Siyamak sits down with California state Sen. Catherine Blakespear to discuss the new law banning plastic bags and its environmental impact. We also talk with Heidi Sanborn, executive director of the National Stewardship Action Council, about the recycling process and the positive changes being made to the system.
Unfortunately, since the plastic bag went into effect in 2016,
plastic waste from plastic bags has gone up by almost 50%.
So you see that it just was clearly not working.
We are not managing all of that at the level we should be,
given how much we care about the environment.
Unfortunately, the loophole still in this bill that I see
is that we can still have reusable bags coming from China
that are not made to be recycled.
My guest today is Kathleen Blakespear, California State Senator.
Today, she'll explain her new law that bans plastic bags at grocery stores.
We also sit down with Heidi Sandborg,
Executive Director with National Stewardship Action Council.
She'll explain the recycling process in California
and discusses the positive changes being made to the system.
There's no way to avoid plastic completely.
I mean, we use it in so many things all the time,
but we can do our best and we can try to set up our systems
so that we produce less of it.
I just want to give people confidence.
Most things are getting recycled,
and the system is going to get better and better.
Your recycling matters, and it's going to matter more and more
as the system gets more and more refined.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Kathleen, it's great to have you on. Welcome.
Thank you. I'm happy to be here.
We want to talk to you about a law that just made,
and you were instrumental in passing this.
This was your bill banning plastic bags in California.
Can you tell us what this bill is about and what does it do?
Yes. So when you go to the grocery store, you will be offered,
if you did not bring your own reusable bag,
you'll be offered a paper bag.
So instead of saying, would you like paper or plastic?
The question will be, would you like paper?
And so the bill eliminates that plastic option.
And why did you introduce this law?
Because plastic is a scourge and it's polluting our planet,
and we don't need to have so many plastic bags.
The voters actually approved a plastic bag ban in 2016,
which was a referendum on something
the legislature had passed.
So the voters, the plastics industry,
wanted to overturn a plastic bag ban,
and they took it to the voters and said,
hey, do you really want to do this?
The voters said yes.
But what happened was in that, in the process of that,
what was allowed is essentially a loophole
where those thinner plastic bags were banned,
but thicker plastic bags were considered
reusable and recyclable.
And that, so they were still allowed to be distributed.
And actually, they're being sold.
It's not just distributed.
They're sold to people who are taking their groceries home.
And unfortunately, the bags are not being recycled
and they're not being reused.
So Nowhere in California recycles them,
and people largely do not reuse them.
So what we see is that they blow around everywhere.
They degrade into toxic microplastics in the ocean.
They're in our landfills, and in our landfills,
they put up a fence to catch the plastic bags.
So the fence is not to keep out any other thing
who wants to come in or anything.
It's the plastic bags blowing around everywhere.
And we just know that plastic is a pollutant.
It is used for 12 minutes in that plastic bag form,
and then it takes hundreds of years to degrade,
and we just don't need them.
So people use them for 12 minutes when they get...
That's the average lifespan.
And why doesn't it get recycled?
Because thin film plastic just doesn't have a market.
I think, unfortunately,
there are lots of thin film plastics, too.
Like, they go around shipping containers,
this plastic, and Saran wrap,
and the plastic that your cereal is in or your crackers.
These thin plastics, they just don't have a market.
And so we end up with them all in the landfill,
all of these different sources
of that same type of really thin plastic.
And it's not great.
I mean, we need to have an alternative
for all these different uses.
And the good thing is, at a grocery store,
there is an alternative.
It's the paper bag, which, on average,
can last 12 minutes and actually comes
from a renewable resource, which is trees.
It's higher chance to get recycled,
but also part of my bill requires
that the recycled content goes up to 50%.
So what's in the bag will actually be recycled as well.
So it, overall, will have a much smaller footprint.
Unfortunately, since the plastic bag went
into effect in 2016-
It was supposed to ban the thin plastic.
The thin, right, exactly.
So since that happened, plastic waste
from plastic bags has gone up by almost 50%.
So that means that we supposedly banned
this one thin thing, but because a thicker one
was introduced, plastic bag waste has gone up by 50%.
So you see that it just was clearly not working.
So there was a loophole that they could make it thicker.
Is that- Right, exactly.
Because then it's considered reusable and recyclable.
And so there were some studies done
of where are all these plastic bags going?
And it was a news organization that put trackers,
like Apple trackers, into the plastic bags.
And they are, where they ended up going
were some were incinerated, some ended up in Asia,
and others ended up in the ocean,
and none of them ended up recycled.
We are covering California issues, as you know.
If you want us to cover the stories
that are impacting your day-to-day life in California,
reach out to me at siamak at californiainsider.com.
And when you introduced this bill,
did you face any opposition?
Well, yes, the plastics industry.
The plastics industry came out really strongly
because, of course, they make money on these bags.
And also, the oil industry is the plastics industry.
That is who makes plastic, is the oil industry.
So they're well-financed and they see plastic.
Plastic is going up.
So in a macro way, the amount of plastic being used
and being purchased is going up.
And so the oil companies are seeing this
as an alternative to selling oil
as we're transitioning into a cleaner energy future.
And we need to make sure that we don't just continue
down that path of more and more single-use things.
Like most people in their own homes
are still using plates and cups and forks, right?
But you can envision a future
where absolutely everything is single-use,
where people at home are using single-use things
and throwing them away.
But part of that is not having a sense
of the consequence of it.
I mean, we need to be reducing our landfilling
and we need to be using less plastic.
And plastic is not good for your body.
It's not good for animals or people.
And we really don't want to have so much of it everywhere.
And this was ending up in the ocean
and affecting some life in the ocean.
Yeah, I'm sure you've seen these pictures
of the turtle that's been died
and inside it has plastic straws and plastic bag bits
and all sorts of things, plastic forks and spoons.
I mean, all this, yeah, it really is terrible,
and the plastic in the ocean,
just the big plastic waste heap
in the middle of the ocean is a big problem.
And we just need to do better.
Now, do you think California doing this
will have an impact in the rest of the country?
Do you think other people will follow?
Well, yes, other states have done it already
and there are various ways that they do it.
But I'll say that one key to the success of this bill
was the partnership with the Grocers Association.
So the grocers represent the grocery stores
and there are some grocery stores
that have already made this decision on their own,
like Trader Joe's and Whole Foods.
And Trader Joe's, if you go there,
you know that they just have a stack of paper bags
and if you don't have your own reusable bag,
they'll put it in that bag.
And that's the only, there's not even a discussion really.
And so they've made this choice,
they've gone to this because of customer preference.
This is what the answer is that I've heard
is that it's customer preference.
And so now all the grocery stores,
Safeway and Kroger and Vons
and all the grocery stores will be doing that.
And so it's not as if this is untested
or we don't know if it's gonna work
or if customers will accept it or, you know,
it just, it's the direction we're going.
And I see this very much like the way we changed
our approach to smoking inside.
Like we realized, well, maybe somebody wants to smoke
but it's affecting everybody else
and for the collective good,
we need to not have workers in environments
where people are smoking.
And so laws changed and it's the same thing
with this plastic.
I mean, we just, we don't need to have
so much single-use plastic.
Was there a reason you jumped on this to do that?
Was, did something spark you to work on this bill?
Well, you know, I've always had the sense
that it's unsustainable, the way that we consume things.
And I think I partly got this from my grandma
and living in Encinitas and next to the ocean.
And, you know, my grandma was affected by the depression.
And so she would wash out the plastic Ziploc bags
and I still do that and, you know, dry them
so that you can reuse those and turning off all the lights
and making sure to use the food in the refrigerator
that you buy so that you're not wasting food.
So I feel like my ethic, my personal ethic,
and it's reflected in the constituency
that I come from too in Encinitas.
I think many people care very deeply about sustainability,
you know, is to try to live sustainably
with our beautiful planet and to recognize
that we all have a role in that.
And we obviously can't,
there's no way to avoid plastic completely.
I mean, we use it in so many things all the time,
but we can do our best and we can try to set up our systems
so that we produce less of it.
And unfortunately right now with Amazon packaging
and with all the things in the grocery store,
I mean, it is impossible not to buy plastic, you know,
from the deodorant to the packaging
that your salad comes in.
I mean, it's everywhere.
But the extended producer responsibility laws
that we have in California will start to kick in
where the industry will come up with its own alternatives
and will be responsible for picking up things
on the back end.
And I think that will fundamentally change the picture.
So I personally care about sustainability
and I also feel that it's reflected by the people around me.
And when you look at youth,
the thing they talk to me about the most is climate change
and climate change and gun violence prevention.
Those are the two things that youth, I think,
are the most activated about.
And so they're the ones who are at the plastic bag ban rally
with the signs and the turtle and all the things
because they care about this.
So I do feel like it's personal
and it's also a reflection of who I represent.
If we were to look forward,
how would you see this impacting?
Is there gonna be more action on plastic bags
and plastic in general?
Well, yes.
I mean, this doesn't apply to all plastic bags.
Like if you go buy clothes at the store,
so like a clothing store, you could have a plastic bag.
So this is only grocery stores.
So there are other types of retail establishments
that I think this could move into.
But I also just wanna work in general on plastic reduction.
And I've been working on it even in the state legislature,
us walking our own talk.
We, in many ways, are not recycling,
managing our organic waste with the composting
and the landfilling.
We are not managing all of that at the level we should be
given how much we care about the environment.
So I have been running the subcommittee
and we have these recommendations
which hopefully are being implemented right now
to change the way that the legislature itself operates.
Now we have been covering recycling
and we know that recycling a lot of times is not happening.
Can you tell us why or what's going on with recycling?
Even though a lot of Californians actually do the work
of putting, collecting the material
and putting it into the recycling bin.
Yes, it's really unfortunate
because individual people want to do the right thing
and are, they are separating.
They are putting things over and taking them out
to their blue bin and not putting it in the landfill.
But yeah, recycling is not as successful
as you'd hope it would be.
And that's why I come back to reduce, reuse, recycle.
The first thing is reduce and then reuse
and the last is recycle.
So the idea that like we need to have our water
in a plastic water bottle.
I mean, we should be trying to think about having our water
in a cup that we would wash.
I mean, like we used to do.
There's no reason that we have to have
so much single-use plastic everywhere.
But recycling, I've really tried to jump into this area
and what can make, how can we change it?
It's tremendously complex and there are lots of interests.
There are lots of waste hauler interests
and the what, who and how is it managed on the backend?
We have this also composting that's happening in California.
So I feel as if it's something we could do so much better on
but it's not exactly clear where we're gonna be able
to make that change immediately.
I think that focusing on plastic and single-use reduction
is someplace that we can make a big difference right away.
Some people might say we have much bigger problems
than plastics and we have the rent issues,
the rents are high, housing cost is high
and we have a lot of problems in California.
What are your answers to that?
Well, my answer to that is that we can do many things
at the same time.
So I care about affordability
and I care about the rents being too high
and insurance prices and access to insurance
and gas prices.
I mean, there are lots of things to focus on.
Homelessness is a top issue.
But we can also say what are some of the things we can do
that make a big difference right away?
And a lot of changes are incremental.
You don't just come in and make sweeping changes
to systems, right?
Systems change is tough.
So to me, this is something that is we can do,
does make a difference.
We have tens of thousands of plastic bags
in this state alone every single month.
I mean, we can really do something
about this source of pollution.
So we should be working on those other big things
and I am, but we can also do this.
If you like California Insider
and you like to know what's going on in California,
make sure to check out Epoch Times.
This is a newspaper that started
by a group of Chinese Americans
because of human right abuses in China
and now it's starting to grow here.
Make sure to go to the Epoch Times website
and check out the California section
where you can get a lot of fresh perspectives
on what's going on in California.
Now let's go back to the interview.
So last time that this happened,
there was a loophole and these plastic bags came back.
Do you think there is gonna be another one
that could come back?
I don't and interestingly, as we were developing the bill,
at first we had a definition of what is a reusable bag
because there was a certain amount
of how much plastic could be in it,
what is the weave, all this kind of complexity
and what we felt would happen
is that we were creating a new loophole
because if we say it has to be usable for 800 times
or it has to, instead of it being 300 times,
all these different things create a new loophole
to try to get around.
So in the end, we just eliminated it completely
and said only paper bags available
when you're buying your groceries
and so there's no discussion anymore about that
and if you think about it,
if you're doing a definition of like a backpack
or something that is truly reusable,
nobody is saying how many times it has to be reused
or what woven quality does it have
or what's its stitches and this kind of thing.
Backpacks are reusable
and so you don't even talk about that
and that's ultimately,
I think that that's a really important distinction
is just to say, we're not gonna talk about
what is a reusable bag.
We're gonna just talk about the fact
that you get a paper bag.
So when you were working on something like this,
which is gonna impact an industry,
was it hard to work with them
or did you guys have conversations on the table
or was it difficult?
Well, the plastics industry came in to lobby me
and they, in many ways,
their worldview, I just can't and don't agree with.
I mean, they're trying to tell me
that plastics are great for the planet
and that we need to have more, not less of this
and so it's very much this topsy-turvy world
where at the end when I was having this conversation,
it was just like, I don't think we're gonna agree here
because I just do not see that.
I don't believe that
but everybody's entitled to their opinion, right?
And they're lobbyists and that's who they work for
and so it seemed like they were sincere in their belief
but you're just coming at it
from completely different positions
but it was really important
that the Grocers Association supported this
because what they said is,
we're just over the paper or plastic dispute.
You know, we don't have a problem
with just siding with the community
and the environmentalists by saying,
we don't need these plastic bags,
let's just simplify it and have paper bags.
So I was so grateful
that the Grocers Association took that position
because what you see is a lot of times
if it's business against environment
and it's a head-on conflict, business wins.
It's not environment that wins.
So when you put business and environment together
on the same side
but then you have plastics on the other side,
then you can win.
So it's like that was something
that was a really important alliance
and I think the partnerships matter.
You know, who is it that's on the side of your bill
and who is it that's against it?
Those things really matter in Sacramento
and so making sure that you do a lot of work
as a legislator to get partnerships,
to get buy-in, to figure out
what are the core issues that matter
and then to try to craft those compromises.
I mean, this is a lot of times
why when you see legislation, it's incremental.
There are lots of bills that are,
they cut a little bit of red tape
so they make something a little bit easier.
Like I had a bill about building accessory dwelling units,
making it easier to get through the Coastal Commission.
You know, that's the kind of bill
that you could say is small
but those things make a big difference
when you add them up.
Now, do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
I guess my last thought would be
that individual decisions do really matter.
We collectively make up the society
and the culture that we live in.
So making that decision to have a cup of water
instead of taking the plastic water bottle,
those decisions matter
and remembering to use your reusable bag.
People will say, well, what if,
how am I supposed to remember?
It's like, well, you remember your wallet and your keys.
It's just, it's deciding that this is something
that's gonna be part of your habit,
that when you get out of the car,
you go to the back and get the grocery bags
that you have brought with you.
You know, that's just part of it.
So I think individual actions matter.
Collective and systems level change matters a lot.
And so those are things that I will continue to work on
but we shouldn't lose hope that what we do individually,
that somehow it doesn't matter,
because it really does.
Kathleen Blakespear, California State Senator,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
Well, thank you for interviewing me.
Heidi, it's great to have you on, welcome back.
Thanks so much for having me, it's great to be back.
We wanna talk to you about an important topic,
you know, recycling in the state.
And one of the things that we are covering,
we have had discussion on this plastic ban.
There's a new law that's just passed
that's going to ban plastic bags at grocery stores.
One of the reasons that this law is passed
is because a lot of these bags are not getting recycled.
Can you tell us more about this?
Yes, 10 years ago, California passed a law,
I had nothing to do with that bill,
that banned certain bags,
but it allowed the reusable bags to be used
that were plastic that were thicker.
And people thought that that would be enough, and it wasn't.
I actually thought it wouldn't be enough.
So this is kind of playing out the way I had predicted it.
Unfortunately, didn't wanna be right on that.
But they went back,
the people who had sponsored that original bill
and wanted to fix it, so they banned the bags.
But unfortunately, some of the businesses in California
that started designing bags with recycled content
to meet, you know, trying to be more sustainable
and are here in California got caught up in this,
and now I think they won't be able to sell here.
But unfortunately, the loophole still in this bill
that I see is that we can still have reusable bags
coming from China that are not made to be recycled.
We can't recycle them.
So what I'm worried about now
is we're hurting our California businesses,
but we're allowing the importation of non-recyclable bags
that are made of a different type of material
that feel like more of a fiber,
but they're actually plastic that can't be recycled either.
And why is the reason that recycling
is not happening in this state?
There is a big issue with recycling here, right?
Yes, and with bags, the problem was
there was supposed to be an infrastructure developed
for bags to be collected at grocery stores,
and then they would go back and be recycled into new bags.
And while some of that was happening,
not nearly enough was happening.
And so the companies that are in California
were getting frustrated that make the bags
out of recycled content bags.
They were starting to put their own bag drops
out in grocery stores,
but I think it was unfortunately too late
because the infrastructure
just wasn't built up fast enough.
And there was just such a distrust in the system
that this is the result.
Now, one of the things that we do as consumers,
as Californians, a lot of people want to recycle.
So most people probably want to recycle these material
and they won't throw them away.
They'll throw them in a recycling bin.
But does it not get recycled?
Oh, it does get recycled.
The vast majority does get recycled.
The media picks up a lot on the stuff that doesn't,
and it certainly happens.
I'm not gonna defend the indefensible,
but by and large, materials are getting recycled.
Now, we are hearing that air tags now
are being dropped into plastic products,
and then they're saying,
oh, well, they're not getting to the place
that they said they were going to.
What we're finding is some of these air tags,
because they're metal,
are getting pulled out as recyclable metals
and never get to the ultimate destination
of that plastic, for example.
So I just want to give people confidence.
Most things are getting recycled
and the system is gonna get better and better.
It does not change overnight,
but by and large, your recycling matters,
and it's going to matter more and more
as the system gets more and more refined.
I just got back, actually, from a conference called Pivot,
celebrating the 10-year anniversary
of the Recycling Partnership,
which is a bunch of big companies that got together
and said, we want to improve recycling,
and we want to give grants to local governments
and businesses to recycle more,
put the containers out,
put the curbside recycling carts out,
and they just celebrated their 10-year anniversary,
and I have never felt so much excitement in a room
to partner, to collaborate,
and to make the system work.
We now have five states that have what we call
extended producer responsibility policy for packaging,
and that means the manufacturers of the packaging,
whether it be brands like Mars or Procter & Gamble,
they are all paying into the system
to actually help us do better at sorting and recycling
and educating the public.
So now, all of a sudden,
we're gonna have a flood of resources across the country
making this entire system better.
It's long overdue, but it's coming,
and I'm very excited about it.
Now, Heidi, last time we talked to you,
there was a dilemma where our recyclable materials
from California were getting purchased by Chinese companies,
and we ended up shutting down our infrastructure here
because the Chinese companies were buying them,
but then now we didn't have the infrastructure
to recycle a lot of these materials.
Is that changed, or is there a new path,
or is there new development in this phase?
Great question.
There's definitely development here.
So there's a lot of momentum around keeping the jobs here.
In fact, I was literally just at the ribbon cutting
of a new battery manufacturing plant
here in Sacramento County.
We're hoping to co-locate a recycling facility
for batteries nearby this plant sometime in the near future,
but California is definitely focused
on keeping the jobs here for recycling.
Other states are doing that as well,
and the states where they already have recycling,
like Tennessee, a lot of the southeastern states, actually,
have some of the lowest collection rates
of the materials needed to feed those plants.
For example, on bottle bills,
like we have one in California
where we put a deposit on bottles and cans
and get that back when we return it.
That's only in 10 states.
The 10 states that have those bottle bill,
or I call them recycling refund programs,
are the ones that are feeding those plants,
the plants where the states that they're in,
their collection rates are sometimes in the teens,
where ours are in the 70s.
So it's very, very important,
and we're now seeing a lot of other states
consider producer responsibility or recycling refunds
for bottles and cans, but even for packaging.
So it seems like the recyclables
that what we are recycling here is going to the other states
and actually getting processed there, right?
Sometimes, but sometimes we process them here.
We've had multiple businesses here in California.
We used to have a lot of paper mills.
Of course, a lot of us have lost paper mills,
and a lot of that went overseas, that processing.
Plastics, we've got in Chico, we've got PreZero.
They're a company that, like I said,
takes those old plastic bags out of grocery stores
and makes it into new bags.
I think they're at 35,
sometimes higher percentages of recycled content.
We have carpet recycling here, carpet pad recycling.
We have bottle-to-bottle plants
for bottles and plastic bottles.
So there's a lot happening here.
I've seen, again, film plastic bags, like garbage bags.
Those have recycled content that are made here.
So there's more and more and more to come
with the new investments
that are coming from industries to help us.
And paint recycling, even, things like paint.
So you have been instrumental in a few of these bills
and some of this momentum.
Can you tell us more about them?
Thank you.
On paint, I'm very proud that we helped pass
the first permanent paint stewardship program
in the country here in California in 2010.
And I just passed the bill, Governor Newsom just signed it,
that we sponsored at the National Stewardship Action Council
SB 1143 by Senator Ben Allen from Santa Monica.
It started as a big bill
that was gonna be all household hazardous waste,
but we pared it down to where we had agreement,
which was to expand the existing paint program
for latex and oil paint to not only aerosol cans,
but to marine paint, furniture paint, furniture oil,
thinners, all kinds of different sorts of paints,
arts and crafts paints,
so that all of that will go
into that paint stewardship program
that you can return to paint stores.
So we're excited about that.
But we would like to get,
we also did have a bill on the governor's desk
for marine flares, which are very niche,
it's just required SOS signal for boaters that explode
and they do not have an end of life plan.
The governor vetoed that unfortunately,
so I hope we can get that done next year.
But we also did pass and the governor signed
an expansion of our carpet program,
carpet stewardship to make that program work better
because that's about 3%, 4% of our landfilled materials,
and it's mostly all plastic now.
And we do have infrastructure
to recycle that carpet here in California
with multiple recyclers across the state.
You mentioned that 3% of the landfill.
Three to 4% just is carpet.
Wow.
1% is diapers.
Wow.
Yeah, it's interesting
what you have large volumes of one thing.
Hazardous waste is less than 1%,
but none of it is supposed to be going in the landfill
and it's dangerous and it's ending up in the wrong places,
it's affecting the safety of our workers.
So that's something I'm really focused on now
and we'll see that legislation come back next year.
And Heidi, you have a strong passion for this.
Can you tell us more about it?
It started when I was a kid,
I actually collected newspapers with my little red wagon,
my red flyer wagon, I'd go around the neighborhood
and my dad and I would put them all
in our town country station wagon and drive them downtown
and they'd weigh the car in and out,
we'd empty it and I'd get paid for every pound of paper.
And I don't like litter.
And so I've become very, very passionate
about treating our earth with respect,
this beautiful planet we've been given to preserve it.
But it's also about public health.
We're not gonna be healthy
if we have all these broken microplastics in our water
and we're exposed to chemicals
that we don't even know are there.
So to me, this is a passion project
for earth and for our health.
And do you have any other thoughts for Californians?
I do.
I want you to keep hopeful and stay with us
and use the programs that exist
and really tell your legislators
and the people that are in policymaking,
decision-making positions that this matters to you,
that you wanna see a cleaner environment in California.
You wanna be able to close the loop
and you wanna keep the jobs in California
because when they hear that,
they'll work towards that because your vote matters
and it's that time of year.
Heidi Sanborn, Executive Director
of National Stewardship Action Council.
It was great to have you in California Insider.
Thank you so much for having me.
It was great to be here.