a comp pick if we can't sign Coy James, similarly to how
we couldn't sign Conor Griffin last time. So this is a safer spot to pick him, for sure. Second
round now, I'm gonna pick Jaden Stroman. I like his fielding ratings. I like that he is a good
contact hitter. The power is probably where he's lacking most, but I feel like he's the best player
available, particularly the best player available with a good personality. And that includes high
intelligence, which should aid in his development. Third round now, Sam Cozart is a high school
pitcher who I almost picked in the second round. Glad I didn't, he sticks around for the third.
His demand is a little bit higher than the slot value, which might make it tricky to sign him,
especially with, you know, Coy James being one of our first round picks, but I will still draft him
and I can get a comp pick if I'm unable to sign him. Fourth round now, I've had my eyes on Donovan
Jeffrey, and I haven't really drafted for power much, but this guy has some of the best projected
power in the entire draft class, a 65 and high work ethic. Doesn't really look great otherwise,
doesn't have much to offer defensively, would probably be a first baseman, but for the power
potential, I'm going to take Donovan Jeffrey. And in the fifth round, I will be picking Brady Neal,
a college catcher out of LSU. He has some of the best defensive ratings in this draft class among
catchers. Offensively, he's going to have to hopefully outperform this. I do like that he
hits lefty, you know, that could be a platoon someday, right? But Brady Neal coming in as our
fifth round pick, I will do the rest of the draft on screen and I'll let you know how far I went.
The draft is over, I ended up doing the first 15 rounds and letting the CPU take over from there,
but here are our top five picks. We will begin negotiations with them. Hopefully it goes better
than last year. We'll start with Devin Taylor, the fifth overall pick in the draft. He wants slot,
he gets slot. Jaden Stroman, he wants slot, he gets slot. And Donovan Jeffrey, he wants slot,
I will give him slot. And then next up is Coy James, who I'm gonna have to make a tough
negotiation with. He's not coy about the fact that he wants 9.5 million and he's threatening
to go to Ole Miss if I don't give him that. However, if I try to meet his demand and submit
the offer, I get this again, the owner does not approve this offer because it's over the recommended
slot bonus. And I think this is sort of the key sentence here, the owner will not approve over
slot bonuses. Now, I don't know why that's the case because even if my draft budget is 5 million,
if we take a look at the just overall finances of the team, let's go here, right? You know,
we have a lot of money available to us. We have 10 million projected in budget room,
13 million potentially available. You know, I could take money out of scouting budget and
development budget, but the point is it doesn't seem like it would go into my draft budget,
because that's exactly what it was last year. So I don't, I guess, is this just my owner? Is
that what this is? I mean, his involvement is normal, but is that just one of his rules as a
penny pincher is that I will not sign anyone over the slot? Because I just, I guess I didn't
totally understand that. I mean, I thought if I could save money, you know, then I could spend
it on the draft. And that is not looking to be the case unless I'm totally missing something. So
with, with Coy James, probably not going to sign him. And it'll be a similar situation to
Connor Griffin. We'll get a comp pick around this spot. And what's tricky too, is Sam Cozart and
Brady Neal, both technically won over slot. I have a good feeling that we won't get Cozart,
in which case we would get a comp pick for that as well. Because the best I can do is in this
situation is offer slot, it appears. So I can offer him the slot money. I bet he won't take it,
but this is so close, the 520 to the 505. And the fact that his signability is normal here for
Brady Neal, I bet we will get him playing hardball with a slot, even though if it were me, and I was
in charge of the budget, I would be happy to just give him the extra 15 to make sure we get his
services. But we'll set to slot, submit offer. And I guess with Coy James, we don't have anything
else to do besides set the slot and submit the offer for him as well. All right, here we are at
the All-Star break with a 38 and 58 record. And I think this is a low point. I have scrolled through
the AL All-Star roster. And look, if you see someone with an OAK next to their name,
you know, feel free to let me know in the comments, but I don't. I don't think we got a
single All-Star this year, which I don't think, I think the game should just give me an All-Star,
right? You have to have at least one All-Star. The game did not give me an All-Star. I would have
guessed Denzel Clark or someone like that, or maybe a reliever. We'll see. But, you know,
in terms of who's having a monster season, in the American League, Julio is having a monster season.
He finished runner-up in MVP to Marcus Simeon last year. Looks like he's trying to get that
this year. Ricky Tiedemann, in terms of F4, is having a monster season, although his ERA may
be not as indicative of that. The Blue Jays are really bad. The Blue Jays are really bad,
but he's really good. Although it'll be Corbin Burns for Baltimore starting. So I guess he got
extended. Yeah, so they signed him to a six-year extension for about $150. In the National League,
let's see, Zach Gallin is having a monster year. You'll recall he was traded to the Mets. He's
doing much better with the Mets than he did the previous year in Arizona. I will point out Acuna,
who was MVP last year, broke a kneecap out five months. So he is an All-Star, or he would have
made the roster, but broke a kneecap out five months. Maybe we'll get an injury replacement
or something like that. In fact, I'm seeing, you know, Jackson Merrill injured and Austin Reilly
injured as well. But the big one is Elie De La Cruz. He's having the best season in the
big league so far, slugging 700 on pace for 60 home runs and 34 stolen bases. So that's a look
at your All-Stars. As we get to July 20th and approach the deadline right here, I do want to
point out Paul Blackburn. He has pitched another good game for us, five innings, one run allowed,
picked up the win. He's been probably our best pitcher this year, and he is a free agent after
2025. So he is definitely someone that I'm thinking could be traded at the deadline,
because otherwise we're going to have to extend him. The other option, and I mean, he's pitched
really well the last two years, so I don't know how it would go down, but would be to, you know,
let his contract expire and then try to submit a qualifying offer. And either we get him back
or we get another draft pick. So I'm curious about that. I'll have to weigh the pros and cons
of the comp pick versus what I can get for him at the deadline. So the end result for our top
draftees is Coy James won't sign with us and Sam Cozart won't sign with us. That's kind of what I
predicted, that that college catcher, I think his name's Brady Neal, his demand was close enough to
the slot that it didn't matter. But for Sam Cozart it did, and obviously for Coy James it did. So we
will get comp picks for both of these, I believe. July 26th, Walker Buhler's 30-day rehab is run
out. How did he do during his 30-day rehab? Fine. Honestly, it helps to remember that the offensive
environment is crazy in Las Vegas. We're going to bring him up and we may take, you know, Braxton
Ashcraft or someone like that out of the rotation for a turn, but the idea is we're probably going
to trade Paul Blackburn. In a corresponding move, I've sent down Zach Jackson, which is surprising.
He was maybe our best reliever last year. He was really, really good. This year, not as good. It's
really the home run rate that is killing him. Nine homers in 41 innings versus five in 66 last year,
but yeah, total night and day, and he has options. You know, we have him on a contract where he's in
his RBers right now, so hopefully just a reset in AAA for him. I imagine he could be back up
back soon. July 29th, it is Blackburn bump day. It could be the last Blackburn bump day. We know
how well he's performing. We know he's in the final year of his contract. We know where the team
is at. We're at a 44 and 62 record. Let's see how he can do. We lost one to three. That means he
didn't allow too many runs. He allowed three runs and five and a third, and yeah, we will seek out
our opportunities on the trade market. All right, we've hit the trade deadline. I would say the most
likely players to be traded are Jared Triolo and Paul Blackburn. I'm going to shop around and see
what I can get done. All right, from using the shop feature, I would say the Houston Astros are
probably the team most interested in Triolo, so I'll see what I can formulate for them. So here's
the deal I worked out with the Astros. It is centered around the young pitching prospect,
Luis Rivera. His projected ratings look pretty good to me. I like that his changeup could be
his best pitch, but he's only 17, and there's a lot of development left for him to do. We'll get
Tyler Matzek as well. You know, his contract expires at the end of this year, and we've just
kind of struggled with lefties in the bullpen, especially in Kyle Muller's absence. We'll take
Hunter Brown. Things have not gone well for Hunter Brown. He started the year with Houston, had a six
ERA, and then now he's been pitching in AAA, where he has an eight ERA. I think convert him to a
reliever is probably the smart thing for us to do here. And Joey Loperfido. Some of these
experiments with, you know, Miguel Sano and, you know, even Joshua Mears, I think are coming to an
end, and I would just like to have another option in terms of just having a bat, you know? So that's
what we're going to do. That's the trade we're going to make. Oh, I guess we'll have to include,
let's go Miles Naylor to make this work. A former 2023 first rounder, by the way, not my regime,
but, you know, he has high work ethic, and he's only 20, so he could outperform these projected
ratings, but these projected ratings have gone down since we've had him in. If you look at what
he's done in 2024 and 2025, it's just not great, and maybe he was overmatched. Maybe he was too
young to be an A ball in 2024, but this year the repeat still is 78 OPS plus. I'm okay letting him
go if this is the return. We still have a upside prospect here in Rivera, and we've got our less
lucrative Paul Blackburn trade. We'll also throw in Kyle McCann, who in real life, at least as I'm
recording this, and you're probably watching this episode well after I recorded it, just had like a
big go-ahead home run in the majors for Oakland, but Blackburn goes. I thought about keeping him
because the return, the interest level on him was low, and I think maybe one thing this game could
tweak is the interest level in pitchers with expiring contracts because they pay for two
months. People pay for two months of good pitching, and Paul Blackburn's been a good
pitcher the last two years. Anyways, we're getting Zach Brixey in return, and what we've really
needed is a relief prospect, a young cost control reliever who has options. That's something we've
lacked, and the bullpen has really let us down, and I'm trying to definitely bolster it. Again,
thought about keeping Blackburn, but my fear is he limps down the stretch, right? Then I can't do
the qualifying offer, but I wouldn't necessarily want to extend him either. With Walker Buehler
back in the rotation, I think this is probably the smart move, although it hurts because Paul
Blackburn is an Oakland A's legend. I'm really trying to keep original Oakland A's around,
and it's becoming more and more difficult to do that, so we'll complete this trade for Zach
Brixey of the Washington Nationals. August player development update. Walker Buehler's ratings are
back up, which is good. They're back up to about what they were when we signed him, so that looks
good. He is in the rotation now. He'll get his first start with the team soon. Also, some positive
updates on this guy who is actually a scouting discovery, so I had nothing to do with signing
him. He was just discovered, and granted, he's only 16, and there's a lot of development left
to do, but potentially looking like a really good pitcher. Trent Colcott, who has just turned 17,
is someone who I signed and is someone who I actually scouted out myself, but I signed him
for 1.5 million international amateur last winter. Switch hitting Australian catcher has some pop,
and his ratings are back up. Let's talk about player development as a whole because
we have some prospect updates. A quick prospect check-in, not much news from Rookie Ball,
which is where actually the majority of our prospects are. We're a very young system because
I keep drafting high schoolers. I had some good international amateur signings,
and my scout has made some scouting discoveries, so we don't have a lot of prospects that are in
A Ball or AA or AAA right now. They're all kind of in Rookie Ball and waiting to make their debut
in full-season ball. The closest is probably Adrian Santana. I mean, he will almost certainly
start in A Ball next year. We do have Devin Taylor in A Ball. That was our fifth overall pick
in the draft this year. He's looking like he could be pretty good. His potential is up to a
three-and-a-half star. The big news as we were progressing was with these outfielders, Enrique
Bradfield Jr. and Brock Jones. Earlier this year, they got a promotion from AA to AAA. Bradfield,
as you can see, has not taken to it well. In AA, he was hitting pretty well with a 400 on base
percentage, and in AAA, he has a 4 OPS+. I thought maybe he would make a run at the big leagues this
year. It didn't happen. The closest one is actually Brock Jones. Brock Jones has made a better
transition to AAA, I would say, and I will be moving around the roster quite a bit post-trade
deadline. I'm ready for basically some experiments to come to an end, and I'll show you all what I
mean by that. The first order of business is waiving and DFAing Miguel Sano. He just hasn't
gotten the job done for us. It's that righty power bat I've been looking for. 73 OPS+, no defensive
value to speak of. Waive and DFA. The second is sending Joshua Mears down to AAA. I was very
confident in him. I made him a starting player right away on our roster as soon as we traded
for him, and it hasn't worked out. He's on pace for a record-breaking amount of strikeouts,
and basically he needs to get down to AAA and probably get in the player development lab
this offseason. We'll really try to bring up that avoid case. If we can bring that up to a 35,
bring that contact up just a little bit, he's going to be really good, I believe, in him for
the future, but right now we need to explore other options at the big league level, so we're going to
go ahead and send him down to AAA. So this is how we're lining up for now, albeit with the caveat
that Nick Ahmed is coming back in two weeks and he will play shortstop. We'll have Jacob Wilson
still leading off, still playing shortstop. Lawrence Butler joins the fray. He will play
right field and bat seventh for us. Joey Lo Perfido, who we traded for at the deadline,
will DH against right-handed pitching for us, and Brendan Malone will bat ninth and play second base
versus left-handed pitching. We have also brought back up Anthony Seigler, who is really, his main
skill is just his eye. He walks a lot, and so we're actually going to have him bat leadoff and
play catcher those days with Langeliers DHing. Lo Perfido still stays around. He's going to bat
ninth and play left field, and yeah, that's how we're going to set up. Pitching-wise, it looks
like this. Walker Bueller in the rotation and Tyler Matzik as a lefty specialist, as well as
Hunter Brown as a middle reliever. August 10th, 2025, a day-to-day moderate injury for Brady Basso.
I have to decide whether I want to put him on the IL or not. I would say yes. I mean, the season is
lost, and we will probably just put him on the 15-day and throw Scherzer or Hunter Brown in the
rotation. August 28th here, Zach Gelof is injured, diagnosis pending. We're also 53-79, where we will
almost certainly finish with a worse record than last year, which is a really bad feeling. It feels
like we're going backwards. Zach Gelof, knee tendinitis, four weeks. That'll just about end
his season. He may be able to come back for the last few games, similar to Kyle Isbell. So it's
going to be Malone playing second base down the stretch for us, which kicks Jacob Wilson over to
third. He has played, you know, all over the infield and hasn't quite hit yet. It may have
promoted him a little bit early, but at the very least, we'll see if, you know, we can get him on
the right track for 2026. September 1st, we are 55-81. We've already clinched the fact that we're
not going to have a winning season here in Oakland. It is time for roster expansion, so I've called up
another arm, and I'm going to bring up Joshua Mears again and at least get him some at-bats against
lefties at the Major League level after spending a month in the minors and doing, you know what,
all right. What you may be more interested in is the playoff picture, so let's send through these
last couple series and see what's going on. The Red Sox have pulled out a 101-win season already,
102 make that, in fact. A.L. West is still up for grabs, and that's what's kind of killing me about
us being so bad. This A.L. West was winnable, honestly. It appears to be one of the weaker
divisions, if not the weakest division. Oh, Shea Langley has got himself a player of the week and
Kyle Isbell eligible to come off. We'll do rehab again, like I said. No point in bringing him
back for one game, but back to the standings here. Let's see, still not decided here in the A.L. West.
Braves have clinched the A.L. East, and Cubs have clinched the Central, but, you know, the Mariners
are still in competition with the Yankees for a wildcard spot, and the Mets and Reds do have
wildcard spots as well. It looks like Cardinals clinched a wildcard spot there, so the playoff
picture for the National League is set, and the American League is not. It comes down to the final
day, and the Rangers clinch, and the Mariners will miss out on a playoff spot at the expense of
the Yankees, so your playoff picture is set. So here's how our player stats ended up. It was
definitely Denzel Clark and Shea Langley leading the way. Denzel Clark, great year for him, or I
would say a breakout year for him. 17 stolen bases, 24 homers, 110 OPS plus, three and a half war,
and Shea Langley, who had such a slow start to the season, was excellent down the stretch. Picked
up Player of the Month in September, 30 home runs for him, 116 OPS plus, 3.2 war. He doesn't quite
fit what we're looking for defensively at catcher still. I'd love more catcher framing, but it's okay.
He's an OG Oakland A, and we intend to keep it that way. Ryan Noda was a league average hitter.
He showed me something, you know? He showed me something, but everyone else, really not great.
I mean, you know, Santander was just dreadful, just absolutely dreadful. He did hit 30 home
runs, but that was pretty much the only thing he did. Lawrence Butler, we gave a chance 300
play appearances this year. Still not good, and has really just throughout the save not been good
at any level, and that's disappointing because I know he has some hype in real life, and I'm sure
in some of your other saves, if you play as the A's, he has done well for you. Joshua Mears,
hilarious year, almost struck out 200 times, 18 home runs. He has potential for us in the long
term, but he didn't have it in the short term. Nick Ahmed, didn't hit, was there to play defense.
Jacob Wilson, you know, finished as a replacement level player, and that's fine. He'll hopefully be
set up for more success in 2025. I'll also point out Kyle Isbell, and you'll recall we didn't have
an all-star. We did. It was just because he was injured at the time, but he was elected as an
all-star with only 54 games on the season. I'm interested to see with guys like Enrique Bradfield
coming up, and you know, Denzel Clark had a good year in center, although he could play in the corner
as well, like where he fits in because he could be someone who's traded as he gets further into his
arb years, and then the other would be Zach Gelof. Not as good of a year for him this year as it was
in 2024. He kind of led the way for us in 2024. That's a good 2025. Pitching-wise, we definitely
took a step back from last year. I think that was the big difference. 14th in pitching war, 12th in
FIP, and 11th in runs against. J.P. Sears, who was our ace last year, not so much the case this year.
Way fewer strikeouts. The strikeout rate went down a lot. Walker Buehler, I thought looked pretty good,
but then he kind of struggled down the stretch. He had, you see, a blow-up start here and a blow-up
start here, where he was allowing six runs. If you take those starts away from him, honestly, he did
well for us down the stretch. Braxton Ashcraft, this guy's just a great back-end, like, innings-eater
guy. I'm pretty happy with him overall and what he's given us these past two years. And then Brady
Basso, honestly, same thing, but from a run prevention perspective, more impressive. Look
what he's done for us in 2024 and 2025 at the big-league level. If you combine these two into
a full season, I mean, he's arguably been our best pitcher in this sem, I guess, besides maybe
Paul Blackburn. And then Tyler Wells had a great first half and a not-so-great second half. We'll
see where he fits in. Scherzer, you probably also want to know about. Just not a good year for him.
And he's got an option. And I don't know what we're going to do about that because
I'm thinking we may decline it. He wants to be in the starting rotation. I understand why he's
next Scherzer, but I don't want to keep unhappy players around, especially ones that couldn't
perform in the rotation or the bullpen. As far as the bullpen goes, Mason Miller and Colin Poche
were definitely our two best guys, but the bullpen as a whole took a step back. Here's our
pitching staff sorted by war. And here's our pitching staff sorted by ERA. There you go. At
least Tyler Matzek was good for us down the stretch. That was maybe a nice pickup. And now
it's time for the playoffs. We'll start with the Wild Card Series. We'll see Mets and Cardinals
will advance. Orioles and Rangers will advance in the American League. Moving on here to the
Division Series. We have an early lead for the Mets and the Dodgers in the National League.
Sorry, we're simming along here. Early lead for the Guardians and Red Sox as well. This could be
some sweeps. We've got sweeps here, sweeps here, and then we'll see what happens here in the
American League. Guardians advance and Red Sox advance. Let's meet these last four teams, shall
we? Red Sox have been a nice surprise. 103 wins. Just a really well-balanced team overall. They've
got some youngsters in there making an impact like Marcel Maier, who's the former number one
prospect, and Kyle Thiel. Tristan Casas, definitely their focal point offensively alongside
Devers. These guys, a lot of home runs, especially Casas, 49. The pitching has also been really good
for them, but they'll have to win this World Series without Shane Bieber and without Brian
Baio. The Guardians won the Central. They, by and large, look like the Guardians we know from real
life. They've brought Josh Bell back into the mix. He was once a Guardian. Stephen Kwan there.
Cedric Mullens is really the only new face in terms of the lineup. We've never seen a
Cleveland uniform before. Top of their rotation looks good. Tristan McKenzie, a former Cy Young
winner in this save. Another, just a lot of innings for him. Wow. And the bullpen has also been
the best in the American League, headed by Emmanuel Classé with 47 saves. They are first in runs
against. This Mets team went toe-to-toe with the Braves for the division. They finished one game
back, but they get the last laugh as they sweep them in the playoffs and they're on their way to
the NLCS. Another really well-balanced team. Francisco Alvarez had a phenomenal year. Wow.
OPS almost 1,000. And they have Blake Snell as a new addition, as well as Zach Gallin. So,
a really good starting rotation as well. And finally, it's the Dodgers who won 94 games and
easily won the West because it wasn't as competitive as last time. You'll remember
the Padres upset them in 2024. Headed by Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Bobby Miller in the rotation.
Juan Soto, who was their big offseason acquisition, had a very great Juan Soto year. And they're going
to need him because no Shohei Otani for this series. Let's start the NLCS and ALCS. Dodgers
take game one. Come on. Dodgers take game two. Split in the American League. Dodgers take game
three. Two to one. Red Sox over here. Dodgers will advance. Who will they face from the American
League in the World Series? Two apiece in this series. Three for Cleveland. And it's going to be
the Dodgers versus the Cleveland Guardians. Let's see who comes out on top. Gonna have to sim a
couple days here. Guardians take game one. And they take game two. Oh, boy. They do have a strong
first two starters with McKenzie and Bybee. Oh, and the Guardians take game three. And it is a
sweep. Cleveland Guardians are your 2025 World Series champions. Congrats to them. They were not
the strongest regular season team in terms of the win total, but they really showed what they could
do in the playoffs. Way to go, guys. The World Series MVP is Kyle Manzardo, who hit three home
runs in those five games. And with that, the season ends as well as this episode. Next up,
the offseason.
