Strong spending data shows economy can grow without rate cuts: Point72's Dean Maki

Thrifty Thinkers
9 followers
1 Video View·Oct 18, 2024
Dean Maki, Point72 Asset Management chief economist, and CNBC's Steve Liesman join 'The Exchange to discuss new economic data, the Fed's next moves, and more.
Joining us now is Dean Mackey.
He's the chief economist at Point72 Asset Management.
CBC senior economic supporter Steve Leesman is here with me as well.
Dean, I'll start with you.
And Steve made an interesting point earlier.
You almost think there'd be a bigger market reaction
to how strong the data was this morning.
We're talking kind of in the sense of,
you know, how many more Fed cuts to really expect here?
Yeah, well, I mean, it really was strong data
with the seven-tenths rise in core retail sales.
And it's looking, again, like we're going to have
a 3% growth quarter on real GDP.
In the third quarter, we have that in the second quarter,
and we've averaged that over the past year.
So there's kind of a theme emerging there.
Consumers are spending, it looks like,
a 3.5% growth quarter for consumer spending at least.
So it is very strong data.
Does the Fed need to be cutting at all in this kind of environment?
I think the economy would grow fine if the Fed was not cutting.
The Fed is trying to reduce any potential risks
by cutting at this point and trying to get closer to a neutral pace.
But if the Fed wasn't cutting,
I would not be concerned myself about the growth outlook.
So are we saying that the neutral rate is 4.8%?
I don't know what the long-term neutral rate is,
which is really what the Fed is thinking about,
you know, several years out, what would be the neutral rate.
But I do think what we're seeing is that growth has been 3%
with the Fed funds rate at five and a quarter to five and a half.
So in the short term, anyway,
the economy is able to grow with rates at that level.
Yeah, Steve, it's remarkable.
I mean, who would have thought we would have been here?
I think that there are reasons to cut,
and I'm interested what Dean thinks about this.
There are people out in the economy that are paying
very onerous interest rates right now.
You look at the recent survey I saw,
small businesses paying interest rates above 10%,
home credit cards, those sorts of things.
There are reasons, and I just, I worry a little bit
just because the marathon runner is still doing his or her,
what is it, six or seven minute mile in a marathon?
Maybe it's five minutes these days.
For the pros, maybe less.
With 100 pounds on the back and he's on the way to get by,
does it mean it's the optimal amount of weight
this marathon runner should be carrying?
The only thing though, and I take your point,
is if for some reason it is the optimal thing
to be doing right now, and you start cutting
and stocks are at record highs
and services inflation starts looking a little sticky,
do you have a problem on your hands?
I think you do, but I think,
and again, I mentioned Dean's point of this,
what I think Fed Chair Powell and the Fed
has told us to focus on, and whether or not it's right,
I don't know, is that GDP in and of itself
and the labor market in and of itself
are not the sources of inflation.
That we have still some of these supply side things
to work through and other issues that are out there
and that he is less concerned about either GDP
or jobs as the source of inflation,
definitely the labor side,
and maybe less so the GDP side.
I think that the U.S. economy is dynamic,
finds a way to get by, but that doesn't mean
we're at the optimal amount of weight
it should be carrying.
Dean, what would you say?
I don't object to a gradual interest rate cutting
program by the Fed.
I would get very worried if the Fed were to keep
moving at this rate quickly down
to what they perceive as neutral.
But if they're going 25 per meeting
and observing the data,
I don't think the risks are that high.
I think the main risk is just that
we don't get inflation down.
Inflation right now is 2.7% on the core PCE.
It could just get stuck in that
two and a half to two and three quarters percent range.
It's not a disaster,
but it isn't what the Fed's trying to achieve.
Did you hear the gentleman from BlackRock on this morning
who said that, and these guys stand astride
the housing market,
they say their housing increases are 2%.
And we have inflation in the CPI at 5%.
For housing inflation.
So that's going to come down.
And by the way, people ask me,
why is Europe doing better than the U.S. on inflation?
One reason is they don't include housing
in their inflation numbers.
So they use this thing which we talked about,
the Harmonized Index of Consumer Prices,
the HICP.
As the ECB keeps cutting.
Right. And we're, I think,
Dean, I haven't looked in a little bit,
but we're kind of in line with them on that.
So the ECB has cut twice and we have a Fed
wondering why it ought to cut again.
Yeah, I mean, it gets into kind of a philosophical argument
about whether we should have housing costs in there.
I think the Fed would have a real problem on their hands
if they were to strip out housing costs from inflation.
So I do think they're supposed to be in there
and it's a reasonable way that we define them.
And the Fed has defined their inflation target
to include those costs.
So I think that's where we're at.
We'll monitor them.
Dean, I hate this phrase, but I think it's a good one.
The data is not a suicide pact in the sense that
just because it's in there
doesn't mean we can't look through it and say,
you know what?
Because you want to be consistent.
I think that's what you're saying, Dean.
But in the idea that if it's in there
and we have other data showing,
better data showing it's down.
Of course.
Doesn't mean we shouldn't make policy.
What is the super core showing these days?
The super core was north of three.
I have to look it up again.
Dean, are we still north of three on super core?
Yeah, I would hesitate to,
not to include the housing there
because once we start stripping out this and that,
it gets into a pretty dangerous game
where the Fed says inflation is low
except for the stuff that's not low.
So my view would be,
we do need to have those housing costs in there.
