This ultimate guide to choosing climbing shoes 2023 is designed to help you on your way to choosing the best pair of climbing shoes for you. In collaboration with James at @OutsideHathersage , this guide covers everything you need to know before buying your first pair, some tips to help you understand what the best brand and model might be for you and answers a couple of frequently asked questions. I hope you find this guide helpful when looking for your beginner climbing shoes or upgrading!
☞www.outside.co.uk
00:01: How to Pick the Right Climbing Shoes for you 00:55: Fit: How Should Climbing Shoes Fit? 02:10 Shape: What shape of climbing shoe is best | Symmetrical vs Asymmetrical climbing shoes | Do I need a downturned climbing shoe? 03:27: Last: What does Last mean in climbing shoes? 06:31: Climbing shoe materials: Leather Vs Synthetic Uppers | Will my climbing shoes stretch? 08:03: Which Climbing Shoe Rubber is best? Different Rock Types demand a different type of shoe 09:32: Scarpa Instinct Vs Scarpa Instinct VS Comparison 10:27: Low Volume vs High Volume Climbing Shoes 13:05: Climbing Shoe Closure Types | Slipper vs Velcro vs Lace Up Climbing Shoes 14:43: Trying Climbing Shoes | Upgrading your climbing shoes 15:12: 5:10 Anasazis 15:56: Can you get performance from a flat climbing shoe? Tenaya Iati and Tenaya Mastia 17:00: La Sportiva Skwama VS La Sportiva Solutions 19:26: The best all-round bouldering shoe? 21:30 Pay attention to climbing shoe sizing between brands!
This video is sponsored by Squarespace. If you're confused about climbing shoes then
this video will clear a few things up. This ultimate guide to climbing shoes covers everything
you need to know about choosing a climbing shoe, including how your shoe should fit,
which shoes are best for different styles of climbing, and how to know when it's time to
upgrade. Today we are at Outside in Heatherfordge and I'm here with James, who is the owner of
Outside, who's going to be talking us through how to pick the right climbing shoe for you.
So I feel like the climbing shoe market can be fairly confusing, it's a complicated world out
there. Very much so. So today we're going to help you do a bit of jargon busting on kind of
climbing shoe characteristics, the things you might want to be looking out for if you're buying
your first pair of climbing shoes, or perhaps you own a pair of climbing shoes but you're hoping to
upgrade them to something that's kind of better suited to you and what you need personally from
I know there's generally maybe a bit of a myth that climbing shoes are supposed to be like
super super tight, would you agree or not? That's the thing I probably hate the most,
people come in and go oh no I've heard they're meant to be tight, my dad tells me you get them
10 sizes too small and you watch them cramming in. Not at all, you're trying to enjoy climbing,
you want to like it. You get a pair of shoes and your feet are not used to it and they're
really tight, you're gonna hate climbing, this is awful. So the best thing to do is get a pair that
is snug, they need to be snug because if you're not hitting the end you might as well be in your
training skis just flop off the end of the hole, but not painful. You need to be able to put it on,
realise you're filling all the voids of a shoe without crushing anywhere, you don't want the
hot spots. The toe box needs to be fitted and you'll often see they're quite, some are really
deep in the toe box and that's quite an obvious example that they've been built to fit tight,
that's why you don't want to get a shoe like that because if there's what you call a love bump where
obviously a knuckle should be up in it, that's because they expect your toe to be sort of like
slightly knuckled. If you put your foot in there flat there's going to be dead space above it,
so you'll be flopping around, you might roll off footholds. If you have a much flatter or lower
profile, there's some that are flatter than this, you can fill the whole void while still having
your toes flat which is often comfier for longer. Something that crops up a lot when you kind of
like beginner climbing shoe articles is symmetrical versus asymmetrical and shape,
but it's not immediately obvious sometimes what that actually means. So I guess we all sort of
know what symmetrical means because they'd be identical shoes, there wouldn't even be a left
and a right, so what in reality that ends up meaning is that it's a lot more, the toe at least,
is a lot more centralised, so if you came in and said I've got a much longer second toe,
you'd pretty much need an asymmetrical boot because your toe would be sticking out longer
than that one, if that makes sense. You might just find how it feels as well because I mean
a well-known designer of these shoes actually said to me recently people worry too much about
whether it fits their foot, you need to work out whether it works for you, so you might like your
toes being knuckled like that, other people might like them flat or just curled. It's really hard
to know but yeah certainly when you're getting your first shoe don't knuckle them, don't probably
get one that's so downturned like that, but also don't be afraid of getting a shoe that you might
think oh I don't climb hard enough to have that, we all need the same level of help and if you get
a technical shoe that is comfy there's no real problem with that. So another word that crops up
quite a lot when I've been researching climbing shoes is last, so do you think you could describe,
well explain what that means because I don't think I'm 100% sure. Well I wish they wouldn't
use that word as well, it's funny isn't it because basically it is fit, so you could have a shoe with
the same last and the fit is the same but it might have a totally different rubber on it or a different
heel on it or different sort of maybe even different tension in it, but the actual shape because you
know when they sort of make these things out of wood, you know the shape of a foot essentially
to mould the shoe around, that would be the last. So if a factory making these shoes
lost a last, they basically lost that wooden bit of material that they were actually moulding
this rubber around to make it fit. So if you know oh I'm a katana last or whatever you could
have the velcro and the lace-up and they would fit, the last, the shape would be the same,
but they perform very differently from the soft flat velcro to a really stiff downturn aggressive
lace-up shoe. I think heel is often just thought of as oh a heel hook, I need a good heel,
but the heel is so important for how the rest of the shoe performs. So if you're looking at your
first shoe, what you'll find is you probably want to have a look at one with a quite straight heel
at the back. The reason being you could have, so this shoe is very comfortable because your heel's
up, but it's actually got quite a technical toe. If this heel was pushed and cambered sort of in
further, it would only not just sort of make the heel feel more secure for heel hooking, what it
does is it pushes you into the toe, so that makes you stand on a small edge much better because
you're getting forced forward. Sure. So often, you know, with the Scarper Instincts they say
like everyone thinks the low volume has a lower forefoot, it doesn't, it's got a scooped heel
to make you fit further forward in your shoe. Right, okay. So yeah, that can be hugely different
to that in terms of the scoop, but it's not just for heel hooking, it's also pushing you forward
to the front of the shoe. So for a beginner option you'd probably tend towards or recommend
going for something straight at the back? Yeah, straight to right, yeah. Okay. Certainly if anything
more than that feels uncomfortable. Before we get into the rest of the shoe guide, I wanted to have
a quick word from the sponsor of this video which is Squarespace. I have been working with Squarespace
for the past year and a bit, but I've been using their services for a lot longer. So Nathan and I
recently launched our merch business, we sell t-shirts and stickers over on hannamorrisfoldering.com
and Squarespace has honestly just made the whole experience of setting up a shop and dipping our
toes into the world of commerce really easy. One thing that I really love about Squarespace is how
customisable the checkout process is. So we can add a custom checkout form, we can add a subscribe
option to your newsletter, we can also use Squarespace to market our products. So we can use
their inbuilt marketing tools to offer sales and promotions, we can connect our social media
platforms. If that sounds like something that you would be interested in then head to squarespace.com
forward slash hannamorris and when you're ready to launch use the unique code hannamorris for 10%
What kind of different materials have we got going on with climbing shoes? What's the difference
between different uppers? Okay so the main two out there really, I can't really think of any
others, are synthetic or leather and so everything sort of gets really held up on it. Leather is
very traditional of course, that's why they're using boots and things because they're walking
boots because it goes soft and pliable and molds to your foot, but also it's known to stretch quite
a lot and also you know there's some ethical thoughts going into whether you want leather or
not as well. Whereas synthetic, I mean certainly a lot of the new synthetics like Loric and things
like that, that Scarf use a lot, can be really comfortable and sort of feel like leather and
perform like leather but without maybe that extra give so you can sort of rely on the
boot keeping its shape better. Now I definitely, we're talking about this for a minute, definitely
don't agree that you, leather stretch and synthetics don't. Okay. All stretch, all of them stretch
and leather maybe a bit more but not like, I don't think it's as big as everyone thinks.
I remember well it's inside a 510 box and they used to say these shoes won't stretch and I was
like yeah they stretch massively, you know, so you do need to, you'll find out basically when you're
further on in your career of climbing, you know, your first pair might stretch too much, it's not
a big deal, don't worry, you're just getting into it, you'll learn what works and what doesn't.
And also, yeah, think about how tight you're fitting, you get a really tight fitting shoe,
you're going to stretch it a lot more than one that's loose, you've got no pressure on the front,
it's not going to stretch is it, get them really snug, you're going to push them and they'll stretch more.
Am I right in thinking that some types of rubber are better for different types of climbing?
Absolutely, yeah. So everyone wants, the dream shoe would be, wouldn't it, the stickiest thing
in the world that never wears out. Super glue shoe. So the manufacturers have this constant problem between
how sticky shall I make it versus how durable shall I make it. Right. So I thought it was
really interesting, a video I did before, if you haven't watched it you should, on rental shoe versus
your pro shoes. Now we have already discussed that you had a very good rental shoe with really good
rubber on it, so that makes quite a big difference. But yeah, some rental shoes will use very durable
hard rubber. Now hard rubber is not sticky but it lasts a long time, so your foot will be scrabbling on
things and thinking, oh I can't climb this. Put a good shoe on with good rubber and suddenly you stick to it
and you're climbing. Oh wow, it does make a big difference. There's also this point that the rock
or what you're climbing on matters, so gritstone or indoor bouldering and volumes and blobs and
smooths. You really want your shoe to stick to it the best you can and if it softens because of that
then that's usually okay, whereas particularly say peat limestone, tiny little edges on vertical
walls, you want a particular edging power. Even if it was slippery it probably wouldn't matter
loads, but you want it to stick and keep its structure. So the particular obvious one is the
Scarper Instinct now, probably one of our best-selling shoes and certainly about my favourite shoe ever.
A lot. Yeah, so everyone seems to love these, good fit. Now they look identical, the last which
you already know about is the same, but the rubber is different. So you use excess edge on the orange one
and excess grip on the blue one and basically that means, out of the box it might feel the same, but
this might be stickier, but it's not really why they've done it. It ends up being softer because it
actually is more pliable and sort of will fill those voids in the volumes better, whereas again
the peat limestone or whatever, you might want it to hold its edge a bit more and stay stiffer and
but then if you put a brand new pair of these and went indoor bowling, you might find it quite
clumpy. You might not get the sort of feedback and sort of forgiveness you need against a volume or
a gritstone smear or something. When I've been looking online, you kind of have what appear to
be the same shoe except one is the low volume option. Is that what we've got going on here?
No, actually the volume of these are the same. So the volume of the shoe
is often to do with people think, oh I've got a wide foot, they want a high volume shoe,
whereas width is usually that and volume is depth or like the whole total of your mass,
if you will, of your foot. So if you've got a bit, it might not be wide, but a really deep foot and
it fills a big void, you need a high volume. You could have a long thin foot and you've got low
volume. So usually low volume means you take less out of the top of the boot, skim less off it.
Like I was explaining with this one actually, the volume of the front is quite similar,
they've just scooped the heel a bit more so you sit a bit forward in the boot to take more volume
out. They reckon there's like a weight cut off, so when you use a softer rubber, if you're, say,
much lighter weight yourself, then you would find these maybe too clumpy and you'd not get any
feedback and just feel like bricks against the wall. But when you go sort of above 70, 80
sort of kilograms, that I'm well into, I can sort of squish these too quickly for myself
and I need to get a bit more support and sort of hold me on the edge of it better.
If you're newer to the sport, I think it'd be fair to say that maybe your footwork might be
a little heavier. So I guess you might want your first pair of shoes,
especially if you're just starting out and you're not sure if you're kind of like in it
for the long haul. Shoes are expensive, yeah, so is there a kind of a good durable option, I suppose,
or like advice that you would give for finding that balance of something that works for you
but that's also going to kind of last longer? Yeah, that is hard to get right because like
we said before, you could make a climbing shoe with a metal sole that would last forever,
great, but you couldn't climb a thing. So there is sort of, it's tricky to get it just right and
especially you don't want to get your first shoe, buy one of those rental ones we talked about where
it doesn't stick to anything, so you just think you're rubbish when you're not. You do want to
get something that's fairly durable, I wouldn't go straight in for super sticky, super downturned,
thin, so you're just trashing, especially when around here when you end up like not placing
foot as well, you might drag it up a wall, especially in the walls it can wreck. The toe
before here, if you're climbing well you wear your foot out there, if you're dragging it up
you end up wearing it out there. Means Nathan behind the camera is climbing very badly.
And something else that you might see fairly often referred to as different types of closures,
so could you briefly kind of go over what different types of closure are on the market?
Well I guess there's mainly three, I've only got two here, the other one's pretty obvious,
so there's slipper that has nothing, as you can see just put it on like a slipper,
velcro and lace-up. Now they all offer certain advantages, slipper is usually really popular
for people like they're plodding around and sort of warming up or training, they're not too worried
about pulling on their heel, they're just often comfy shoes, so people like them for that sort
of thing. And then you've got velcro which is obviously really quick, if you want to take your
shoes on and off all the time that have the best performance you can, then often people go for
velcro, so it holds you in place, you don't get any movement, heel stays put but it's quick to do.
The only downside is if you are really low volume or really skinny feet,
then sometimes you just can't crank the boot up enough or have enough adjustability I would say.
And then you can go to lace-up where you can adjust every little area, you can have it super
tight at the front and loose at the top and sometimes you can even do it the other way
around but it does find that it holds your foot even more securely. I think the other thing to
what you're doing with it, you know, if I was bouldering I would probably try and usually have
a velcro shoe because I'm probably going to take it on and off a lot, I'll try a problem, fall off,
take them off because they're not that comfy, they're not too tight but they're not that comfy,
whereas once you've got a lace-up on you're generally in it for quite a long time especially
if it's got a lot of lacing on it and you're going to do a multi-pitch, you want to be in it all day
so get it just right and leave it on. So I suppose now we should get to trying some shoes on and
covering some kind of practical examples of shoes that we might be looking at for that kind of like
entry level or um or next, oh yeah I guess kind of like upgrading your shoe from your
your first couple of pairs. So we're going to quickly go through a couple of questions that
we had on the previous rental shoe video specifically about shoes that people wanted
to ask you, one of them being they're doing v3s and they're 510 Anasazi, at what point should
they change up their shoe level? I think the main thing that's obvious from that is like you
don't get held up on a grade so like you know you don't need to change because you're going from v3
to whatever, you need to get to the point where my shoe is the thing holding me back, if your heel's
pinging off every time you're trying a problem then maybe the heel isn't right for you etc.
If they've worn those shoes out and they're ready for a new pair then definitely give it some real
thought, what what wasn't working for me is it because they're too flat that last, if you are
mainly indoor bouldering the steep stuff Anasazi is a very flat shoe you might want to get into
that more clawing type shoe to pull you in on the overhangs and that's quite a simple thing.
This person has really flat feet and he's experienced that for him really highly downturned
shoes are really really painful, can you get performance from something flatter? Yes you can,
look at some of the more maybe soft and sensitive downturned ones, I don't know if you want to see
some examples but I really like Tenaya for that reason so things like Ayati, Mastir, they always
show you on the internet when you're looking at them this, it looks super downturned so like
photoshopped in it looks like it's stood on a pin or something like that but in reality when you
put that flat I mean it's pretty flat yeah it might be a bit scooped in the arch as long as
that's not too much for this person then it's not a claw that holds its shape like a total banana
and these are actually some of the shoes that I found incredibly comfy
yeah I climb well in them that's sort of perfect for me they might be a bit soft for
a big guy like me on the big on the edges but indoors you'll often find me in them or
on the grit or whatever because they are one of those shoes I was talking about earlier that if
this ends up being your second shoe it might be Magos' shoe for climbing 9b but it's also
comfy it can be your second shoe easily you can do some bs's or whatever at Standage. They've been
climbing for about a year now and they're looking for a more aggressive shoe their first option
would be the Squama model and could we explain why opt for that shoe possibly over other models
like the Solutions? Okay so I would say firstly be careful you've been climbing a year I mean
unless you've got really good really quickly which you might and your feet be quite immune to this
sort of pain both of these are fairly aggressive shoes like we talked about some that might forgive
a bit more because of the softness they're quite structured quite solid I mean I suppose people
make beautiful shoes but the whole point is that this doesn't forgive that much it holds its shape
so do you just think about whether you want to go this far or whether you want to consider something
like the Kubu which I'll show you in a minute which is a great void filler um but yes the
difference between these two is not huge but it is quite significant so you know we talked about last
yeah so for years everyone's thought La Sportiva is quite a skinny fit shoe so it's quite slim
on on here and also it's way more symmetrical you'll see the point is very much second toe
yeah so often that feels like you get sort of power point a really good edging um whereas when
they brought out Squama it's quite a lot broader okay um and for the UK that's actually really
significant thing we've sort of got wide forefoot and skinny heels in Britain quite a lot
and also with the the strap it means you haven't you can't take any of the excess volume there as
you can with this one so again I'd say a slimmer foot and a bit broader and also this definitely
feels a bit stiffer because it tensioned more on a slightly thicker sole definitely feels more edgy
this is definitely better for the paste and the smears okay and both of the heels are fairly
solid heels so definitely worth mentioning while we're talking about this the new one to the
seen the solution comp which then talking the difference between those two so we've got the
shape yeah so much more symmetrical but softer all around so more forgiving more paste and a
slightly less aggressive heel so it's not shooting it's the front of the boot as much it's not as
insensitive and solid yeah softer and more forgiving and again there's no right or wrong
some people love this heel some people hated it I'm not really sure what I want I just want to
save some money all right and so I want a good all-rounder okay something that has kind of like
a good combination of everything yep um so when you say an all-rounder are you an all-around
boulderer or an all-around climber I'm an all-round boulderer okay yeah I just started climbing at my
local bouldering wall yeah and I've been getting on okay with their rental shoes yeah but I want
a pair of my own to save on rental costs and I just want something that's like
yeah a good all-round indoor bouldering shoe if you were to describe that to me I would absolutely
things like that um possibly even things like these uprises as well which are really popular
because even though they're not as downturned because of the tacky rubber and the feel on them
great for toe hocking they are a really good indoor outdoor all-rounder really okay depending
on how tight you fit them whether they're going to be painful or not like we say don't get too
painful it's not worth it no yeah okay can I try some yes please okay and what size would you think
okay or 37 yeah I guess so I brought out some of the ones we were talking about that I think would
hopefully be quite a good all-rounder for someone of your sort of weight and size as well because
softer shoes I think will work better for what you've discussed yeah so I think something like
the iati here would be sorry this is the oasi the stiff one's called iati okay um in a size four
yeah it feels like it feels snug yep definitely not painful cool I can feel that my
you're still feeling knuckles are quite like bunched up here okay yeah it's definitely
not sometimes you put on a pair of or I put on a pair of shoes and it's like
I want to take those off straight away whereas
yeah that's it feels like a good fit I'd say yeah it's often worth feeling how
you know you can see how much volume is left here so you probably could go a bit smaller to get rid
of this yeah but it matters or not is uh depending on how you're feeling and it's also worth having
a paste on the sort of grip tape there to see how much rubber you can get against it as well
and a lot of people just hit all around the side to see whether it's staying in place and give it
a good pull so I thought it'd be interesting to try these and I'll tell you why I think it's
okay that feels tighter it feels tighter okay but less snug if that makes any sense like it
feels more rigid yep and tighter like in here a little bit maybe more painful right but not
necessarily a better tight fit yeah so what I thought was really interesting to see how you
feel with that was this pair you put on you said oh that feels good I could maybe even go a bit
smaller because you know it wasn't too painful that's a uk4 and that's uk6 it's two sizes bigger
than this okay you're saying that's more painful yeah so this is how I you can't just go I'm a 4
I'll wear a load of shoes online and try them on because you would have such a huge range of size
I mean colossally different yeah I would just can't do that you need to know and those would be
like you wouldn't get it on very painful yeah yeah so I think that about rounds up everything
nearly everything the comprehensive guide to picking your first shoe as a beginner I hope you
found it informative and I hope that it helped to clear up a few questions that you might have
had about picking the right shoe for you thank you very much to James for his time this evening
here's a font of climbing shoe knowledge it turns out I will leave all of the links to the individual
shoes that we talked about that are stocked by outside in the description of this video so you
can click through and have more of a look at the individual shoes if any of them took your fancy
but beyond that yeah I hope that answered a few of your questions and we will see you
in my next one bye