🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
In 2018, Jamie Reed began working as a case manager at a pediatric gender center. But after witnessing firsthand the irreversible effect that “gender-affirming care” was having on the patients, she decided to speak out.
She was recently instrumental in Missouri state legislation to extend the statute of limitations for those harmed by gender treatment. That fear of liability, claims Ms. Reed, was enough to close her former gender clinic.
Views expressed in this video are opinions of the host and the guest, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
CHAPTER HEADERS 00:00 Becoming a whistleblower in pediatric gender medicine 02:02 The closure of the pediatric gender clinic 04:01 From believer to whistleblower 0:06:24 Questioning the core assumptions of gender-affirming care 0:09:57 The Dutch Protocol 0:12:36 Social conformity and the need to belong 0:16:07 Systemic failures and the lack of accountability 0:18:51 A heartbreaking anecdote 0:21:27 Closing
we were bullying people into these
Concepts it was an ideological bullying
across the medical Spectrum in 2018
jimie Reid started work as a case
manager at a pediatric gender Center but
after witnessing firsthand the
irreversible harms of so-called gender
affirming Care on children she decided
to blow the whistle at the end of the
day in these centers nobody was the
responsible one the therapist would
write a letter thinking that the
endocrinologist was making the decision
the endocrinologist would say but the
therapist wrote the letter and then they
would all go and say but the parents are
making the decision I worked in an
industry that was harming children and
the thing that I have to Grapple with
every day is trying to address the
wrongs that I participated in this is
American thought leaders and I'm y
[Music]
Kell Jamie Reid such a pleasure to have
you on American thought leaders thank
you so much
well it's been about a year almost now
since you announced that you're going to
blow the whistle on the Pediatric gender
clinic at Washington
University and my goodness a lot has
happened since then why don't you tell
me for starters a little bit about what
it's like to become a whistleblower in
this
field surprisingly um it's been very
positive there is is a
great cultural moment in time where this
is a topic of huge interest to the
American public and there are so many
thoughtful intelligent people who are
discussing this debating this and having
courageous conversations every day and
I've been really welcomed into this
network and circle of
people so as I understand it the clinic
is now closed so that that's been a
significant change right yes it was a
bit of a process so in the state of
Missouri um they did introduce some
legislation the similar legislation had
been introduced for a few years previous
to my
whistleblow but after that occurred um
the legislation was was working through
and um the state of Missouri passed a
law to uh impose a moratorium a fouryear
moratorium on any new pediatric patient
starting a puberty block or cross- sex
hormones or having surgery and there was
a grandfather clause in so basically
anyone who had already been on these
treatments could continue but one of the
things that the legislature did is they
increased the limit of time that
somebody could sue if they were harmed
by treatment so in Most states this is
really limited it's maybe one or two
years so they increase the limit of time
and just that fear of liability um
closed the center so most of the centers
in the state of Missouri that were
offering Pediatric Care have ceased to
do so because of the extended period of
time for liability fascinating I mean
it's incredible how what seems to be
like a small change you know in
legislation what is a small change but
also it's interesting for the narrative
because the narrative is these are safe
effective treatments long-term good care
and if that were the case then nobody
would be afraid of an extended period of
time for malpractice I read you the
affidavit you provided to the Missouri
AG
um it's utterly shocking um and I think
we kind of gu have to start at the
beginning for starters you were working
at this Clinic uh fully bought into the
whole Approach at one point tell me how
you got in into this in the first place
so I've spent years working in roles
that are social work roles so case
management roles working with
individuals who are coming into their
own for age and learning how to navigate
adulthood and being a teen so I was
working with young adults who were HIV
positive and there is a big overlap for
some trans people and HIV particularly
trans women experien high levels of HIV
infection and so I was finding that a
lot of the individuals that I were
working with were trans
identified so I became sort of an expert
in trans issues within that setting um I
was really good at helping people with
things like legal name change gender
marker change I understood these systems
I was looking at resources and you know
ways to help people and so this position
came up working in the Pediatric Center
and a number of people came to me and
said you should apply for this this
really seems um just something that you
would be really good at and so I applied
I started um that would have been around
2018 the center had only been open for a
year um and I was the second person to
take the role of the case manager in the
center and really probably only one of
two people in the entire state of
Missouri to have such a role and I
really did go into this believing that
we were going to alleviate suffering and
help young people um become their truth
selves and embody their their truth
that's interesting right because this
this is the kind of the core idea here
behind this is that if you help young
people early to realize they're the
opposite sex or something different than
their as what they call assigned at
Birth which I find I find that
phraseology frankly highly problematic
but
um yeah that if you were if you deal
with that early then you'll have a
healthy happy person on the other side
that's that's the core so would you
agree yeah that's the core idea behind
the uh the whole concept yes and
everything I've been learning and about
this over the last several years tells
me the because it is
true yes
it if you really start to look at where
these treatments came from and evolved
and how we came to even be interfering
in the Pediatric body you start to
really question the whole model of care
itself I didn't realize when I started
at the
center the history of how this veloped
out of something called The Dutch
protocol um that came out of the
Netherlands um and how truly
revolutionary
and without a lot of good quality
research it was to start blocking
puberty in a healthy developing body and
go from a puberty blocker to a cross-
sex hormone in a in a pediatric child's
body
and as you you know as I worked in the
center and as I began to understand more
and more not only where this came from
but what we were seeing in the
population so many truths about the the
treatment there just weren't holding
water so one of the things that's in
your affidavit is that I believe is that
in the Dutch model um they
excluded young people with these
psychiatric comorbidities where whereas
in the scenario that you were
working almost every prospective
patient had the serious psychiatric
comorbidities yeah yeah so the Dutch
were excluding individuals with severe
or
um concurrent mental health issues but
they were also excluding patients who
did not have lifetime gender dysphoria
so part of their protocol was people had
to have been experiencing this condition
that we call gender dysphoria from a
very very young age and what we're
seeing in this cohort in the United
States is a huge number of frankly
teenagers who do not have any
um lifetime or early onset gender issues
presenting in these clinics and there
are teens who have learned enough to say
oh but I have been experiencing this
from an early age but we see this
disconnect where they claim this but
there's no real um uh family history
um in medicine you want to not only
trust but verify so if somebody tells me
I have been I've had this since I was
you know my earliest memories but yet
you can find nothing in their medical
records there was nothing where they
came to pediatri and Mom had a
conversation with the pediatrician about
I'm concerned about my child's gender
presentation or a kindergarten teacher
you know there's nothing documenting
this these are really um a significant
number of teens who are coming forward
at
1516 with these presentations that we
just don't see any history of and these
are patients that were always excluded
these were not patients that were
included in these early treatment
models and with that we'll be back after
a short
break and we're back with whistleblower
from a pediatric transgender Center
Jamie Reed what were you thinking you
you you mentioned you you believed you
were stepping into something that could
be helpful right to to to young people I
think but just explain to me the the the
mental state or the reality or the core
assumptions of a person that is involved
in this ostensibly in believing they're
doing good I think there's a number of
themes that you see in pediatric gender
medicine so in a number of these centers
these are doctors psychologists
psychiatrists social workers who really
do have strong beliefs
about helping young people they see
suffering a lot of these doctors are
young doctors um they're newer in these
fields one of our one of our doctors was
directly out of residency and he was
named a
co-director and there is an intentional
practice of hiring into these centers of
people directly from my community so
they are hiring individuals who are
within the
LGBT and that's
intentional and it also um creates these
These Feelings where you cannot go
against the narratives because you're
not just you're you're going against
your own tribe you're going against your
own people if you if you step forward
and say I don't see this working the way
that it was sold I see people being
harmed and one of the reasons why there
are so many lesbian gay by adults who
are working in this field is because so
many people experienced gender
questioning and confusion as a young
person for so many lesbian gay
and by people it's just part of our
growing up we experience gender in
different ways we are tomboys we are
what used to be referred to as
girls like we're we experience gender
differently and part of the problem is
we see ourselves in these kids yet we
have no good way of diagnostically
differentiating who of these patients
would just grow up to be a gay person
vers is who might experience more of a
lifelong
gender questioning pathway which which
by all it for all accounts is extremely
rare extremely rare honestly if you
looked at earlier data most of these
kids are gay
kids and most of the gay community that
I struggle with is we are taking away
sexual function and fertility from our
own selves as younger
people and that's something that is hard
to face as a as an adult who has had
biological children who has been able to
find comfort with in my own gender and
sex um we're taking these decisions and
we're taking this away from children if
there's anything we've learned about the
from the last few years is this power of
social Conformity or the power of the
need to belong overcoming Frank Frankly
in a lot of cases rationality yeah right
so I kind of I'm kind of beginning to
get a sense of how this works but the
the the effects as you pointed out
moments ago on these kids are a life of
suffering I mean that's not
oversimplifying it is it like for in
many cases no we were not just an
ideological bubble but we were upheld by
the university our culture right now is
upholding places like these as if we are
um somehow the
sacred the unable to be questioned um we
didn't just run the Pediatric gender
Center we infiltrate like we went into
the other medical divisions and we had
the audacity to go in and train in these
other
divisions so that they would start to
take on the language in my training I
would directly say we are not here to be
the language
police but
you can't say this to your patients you
can't say this to your patients you have
to use whatever pronouns your patients
come forward with you have to change the
charts to um update how they're
identifying we were going into these
Medical Systems like tentacles and and
going into them to shift this all across
the board and when we first went and
were doing these trainings in 2018 there
was no push back the the audience would
be kind of just like oh these are are
you know they they know everything
they're they're so great and by the end
of 2022
2023 um other medical professionals were
slowly starting to
recapture what they already knew they
were starting to push back and ask
questions and they would say is there a
line anywhere do we just affirm anything
these children are saying
and and part of the compl ity that I
still feel is I feel like we were
bullying people into these Concepts it
was an ideological bullying across the
medical spectrum and as you pull out of
medicine you see this in the schools and
journalism in peer-reviewed Publications
it's everywhere it's that if you
question this you get to be you're
you're the worst of the worst you're
transphobic you're homophobic you're
Nazi I mean it just the capture in all
of these systems is just remarkable how
quickly it
occurred I'm going to read something
that I pulled the center tells the
public and parents that it makes
individualized decisions one would hope
right this is not true doctors at the
center believe that every child who
meets four basic criteria age or puberty
stage therapist letter parental consent
and a 1-h hour visit with a doctor is a
good candidate for irreversible medical
Intervention when a child meets these
four simple criteria the doctors always
decide to move forward with puberty
blockers or cross- seex hormones there
were no objective medical test or
criteria or individualized assessments
how is that remotely possible those were
some of the basic scientific questions
that began to really trouble me so in
medicine there should be a differential
diagnosis done
and everyone presenting cannot just
statistically cannot come through to the
other side meeting the differential it's
almost like if everybody went and said I
have rheumatoid
arthritis and everyone that presented
that claimed that they had already
diagnosed themselves came out the other
side with treatments for rheid arthritis
we had set up a system where children
were
basically fulfilling the role that we
used to give to doctors with training to
provide uh a differential diagnosis and
what was so challenging was that seeing
it continue to fall on the kids because
in these rooms I would watch parents you
know basically turn to their adolescents
who were struggling or in so much
distress and basically say to them you
know you you have to be sure about this
are you really sure because this is and
everybody at the end of the day just
looked at the
kid and part of what as a parent I know
makes children even more
anxious and struggle even more is when
we don't tell them that the adults in
the room we've got this covered we're
the adults we make the decisions it is
not on your shoulders and we have
created a medical system where we have
put all of this on the kids so then
imagine if you're a kid and you say in a
room yes this is it I know this is the
treatment that I need and then you find
out two three four years later it's
not there's so
much pressure on them to continue
because we have allowed them to make
that decision a decision that should
never have been theirs in the first
place well there's
a incredibly heartbreaking uh anecdote
which you cite which is the the young
girl who you know asks to have her
breasts put back on after double
mastectomy I don't even know what to say
about that but horribly misled and you
know abused it comes to
mind it was a failure on so many
individuals going in to allow her to
have that
surgery but the the thing
then that just was such a gut check was
on the back end you have a patient
calling within 3 months of surgery
reporting this and the
surgeon couldn't even bother to take the
call or call them
back the person who
actually removed this healthy tissue
from the from this person in front of
them couldn't even be bothered to pick
up the phone and call them back hear
their pain and acknowledge it it was
pushed off on myself and our nurse to do
this followup the hubris the lack of
being willing to see the harm that one
did it's
horrible what kind
of um accountability followed this
scenario there was no
accountability the university the
hospital administrators the was no
accountability and
what made me realize that this was not
an individual patient failure this was a
systematic failure was because this
patient met the
criteria I mean they had a letter from a
therapist they had worked with the
therapist ahead of time they had met um
what uh was laid out by uh what's
referred to as W path it just continued
to show me that this was a uh the whole
machine was
broken not just an individual Cog or an
individual Cog there it was every
element was the only way that the
machine could spin was to take someone
and put them into these into the
treatment path and there was no there
were no off ramps at any
point well Jamie Reid it's such a
pleasure have had you on thank you so
much for having me thank you all for
joining Jamie read and me on this
episode of American thought leaders I'm
your host Yan kellic
[Music]