Maxwell's Equations FAIL to Explain This Experiment

James Clerk Maxwell
6 followers
In 1632, Galileo Galilei introduced the so-called principle of relativity,
and he used an example of a ship traveling at a constant speed on a calm sea without rocking,
and he said that any observer below the deck would not be able to say whether the ship was
moving or stationary. In other words, you would not be able to conduct any experiment
that would distinguish a motion. As an experiment, I always imagined this box,
which can give you a result in a form of ordered sequence of letters, like AB. If you put such a
box in a frame that is moving with a constant velocity, the result is going to be always the
same. At least experiments using mechanics only, since at that time not much more was known.
Then people started to discover electric and magnetic fields, and everything culminated with
this gentleman, whose name is James Clark Maxwell, who introduced these four differential equations.
And from now on, things become complicated. And it is not because how scary these equations
look like, it is because how they were derived. Maxwell didn't use any frame of reference
when he derived his equations. They are field equations, they hold for any stationary observer.
This means that if you measured a certain value of electric and magnetic field,
then you can use Maxwell's equations to determine the evolution of these fields. It depends only on
the values of the field you initially measured. But the problem happens when you want to use
these measurements for a moving observer. Then you get the wrong predictions, because the moving
observer has to measure these fields for himself, and then he can make predictions. So the moving
observer can't use your measured values and predict anything about this field, and that's
really weird. If you try to calculate the force acting on a moving charge in an electromagnetic
field, you would get the equation which is called the Lorentz force. You can immediately spot a
problem with this equation though, and it is the fact that the force depends on the velocity of
the charged particle. But the velocity is a relative quantity, so how can a force be a relative quantity
as well? What is the reference frame we should measure this speed relative to? A good example of
this is this experiment. Imagine an infinite wire with a non-zero current. This current is represented
by moving charges inside the wire, in particular electrons moving to the right. This means that
the direction of the current is to the left, and according to this particular Maxwell's equation,
current creates a magnetic field around the wire. We can make an assumption that the density of the
electrons inside the wire is the same as the protons, and therefore the total electric charge
of the wire is zero. Imagine we have a positively charged particle moving to the right with the same
velocity as the velocity of the electrons inside the wire. According to the Lorentz force equation,
there should be a force acting on the particle in a perpendicular direction to the magnetic field
and its velocity, which means the particle should be repelled from the wire. Since we assume the wire
is neutral, the contribution to the force from the electric part is zero. So the result of such
experiment is a particle that is slowly drifting away from the conductor. But now let's take a look
at this problem from the reference frame of the particle. In a frame of particle, the electrons
are stationary and the protons are moving to the left, which means the current is still flowing to
the left, creating the same magnetic field, but now the velocity of the particle is zero. And if we take
a look at the Lorentz force, then not just the electric part is zero, but also the magnetic part,
therefore there should be no force whatsoever. This is certainly a problem, because the result
of an experiment should not depend on the reference frame we choose, and therefore there are only two
possible resolutions of this problem. There is either a global frame of reference we should
measure the velocities relative to, which basically breaks the Galilean relativity, but all observers
would put the same velocity inside the Lorentz force equation, and therefore the force would be
still the same. And the second possible resolution is that the charge of the wire depends on the
reference frame of the observer. This would mean that the electric part of the Lorentz force
would not be zero and produce a force on the particle. Okay, there is maybe a third option, and it's that
Maxwell's equations are simply wrong, but this gentleman did a series of experiments throughout
his life, and all were in accord with Maxwell's equations, so this option seems kind of unlikely.
Then there were these two gentlemen, Michelson and Morley, who tried to find a global inertial
frame of reference for electromagnetism, but failed. It is the famous Michelson-Morley experiment,
which measures the speed of light in two different directions by measuring the interference pattern
on the detector, and they found out that the speed of light is the same in all directions.
Since the Maxwell's equations have a problem with Galilean transformations, this gentleman,
whose name is Henrik Lorentz, calculated how the proper transformation rules should look like
for Maxwell's equations, and came up with this set of transformations called Lorentz transformations.
If you apply these transformations on the electric and magnetic field, you would find that they mix,
which suggests that the second resolution is correct, and the electric charge density depends
on the frame of reference. But why? Why should a charge density depend on the observer? Henrik
Lorentz didn't give any physical explanation for these transformation rules. He thought of them as
being just pure mathematical constructs. The final resolution came with this young gentleman,
with his special relativity. According to special relativity, the distance interval between two
points in space depends on the relative velocity of the observer. So, if there are two points in
space that are stationary relative to us, and we measure the distance l, then if we start moving
relative to these two points, the distance between them becomes shorter. And this is the resolution
why charge density depends on the observer. Because if we look at the wire again, from a stationary
frame point of view, it is the magnetic field acting on the particle, but if we jump into a
frame of the particle, the distance interval between protons shrinks as they start moving
relative to us. And moreover, the electrons that were moving relative to us are now stationary,
which causes their stretch. Now, we can clearly see that there is a positive charge density of the
This is kind of eye-opening to me, because the discovery of the magnetic field around the wire
happened a long time ago, and for all this time, magnetic field was here as a hint for length
contraction. And it took almost 100 years to actually discover it. So, there is in fact just
one force, which is electromagnetic force. But this name doesn't work quite well for me, because
it still kind of implies that there are actually two, electric and magnetic force. But those are
just two manifestations of just one force. The reason why we perceive them as being two different
forces is because we are not used to think of time as being another dimension. And here we are trying
to describe a four-dimensional quantity in terms of two three-dimensional vectors in space. But
having two three-dimensional vectors in space is kind of redundant, as there is overall six
quantities in total. But electric and magnetic fields are coupled together via Maxwell's
And by a proper definition of these fields, we get just four independent quantities, which is
what we want in four-dimensional space-time. Electromagnetism, however, is not the only thing
that needs to be rewritten in terms of four-dimensional quantities. Position, velocity
and momentum all have their four-dimensional representation in special relativity. Since the
velocities we are dealing with on Earth are very small, it is really difficult to notice any
relativistic effect. But there are so many electrons inside a wire, that even small velocities
of a charged particle can have a big effect. And that is why magnetic field around the wire
was discovered much more early. Einstein in his paper discovered the same transformation rules
as Lorentz, but he didn't even know about his existence at that time. Those transformation
rules just tell you that when you see a charge that is stationary relative to you, then if you
start moving, then the magnetic field appears. Similarly, if you see a magnetic field, when you
start moving, the electric field appears. And all this because we have two three-dimensional
representations of a four-dimensional quantity. When I first learned about the connection between
electricity and magnetism, it just blew my mind. And I hope that similar thing happened to you as
well. If it did, please give this video a like, since it really motivates me to create more. And
I see you in the next video.
