#Business "Buyer demand continues to be soft, in spite of falling interest rates, and many sellers are biding their time until the market recovers. When should we expect transactions volume to pick back up?
Watch the replay of our October 10th with Altos President Mike Simonsen, who'll share all the latest data on the fast-changing housing market. He’ll touch on what’s happening with mortgage rates, discuss which signals he's watching for market momentum, and look at other leading indicators that tell us what to expect for the rest of the year. He'll also dive into the latest data for local markets across the country.
Topics will include:
What to expect with home prices in Q4 An update on inventory, and where this is likely headed Which leading indicators to watch for the rest of the year How mortgage rates are impacting demand How to talk to buyers and sellers about the data right now … and more."
Well, good morning, everybody.
It is now October, we're in the fourth quarter,
and it is quite an eventful market happening here.
So we're gonna, as people are dialing in,
I'll go through the basics first,
which is we like to use the chat for questions
and conversation along the way.
Jeff and Lael from the Altos team are in the chat
so that you can, they can try to answer questions
on the fly, I'm not able to monitor the questions
as I'm talking today, but as always,
you can, we like to hear where you're connecting in from
and we get hundreds of people on these calls,
so it's really great to see all over the country.
The webinar is recorded and you will get a,
you will get an email later today
when the recording is up and available
for all the registered attendees.
So we will, so let's just start rolling in.
It is now October 10th.
You know, the big question on everybody's mind
in the last few weeks has been,
are we finally going to get some home sales?
Is it finally gonna pick up the dramatically slow pace
of the last two years?
As mortgage rates fell, particularly in September,
did that, was that enough to motivate sellers?
What could we see in the data?
So we're gonna focus on some of that today.
I've actually got some hurricane market content
and see what we can see there.
We're also going to talk about the local markets,
the inventory, the pricing, all of those things.
Before I dive into the data,
we have, if you are new to Altos
and you haven't already downloaded a free ebook,
How to Use Market Data to Build Your Business,
I recommend doing so now.
There will be a, Lael and Jeff will drop the link
in the chat for you to click through and go download that.
It really helps you talk about the data
in the way I'm talking about it today,
help you understand it includes things like scripts
and scenarios and really like what are the data points
to communicate?
How do we do it?
What are the best ways and how to use it in the business?
So get that free ebook and it'll help you work along
with me while I'm doing these webinars.
So are home sales finally recovering?
If so, how much are they gonna recover?
But also then, we've had inventory climbing all year
across the country.
Is that gonna keep happening?
Where are home prices gonna finish the year?
What visibility do we have for home prices?
And then we have some really impactful local market stuff.
This week we have the two hurricanes
and we can see some of those
and I've got some local market data for those areas.
We have the big bifurcation that we've had
with the Midwest and Northeast with low inventory
and the Sunbelt with climbing inventory for the year
and we're gonna investigate whether that's holding up
and what's next for the different local markets.
So that's the agenda for today.
Let's dive in.
So let's start with home sales.
There are 61,000 new single family homes sales pending
this week, new pendings.
And for two weeks in a row, that's higher, more sales
than the last two years in that middle
or the second week of September, of October.
All year long, sales have been maybe a little above
last year, maybe a little below last year,
but definitely below 2022.
In 2022, when rates rose the first half of the year,
people were trying to get the deal done.
More sales were happening.
You could see 70, 80, 90,000 single family home sales
happening per week in the first half of 22.
But then in July, there's a big dip right in the middle
of the chart, July 4th week, and home sales didn't recover.
They fell again in September and October of 22
because that was a moment when mortgage rates
went from the sixes to seven and a half.
There was a surprise jump at that time late in the year
and you can see really clearly what happened
to home sales at that time.
The home sales backed off in October of 22
and they haven't recovered until maybe right now.
So we've had two weeks of the dark line here
is this year's curve.
Two weeks where we've had more sales
than the previous two years.
In October of the previous two years, rates were climbing
and up till last week, mortgage rates have been falling
pretty notably.
We got around closer to 6%.
But then suddenly last week,
we had really strong jobs numbers.
So employment numbers came in strong.
That kind of spooked the bond market.
Mortgage yields went up on the 10-year
and drove mortgage interest rates up from like 6.1
to 6.2 all the way to 6.5 or 6.6% this week.
So we've had a spike in mortgage rates
and it's going to be really interesting
to see how that carries.
So some of the data we're showing right now,
like these sales, is showing the momentum
for mortgage rates getting closer to 6%.
But some of the data we can show what happens
when suddenly rates are back at 6.6 or maybe even 6.7
because they're on their way up again today.
So the good news is we finally see some loosening up.
And for perspective on mortgage rates,
what I've got here is the distribution
of mortgage rates over the last 12 years.
And each dot in here is the average
30-year fixed rate for a week.
You can see most of the last decade
is in that left turn bubble,
that 2.5, 3, 3.5 to 4.5 to 5%,
that big bubble, most of the last decade.
The last few years have been in the rightmost bubble,
6, 7, 8%.
And in fact, most of this year
was in the fat part of the rightmost bubble.
We're around 7%, upper sixes, lower sevens.
And when we were in that phase,
the question I had was, as rates fell to 6.5,
would that be enough to motivate homebuyers?
And what we noticed is rates peaked in May at 8%,
and then they eased down to seven,
and then they eased down to 6.5.
And at 6.5%, we still could really not see
much motion for homebuyers.
But then a couple of weeks ago,
rates fell further and we started getting close to 6%.
And then suddenly we could see upticks in home sales.
We could see, like I said, we had two weeks in a row
with greater home sales than the last two years.
And so you can really see these bubbles.
Once we got to the left side of that rightmost bubble,
close to 6%, we could finally start to see
some sales moving.
But then what happened?
Well, like I say, I've said on these webinars often,
I don't have an ability to predict mortgage rates.
I've been wrong on mortgage rates for 30 years.
Rates can go up, they can go down.
It felt like they were peaked and heading back down,
but we had a very strong spike.
It just takes a little strong economic data
and the bond market says,
wow, the economy is stronger than we thought,
and therefore rates start going up again.
So in the last week,
rates have now bumped back over 6.5%.
And so the question is,
what do we see in home sales like next week,
in the next two weeks?
How quickly does it put a damper on buyers?
We've been pretty lucky,
or is this a temporary jump in rates?
Does it ease back down closer to 6%?
The inflation numbers that came in today were nice and low,
so maybe that's encouraging.
Those are the variables,
and there's all kinds of other variables.
There's weather variables and there's war variables.
Those kind of things that are not predictable in rates,
and so we don't know where they're gonna go.
But what we can do is say,
what's gonna happen if rates move back towards 6%?
And I think we can see loosening in the purchase market
as we get closer to 6%.
But now at 6.5%, I'm not so sure.
We can see this, so I started with the Altos,
new pendings per week,
so the new contracts, homes that are listed,
they take offers and then they go into the contract process.
That was where we started.
That was up, it's been up for six weeks in a row,
and it was up over the last two years.
This is looking at the MBA's purchase mortgage applications.
And for the first time all year,
we had more purchase applications than last year,
in the last two weeks.
So, and we've had six up weeks,
and in fact this week just came out,
and it ticked down just a hair for the week,
but is still up over last year.
And you can see, these are, each line here is a year.
You can see the 22 line,
big drop in mortgage purchase applications
at the same time the Altos pendings data dropped.
You can see drops last year in purchase applications.
They were already low, they kept going lower,
because in September, October, November last year,
rates went all the way up to 8%.
And so you can really see the,
you can see it in both of these numbers,
both of the MBA's numbers and the real time numbers
from in the Altos data, in the Altos pendings data.
And so, the question is, how quickly does six and a half
or 6.6, does that slow this back down?
And I don't know, because we don't yet know,
is it only two weeks of a jump,
or does it climb all the way to the end of November
like it did in 22 and 23?
Those are things to keep our eyes on.
The good news is that we could see some loosening
of, and some improvement, some year over year improvement.
It's not a lot of home sales, but it's improvement.
And that's, I think, a positive view for us.
However, if we look at payments,
so what we're doing here is the median price
of the new pendings, the sales price,
the price people are paying for homes,
at the current mortgage rate.
And we can see the dark line for this year,
peaked in May with mortgage rates.
Prices have held pretty well,
but mortgage rates have generally declined
all the way into September.
And then we had a sharp spike in rates.
So we've had a 7% mortgage payment jump this week.
And I think that may be enough to make
a bunch of potential buyers put the brakes on
and say, I'm gonna wait to see, wait a few weeks.
I'm gonna wait maybe till the spring.
But that's really how you can see the payments came down
almost less than in 22, but then they rebounded again.
So we're in this really fragile zone.
We can see recovery, but we can also see,
we can see exactly what happened in the last two years
when rates spiked again.
And so we're now in a little bit of a short rate spike.
And so we can, you can see how fragile
any recovery might be.
All right, let's switch over to inventory.
There are now 734,000 single-family homes
unsold on the market across the country.
That's 36% more than last year at this time.
And last year at this time, and in 22, in fact,
inventory was rising pretty quickly
in October and into November.
Inventory didn't peak until the end of November.
This year, I think we have another two or three weeks
of rising inventory through the end of October.
But inventory rose only about 4 1⁄10 of a percent
this week, so it's like flattening out.
Unless, of course, the rate spike really forces people
to, buyers to wait, and then more homes build up.
We have, at the same time, we have the hurricane impact.
So a lot of Central Florida, Western Florida,
we have some of those counties in Georgia
and North Carolina, which I'll get to in a few minutes.
Those are, you know, people are not,
you're not listing your house for sale in Tampa right now.
And so that will keep a cap on, you know,
a few hundred or a few thousand listings
that will also keep inventory from climbing.
There's some really fascinating impacts
to what happens in those markets.
Of course, you know, our hearts go out
to everybody impacted in those markets.
It's crazy.
We did a check from the Housing Wire team this morning
and the people in Central Florida.
We got a bunch of thumbs up, a long night
as Milton went across the state,
but I was happy to hear that we were,
everybody was intact.
And so I hope for your families and friends
that that is also true.
As we're watching inventory, you know,
the next step is to also always watch
the new listings pace.
So there were 61,000 new listings this week
unsold across the country.
You can see just barely more than last year,
4% more than last year.
You can also see that it is fewer
than the gray lines of the past year.
So we still have fewer sellers each week
than we did any of the previous years,
except for the last two.
The thing we're watching for in new listings,
if mortgage rates fall, let's say they fall back to six,
we can start to see some activity.
Some of the people who are on the fence,
maybe they were on the fence as sellers
who are waiting because they are locked
into their nice cheap mortgage rate,
but they really wanna upsize or downsize
and they've just been waiting.
So let's say 6% shakes some of those free,
like it did in the last couple of weeks.
The question is, and the fear that a lot
of potential buyers and sellers have right now,
the fear is that while when rates finally fall,
there's a bunch of pent up supply
that sellers that are gonna list their homes
and it's gonna flood the market,
and then we're gonna get things out of whack.
We're gonna have more sellers than buyers
and we're gonna have, therefore,
that would create supply demand imbalance
and downward pressure on home prices.
So there are buyers who are waiting,
who are saying, I'm just gonna wait on the sidelines
until prices crash.
And they've been, of course, saying that for years,
but now the thing they're watching for is
if rates fall, does that shake loose too much supply?
So what we do is we watch the new listings volume.
And if that's going to happen,
the first thing we're gonna see
is that new listings volumes start climbing
and it's gotta climb above these gray lines.
It's gotta be more sellers than normal.
And of course, what we see right now
is fewer sellers than normal.
So we don't see in the data any evidence
of too many sellers happening.
It's a valid thing to track
and it's a valid thing to discuss
with potential buyers and sellers
who are waiting, who are afraid.
And the right way to do it is to say,
look, the market cooled down,
there are more homes on the market,
but we can see that there's not a flood of sellers.
Any seller who doesn't get the price they want,
those folks have their cheap mortgage,
they don't have to sell.
A number of them, a lot of them don't have to sell,
so they don't have the house on the market,
they withdraw, they don't list.
And as a result, that keeps a cap on inventory,
it keeps a cap on the supply,
and it doesn't allow that scary price scenario
to materialize.
So what I'm watching for in the new listings each week
is I'm interested in getting us back
to normal levels of new listings,
getting the 2025 line into those higher grades,
because more sellers means more sales can happen,
more sellers means more buyers.
So I'm interested in a continued increase in sellers,
and I think we will get another increase in sellers.
Like we've had, the dark line is greater
than the light red line this year, all year.
I think next year we'll have another little lift there,
and that will be healthier for the market.
So generally, slowly getting more healthy.
But I'm also on the lookout for, is there a surge?
And if there's a surge,
then we wanna start looking at any imbalanced potential.
But as of right now, there's no evidence
anywhere in the data of any kind of imbalance
in the total sellers.
We talk about the new listings unsold.
There's also the cohort of properties
that are the new listings that are immediate sales.
They get listed and they go into contract immediately.
There's like 8,400 of those this week.
That's as a percentage, just about the lowest we've seen
since we've been tracking during the pandemic.
And it shows us, though, that even though
there's some home sales ticking up,
we could watch the new pendings ticking up,
there's no urgency on the buy side.
So that implies the fewer bidding wars
and fewer multiple offers.
And that implies to your sellers
that while home sales are ticking up,
we still wanna price the right way.
We still wanna price right from the start
because buyers are perfectly willing
to pass on the overpriced house,
on the not right conditions.
And so that is something to keep in mind
and something to be discussing
with your potential sellers right now.
Okay, inventory per state.
So if you've been watching these webinars
over the last few months,
you'll know, obviously, that the Sunbelt states
have had the greatest inventory growth over last year.
And the Midwest, the Upper Midwest, and the Northeast
have had less inventory growth over last year.
The redder the state,
the more inventory change versus 2023.
The interesting change in this pattern
over the last few months
is so Texas right now,
44% more homes on the market than a year ago.
But last month, it was like 48%.
Two months ago, it was like 50% more.
So inventory in Texas was climbing faster in 23
than it is now.
Same in Florida.
Florida was over 60% inventory gains last month.
Now we're down to 55%.
Arizona is at its peak right now,
70% more homes on the market than in 2023.
But I have a feeling that Arizona
is about peaked out as well.
Now, on the other hand,
New York was fewer homes than 23 most of the year.
New York is starting to gain.
Illinois is starting to gain
off of the pandemic lows of inventory.
And so what we're seeing is an evening out
of the inventory growth straight.
In general, what's happened is that
as interest rates are higher,
both mortgage rates and interest rates
in the economy and bonds and things,
we have not only are we buying and selling fewer homes,
we're also doing things like moving less often.
We are migrating from Chicago to Phoenix less frequently,
from New York to Florida less frequently.
In fact, Austin, Texas and some of the,
like Sarasota, Florida had negative migration
for much of this year,
like people moving out of those areas.
And so what used to happen,
and it's also true with jobs.
Unemployment is very low,
but we're kind of nervous about that.
As employers were doing less fires and less hires,
as workers and employees were quitting less.
So there's fewer hires, fewer quits,
even though job unemployment is very low,
we have fewer of those actions.
And I've been calling it the great stay.
We're staying in our jobs, we're staying in our homes,
we're staying in our towns more than we did,
especially through the pandemic when we had big,
a lot of migration.
So a lot of that's held.
And so as a result, you can see it,
the places we used to migrate out from
are fewer, less inventory growth
because we're not selling the houses there.
And the places we used to migrate to,
the Sunbelt has greater inventory growth
because we're not buying the houses there.
So over time, as interest rates ease down
and the economy allows us to do things like move more off
more easily, those inventory changes will moderate.
There'll be a more even across the country.
All right, here's a fascinating way to look
at how demand picked up in the last few weeks,
not in, but not yet with the most recent week's data
in there.
This is with the withdrawal rate.
We're estimating withdrawal rate,
we can watch all the homes that are on the market.
We can watch all the new pendings.
And if your house is no longer on the market
and it's not in contract, we can call that withdrawn.
The dark line here is this year,
and you can see it most of the year,
more withdrawals than either of the last two years.
And in fact, in September,
I think when we did this webinar in September,
we actually had the most, we had about 30% withdrawals,
which implied for every two homes sold,
another one was withdrawal.
And so for those, through September,
rates had stayed higher for longer, sellers were frustrated.
And if you don't get your offer, you have two options.
You can cut your price or you can withdraw the listing.
And so we would see more and more people withdraw listings.
That was keeping a lid on inventory,
but also keeping prices from correcting down
because sellers weren't getting the prices they want.
Then what we noticed is then in the last few weeks,
rates marched down closer to 6%.
And each week through September,
we had fewer withdrawals necessary.
You could see that fewer sellers
needed to withdraw their home.
Some of them were getting their offers.
And so we are, in fact, this week,
at 24% of the active inventory being withdrawn,
you could see that less fewer
than either of the last two years.
And remember, the last two years,
we had those big mortgage rate spikes
and people were really discouraged.
And so withdrawals were on the way up.
And withdrawals climbed through the end of the year anyway
because now you get closer to the holidays
and some people just wanna take their home
off the market for the holidays
and then maybe put it back on in the spring.
So you get a normal curve here.
But we could really see the impact on the withdrawal rate
over the last few weeks.
Now, with the hurricanes and with the rising rates,
I expect our withdrawal rate to kick up.
So there's a lot of homes in Western Florida
who are just like, well, I guess we're not for sale
right now and we'll figure out what happens next.
So those get withdrawn.
There are probably a lot that should be withdrawn
but won't go through that process
so it'll still look like it's listed for sale.
So there's probably several weeks
of that market correction to take place there.
But this is what we can see over the last few weeks.
And so we're really in this fine transition point
where it looked like we were getting some sales
but then suddenly we got another mortgage rate spike.
And so let's combine that all in together
to the forecast for inventory.
So we're forecasting inventory to finish the year
up 27% over 23.
That's a pretty big gain
but it's actually less than we are now, right?
So right now we're at 37% or 36%
more homes on the market than a year ago.
And because inventory was climbing so quickly,
September, October, November last year,
then therefore we're not gonna climb as quickly this fall.
And so we'll end the year at up at about 27% more.
That's about 655,000 single family homes
on the market at the end of the year.
We will get, then we'll start showing the 25 curve.
We expect the 2025 curve to be up a little higher again.
So get each year with higher mortgage rates,
we get closer and closer
to the old normal levels of inventory.
So there's 734,000 right now.
It's not that long ago that we would have had
over a million homes on the market
in the middle of the summer.
And so we still have 25, 30% more to gain
before it even gets back to the old normal levels.
And again, right, this is in,
and I'll show you some of these.
This is in the Midwest.
It's in the Northeast.
Many of those markets that still,
still barely have more homes for sale than the pandemic.
And I will switch into those in just a minute.
Total sales pending.
These are all the homes in contract.
So 355,000 homes in contract right now.
You can see the nice little, there's a step each month.
So at the beginning of the month,
we close a bunch of sales.
And then during the month,
they new pendings happen and then they close.
And so you can see the little step functions.
But we can see home sales growth over 2023.
And if we're lucky, as we go through October,
you could see the dark line may finish higher
in the fourth quarter than 22.
What I think this is gonna lead to is we had,
I started with a slide with the new pendings each week.
This is all the homes in pendings, in contract.
And what I think this implies is that in the fourth quarter,
you're gonna start to see some like bullish headlines
from a lot of the other sources.
They're gonna say, home sales are up year over year.
Home sales ticked up.
Home sales are up highest in the last two years.
We're gonna start to see some positive headlines.
And that's gonna be a fascinating to see
how the buyers and sellers react to that.
If that motivates more action,
like, oh, maybe there's things happening.
So I think you're gonna start to see some positive headlines
because the fourth quarter of the last two years
has been, was really rough.
And so maybe we get lucky.
And you can see in the 22 line, the light red line,
that steep drop in the total number of homes in contract
in that October period, when we had that,
really that second surprise mortgage rate spike of the year.
Last year, we had, we went to 8%
and you could see in October and November,
big home sales declines then.
So, if we're lucky, we'll get, we get moderating rates
and we finish the year up here above 22 and 23
with the total number of homes in contract.
So these homes are in contract.
It takes, it takes like three or,
you know, 20, 25, 35, 40 days to close.
So these are homes that'll close in October
through the beginning of November.
Now at the same time,
the hurricanes will impact the pending sales rate too.
You know, there are some big chunks of the country
and some big metro markets
that are really slowing down right now.
And so let's take a look at those.
Tampa Metro is obviously the biggest one.
What I've pulled here from the Altos Advanced Analytics
is, are the, the weekly pending home sales.
And so you can see several hundred drop last week
from Helene.
And then you're gonna see another one from this week
and you'll see it again next week.
Like you'll see big drops down here.
So you can see a really big impact.
So knocking out, you know, 800, it'll, you know,
500 to 600 more home sales out of the national,
like that's like 1% of the national home sales
in a given week would come from the Tampa Metro
and the surrounding areas, maybe 2% by then.
We can also see it in, in the Asheville area.
And so Henderson County and Buncombe County
both had big dips in their new pendings.
The other thing about the pending sales rate
is there's a lot of, a lot of places where
if there's a named hurricane, even if it hasn't landed yet,
insurance companies can't write policies.
So if you're scheduled to close,
you won't be able to get your insurance done.
And so even if the house is safe,
like there are those types of things that are,
will restrict the home sales process.
Maybe some of those will delay and get done in November,
but a lot of those aren't gonna get done.
And so those are really under impact.
And it looks like, you know,
Tampa and Sarasota and further South.
Now, if we went all the way down,
the most like far Southwest Florida,
you can see less impact on the sales.
And then further up Northern Florida,
you can see less impact on sales.
But, and I'll dive into Asheville and Tampa
in the local data in a minute.
But that's how the, you can see it impacting
the national numbers from the hurricanes right there.
Okay, let's switch over to prices.
So the median price of single family homes
in the US is $440,000.
This is the asking price from every home on the market.
It's unchanged from a year ago
and just fractionally higher than 2022.
You can see we're like following this down.
So it is a, the price has declined
in the second half of the year.
I had been, you know, in the last few weeks,
a little optimistic because we could see
home sales improving.
But now that's backing off.
So on the low end of the range, home prices for 2024,
we can see asking prices are essentially
at a 0% gain from over last year.
And that's roughly gonna continue
through the end of the year.
On the other hand, if we look at the median price
of the new contract, so these are the homes
going into contract, these are the homes
that people are buying.
This has been up three to 5% over last year, all year long.
So showing home price gains three to 5%.
In September, August and September,
as rates were staying higher for longer,
buyers were getting discouraged.
We saw the withdrawal rates climbing.
We saw, we haven't gotten to the price reductions,
but price reductions were climbing at this time.
So the price that people were paying
was starting to tick down closer to where it had been.
So it was getting in the zero to 3% range.
And then we had our little boost for mortgage rates.
We could see our home sales increase.
And we could see four weeks in a row
of climbing prices of the new contract.
So this is the price point that people are buying.
And it really surprised me.
I was not expecting buyers to be this aggressive
to having this visible in the home price changes.
And so you can see, compare that to 2022,
the big mortgage rate spike in 22,
you could see that sharp dip then,
and we have a sharp spike now.
And so what this shows us is how sensitive
buyers are to payment changes.
Payments had been declining.
I showed the payments earlier.
Payments had been declining for most of the year.
And then we had a sharp spike.
So it'll be really fascinating to see what happens
with contract prices next week,
and if it turns the corner or if it stays elevated.
I expect it to ease back down.
I expect, so this is, we're now 5% above
last year at this time.
So you can see, asking prices are 0% above last year.
The contracts, the price people are paying are 5%.
You've got a 0% to 5% range.
And my expectation is it's gonna ease back down
into 3% to 5% range.
But because we had some good momentum,
probably not closer to zero.
It's probably looking at 3% to 5% home price gains
through the end of the year.
Given that we had dramatically slower, fewer home sales,
we had a hard landing in home sales,
home prices really showed a soft landing.
Some markets are down, some markets are up.
But nationally, this is the price point, $395,000
is what people are paying across the country.
Okay, and we talked about the state-level migration
and where inventory is higher in the Sunbelt
and lower in the Northeast.
Well, it turns out because inventory is restricted
in the Midwest and Northeast,
that's where the home price gains have been.
13% in New York this year, 10% in Wisconsin.
So we can really see those tight inventories.
You can see the Northern states
having much stronger price appreciation.
Anything plus or minus 2% is flat year over year.
Things can bounce around.
So all of these states across the South,
even South Carolina that's negative,
these are all basically flat home prices year over year.
Some markets are up a little bit, some markets are down.
But you can see the stronger appreciation in the Northeast
and the Northern states across the country.
So this is really that same function.
We had been selling homes in Illinois
and buying them in Arizona and buying them in Texas,
but we stopped doing that
because we've stopped quitting our jobs,
we've stopped moving,
we've slowed down on buying homes too, the great stay.
All right, we're gonna do price reductions
and we're gonna look at some local data.
I've got a few different local things up for you today.
And then we will wrap it up for the day.
So there are 40% of the homes on the market
have had price reductions across the country right now.
If you'll notice, that's been in this range,
40% for several weeks now.
Price reductions were climbing late in the summer
and then they peaked at the end of August
and have been bouncing around 40% or so.
At that time, at the end of August,
we had that spike in withdrawals.
So if your house, you'd had a price reduction,
you still didn't get your offer,
you could cut your price again
or you could take it off the market.
If you take it off the market,
that makes this price reduction number drop a little bit.
And so we had this cap in price reduction.
Each of the last two years,
with those spiking mortgage rates,
you can see the real big spike in price reductions
in the last two years through November
before the seasonal decline.
Homes get taken off of the market over the holidays.
The best fresh inventory comes on in the first quarter.
And then if the house hasn't had its offer
by June and July,
that's when the price cuts start to accelerate.
So you get a normal seasonal curve here.
If rates go from here, where it's 6.5, 6.6,
if they go up to seven,
you're gonna see inventory climb,
you're gonna see price reductions climb,
you're gonna see the withdrawals climb.
All of those are gonna be very sensitive to any buyers.
They're perfectly happy to hit the brakes
and wait for better options to happen.
But we could see them start tiptoeing back in
as rates got closer to 6%.
So we can really see that threshold happening.
Okay, let's switch over to the application
and dive into some local data.
First, I wanna show you,
so this is the Altos Advanced Analytics platform.
And I've got some queries up that I am interested in.
I can build my queries.
And what I did was,
I'm interested in watching Dallas
compared to pre-pandemic time.
So this is Dallas inventory.
And I can see here 26,000,
almost 27,000 homes on sold in Dallas
compared to like 21, 22, 23,000
in the years before the pandemic.
So while I believe that I've been pretty optimistic
national inventory about topping off the last few weeks,
we really haven't seen it hit in Dallas yet.
And I think this is a really stark comparison.
Dallas is a bigger market,
tons of new construction,
and it relied on inbound migration.
So if that slows down,
you can see a lot of difference over the last few years.
I've also been watching prices in Florida.
This is the pending home sales prices in Florida.
And we can see earlier in the year in like April,
home prices peaked and they've been ticking back down.
I'll be curious to see if home prices finish 24
at or below the 23 level in Florida as a whole.
That's something I've been watching.
And I pulled up a bunch of counties
in North Carolina too over here.
Here's Buncombe County.
You can see the new listings rate
just dropping dramatically.
Here's Henderson County.
These are both Asheville areas dropping dramatically.
Yet, if you go down to Charlotte, Mecklenburg County,
no impact from the hurricane.
And I just wanted to see,
I pulled up those because I'm interested
in watching both new listings and new pendings.
That's where we can see it most quickly.
The impact of the weekly,
like if I was gonna list my house,
now I'm not gonna list it.
And so these will drop even lower this week.
And so, but it was really fascinating.
So I've got these queries picked up
to keep my eyes on the impact of the hurricanes this year.
Price reductions at the local level.
We have, Tampa is now at the peak.
And it's fascinating, but Tampa ticked down this week
with price reductions.
And I'll show you why that is in just a second.
But now we've got Colorado, Texas.
We've got many of the Western markets
are starting to dominate the price reductions.
And that's different from earlier in the year
when it was the Florida markets
in the first half of the year.
We still obviously have a lot of Florida markets
in the price reductions peak.
But, and then here's Asheville down here with an uptick.
So let's dive into some local.
I've got the Asheville metro level report up.
And median price in Asheville is $587,000.
And it's been interesting to watch Asheville over this year.
So home prices are still way up over pre-pandemic era,
but actually ticked down this year overall
from last year at this time.
If we look at the inventory in Asheville,
we can see a few things.
The long-term trend is Asheville,
I talk about the Northern markets and the Sunbelt markets
where people in New York is barely off the pandemic lows,
but Florida is 50% more homes than last year.
Asheville's kind of in between.
So Asheville is climbing,
is 50% more than last year at this time,
but still just starting to come out of the pandemic
and still significantly fewer homes for sale
than pre-pandemic times in 2019.
You can see where the demand is in Asheville,
which is, this is at half a million dollars.
You can see the bigger lots
and you can see that that's the shortest time on market.
Now, if we zoom into the inventory,
what we'll see here is,
let me zoom in even shorter here, is take this guy off.
We can see, here's our inventory impact of the last week,
ticking down like a sharp turn.
And that's just the total inventory.
So there's homes that are on the market
that some will still sell,
some that will need to be withdrawn that aren't yet,
but you can see the little sharp turn of inventory
in Asheville over the last week.
On the other hand, Tampa is potentially more impacted.
Tampa was last week with Helene, this week with Milton.
We can see days on market climb.
We could see prices adjust down,
price per square foot adjust down.
We can see the inventory turn right here,
10% fewer homes or whatever it is,
five, 6% fewer homes in just one week there.
Here's the inventory zoomed in in Tampa.
But let's look at price reductions in Tampa.
And so I'm gonna turn this guy off here.
Because we have a lot of withdrawn properties in Tampa,
we actually saw fewer price reductions this week
because there were a lot that are not on the market anymore.
And so if they were sitting on the market for a long time
and they did a price cut and now they're withdrawn,
they're like, well, we have to wait until next year.
So that's actually showing a downtick in price reductions
rather than an uptick, which would be like,
well, we're still gonna try to sell this home this year.
We're just think it's weak demand.
Like this is a more structural change
in the Tampa housing market
because those homes are no longer for sale.
And fingers crossed that they are,
that's not worse than that,
but that is what's happening in Tampa.
Let's look at Cincinnati.
So Cincinnati is one of the Northern markets
where we are barely up off of the pandemic lows
and in inventory.
We can see a much stronger market action index.
We could see the days on market is fewer
than in places like Tampa.
If we go down into the price ranges here,
anything under half a million bucks in Cincinnati
is moving very quickly, still 30 days at the low end
and even 42 days at the upper end
of the market in Cincinnati.
So you can really see that difference
in the Sunbelt versus the Northern economies.
I have Sacramento up.
I like to say the Sacramento housing market
is like the whole US, only more so.
It is the inventory trends, the migration trends,
the price reductions.
So price reductions in Sacramento really spiked in 22.
It was a real recovery year in 23
and a slight recovery now this year,
but not a strong market by any means.
So it's a really fascinating trend to watch.
We can see anything under 750 in Sacramento
is where the action is, 49 days instead of 70 days
if it's over a million bucks.
So Sacramento had, and let's look at pricing over time.
We could show a little bit lower than last year
at this time on the asking price,
but it's this time of year is when you get
that down cycle in Sacramento.
And obviously still significantly higher,
a lot of equity for homes in the Sacramento region
from 500K to 700K over the last few years.
So you can imagine being a seller in Sacramento,
not getting the offer you want,
and you can reduce your price or you can withdraw
or not list it and say, I'm just gonna wait
because I have a cheap mortgage and I have a lot of equity
so I don't have any urgency to sell this house.
I've got Washington DC up and inventory in Washington DC
is actually much more like the Northern markets,
which is barely more homes for sale
than the pandemic period.
It's actually got from 4,200 to 5,700.
So a third more homes are for sale this year
than last year.
So slightly more, but still fewer than 22.
And so the DC area is a strong economy.
There's still a lot of inbound migration.
So you could see what happens to inventory in there.
Like they're not, it's not like those Sunbelt economies
that had a ton of inbound migration that suddenly stopped.
You could see still under a month on market
for homes that are the cheapest, the entry level homes,
the first time homes in the DC Metro.
So very strong differences in the metros.
I do believe over the next year,
we will see these starting to moderate a little bit.
We'll see more inventory growth in the Northeast.
We'll see some of that migration pattern
picking back up again.
And we'll see therefore picking up some of those homes
in places like Texas.
And in some ways that's optimistic for Texas
and Florida and Arizona,
because more homes on the market means a better opportunity.
It means for first time buyers, for inbound migration,
it means less upward pressure on home prices
when we already have an affordability challenge.
So in some ways, those Sunbelt markets
where you build a lot of homes
maybe are looking at a much more positive 2025.
As I mentioned in the beginning,
if you haven't already grabbed the ebook from Altos,
I recommend that you do it.
We'll put a link in the chat.
Lail and Jeff will put a link in the chat.
It helps you talk about the data the way I do,
understand the data, use the scripts,
use the conversation parts for your buyers and sellers
because they need to know what's happening right now.
And that's what the data does.
I don't have time to talk about every local market,
but we have every zip code in the country.
So if you wanna go understand your local market,
you wanna get started by getting the data
to your buyers and sellers right now,
go to altosresearch.com.
You can see a demo.
That's book a free consult with our team.
We'll look at your local market.
We'll start building your system
so that you can communicate with your clients right away.
All right, everybody,
that's all the time we've got for today.
Thank you so much.
The webinar is recorded.
You'll get an email later today when it's available.
And thank you so much for sharing your time with us.
I'll stick around and make sure all the comments
in the chat are done, covered now,
and we'll see you soon.
Thanks everybody.