How horse nomads took over Europe 5000 years ago – David Reich

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
About 5,000 to 4,500 years ago in Europe, there's a radical transformation in the ancestry of
Europeans. An example of this is what happens in Britain. So about 4,500 years ago, the farmers who
are there, they arrived there 6,000 years ago, they build Stonehenge, and then within 100 years,
90% of them are gone. And they're replaced by migrants from the continent bearing majority
ancestry from the steppe north of the Black and Caspian Seas. This is one place where we know
what happened very well, but we see it all over Europe. This wave of people from the east arrives
and it displaces these successful, densely packed farmers with new people who have this ancestry
from the east, who are not as focused on farming, although some of them are. The Yamnaya are these
groups that thrived between about 5,300 and 4,600 years ago. They're probably the first people to
domesticate the horse. They use the horse and the cart, which was newly invented, and the wheel
to exploit the open steppe lands and be able to economically expand much more rapidly. They're
the world's first extreme mobile pastoralists, but they can't get further than the steppe.
So they expand into Europe, they expand into the little island of the steppe that's in the
Great Hungarian Plain in the Carpathian Basin, and they stop. They can't expand their way of life
to the forested parts of Europe, which is most of Europe, and somehow the ancestry of the Yamnaya
gets absorbed by the Corded Ware group, and then later the Beaker group, and that takes it further
through Europe. — In many of these cases, you're talking about 90-95% of the population being
replaced, to the extent that sometimes you refer to them as ghost populations, because
only in the aftermath with this modern genetic knowledge can we even tell that there was some
other population here. — Ancient DNA has been very disruptive to conventional understanding of
the past, and what happened when we had these findings of massive disruption of the local
population in Germany about 45-4700 years ago, based on arrival of people from the steppes north
of the Black and Caspian Sea, was some of our archaeologists co-authors really just were very
distressed by the implication. Because after the Second World War, there had been a reaction
where people said this initial idea that people had, based on archaeology, where in the beginning
of the 20th century, when people would see new types of pots in a certain layer of the
excavation, they would argue that this is the arrival of a new people coming through
invasion or through movement into a region. And that was used by, for example, the Nazis to argue
that these were spreads of Aryans moving across the landscape and being very disruptive and
violent, for example. And the reaction after the Second World War was to say, we don't know this.
And in fact, when you see the arrival of new types of material culture, pots, for example, or tools
or ways of organizing life, what you might be seeing is more the spread of culture, and it's
not actually movement of people. And in fact, how could there be a big movement of people? You're
looking at densely settled Europe with well-developed agriculture. How could it be that new people
coming in from outside will unseat these people, disrupt these people? But then you look at the
genetic data and there's a 50%, 70%, 90% population disruption. You take the DNA from people after
these events, and almost all their ancestors are from Far Eastern Europe, right across most of
Europe. And so the DNA proved that that idea was wrong. It was very disruptive. It was a real
challenge to our understanding of prehistory. It was sort of a case example, a prime example that's
been important for me in showing that we really don't know what the past was like until we actually
look at it and have hard data telling us what it's like. Our guesses, our models, including many of
mine, are likely to be wrong.
