Manta Rays: The Gentle Giants of the Sea | Great Blue Wild 204

Explore The Ocean
121 followers
Indonesia, the crossroads of two mighty oceans,
where the waters of the Indian and the Pacific converge.
Powerful currents help feed the most vibrant coral reef
system on Earth.
An explosion of plankton draws giants
from the depths of the ocean.
It's just incredible when you see a manta ray sort of come
out of the gloom.
They're just magnificent, beautiful creatures.
A team of researchers has set out
to study and save these gentle giants with secret lives.
The giant manta ray, the largest ray on the planet,
nearly as wide as a tennis court, as heavy as a car.
One of the world's largest fish, fueled
by some of the ocean's smallest creatures.
The tiny plants and animals that drift through ocean currents.
The giant manta ray is one of the most intelligent fish
in the ocean, but little is known about them.
Manta rays were first scientifically cited in 1798.
It wasn't until 2009 that researchers
discovered there isn't just one species of manta ray.
There are two, the giant oceanic manta ray
and the slightly smaller reef manta ray.
Both species thrive here in Indonesia's pristine waters.
On the edge of the Pacific and Indian oceans
lies an underwater paradise, Raja Ampat,
a coral garden packed with mesmerizing marine life
and one of the only places on Earth
where both species of manta ray coexist.
Raja Ampat is located in the remote eastern corner
of the Indonesian archipelago, more than 1,000
miles south of the Philippines.
It sits just below the equator, along the southern lip
of the Ring of Fire, a belt of raging volcanoes
and tectonic plates that rims the Pacific Ocean.
The reefs of Raja Ampat are a hotbed
of activity, plunging walls and soaring
seamounts encrusted with more than 600 species of coral
erupt with life.
75% of the world's coral species thrive here,
and more than 1,700 species of reef fish
call these corals home.
Raja Ampat means four kings in Bahasa,
the official language of Indonesia.
The name comes from a local myth of a woman
who found seven eggs.
From these eggs came four kings, who
occupied four of the archipelago's largest islands,
known today as Raja Ampat.
Underwater, the reigning kings of Raja Ampat
are the manta rays.
To preserve the thriving population here,
Indonesia established a manta ray sanctuary in 2014,
stretching across two million square miles of ocean.
At nearly twice the size of India,
it is the largest manta ray sanctuary on Earth.
Fortunately, there's an awakening
which is happening now in Indonesia.
It's been led, I think, by manta rays.
That's been kind of because of the tourism
value of manta rays.
And so we've seen really an awakening about the need
for conservation.
Dr. Mark Erdman and the team at Conservation International
want to protect these charismatic creatures.
Mark has logged over 10,000 dives throughout Indonesia
and discovered more than 100 new species of reef fish.
He now uses his knowledge of these waters
to track Indonesia's manta ray population.
From our photo ID database that we have of the manta rays,
there's over 400 individuals of the reef manta rays
that we've recorded, and something just
under 200 individuals of the oceanic manta ray here.
We think this is quite a big population of manta rays
that we have here in Raja Ampat.
It's a really, really unique place for manta rays
and really important that we protect it.
Sarah Lewis has worked with Conservation International
and Manta Trust, a UK-based charity that
funds manta ray research since 2010.
She and Mark are using a database of photos
to help track the populations of mantas here in Raja Ampat
and throughout Indonesia.
We have a lot of individuals to ID in this population, which
is very exciting.
Raja Ampat's manta ray population
could be as high as 3,000.
So far, Sarah has identified just 600.
The team still has a lot of work ahead of it,
and Indonesia's powerful currents don't make it easy.
The Indonesian archipelago is bound by two great oceans.
Strong easterly winds lift the waters of the Pacific
one foot higher than the neighboring Indian Ocean,
pushing water through the islands
and creating some of the strongest currents on Earth.
For the tenants of the reef, these currents
present both rigors and rewards.
For those firmly anchored, such as these soft corals,
the flow of water brings a steady stream of food.
Others must fight to keep from being swept away.
On the reef, shelter comes in all shapes and sizes.
Crustaceans tuck into nooks and crannies in the coral.
Smaller reef fish sway side to side beneath the canopy,
bullied by the current.
Larger fish duck behind the plunging walls and seamounts.
For researchers, currents are one
of the most underestimated and overbearing of all obstacles.
Water is 800 times more dense than air,
creating strong resistance.
Swimming in powerful currents is like walking
through a storm-level wind.
A current of two knots is strong enough
to sweep a diver out to sea.
Indonesia's currents can reach up to eight knots,
creating a challenge for anyone trying to observe
the undersea creatures.
Assuming that the current is moving in a regular fashion
and not up or down, most of us divers,
we tend to hook in with a reef hook and stay in position.
Reef hooking allows divers to stay put
without exerting any energy.
Divers use a metal hook attached to a rope
to secure themselves to the reef.
And when the current is raging, the sharks and mantas
will generally come closer to you.
So if you're lucky, they could come by and hover
over you in the current.
But reef hooking is not an option for Mark and Sarah.
They must be mobile to locate and tag
as many manta rays as possible.
We're spreading eyes everywhere.
And then we'll all be holding cameras,
so we'll be armed and ready.
OK, camera cut.
OK.
Mark and Sarah leave a remote camera
on the reef for an extra pair of eyes.
Meanwhile, their colleagues, Abam and Abdi,
patrol a tried and true manta site.
In the last year, their tracking data
has shown that this site is one of the most frequently
visited in Raja Ampat.
Abam assembles a pole spear so he can get close
enough to attach the tracker.
But there are no mantas in sight.
We wanted to spread around our tags,
giving more numbers out there, and see what happens
and what we can capture from the behavior of this mantas.
They're hoping that if they tag more mantas,
they can learn what draws them to this place
and where they come from.
But the visibility is poor, and the currents are strong.
The best bet is to stay put and wait
for the mantas to come to them.
Mark and Sarah use a motorized scooter
to move from one site to another.
They scour the reef.
But after several dives and hours of fighting the current,
the team comes up empty handed.
Studying any wild animal, we have
challenges with our research.
Even though we have a very abundant population
of manta rays here in Raja Ampat,
sometimes we turn up in the right season,
the high season for manta rays, the sites
where we know they aggregate regularly,
and they're just not there.
But more shocking than what the divers didn't see underwater
is what their remote camera did.
Actually, we had mantas about every five minutes
showing up in the frames.
Unfortunately, quite a few of them
had just a wing or a head, not a lot of belly shots.
But nonetheless, we have definite proof
that there were mantas there all the time.
And perhaps most exciting, we got a manta by Rostrus,
the oceanic manta, which up until this time
has never been recorded from northern Raja Ampat.
So we're delighted with that.
That's a big find, actually.
It's a big find because typically,
oceanic mantas and reef mantas aren't seen in the same area.
As a general matter, of course, around the world,
there's very few places where you get both reef
and oceanic mantas together.
Raja Ampat is one of those few places where you do see it.
But for the most part, they still segregate.
Both species live their lives out in the open ocean,
visiting reefs to feed and to be cleaned.
Creatures of all shapes and sizes
stop in for a tune-up at the ocean's
most efficient body shop.
Smaller reef fish, like these cleaner wrasse,
are specialists at removing parasites and dead skin
from larger fish.
Butterfly fish specialize in repairing bite wounds.
Cleaner shrimp tend to concentrate on the mouth.
A manta ray comes in for a cleaning,
hovering almost motionless over the reef.
A host of cleaner fish greets the long-distance traveler.
Gills flared, mouth open, and wings spread wide.
The manta ray advertises the areas that need detailing.
The T-shaped pattern on its back and fewer black spots
on the belly indicate this is an oceanic manta ray.
A reef manta ray has far more spots on its underside
and a Y-shaped pattern on its back.
Despite these differences, for years,
these two distinct species were thought
to be the same, largely because they were so seldom
seen side by side, until now.
They have their own separate types of cleaning stations.
This is a case where you've got them, both species,
using the same cleaning station.
That was something we've never seen before.
We've only seen reef mantas over the last 15 years
of diving on that site.
And it really begs the question of,
how much do we not see when we're
down as bubble-maker divers?
When the team isn't around to monitor the mantas,
a series of acoustic stations listen in on their behalf.
These stations sit along the ocean floor
and receive pings from any tagged manta ray that comes
within a half-mile radius.
Every tag transmits a unique signal
that's recorded by the receiver.
A network of these listening stations
tracks how long a manta ray spends at each site
and where it travels.
The day is coming to an end, but the team still has work to do.
We have here an acoustic receiver,
which has been in the water since November of 2013.
We download it every six months or so,
and it's time to download it right now.
We're basically going to drop in 20 meters of water
and hope that we find it.
Mark and his dive partner, Eddie,
manage to locate the listening station.
It's a simple but effective setup.
A rope is chained to a sturdy piece of coral
on the ocean floor.
The receiver is attached to the rope
to detect any tagged mantas that pass by.
Buoys keep the top of the rope afloat.
Eddie heads up to the boat to download the data,
while Mark stays behind to clean barnacles
off the listening station.
The receiver is sealed with tape to keep it clean
and prevent malfunctions.
But when Abam downloads the data,
the results surprise him.
There's nothing there.
Well, unless there's a malfunction.
I would think it's just the batteries have all died out.
Put some more tags in.
After almost three years, the tags on the mantas
are no longer working.
With the old tags now out of commission,
the pressure's on tomorrow to tag
as many new mantas as possible.
As the morning sun pierces through the surface,
the underwater world ignites in a kaleidoscope
of shapes and colors.
Smaller fish swim to the surface to feast on the plankton stirred
up by the unruly currents.
A tornado of tiny bait fish whips through the water.
They came here to eat plankton.
A shoal of pygmy devil rays, cousins of the manta ray,
pursues the bait fish.
It's one of nature's most elegant high-speed chases.
The devil ray is one of the deepest, fastest divers
in the ocean.
It can descend more than a mile and swim at speeds
of up to 13 miles an hour, nearly three times faster
than an Olympic gold medalist swimmer.
The bait fish defend themselves by joining forces.
An army, thousands strong, moves as one large organism,
a ploy to confuse the hungry predators.
It's hard to pick out a single fish within this silvery mass.
Several fall out of line, and the devil ray
zeroes in on its target.
Devil rays are also known for their aerial theatrics.
Like acrobats, they launch themselves out of the water,
then twist, then turn through the air.
No one knows for sure why they do this.
It may be a courtship or mating ritual.
Another theory is that the devil rays
breach to rid themselves of parasites
that may be shed when the ray smacks back onto the water,
or they may simply be trying to escape a predator.
Manta rays are also known as devil rays,
thanks to the pair of horn-like fins
extending from their mouths.
While feeding, the mantis fins unroll to direct plankton
into its mouth.
After dinner, the fins neatly roll back up once again.
Manta rays are filter feeders.
Most often, they are seen feeding on the surface,
where plankton is abundant.
Their mouths are wide enough for an adult human to fit inside.
But the mantis throat is no larger
than a human fist, restricting its diet to tiny plankton.
When there's no plankton floating on the surface,
manta rays seek it out in other ways.
These manta rays twirl through the water column,
performing barrel rolls for hours.
This graceful underwater ballet is actually
a sophisticated foraging technique
designed to clear a densely concentrated patch of plankton.
Both the surface and mid-water feeding methods
require specialized filaments called gill rakers
that filter food.
Plankton-filled water enters the mantis throat
and is pushed through the gill rakers.
The water comes out through gill slits on its belly,
while the plankton is trapped inside.
Fisheries target mantas for these gills.
Rakers are used in Chinese medicine
and are thought to cure everything from cancer
to the common cold, though there is no scientific proof.
Manta rays are listed as vulnerable to extinction
due to reckless overfishing.
For decades, Indonesia has been one of the world's
largest exporters of shark and ray parts.
So the study at Raja Ampat is key to manta conservation.
If they can understand where Indonesia's manta rays spend
most of their time, they can better
decide which parts of the huge ocean territory to monitor.
Patrol boats are assigned to frequently visited manta sites
to ensure illegal fishing boats stay away.
But if they don't know where the manta rays are,
they can't protect them.
The discovery last night that the batteries on the old tags
are beginning to die means Sarah and Mark urgently
need to tag new mantas to continue the study.
We work together with all of this research
and specifically with the tagging.
It's really important that we have at least two of us
to do this tagging process, because it's
important that we get the photo ID of the manta
before we tag it.
They'll use the photos to keep track of which mantas they tag,
if they manage to tag any at all.
The water is clouded with plankton,
which increases the chance that there
will be mantas on the reef, but decreases Mark and Sarah's
ability to see them.
Visibility is less than 30 feet.
Even if the mantas are here, Mark and Sarah
might not see them.
Through the cloud, Sarah spots a moving shape.
Every single individual manta ray
has a unique pattern of spots on their underside.
And these act kind of like a human fingerprint.
So we can use these spot patterns to actually identify
individual mantas.
She positions herself beneath its belly for the perfect shot.
And we just aim to try and photograph the bellies,
the spot patterns.
And during this process, we're also
observing things like pregnancies.
We're observing the sex of the manta,
so whether it's male or female, whether it
has any injuries or mating scars,
and what sort of behavior it's doing.
This is a male reef manta ray.
Mark approaches cautiously, careful not to spook him.
Tagging requires focus and precision.
He has to aim the pull spear at a small area
in the crease of the wing, where it won't hurt the manta
or limit its mobility.
Success.
With one manta tagged, the team soon spots a second chance.
Sarah tucks beneath to get a photo ID.
Mark waits for his signal, then edges forward.
Another tag is in.
These tags give us very different insights
into the manta ray's habitat use and movement patterns.
We're getting a much better idea of how they're actually
moving between specific sites, and how long they're actually
using these sites, how important they are for them.
The quick jab feels like being poked
with a vaccination needle.
But a little discomfort now will save this species later.
So this is really important data for us.
And it also means that we are better
understanding which sites are most
critical for further protection and further conservation
efforts.
After a successful day, Sarah is eager to upload her photos.
Every time we get a new photo, we
can then compare that with our database of already identified
individuals to see if it's a new one,
or if it's one that we've already sighted before.
We actually recorded eight new individual mantas,
which is fantastic, and adds to our database.
And over time, we can actually make
estimates of population size.
So if we're continually identifying individuals
from population, once we reach a stage where we're getting
mostly re-sighted mantas, we can then
start to make an estimate of how big that population is.
So far, all together in Raja Ampat,
we have almost 400 individuals identified.
With an estimated population of nearly 3,000 mantas,
there is still a lot of work to be done.
As night sets in, the team sets out.
Wayeg Island, more than 350,000 acres of lush atolls
and vibrant corals.
Limestone islands rise from the water,
like mushrooms sprouting in the sea.
Green jungle blankets the islands.
Pristine beaches skirt the coast.
The crystal clear waters of Wayeg
offer a window into an underwater world
that is equally enchanting.
Wayeg Lagoon is the first manta ray
nursery discovered in Southeast Asia,
a place with the potential to answer
two of the most important questions about manta rays,
where and how they give birth.
Manta rays are ovoviviparous.
They produce eggs that hatch within their body,
so the young are born alive.
But a manta birth has never been documented in the wild.
It is assumed that a healthy mother gives birth
to just one pup every two to five years
throughout her lifetime, which is thought to be 40 years.
Most females don't reach sexual maturity
until they are 10 years old.
Pups can weigh up to 25 pounds and grow to 5 feet in length.
The pup's fins stay curled up while they're
inside the mother.
Once born, the fins stretch out, and the pup
intuitively starts to swim.
Mark and his team discovered Wayeg's nursery
just one year ago after successfully
tagging juvenile manta rays in these waters.
But many questions remain unanswered.
Mark isn't sure whether females are giving birth in the lagoon
or whether the juveniles have somehow found their way here.
He wants to tag more juveniles or a pregnant manta ray
to find out.
It's rising tide, and the team suspects manta rays
will be feeding on the surface.
For the first time, they will use a drone to survey
the area more efficiently.
Normally, we do this both ways.
So we basically have polarized glasses on,
and we're just cruising around, and it's
a bit hit or miss as to what you can see through the water.
Occasionally, we've been lucky enough to have a helicopter,
but this is fantastic.
So we've got the drone hovering right over the cleaning station
that we found, and just hoping that we're
going to see one of the baby mantas
come swimming along right there.
I think it does.
Oh my gosh, it really does.
So we're not 100% sure, but we have
what looks like a manta right up on the surface.
It's got a lot of glare, so it's quite difficult
with the overhead sun.
But it looks like a manta, so I think
we're going to run over there and check it out.
Here we've got a little baby juvenile reef manta ray.
And we just discovered this morning
that this site right here is actually a cleaning station,
and we've seen him now a couple of times cleaning right here.
So we're going to get Ronald in to try and get an acoustic tag
in this little baby.
Ronald is a local diver.
He's worked with Conservation International
for the past decade and has been diving here even longer.
What we found with these babies in this lagoon
is that, for the most part, most of them are quite skittish,
a little bit scared of people, but they also
tend to be a little bit curious at the same time.
Ronald slowly approaches the juvenile manta,
but his presence isn't well received.
It was in curious mode, but it very quickly
switched to skittish mode and shot away.
Sometimes we come across individuals
that just weren't really skittish,
and we'll give it a chance.
Unfortunately, that's just kind of the game
here with the little ones.
With the juvenile slipping away and no pregnant manta rays
in sight, this time, the team must
leave Wyegg's nursery with their questions unanswered.
But over the next few days, the team
identifies seven more new individuals,
adding to their growing database of 600.
It's a great start, but there's still a long way to go.
We reckon that there's probably at least two or three times
that amount in the total population.
Mark uses the last few dives on this mission
to collect genetic samples.
He wants to know if manta rays and Raja Ampa
are mating with the populations from surrounding islands.
Mark uses the probe attached to his tagging pole
to collect a tissue sample and stows it away
in a vial for safekeeping until he's back on dry land.
These genetic samples will reveal
whether the mantas at Raja Ampat have
been breeding with more distant populations in the last three
to five generations.
Knowing whether there is a genetic connection
is critical to their conservation.
If there is none, it would mean that one population can't
replenish the other, and these manta rays
will require far more protection than previously thought.
Genetics also provide clues about how
these gentle giants evolved.
Sharks have been swimming in our oceans
for more than 400 million years.
Scientists believe rays originated from sharks
more than 150 million years ago.
They evolved to adapt to life on the seafloor.
Primitive rays are thought to resemble
the present-day stingray.
They swam using wave-like motions
and were armed with a stinger on the tail for defense.
Modern stingrays have a spine in their tail,
serrated with sharp edges.
Many species also have venom, which
they deliver through their tail.
Manta rays, as we know them today,
appeared about 5 million years ago.
A subtle bump on the tail of the oceanic manta
serves as a reminder of a time in evolution
when the mantas lost their sting.
Both manta ray species can be either one of two color
patterns, called color morphs.
One is all black.
The other, called a chevron, has a white underside
and black back.
Black morph manta rays have a recessive gene
and typically make up only 25% of the total population.
In the Maldives, generally considered
to be a mecca for manta ray sightings,
no black manta ray has been identified
in its estimated population of 5,000.
Sarah and Mark have spotted 10 on this dive alone.
Back on the boat, Sarah's newly identified manta rays
support a theory that has implications for all mantas.
We've added some new individuals to our database,
quite a few black morph mantas.
And this pie chart here is showing the color morph ratios.
We've got 63% chevron mantas and 37% black manta.
Why do we in here in Raja Ampat have
such a high number of black color morph manta rays?
One of the theories is that this area, this region of the world
is perhaps the center of evolution for manta rays.
And that as the populations, the mantas,
spread globally through time, that black morph,
it just got phased out.
But still here in the heart, perhaps,
of where manta rays evolved from,
we still have that relatively high proportion
of black manta rays.
Could Raja Ampat be the birthplace
of the black morph manta ray?
Or is this black manta population growth actually
a cause for concern?
Chevron mantas have what's called countershading.
Whether looking down against the inky black ocean bottom
or up against the white sky, the chevron manta
stays well camouflaged to evade predators.
From below, the dark belly of the black manta ray
stands out against the light sky,
making it an easy target for sharks, the natural predators
of manta rays.
But if they are more vulnerable to predators,
why are Indonesia's black manta rays thriving?
The last 30-plus years, Indonesia
has been the world's largest shark and ray fishery,
and they've been exporting more fins and more bits and body
parts of sharks and rays than any other country
on the planet by far.
That's had an impact, a serious toll on the populations
here to the point where it's quite
difficult to go anywhere in Indonesia
and see large sharks anymore.
They're pretty much gone.
It is possible that the black manta ray population
is thriving because the low population of sharks
means there are no predators to eat them.
Indonesia's waters are now a protected marine area,
declared a no-fish zone for both sharks and manta rays.
We're getting there.
It's a slow process.
And to be sure, there's been a major impact.
I've been watching their populations
recover and rebound, which is something which is really
reason for hope, I would say.
The manta ray is so fascinating for me
in their gentle way of moving.
And they're actually really graceful animals.
They're making progress, but Mark and his team
know there's still a long road ahead.
It's a really, really unique place for manta rays
and really important that we protect it.
From the fight to save these beautiful rays
to the discovery of groundbreaking revelations
about their secret lives, every dive at Raja Ampat
is a chance to learn more about the gentle giants
of Indonesia's untamed seas.
