Philip Stockton: Sound Editing Mini Masterclass

Movie sound effects
101 followers
#Entertainment#sound#soundeffects#soundmovie
The Supervising Sound Editor discusses his craft and his collaborations with Martin Scorsese on films such as Goodfellas, The Departed and Hugo.
For more on sound and music, visit our dedicated section on BAFTA Guru: http://guru.bafta.org/craft/sound-music
My specific job is supervising sound editor and in some cases co-supervising sound editor.
And I'm kind of usually responsible for all the dialogue editing, all the ADR, sort of all the
words. And then in some cases I work with Eugene Geraghty who's more the sound designer,
comes up with sound effects. I think to excel in sound editing
mostly you just have to want to do it and you really have to be able to collaborate.
Our job essentially is to try to get the director, to try to help the director achieve
his or her vision. It's mostly important to realize that most directors are thrilled if
you come up with something that they didn't think of or wouldn't have thought of. But primarily
you're there to serve the film and to help tell the story the best way you can. Usually
I will get it sent a script primarily to help do budgeting with the film because
if the film has a budget, which some don't have much of one, it's helpful to see on paper what
you might be faced with. Maybe get some ideas of what might need to be recorded,
how long it might take to do the job, and also just to get a feel for the film.
Generally as a film is being shot and edited we'll get called upon to simply furnish
sound effects or occasionally if there's a particularly bad sounding dialogue scene
to do a little bit of work on it and maybe mix it a little bit and then give stuff back to the
editor to use in their process for screenings. And then at a certain point when the film is
relatively close to being locked they'll turn over the film and we'll start the process of
working on the dialogue and the sound effects and all the other pieces and that's usually a
eight to ten week process. Then we'll go into the dubbing stage, into the mix,
for anywhere from three to eight or ten weeks, again depending on the size of the film. And then
we eventually make a print master and then do an international track without the dialogue and
we're sort of the last ones usually on the process. Good sound editing to me depends
completely on the type of film that you're watching and listening to. If it's an action movie
then there can be a temptation to just keep piling on one sound after another. It eventually
just becomes a cacophony, you can't, there's no detail anymore. I think an action film benefits
by having very specific sounds that are good and clear and do the job and then get out of that one
and move on into the next one. If it's an emotional scene and suddenly there's a jet going by overhead
it might sort of take you out of the scene. So I think on some films less is more. On a narrative
film I think if you're not aware of the sound at all and yet you're feeling all the emotion
involved then the sound editor did a good job. A film that did inspire me, and this was after I'd
long been a sound editor, was Terminator 2 because it's the kind of, it's an action film,
it doesn't become this big wash of sound and the music complemented the sound effects and vice
versa. And that to me was a very good example of what could have just been a lot of noise but was
very detailed. Scorsese was in LA for many years and he came back and wanted to come back and work
in New York and he was sort of looking for a New York-based sound team. I worked with a partner
named Skip Lovesay for several years and he did a film called After Hours which was the first film
that Marty did in New York after coming back. And I think he was very pleased with the job and
I started working with Skip a little bit after that and I guess my first Scorsese job was
Michael Jackson video Bad and that was about 1986. And since then I've just kind of worked on
everything and Skip moved to Los Angeles so wasn't really available to continue so I sort of
kept it up and continued after he left. I have a very good relationship with Marty.
We love to make each other laugh so I'm sort of the class clown on the mix stage. I keep him
happy, he keeps us happy. He's a very charming man, very funny. He is very specific about what
he wants. It's very, there's very little question whether he likes something or he doesn't.
He won't stop until it's the way he wants it to be. Yet there's a lot of room even in those
places but certainly throughout the rest of the film to just experiment and do what you want and
he's always willing to listen to something. One of the greatest challenges on Hugo in terms of
the dialogue and the production sound was there's steam everywhere. All through the train station
you see steam shooting out of every vent or coming up through the floor or down from the ceiling.
All of those sequences were very noisy with the steam itself and the machines that
made the steam. There were lots of challenges for the production sound mixer to try to cleanly mic
the actors and that became my challenge because Marty Scorsese and Thelma Schoonmaker, the editor,
get very, it's all about the emotion of the scene. Technically they couldn't, they do care but
they don't get bogged down in is this like a perfectly pure take. If a take is the one that
they want, it has the right sound, they don't care if a wrench falls and clangs on the floor.
It's more about getting the right emotional quality from the scene. So a lot of time and
effort was put into trying to clean up the production sound to get rid of the steam as
much as possible. There were several microphones used in each scene, radio mics and boom mics.
Normally I try to use a boom mic track and then sort of embellish it with the radio mic only for
the voice itself and then kind of weave in and out of that. But in this case the boom tracks were
so noisy in most cases that we just had to use a radio mic which means picking up crackle and
moot whenever anybody moves. So it was a real challenge just to try to clean up the tracks and
and get everything heard and get everything to poke through. The additional sounds that take
place in scenes where radio mics were used or things where the dialogue was replaced,
everything has to be added in. But that's kind of the case for everything all the time anyway
because eventually you have to have an international track where the English
dialogue is removed and it's dubbed in one of many languages. So in pretty much everything you
see on the screen you have to have a sound for eventually whether you're using the production
dialogue sounds or not. My favorite sequence in Hugo was one that I did very little work on myself
but my partner Eugene Garrity did a great job and that's sort of the the dream sequence with the
train. Hugo jumps down on the track to try to pick up a key and then the train's coming towards him
and eventually goes off the track and goes barreling through the station and out the window.
That's a good example I think of what I was talking about before which is having a lot of
stuff going on and hitting kind of one detail at a time and having it build and build but not
sound like a mush of every sound you've ever heard coming in at you all at the same time.
I think that's probably my favorite sequence in that film.
