What to Do When an Insurance Company Denies Your Accident Claim
8 Video Views·Oct 16, 2024
Welcome to Lawyers in the House with Motley.
Wish you had a lawyer in the family?
Now you do.
Here's your host, Veronica Waters.
Welcome on in to the house.
Make yourselves comfortable.
I'm Veronica Waters.
Picture this.
Imagine that you find yourself in a place
where you feel the need to say,
this is horrible.
But I guess this is my life now.
Nobody's listening to me when I need help the most.
They call me a fraud.
Police said it was my fault.
I guess nobody's ever gonna take me seriously.
And I have to live with this for the rest of my life.
These are the kinds of cases
from which the two lawyers in the house
with me today never shy away.
And if you've been rocking with us for a while
on Lawyers in the House,
then you've met them both before.
Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran.
I'm your host, Veronica Waters.
You guys, thanks so much for being back in the house
on Lawyers in the House with Motley.
Thank you for having us.
It's great to be back.
We're talking about long shot cases today, folks.
And one of the things I've learned about Mike and Nevis
is that they are so persistent and so passionate.
And as I said, don't run from a fight,
even when things look tough.
But I want to know,
what's a long shot case look like in the first place?
How do you even, how does it even come to you?
What does that even look like, long shots?
Well, there's all kinds of classifications
and it's great to see you again.
Thanks for having us back.
A long shot case can be a low property damage case.
It can be a case that happened on private property.
It can be a case with disputed liability,
but essentially at its core,
it's an insurance company denying a case for a client.
And at the other side of that denial
is somebody who has been horribly hurt.
And what they're hearing is no,
we're not going to pay your medical bills.
We're not going to fix your car.
You're going to be left in financial ruin.
We don't believe you.
So that's what the denial is saying.
And our job would be to get into this case and turn the tide
and turn a denial into a victory.
And that's the most rewarding part.
I think of practicing law is working for somebody
who's been told all those things
and then us being able to lift them out of that.
Yeah, Mike, you told me that you actually relish
these kinds of cases.
Absolutely.
Because they are, they're sitting in their pain.
They're sitting and being told their pain has no value.
They're facing financial ruin, bills, cars, you name it.
And they're desperate and all they've heard is no.
And they may have heard no from other law firms as well.
And those are the cases where I find them personally
rewarding is when they've had a series of no's,
they give us a shot, we get into it
and bring our resources to bear
and turn a no into a victory.
That's incredibly rewarding.
Nevis Yurich, what do these cases have in common
from your point of view?
Similarly to what Mike just said,
we're dealing with cases that sometimes
have very low property damage.
We are dealing with cases with people
who might have disability already
or injuries that they've already dealt with
that are similar to the ones that have now been
re-aggravated in the wreck.
We're dealing with cases where our client
might've been the one that was cited.
So the officer that came to the scene
and investigate the matter put our client at fault.
Essentially, these are cases where either
the insurance company or an attorney
that they've spoken with before
has already said, we can't help you.
And so like Mike said, these are people
who at times are very hurt.
Their livelihood has been significantly impacted.
Their cries for help are not heard.
They've been denied their right for compensation
and they have nowhere to turn.
You also like to get into these cases
and you all are so creative in the ways
that you sort of solve these problems.
But some of it looks like just shoe leather, right?
And elbow grease, from what I'm hearing.
Mike, talk about, Nevis mentioned something
about preexisting injuries.
And I remember that we talked about the eggshell plaintiff
in a previous show that we did.
I think it was our second episode about medical malpractice.
And so we know a little bit about that,
but can you talk, like delve into that a little bit?
What's that all about?
That's gotta be like an extra challenge.
Yeah, I had a client who called me
and it was the perfect storm.
It was, he was hit on the back of his vehicle
by a girl who left the big box store
and she failed the yield.
And there was very, very minor property damage.
So much so that they decided
that they wouldn't even call the police.
So there wasn't even a police report.
They just exchanged information.
Now he had back surgery
about four months prior to this wreck.
They exchanged information and didn't think anything of it.
He went home, sat in a chair
and almost immediately realized something was wrong.
And so it was a perfect storm
because there was very little property damage.
There was no police report that recreated how it happened.
And so I had, I took his case.
I believed him.
I knew he was hurt.
I talked with him.
He was credible to the bone.
I met him at the scene.
We had to take photographs.
We had to recreate how it happened.
And we still got no's, no, no, no
from the insurance company.
This could not have caused the injury.
Ultimately his surgery failed and because of this,
and he had to have a revision done.
So he suffered for a long time.
And we, after repeated no's,
had to put this into a lawsuit.
And the biggest thing was I knew he was credible.
We had to get him in front of people.
He had to tell a story.
And he gave his deposition and he did.
And he was believable and the defense counsel believed him.
And after a long fight,
we resolved that case for $350,000.
And so it went from a zero and a fat no
entirely from the beginning to a recovery for him.
And it was because his condition worsened.
Even though there was no police report,
there was very little property damage.
I knew what happened.
He knew what happened.
And at the end of the day, we were able to prove that.
How must that feel?
Not just for you, the attorney who helps guide this victory,
but for the person who has already been told,
no, no, no, no, no.
I said, no.
They don't understand.
They don't understand that.
I'm sure Nevis has had clients like that as well.
It's hard for them to understand that.
Once we win for these clients,
it is so gratifying to know
that people who felt helpless and hopeless,
whose families sometimes met with us
and told us how their life has been turned upside down,
people are losing jobs.
They have to have surgeries.
They have families to support.
The pain in their voices,
sometimes it's just too much to bear.
So winning for these people who's pleased for help
were ignored by either insurance companies
who deny their claims
or attorneys who had spoken with them before
but didn't believe in the merits of the case,
it is an unbelievable feeling of vindication.
And those are the most rewarding moments for me personally.
I'm sure Mike can attest to that,
to know that we've overcome a challenge
that some people just thought was too much to tackle.
Quickly, why would another attorney turn something down?
Is it just because it doesn't look like an easy win?
It could be for a myriad of reasons.
Sometimes not every attorney has the same experience
in fighting the good fight,
interpretation of the law,
facts being creative,
doing the hard work to investigate
and find the evidence that helps overturn liability.
Some attorneys probably don't wanna do the work,
they want an easy win,
but you can have great wins with some of these cases
that others have turned their backs on.
You've gotta have the resources too
and you've gotta be able to put in the work.
As we go through the show,
I would love to hear some more of your stories
about some of these incredible things
that you've turned around.
Nevis, there was one case, I think in particular,
where you had some folks
who hadn't even gotten to a doctor?
Yes, these folks came to me
having been represented by another firm
for a couple of weeks.
Already with another firm?
Yes, they were already with another firm.
They came, they asked for help.
And once I took their case,
I realized that they were very hurt
without any medical care.
Neither was employed at the time
and it was a really tough situation to be in.
Once I took over the case,
I made sure to help them navigate through the process,
get to a doctor,
get the medical care that they were desperately needing.
And after doing some investigation,
I found out that there was more to the story.
We were able to get punitive damages
on the case as well.
And in a few months,
we were able to get policy limits on both cases.
Two cases that I felt like were neglected by another firm,
but more importantly,
that didn't allow our clients to get better and recover
because they had no medical care.
Are you talking about like a really healthy judgment
for these folks that you were able to recover?
You know, we were able to get the limits on the case.
So in those two instances,
we got the maximum value that we could.
Again, you've got the feeling of the vindication.
Like I really did write by these folks,
but I just keep putting myself in the position
of somebody who's been told,
get out of here,
sorry, can't help you.
And just to know that somebody was on my side
and saw things through.
What about though,
when somebody says,
you're the one at fault,
you did something wrong.
So, you know, maybe the police are the ones who said,
hey, I did something wrong.
I'm writing a ticket for you.
That happens, huh?
Yeah, these incidents very rarely happen
in front of the officers, right?
So when they're called to the scene,
they of course bring their experience to bear,
but they may not have all the evidence, point blank.
They make a snap decision about fault
based off of what they see at that scene.
But then it's when you get into the investigation,
you start getting maybe ring doorbells from neighbors
that are around you.
And like you had said,
shoe leather, knocking on doors, right?
You start getting the 911 calls, the transcripts,
you start getting vehicle inspections.
And there's a lot of evidence that can come to light
after the officer's investigation
that can really turn around a citation or a denial.
And so certainly if you call our firm,
you're gonna speak to an attorney.
You're not gonna get an answer from an intake specialist
or a call center.
You're gonna talk with an attorney
and let them bring their experience to bear
during the free consultation.
Let them tell you what they think needs to happen
and do it soon because this evidence
that I'm talking about goes away.
My mom always taught me never take a no
from somebody who's not qualified
to give you a yes in the first place.
That's great advice.
I would just keep calling and calling.
Nevis, what do you think about the folks
who might be listening to you in this moment
who say, I just don't think I have a case?
Somebody already told me it's a long shot.
When in doubt, like Mike said, give our firm a call.
We have attorneys who are willing, ready,
and able to put the hard work to investigate the matter
if they believe there are merits to the case.
We will not just turn somebody away.
If after investigating we're not able to help these people,
we will tell them honestly and frankly why we can't.
Not every case can be won,
but we do not shy away from the difficult ones.
And if in doubt, if somebody has told you no,
still give us a call.
You might get a different answer from us.
Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran will be back
with what kind of lawyer takes these cases anyway?
This is Lawyers in the House.
Stay with us.
Welcome back to Lawyers in the House with Motlick.
I'm Veronica Waters here with Motlick Injury Attorneys
Mike Moran and Nevis Yurich,
and we're talking about long shot cases,
the ones where folks probably got told no many times
until they wound up with a lawyer
who was willing to fight for them.
What do you think is the defining characteristic
of a lawyer who takes these cases,
who doesn't shy away from these?
Willing to listen, right?
Every person's issue or injury is very specific to them.
And has its own challenges and its own unique situation.
And I think that's the biggest thing
is being able to listen, give the person the ear,
let them air out all the facts.
I don't believe we're called by people
who honestly think they're at fault.
I don't.
I think people who are seeking these consultations
and second opinions are people
who really believe in their heart of heart
they're not at fault.
And so it's worth listening to why.
Why do you feel that way?
And then it can mushroom out from there.
Mike, you were telling me about this case
where somebody was like, she's a fraud.
She's faking it.
She's lying.
Yeah, it was a really horrific case.
I had an older client,
she'll probably kill me if she heard me say that,
but she was walking home
and she walked with the assistance of a cane.
She was walking across the street with a cane
and in a crosswalk and she got hit.
And the police came out
and there was four people in the vehicle
and they literally young guys too.
And they said that she laid down her cane
and laid in the road and yelled, you hit me.
And they called her a fraud and a faker.
And the officer was maybe having a bad day.
I don't know.
And he wrote it up that way.
And it got worse for her
because then the police reports public record
and it got picked up by some of these neighborhood groups
who published it in like a next door.
It was in such and such patch.
Oh my gosh.
So they're dragging her name through the mud too.
Yeah, she was physically hurt
and then her pride took a big beating too.
And so I met with her in person, listened to her,
wanted to hear this and it seemed so improbable.
And she did go to the hospital
and they found physical injuries, evidence that she was hit,
evidence she hit the ground hard, she didn't lay down.
And I took that case
and we ended up with denials of course, right?
And so we litigated the case
and during depositions,
it got real ugly for defense counsel.
And it appeared as if maybe they did some switching
of the driver at the scene.
And perhaps there was some drinking
at a friend's housewarming party
and they left and paid her every penny
of that policy limit afterwards.
But that woman went from being physically
and mentally abused by these companies and these actors.
And we turned that around for her.
I'm really proud of that for her.
Vindication, vindication.
What goes into getting you the justice that you deserve?
Even when somebody tells you that your case is a no-go.
How to find those smoking guns,
Nevis and Mike will tell us.
This is Lawyers in the House with Motley.
Stay with us.
Imagine being shunned by law firm after law firm
because they tell you you don't have a case
or they just can't be bothered.
And then you end up with a lawyer
who is willing to go the extra mile for you.
We're talking about long shot cases today
on Lawyers in the House with Motley.
Welcome back.
I'm Veronica Waters here with Motley injury attorneys,
Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran.
And these attorneys are driven and they're dedicated
and they do not shy away from a tough fight.
But I know that this is something
that requires a lot of time, effort, creativity.
You can toot your own horn a little bit if you want to.
I mean, tell me the truth.
Well, yeah, one of the things that happens a lot
that I see is Georgia follows comparative liability.
And what that means is a lot of times
insurance companies will say,
okay, our insured's at fault,
but we're only gonna accept 70% of fault
and we're gonna assign 30% of fault to you.
And so that means that we're only gonna pay you
70% of your damages
or we'll pay to repair only 70% of the cost of your car.
So it's saying I'm 30% responsible for what happened to me.
Correct.
And it can be anything.
It could be 60-40, it can be 80-20
and they're picking numbers out of their hat
with their arguments.
And so I would just encourage people not to accept that.
If you haven't called already, if you hear that,
call us right away at 1-800-LAW-NEED.
Let us look at this and let us try to add value
back into your case that they're trying to strip
because a lot of times those will be bogus arguments
or unsupportable and there will be some facts
or evidence that can be uncovered that can turn that.
And so just don't ever accept that
because if you accept it on your car,
then arguably you're gonna accept that
on your medicals as well.
So call us right away before
maybe even they assign that to you.
Wow, I never even thought about that.
Oh yeah.
That is incredible.
I always learn so much on this show.
Seriously, I hope I never need your services really,
but my gosh, I've learned so much.
I'm still not gonna go to Google though.
I'm gonna call you up if I ever find myself in need.
Nevis, you talked about the smoking guns.
How do you find those?
In these disputed cases, we have to find the evidence
to help overturn that liability decision.
So how do we do it?
Something that I regularly do in every case
that's similar to this disputed long shot case,
I will submit an open records request.
We do those too in the news business.
To the reporting agency.
And you would not believe the wealth of resources
and evidence that you can unearth
from watching those things.
Body camera footage from the officers who came to the scene,
dash camera footage, incident reports
that sometimes tell you that somebody was arrested
after getting a citation or after they were faulted.
911 calls.
It's a plethora of resources that if you have the patience,
the willingness, you're willing to put in the hard work.
Sometimes that requires watching hours of tape,
listening to audio, and every once in a while,
and more than you can imagine,
we will find what I tell my clients is a smoking gun.
It's the defendant statement
or a statement from somebody, a witness who saw it,
or even a self-incriminating statement
from the person who we're alleging is at fault
instead of our client.
Sometimes we find things that help us win the case.
And in these disputed cases, you have to do that.
You have to put in the hard work.
You have to knock down every argument that they've made
and an excuse they've made not to pay the claim.
And that takes research and investigation and creativity,
but willingness to do it is key.
I see the fire in your eyes, right?
So you've got something in mind, tell me.
There was a case that I handled for a young man
who was a father of three, a very hardworking man
was walking to his employer in the morning time.
It was nighttime, he was wearing dark clothing.
The street that he was crossing did not have a walkway.
And a big commercial tractor trailer made a wide turn
and did not notice that he was there and struck him.
The officer who came to the scene put my client at fault.
They made every excuse under the sun
for why the tractor trailer driver could not see him.
They blamed it on the lighting.
They blamed it on the lack of pedestrian walkway.
They blamed it on the shrubbery
that was allegedly overgrown
that would not give a clear view of where he was driving.
My client was hurt, understandably.
Yeah, he got hit by a big rig?
And he called me, he was desperate, he needed help.
I met with his family, he had small children,
he couldn't go to work.
And after going to the scene,
taking pictures of the alleged overgrown shrubbery,
examining the lighting, getting open records request,
hearing other statements, and then boom, the smoking gun,
a video from a nearby business that captured the collision.
We would have never gotten to that point
had we not done our research
and investigated and pushed hard.
And it is the video from a nearby business
that captured the crash,
essentially of this tractor trailer hitting my client
is what helped overturn the liability.
But what was it about the video?
Because there was no argument
that your client got hit by the truck.
Sure, yeah.
The footage revealed that the tractor trailer
was driving pretty fast, took a very wide turn,
was in the lane of passage that he wasn't supposed to be in,
and that at the time of striking my client,
his vehicle was straight.
He had a clear, unobstructed view
that his headlights would have captured.
And it took a lot of hard work,
a lot of fighting with the firm
that was hired by the trucking company,
but they came to their senses.
And had it not been for the tape
and the images that we took of the scene
a day after it happened,
I don't know that we would have been able to win
for this man and helped him get his life back on track.
That is so frightening.
Once again, I'm just wowed
by how scary it's gotta be to be in these situations
and just feel so hopeless and helpless, like you said.
I mean, Mike, you and Nevis have both had these cases.
Both of you have such a track record with these.
What is it that drives you when you hear somebody say,
well, they said it was my fault?
They said I did it.
Unfairness and a search for the truth,
I mean, to really peel it back.
I've worked a case with Nevis
and we went to the scene during the day.
We went to the scene at night
just so we could immerse ourselves into it
and figure it out and learn about it and understand it.
And it's hard to do that
if you're only giving somebody 30 seconds in a consultation
and you'll miss inevitably an awful lot.
And so getting your hands into the case,
but ultimately it's about uncovering the truth
and making that come to light for somebody
who has been put in a bad position.
Can you tell me about that case that you two were together?
Sure, it was a pedestrian case walking in the roadway,
so not a lot of legal protections struck and killed,
unfortunately, and a grieving family in a different state.
It was a really horrific, horrific case.
And it was a driver who claimed
that she was not able to be seen.
And so we were there, I think a day or two
after it happened on the road
and the officer's paintings on the road were still there.
It was really horrific and heartbreaking.
And then we were there shortly after at night
and the ambient lighting was absolutely not
what the defendant was saying.
It was plentiful and there was other reasons
why this happened.
And so we were able to get at least answers
for a family that were in a different state.
They called you, the family from out of state called?
Yes. Who called?
Yes, the family did and we hit the ground running,
literally, and were there.
And then I think the other thing our lawyers do
is we share this information with our clients
because I think clarity for somebody
is equally as important as taking the case.
They need to be updated and understand what's happening
and what we're seeing.
And I think our firm does a very good job of that.
We mail them copies.
Our clients get copies of everything we do.
And they have an individual attorney.
In this case, it was a team of attorneys working for them.
And we pride ourselves on giving them
really regular updates.
So clarity during these moments of pain,
I think, is really essential too.
The willingness, as Neva said, to spend those hours
because I know this doesn't take, listen,
I know how it takes time to wait
for an open records request
and then depending on what you get,
it takes a long time to comb through all of that stuff.
Body cam footage, that could be very long minutes
of not much happening that you are still doing.
And I'm glad you said that.
Sometimes we have to go back to the reporting agency
two, three, four, five times.
We have to get the court involved
because sometimes they don't wanna release the records.
But we don't stop trying.
If we believe the client and that the case has merit
and that the law and fact can support a win, we don't stop.
We push until we get to the truth, like Mike said.
And typically that means a win for our clients.
But yeah, not giving up, just putting the fight
is super important and we don't shy away from that.
Tell me about a case that sticks with you
maybe that had to do with one of these,
something that somebody said, a witness, a police officer,
anybody that, somebody who wasn't directly involved
Recently, I had a case where two parties,
including my client, were both faulted equally
by the reporting agency that came to the scene.
A lot of dispute is a failure to yield while turning left.
Is this like a merge or something?
One party's going straight,
the other one is trying to take a left in front of them
and typically it results in a T-bone collision.
So they're usually demolished vehicles.
In my situation, my client had a head injury.
He also sustained a very serious injury of the leg
that necessitated emergency surgery.
He had lost his job.
He was disabled from work.
His life was in shambles when I spoke with him and his wife.
The officer said, you know, they're both at fault.
We can't get to the bottom of the truth
because both clients sustained head trauma.
They weren't able to really articulate what happened.
Their memory was vague of the event,
which is not uncommon
when you lose consciousness temporarily.
So neither one of them could really say what happened.
Exactly.
So the officer said, we'll let the insurance company decide.
Of course, the insurance company decided against my client
and he was looking to get nothing, you know,
and he had bills in the tens of thousands
and he was disabled partially.
We did an open records request.
I sifted through hours of footage, audio,
and just when I thought I can't win this case,
I was able to find a statement
from the other driver's family member
who had called in 911 and explained
and gave some information that allowed us
to point the finger at him and say he was at fault
for those reasons.
I can't disclose, but it was the family member
who we believe to be that fault driver
that helped us win the case.
And we would have never found that
had I not pushed for the open records request,
had I not listened to those tapes.
And there was the smoking gun.
The smoking gun.
Dedication and perseverance.
The name of the game.
Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran.
I'm Veronica Waters.
Just ahead, Motlick's closing argument.
Don't miss it.
Welcome back to Lawyers in the House with Motlick.
I'm your host, Veronica Waters.
You've been waiting for this all hour long.
We're talking about long shot cases
and it's time for Motlick's closing argument.
Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran, the floor is yours.
So the four reasons why you should call
Motlick & Associates in case another firm
has already denied your claim
or an insurance company has denied liability on your claim.
Number one, you will talk with an attorney.
You will speak with a lawyer
and you will get a full consult from them for free
and they will listen.
And that's, we've talked earlier
about hearing the fact pattern.
Let them hear what you have to say
and bring forward what your thoughts are.
If you've been hurt by somebody
and you may be getting blamed
and you honestly believe that's incorrect, call us.
Speak to an attorney, not to someone else,
not to any other person at the firm.
You'll speak with an attorney when you call us.
Number two, keep in mind that insurance companies
will do whatever they can to pay as little as they can
or outright deny your case and that's just their MO.
So you can expect that.
You're not special, they're doing that to everyone.
And so call us and ask us about that
and let us talk to you about it.
Number three, there could be additional avenues of recovery
that the other firm never gave you as an option.
And lastly, like Mike said, we will listen to your story.
We will try to help you, but if for some reason we cannot,
we will do our very best to be as frank and honest
and walk you through the reasons why we cannot help.
We might even be able to give you some options
on how to proceed on your own.
But you will never know until you call us
and it definitely is worth a shot.
When in doubt, call us and we'll do what we can to help.
And what's it like when you have those conversations
with somebody that you did have to tell no?
You know, sometimes people actually have thanked me.
They have told me that because I took the time and care
to explain why we couldn't take on a matter,
it gave them a peace of mind and they felt at ease
that there was a true reason why somebody couldn't
take on a case and not just some excuse
that they were given to get them off the phone
as quickly as possible.
I have talked to several Montlake injury attorneys by now
who tell me that they spend a lot of time
on the phone with folks, even when they don't take the cases
because it's important to let them know the why
behind the we can't and how gratifying must it be
to just finally feel heard.
Never give up the fight.
I think that's our lesson learned today
on Lawyers in the House with Nevis Yurich and Mike Moran.
Thank you so much for being back with me.
Two of my faves.
I can't wait until you guys come back again.
Thank you.
You missed some great nuggets if you're joining us late.
So make sure that you follow us on social at Montlake Law.
You can always drop us a line any time of the day or night
at lawyersinthehouse.com and subscribe to our podcast
on your favorite podcast platform,
because we are there.
Lawyers in the House will be back with you next week.
I'm Veronica Waters.
Thanks for joining us.

