How Gucci Fell From High Fashion to Discount Rack

Career Exploration
26 followers
This is the image that Gucci would like to project.
Gucci doesn't belong in a mall.
It belongs in a museum.
Gucci is that brand that makes people think they want to live larger than life
and be sexy and be adventurous and be unconventional.
But behind the scenes, things have been a bit less glamorous.
Still in shock from Gucci's dramatic slowdown.
Gucci sales falling 20% in Asia.
A steep drop in sales at its flagship Gucci brand.
Clearly Gucci isn't at the top of its game.
So how did Gucci and the $50 billion conglomerate that owns it
fall from high fashion to the discount rack?
While Gucci is an icon of Italian fashion,
it's been owned by the French company Kering for the past two decades.
Kering is a luxury conglomerate that is controlled by the Pinot family.
Even though it is an established multi-brand luxury group,
they have other storied brands like Yves Saint Laurent and Bottega Veneta and Balenciaga.
Gucci is really the mothership for the company.
Kering was founded by Francois Pinot,
who built the company through acquisitions over several decades.
He's now 87 and his son Francois-Henri has taken over.
He's well known because he hangs out quite a lot on the red carpets.
His wife is Thelma Hayek, the actress and producer.
Now Kering's big rival is LVMH,
the owner of Louis Vuitton and Christian Dior, among others.
That company is run by Bernard Arnault.
So there's a duopoly in the French fashion world,
with LVMH under Arnault on one side and Kering under Pinot on the other.
That rivalry really came to a head in the late 90s,
when Arnault had set his sights on acquiring Gucci for LVMH.
And that was the point when Tom Ford and Domenico Di Sole were running Gucci as a public company
and they didn't want Mr. Arnault to have it.
And they ended up signing an agreement with Francois Pinot, the father,
who was the white knight who came in.
So initially they bought a 40% stake in Gucci
and eventually they bought the rest of it after a lot of acrimonious moves against LVMH.
During that era, Kering was about the same size as LVMH.
In the years since, they've had different trajectories.
With savvy dealmaking and management, LVMH's value has soared to $450 billion,
while Kering's hasn't.
LVMH's market cap nowadays is about 10 times bigger than Kering's.
Kering is very dependent on Gucci.
Basically, about 50% of its sales come from Gucci,
but more than two-thirds of operating profit come from Gucci.
So when Gucci is suffering, the whole company is suffering.
At LVMH, it's slightly different.
Louis Vuitton generates about a quarter of total sales,
but it's about half of total profitability.
The fact that LVMH is less dependent on one single brand provides more stability.
Even so, Gucci, and therefore Kering, has had a few successful years.
And that was largely down to one man, Alessandro Michele.
In the years that followed the nomination of Alessandro Michele as creative director at Gucci in 2015,
the label did really, really well.
They kept putting out hit products.
There was their Marmont bag in 2016, for instance,
and the Dionysus bag and the Prince Town slippers a year earlier.
The furry slippers really became a hit product.
They really resonated well with the younger generations.
They were bohemian, they were maximalist, and they were chic.
And during that time, the market cap of Kering actually quadrupled.
Sales at Gucci more than tripled.
But being a top fashion brand comes with problems.
Finding that right balance in the fashion industry,
to stay on top and yet have your products be fresh,
it's very difficult to hit and it's very difficult to maintain over the long term.
The Fashion Retail List publishes rankings on the world's most fashionable brands,
and Gucci has fallen down the rankings.
Since 2022, the performance at Gucci and therefore Kering has really suffered.
Sales have missed a number of times, and the stock price has really tumbled.
The success of Louis Vuitton has meanwhile helped turn Barnard Arnault
into, at times, the richest person in the world.
And his was a very different strategy.
So, I mean, in some ways, Louis Vuitton has a more classic image and positioning.
LVMH has been at this longer.
They are really total pros in this game.
There's a difference between luxury and fashion.
In fashion, for instance, you're relying on trends,
whereas in luxury, you rely on timeless, on heritage products
that basically stand the test of time.
That's what differentiates top-tier luxury brands such as Louis Vuitton and Hermès.
A typical luxury product, for instance, is the Birkin bag by Hermès,
which was created in the 1980s.
And that is still very much sought after.
You know, one single bag can cost more than €10,000.
With some of Michele's products, Gucci may have missed an opportunity.
According to company insiders, these products,
like the furry slippers or the Marmont or the Dionysus,
they could have become one of those heritage, timeless products.
But they didn't.
And the mistake was that basically they created many variations of these products.
They were overexposed somehow.
This was a reflection of the short-termism at Kering,
basically trying to maximize sales and profits in the short term.
This is reflected in the company's share price.
For every dollar of profit that LVMH is expected to make,
investors give it about $24 of value.
For every dollar of profit at Kering, they only give it about $15.
That's because they're more optimistic about LVMH's future business prospects
because it isn't quite as vulnerable to the whims of fashion.
So Pinot knows that Gucci basically needs to play more in the most exclusive luxury space.
So in February, at the annual results,
he says they're trying to basically lift the brand
and put it in the same category as some of its peers like Hermès, Chanel or Louis Vuitton.
But the thing is, he's been saying that since 2006.
Some observers place the blame on Pinot himself.
At LVMH, for the most critical and most important decisions,
they're taken by Bernard Arnault himself.
At Kering, the management style is slightly different.
People have described him as being more hands-off,
as being a little bit more laissez-faire,
and as giving the brands more autonomy.
Critics cite the 2022 Balenciaga scandal as evidence of this.
The brand had to apologize after one of its ad campaigns was accused of sexualizing children.
Still, in 2023, Pinot found another reason to lose focus.
In 2023, the Pinot family bought a majority stake in Creative Artists Agency.
According to some luxury observers, that was seen as a distraction for François-Henri Pinot.
Gucci parted ways with Michele in 2022 over a difference in creative vision.
And a few months later, in early 2023, they name a new designer, Sabato de Sarno.
He was a relatively unknown figure from Valentino.
At first, his design seemed more staid than Michele's,
playing into Pinot's plan to elevate the brand.
So Pinot wants Gucci basically to become a true luxury player.
However, making that pivot takes time.
It's a marathon at the end of the day. It's not a sprint.
