105 Video Views·Oct 17, 2024
🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and special events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
This is the TV version of Jan Jekielek’s interview with John Lott. The longer-form version was released on Epoch TV on August 15, 2024.
John Lott is the founder and president of The Crime Prevention Research Center. Jan Jekielek talks to him about his extensive research into national crime rates, arrest rates, as well as gun permit laws and how they impact crime.
“In 2022, the last year that we have the National Crime Victimization data, the FBI showed a 2% drop in violent crime. The National Crime Victimization data showed a 42% increase in total violent crime. And I think one of the big reasons for this is that you have a change in the rate that people are being arrested.”
CHAPTER HEADERS
0:00:00 Introduction - Disconnect Between Crime Reporting and Public Perception
0:01:44 Diverging Crime Data Trends - FBI vs. National Crime Victimization Survey
0:03:33 Plummeting Arrest Rates for Violent and Property Crimes
0:07:06 Challenges with Police Departments Reporting Crime Data to the FBI
0:09:56 Prosecutors Downgrading Felonies to Misdemeanors
0:12:55 Public Perception of Rising Crime Rates
0:15:23 Increase in Concealed Carry Permits and Constitutional Carry States
0:20:00 Concealed Carry's Impact on Reducing Violent Crime
0:23:08 Conclusion - Making Crime Risky for Criminals
Why is there such a disconnect between FBI data showing that violent crime is down and the public’s perception that crime is surging? John Lott: “The media looks at the FBI reported crime data. The problem is a huge number of police departments are no longer even reporting data to the FBI.”
“If you look at large cities, over a million with population, and this is true across all cities, they had an average arrest rate for violent crimes of 44% prior to covid, it started falling in 2020 and by 2022 the arrest rates for reported violent crime was down to 20% from 44% to 20%. That's over a 50% drop, and that's just for reported crimes. If you look at arrests for total crimes reported and unreported, only 8% of violent crimes result in arrest, and only 1% of total property crimes result in arrests, and not everybody who's arrested is charged, let alone prosecuted and convicted. And so that's been a real sea change. I mean, you can look over the last 70 years of crime data and you see nothing like that, even over decades, let alone within a three year period of time.”
According to John Lott, “crime is kind of leaked out of the zip codes where it was traditionally the highest into other zip codes that in the past didn't experience high crime rates. So you've had not only an increase in violent crime in areas where it's traditionally been there, but you've also had it go into areas that had been safer before.”
“I think people realize to varying degrees that law enforcement's collapsed in this country. You
know, we have about 22 million Americans with a concealed carry permit now in the United States. But even more than that, we have, we have 29 constitutional carry states now where you don't even need to have a permit. So we did a survey last year to try to get information on
the rate that people are carrying permit concealed handguns. Pew had done one a few years
ago, where in 2017 they had like 5% of American likely voters were carrying all or most of the time. Our survey indicated that was about 15% now, so that's a three fold increase that's occurred between 2017 and 2023 and one of the reasons why you've had this big increase in the number of constitutional carry States over the last few years has been what happened during covid. You had this big increase in violent crime, and over 20 of the states stopped issuing concealed carry permits. And so people realized that they didn't want to have to depend upon the government to issue a permit for them to be able to go and carry because if you have a disaster that occurs and the government shuts down issuing permits. Again, that's exactly when you're going to need to be able to go and carry.”
“If you want to reduce crime, you have to make it risky for criminals to commit crime."
💛 Support us 👉https://donorbox.org/american-thought-leaders
-------------------------------------------------
© All Rights Reserved.
only 8% of violent crimes and only 1% of
Total Property crimes result in arrest
in this episode I sit down with John lot
founder and president of the crime
prevention Research Center to discuss
his extensive research into National
crime rates arrest rates as well as gun
permit laws and how they impact crime
why is there such a disconnect between
media reporting that violent crime is
down and the Public's perception that
crime is surging the media looks at the
FBI reported crime data the problem is a
huge number of police departments are no
longer even reporting data to the FBI
you have prosecutors who are refusing to
prosecute violent criminals I mean
what's the risk of committing crime this
is American thought leaders and I'm Yan
Kell John lot such a pleasure to have
you back on American thought leaders
well it's great to talk to you again
thanks for having me on well John I've
always come to you for
uh trying to understand what's going on
with crime statistics right and one of
the things we observed at the epoch
times is that in some cases you even
have agencies that are telling us you
know kind of different stories with
different numbers that they're
publishing so I'm trying to make sense
of this so so what are you seeing right
now a lot of the media is talking about
crime rates going down uh the last
couple years the problem is is I don't
think most the media understands the
different numbers that are being put out
you have two different sources on crime
numbers both from the Department of
Justice one's the FBI data collecting
the number of reported crimes to police
and the other one is something called
the National Crime victimization survey
which surveys about 240,000 people each
year to try to get a measure of total
crime both reported and unreported we
know most violent crime most property
crimes aren't reported to police but we
know that from the National Crime
victimization data so for example about
42% of violent crimes are reported to
police about 32% of property crimes are
reported to police and the the amount
that's been unreported has been changing
a lot over the last few years uh and
there's a simple reason I think for why
that's the case but these numbers
traditionally have moved together the
FBI reported crime data traditionally
has moved up and down with the National
Crime victimization data except for the
last years in the last three years
they've kind of they've gone in opposite
directions they've been perfectly
negatively related to each other so for
example uh in 2022 the last year that we
have the National Crime victimization
data for while the FBI showed a 2% drop
in violent crime the National Crime
victimization data showed a 42% increase
in total violent crime and uh I think
one of the big reasons for this is that
you have a change in the rate that
people are being arrested law
enforcement in this country is basically
collapsed and you know people have some
idea about this you know they go to a
CVS or a Walgreens in many parts of the
country and everything's behind glass
they know that that wasn't true a few
years ago but it's much more
systematically across the Spectrum if
you look at large cities over a million
with population and this is true across
all cities but they had average arrest
rate for violent crimes of
44% prior to covid it started falling in
2020 and by 2022 the arrest rates for
reported violent crime was down to 20%
from 44% to 20% that's over a 50% drop
and that's just for reported crimes if
you look at arrests for total crimes
reported and unreported only 8% of
violent crimes result in arrest and only
1% of Total Property crimes result in
arrests and not everybody who's arrested
is charged let alone prosecuted and
convicted and so that's been a real sea
change I mean you can look over the last
70 years of crime data and you see
nothing like that even over decades let
alone within a three-year period of time
and and one of the things we know and
we've known for a long time and that is
as people don't think the criminals are
going to be caught and punished they're
less likely to go and Report the crimes
it's also become more difficult for
people to report crimes too you were you
were pointing out that there are a lot
of CVS's and other type stores that are
open kind of around the clock that have
a lot of their products behind glass
I've seen that in New York I've seen
that in DC but but that's not violent
crime and so the overall rates going up
is that the case across all sort of
types of crime yeah you the one uh
murders if you compare murder before
covid to now it's still about 7% higher
but other types of violent crime have
gone up much more than that and property
crime has soared uh what's happened is
is that as we've had Cuts back in police
the police have focused on the most
severe crimes murder primarily and moved
resources away from other types of
crimes and so these other types of
crimes have have simply uh gotten much
worse you know it's criminals have
little to worry about in terms of
getting caught and punished so you see
more crime so that accounts for the sort
of lower optic and murder because that's
where all the resources they're going to
the most serious things right exactly
and you you see this just in police
response so in many parts of the country
now if you call up 911 they'll ask you
is this an emergency and basically
they're trying to figure out is the
crime stolen progress if the crime
stolen progress they'll send a police
car out if it's not they said well you
can come down to the police station now
and Report the crime that wasn't true
four or 5 years ago before if there was
a crime they'd send out a police car all
the time and but you know it's just an
example of them kind of triaging that
they have limited resources murders
obviously they'll send somebody out all
the time for that but some of these
other types of violent crimes uh they
won't send somebody out and so with
murder I guess the reporting rates and
the real rates are probably close yeah
there right right murder is the one type
of crime where there's not the same type
of reporting problems that you see with
other types of crime that's exactly
right okay well so tell me a little bit
about what's happened to police
departments this is something I've
covered quite a bit on the show in the
past but I'd love to know where we're at
now because I've also been we've had a
number of stories of you know kind of
turnarounds in certain States and
districts and so forth right well I mean
you had lots of big cuts uh in many
places in 2020
2021 in the last year or so they've
started to go back and hire police but
you also had a lot of retirements that
were occurring for police officers so
you may have lost somebody who had 15
years of experience and now you've hired
somebody who's been on the job for 6
months or a year they simply aren't
going to be as effective as of a police
officer as somebody who had 15 years I I
did want to mention mention one thing on
the murder and that is one big problem
that we have right now is that a huge
number of police departments are no
longer even reporting data to the FBI so
uh starting in 2021 there were changes
in the rules there for reporting and in
2022 for example um 32% of police
departments were no longer reporting any
data to the FBI that compares to about
3% in 2020 and and another 24% of police
departments were only partially
reporting crime data so that means less
than half of police departments now as
compared to
97% before are reporting complete crime
data to the FBI now the FBI will kind of
guess and make estimates on what the
missing data is but there are problems
with them doing that and includes
everything from murder to all sorts of
other uh violent crime and property
crimes there that having that they're
having to guess and estimate and and
their problems with that so and those
are the guess guesses and estimates that
they're making into into their that D
FBI database that you're Des exactly
right so why are they not reporting
anymore I mean that's a huge shift there
were changes in reporting requirements
put into effect by the Biden
Administration they were requiring more
information on some things and they were
requiring more frequent reporting and a
number of police departments just say
this is is just too onerous we're not
going to do it plus I think some places
just used it as an excuse uh I mean you
can go to their websites and you can
find out what the crime data is for
places like New York City and Los
Angeles uh but they just have decided
not to report the data to the FBI are
you familiar with the actual numbers of
the decline in different departments
around the country you do see a drop in
reported crime
that's in the FBI data now the National
Crime victimization data also has a
measure of reported crimes and and their
measure not only is their total measure
different from the FBI measure of
reported crimes but their reported crime
measure is different so in 2022 while
the FBI as I said showed a 2% drop in
reporter crimes the National Crime
victimization data showed a 29% increase
in reported crimes there are lots of
reasons for that one of the things you
know I was mentioning before about how
before they'd send out a a police car if
you called in now for many cases they're
requiring that you come into the the
police station to do the report I don't
think a lot of people understand that
simply calling up 911 doesn't result in
the the crime being reported you have to
actually have an officer fill out a
police report uh other problems that you
have is that you have many places
downgrading crime so like in New York
City in Manhattan where Elvin Bragg
who's been in the news a Fairmount
recently he's downgraded 60% of felonies
violent felonies the vast majority of
those are aggravated assaults and what
he's done is he refuses to prosecute
people for for firearms offenses so what
can make something an aggravated assault
as opposed to which is a felony is
compared to a simple assault which is a
misdemeanor is whether a weapon was used
in the assault and since he's refusing
to prosecute these criminals for weapons
offenses he's downgraded Mo he not only
has he downgraded 60% of the felonies
but almost all those have been
downgraded from a felony to a
misdemeanor from aggravated assault to
simple assault because he's kicked out
or removed the weapon part of that and
and and that affects the FBI data
because the FBI data does only includes
aggravated assaults in the in the
violent crime numbers not simple
assaults and so by moving these crimes
from aggravated to simple that helps
reduce uh the FBI number of reported
crimes but the National Crime
victimization data Picks Them Up and the
reason why they pick them up is because
in these 240,000 people that they're
interviewing they'll ask you what
happened with the crime and they'll say
I was assaulted the person had a gun and
so the National Crime victimization data
will record that as an aggravated
assault even though the FBI data will
Rec record it as nothing because it's
not an aggravated assault anymore are
there other databases that will tell you
that that seem to have this incongruence
or other sets of databases in other
areas that well I mean I know the crime
data the best you know we know that
there have been some issues with the FBI
reported crime data before and so kind
of the gold standard that we' used over
time has been the National Crime
victimization data because we care about
total crimes not just what's reported
and you know I think a lot of people
have an understanding that a lot of
violent crimes aren't reported but the
only re way we know that the measure
that we have that is the National Crime
victimization
data what about you know perception sort
of societal perception of of crime I
mean I I my sense from talking to people
and this is just very anecdotal is that
they they sense that there is more you
see headline after headline in the news
articles saying crime is falling but
people think that it's increasing I mean
I can give you dozens of headlines like
that and what they're doing is they're
looking at surveys from Gallup to Harris
to rasmon to others that are showing
people have increasing fears about
violent crime that they say that it's
been increasing uh but but then the
media looks at the FBI reported crime
data and said well that's falling and so
you have all these news articles saying
that people just you know have this
mistaken impression they blame it on you
know the news media for covering crimes
or something like that as creating the
impression and as you know our first
discussion about uh you go to CVS or
Walgreens you know even though that's
property crime that's there people know
that 3 or 4 years ago everything wasn't
behind glass in a lot of these stores
you know and they know that these
companies aren't doing this for fun I
mean you go in I've gone into places and
try to buy things I have to get a clerk
to come over to unlock it they have to
stand next to me while I'm reading the
package agreement ingredients you know
that's I I I feel bad making them have
to do that it's costly for them to do
that they they only do it because they
have to because of all the property
theft I did a study looking at the
geographic distribution within the
County of Los Angeles of crime and I've
done a little bit of work for other
places and what you've seen over the
last few years is that crime is kind of
leaked out of the zip codes where it was
traditionally the highest into other zip
codes that in the past didn't experience
high so you've had not only an incre
increase in violent crime in areas where
it's traditionally been there but you've
also had it go into areas that had been
safer before that's across the board the
only data that I've looked at really
carefully has been Los Angeles County
but I've also looked at Cook County a
little bit and you seem to have a
somewhat similar pattern there too and
John we're going to take a quick break
right now and we'll be right
back and we're back with John Lock
president at crimeresearch.org
so the other thing that again i' I've
seen some statistics around is that
there's more people going out and buying
guns for protecting themselves right I
think people realize to varying degrees
that law enforcement's collapsed in this
country you know we've have about 22
million Americans with a concealed carry
permit now in the United States but even
more than that we have we have uh 29
constitutional carry states now where
you don't even need to have a permit so
we did a survey last year to try to get
information on the rate that people are
carrying uh Perman concealed handguns
Pew had done one a few years ago where
they had in
2017 where they had like uh 5% of
American likely voters were carrying all
or most of the time our survey indicated
that it was about 15% now so it's so
that's a big in that's a three-fold
increase that's occurred between 2017
and 2023 and one of the reasons why
you've had this big increase in the
number of constitutional carry states
over the last few years has been what
happened during Co you had this big
increase in violent crime and over 20 of
the states stopped issuing Concealed
Carry Permits and so people realized
that they didn't want to have to depend
upon the government to issue a permit
for them to be able to go and carry
because if you have a disaster that
occurs and the government shuts down
issuing permits again that's exactly
when you're going to need to be able to
go and
carry the idea
behind people carrying is there's a
deterrence element here right like that
right look just as you can make it risky
for criminals to commit crime with
higher arrest rates higher conviction
rates longer prison sentences the fact
that would be victims might be able to
go and defend themselves also makes it
riskier for criminals to go and commit
crimes I was I was Chief Economist for
the US sentencing commission in
Washington and I must have read over a
thousand trial transcripts and you
constantly are coming across cases where
um you know you'll have one Robber turn
States evidence against another robber
and they got asked the same questions
you know why did you pick the particular
Target that you did there and they'll
say well you know we're talking about
going after the drug dealer down the
street he has lots of money but he has
lots of guns so it' be crazy to go after
him and we were thinking we talked about
going after a cab driver but a lot of
the cab drivers have guns and so we saw
this small woman walking alone across a
parking lot late at night and she looked
like an easy target and so we went after
her and so you know if if you have it so
that victims are able to make it riskier
for criminals to go and commit crime
they respond to that but you have to
make it so that the people who are the
most likely victims of violent crime are
the ones who are caring you know you
have States like Illinois where it may
cost $450 to go and get a concealed
carry permit with the fees and the
training cost so you basically have
people who live in the suburbs go and
get Concealed Carry Permits well they're
not the ones at risk I could have 100%
of the population in an area where
there's zero crime carrying a permit and
it's not going to have any impact on
crime I have to have it so that the
people are the most likely victims of
violent crime or caring and that my
Research indicates to me that the people
who benefit the most from carrying are
basically poor blacks who live in high
crime urban areas the people who are the
most likely victims of violent crime the
other group of people that my research
shows who benefit the most are people
who are relatively weaker physically
women and the elderly you're almost
always talking about a young man doing
the attack and when a man is attacking a
woman there's a much larger strength
difference that exists there on average
than when a man is attacking another man
and so the presence of a gun represents
a much bigger relative change in a
woman's ability to go and protect
herself than it does for a man if my
research convinces Me of anything it's
the most vulnerable people in society
who benefit the most from having the
option to protect themselves and as as
law enforcement is is collapsing I think
people are moving to protect
themselves so is there data out there
that shows you know in places where well
I I guess for there would be two V
variations here one would be the states
that switch to constitutional carry do
you see reductions in violent crime
that's one and two the states where I
guess concealed carry comes in or
there's an increase in concealed carry
does that change we we we're fine is
that moving to constitutional carry
because presumably a lot more people are
carrying in those places we no longer
have the numbers because people can
carry without a permit you see as States
move you see large drops in violent
crime rates the states that don't have
constitutional carry and rely solely on
issuing permits as the percentage of the
adult population with permits increase
you see you see drops in violent CR
crime but it's particularly important
who is caring so if I have lower fees
and uh you know lower cost for people
caring I see more minorities more PE
poor people caring and that's
particularly important in reducing uh
violent crime rates people can go to our
website at crimeresearch.org we have
peer-reviewed academic research on this
you know we also put out a report each
year and we've been doing this since I
guess
2013 on the number of Concealed Carry
Permits by state to track that over time
and so you know we've been able to go
and and and see how as permits are
increasing in the state what's happened
to the violent crime rates and so and
the main factor that that kind of
changes things is the cost of the permit
it sounds like that has a big impact you
know you make apples more expensive
people buy fewer apples uh I'll give you
a simple example I mentioned Illinois
Illinois about 4% of the adult
population is a concealed carry permit
and neighboring Indiana it's about
23% why the difference it's pretty
simple and in Illinois as I said it cost
$450 to go through the process to get a
permit in Indiana it's zero they don't
even charge for a background check
that's there so not only do you have a
lot more people carrying but you have a
lot more zip codes which are lowincome
and heavily minority having permits than
in in Indiana than you have in Illinois
so the very people who benefit the most
from being able to go and carry are the
ones who are carrying in Indiana so you
don't expect even though they both have
concealed carry laws you don't expect to
see much of a drop in violent crime in
Illinois if if even the 4% that you have
are people who are care who are wealthy
people who live in low crime areas to
begin with well John this has been a
wonderful conversation a final thought
as we
finish you know uh if you want to reduce
crime you have to make it risky for
criminals to commit
crime well John lot it's such a pleasure
to have had you on again well thank you
very much for having me I greatly
appreciate it thank you all for joining
John lot and me on this episode of
American thought leaders I'm your host
Yan Kellick
[Music]