Here's Why the E28 BMW 535i Is Now Worth $50,000

Ex Used Car
15 followers
Once upon a time, BMWs weren't over-styled iPhones on wheels.
The ultimate driving machine didn't need technological wonders that eventually turned
into nightmares to achieve their famous motto.
BMWs weren't leased by young executives stretching their entry-level salary to look
rich.
Rather, the people who owned these cars were enthusiasts looking for a car that blurred
the lines between luxury, practicality, and performance.
And just when other European luxury brands were starting to get their foothold on this
now widely popular theme, BMW was on top of their game.
And this 1986 BMW 535i is BMW's equivalent to Prince's Purple Rain.
I never really paid these old 5 Series much attention, and no, I didn't buy this one.
It's actually for sale over at my buddy's car lot, EuroAsian Auto Inc. in Wichita, Kansas.
But in recent years, you hardly ever see them on the road anymore, and I guess that's why
people are starting to go pretty crazy with these, as one recently sold on Bring a Trailer
for $50,000.
No, not 50,000 pesos, $50,000 for a showroom example, although it had 80,000 miles on it,
and it wasn't totally original.
$50,000 for something that's not an M5, that was mass-produced, and what I thought was
a cheap used car that was still widely available.
So then I went searching online, and was shocked to discover that they're all gone.
Currently on AutoTrader, there's just one higher mileage 1988 BMW 535i that's got a
manual transmission like this one, and it looks like a solid car, though it's somewhat
cosmetically challenged, and they want $9,500 for it.
That's the same average asking price as a 2008 535i on AutoTrader.
At first, I was shocked, but when you really think about it, it really is easy to figure
out why this is happening.
Putting scarcity aside and the whole crazy market in recent years with Radwood era cars,
the styling is the first obvious change between then and now.
This shark-nosed, high-roofed sedan is unmistakable for anything but a BMW, no butts or bangle-butts
about it.
From here, BMWs started looking more generic than blobby, and every other car manufacturer
seemed to follow suit.
Now BMWs look like Hondas, or Hondas look like BMWs.
It doesn't really matter, though, as people seem to quit caring about cars looking different
from one another.
Now I'm not done with the exterior, as it's also worth noting how simple this car is.
There's nothing getting in the way of this car to style it just for the sake of styling.
Every trim, every body line, every part here serves a purpose, and anything extra would
just take away from what BMW stood for back then.
The KISS method of construction is pretty hard to imagine with today's offerings from
Munich, but it's really the theme of this entire car, especially in the engine bay.
Ooh!
Ha ha ha ha ha!
Ooh!
Now notice you can actually see an engine.
No plastic dress-up covers, you can see an engine with a simple metal valve cover gasket
with no funky variable valve timing sticking out of it, like it has appendages from being
assimilated by the board.
Any Trekkies watching, I am Locutus of Borg.
But really, look how easy, accessible, and understandable everything is.
Making this 535 a joy to work on, I'm sure, and the simplicity pays off in reliability
as well.
This is probably the last BMW to not have a fatal flaw engineered into it, which has
run rampant with BMW and most other brands as they got more experimental with technology.
From this time forward, you will service us.
And it's not really BMW's fault or anybody else's that modern cars are just so finicky.
It's just the facts of life.
As performance and economy get to levels unimaginable in 1986, things are going to get infinitely
more complicated and there's a lot more that can break, to the point that it's impossible
to keep an aging smartphone-era car running without going bankrupt.
It really is smarter nowadays to just junk one of those cars and buy a new one, as the
maintenance and repairs are endless and ridiculously expensive.
Now, BMW has sort of become the poster child for this era of throwaway engineering, and
seeing how BMWs used to be, the frustration among old school enthusiasts is totally understandable.
This simple theme doesn't stop on the inside either.
Look again at how simple this car is while totally achieving its objective as the ultimate
driving machine.
This little box right here is the only thing you can really call computerized, and it tells
you things like the average mpg and a few other little tricks.
And if it breaks, who cares, it's not going to leave you on the side of the road.
All the other functions have a simple switch that sends a signal to a simple relay that
tells a simple mechanical component to do its job.
There's no body control computer to have a stroke and go haywire and cause your windshield
washers to spray continuously when you activate your turn signals.
But even things you would expect to have some kind of electronic control are even simpler
than that with this BMW, like the climate control.
The vents are controlled by levers that are connected to flaps.
There's no wind door actuators or a climate control computer to break and decide to blue
screen itself and turn the car into a sauna on a hot summer's day.
Even the blower fan and climate control look simple to change as it's actually visible
from the passenger compartment.
I've never seen a blower motor so conspicuously showing in the interior before.
Usually they're just buried up in the dash or in the engine bay and a nightmare to change
out.
Now my favorite part of this BMW's interior is this warning panel up here, which is able
to monitor most everything in the car without a complicated computer system.
It's just a little light bulb tied to a component like the tail lights, brake pads, coolant
level sensor, and other things you want to keep an eye on.
And when something doesn't seem right, the little corresponding light turns on.
They even put a little button up here to check and see if all your bulbs are working, just
like in an aircraft.
Now after seeing this marvelous lack of gizmos, it's hard to imagine this car has anything
relatable to BMW's of the day.
That is, until you actually start driving it.
Which I would need the key to start driving it.
So much for this looking like a...
I don't even have the keys, they must be inside.
God damn it.
Now, I had never driven one of these oldies until this one, and honestly, the first impression
was the smell of horse hair.
They literally used horse hair in the seats for padding, and it smells like it.
But then I ran it through the gears for the first time, and took a couple of turns, and
I couldn't believe how good this car felt.
It has the same tight and heavy steering response, the same rev-happy power curve with its basic
182 horsepower engine, and crisp-feeling gearbox like a modern BMW.
I honestly didn't expect an old BMW like this to feel so modern.
It's also impressive how good this car feels, considering that it has 214,000 miles on it.
It's showing no sign of getting close to the point of being to be put out to pasture.
Now, it has some age-related wear with the interior and the weather stripping, but it's
amazing how well this car has held up overall.
This 535i and I are literally the same age, and while I probably couldn't last a lap jogging
around the block without getting a leg cramp and hyperventilating, this thing seems ready
to drive cross-country.
So really, it's easy to see why these are getting more desirable, and it makes me feel
like I made a big mistake buying a 1991 BMW 850i, one of the first complicated, computerized
BMWs.
I really think the brand should pay attention to the market demand of their young classics,
much like Porsche has, and build cars that mirror this simple, pure creation.
Obviously, the success of the recent 1M is a testament to that demand, but imagine an
even more simple, bare-bones four-door sedan that still drove like a BMW without all the
stupid techy crap that started for under $30,000.
There'd be a line, there'd be a waiting list if they still built a car like this.
I'm sure of it.
Go, baby, go, baby, go!
Though really, this is kind of a fantasy, as it's much cheaper nowadays to build things
that are all electronically controlled, rather than installing a bunch of switches and levers
and gauges, and really, gadgets are what sell cars nowadays and puts them in the headlines.
So I'm sorry to report that you'll never see another BMW like this ever again.
And what few of these old cars left that haven't been driven into the ground certainly deserve
the crazy prices we're all starting to see.
No need to gripe about how these used to be really cheap, just buy one while you still
can and enjoy watching it leak away in your garage as it steadily appreciates in value.
Thank you for watching.
