Winter Survival Food: Potato Soup

History Of Food
342 followers
9 Video Views·Oct 14, 2024
Studying how folks survived harsh winters in the 18th century is fascinating.
Journals seeing ledger and seeing how people were preparing for the winter and
thinking about things like the only food you're going to eat is the food that you
grow. There's nothing else that you can count on.
It's easy for us to romanticize what it would be like to live 250 or 300 years
ago. Us as we're researching for videos and we're reading books,
you guys in the comment section and oftentimes we'll even see this term called
simpler times or we'll say that there really wasn't anything simple about it.
It was pretty darn terrifying. If you think about it, it's the middle of winter.
It's freezing. There's snow storms up north.
There is no drips because there's nothing to stop the wind from blowing across
and you are kind of hold up in your house or your cabin by yourself or with your
family and all you have is what you were able to store back for the winter.
This is not a situation where there are grocery stores close by.
This is not a situation where there are neighbors close by that you can go to
and ask for food if you need it. This is isolation.
It's nothing new. They knew what they were getting into,
but not only are you getting to an area where you're building house and you're
starting to prepare your property and get everything situated when are still
coming. So while you're doing all of that work,
you're still putting things in the ground and planning everything so that you're
going to have food stores come winter time.
One of the main things that people are going to be storing back for winter are
root vegetables. Now they're going to be salting meat.
They're going to be drying grains. There's going to be other things to eat,
but when it comes down to the day to day,
what can we store back at a high volume to get through this winter?
It's root vegetables and in the onion video that we did not too long ago,
we said the onion was the king for a savory flavor and for the potato,
it is the king to fill the belly.
If you go searching for poor people food in the time period,
you're going to find potato, potato, potato.
If you're going to look for food that can be a substitute for something to make
something cheaper and still be filling, you're going to find potatoes.
If you're looking for anything that can be added to something to fill it up,
it is potato. No matter what, if it's an apple pie,
you will find apple pies with potatoes. We've done them on the channel.
If it is, I need to substitute flour, you're going to make potato bread.
If you're looking to spread anything, it's potatoes. In fact,
primitive cookery was a cookbook that was put out in the time period and it was
a way of making cheap meals. And the back of that book,
there are several for the dirt cheap and so many of them use potatoes because
they're plentiful.
They're easy to grow and they don't really cost a lot on top of a potato being a
cheap and sustainable way to feed your family and yourself.
It is a fantastic way to feed your livestock. During my research,
I found this little bit of reading. This is after all,
the chief object of modern husbandry for if a man can rely upon this potato for
the winter consumption of his yard and fattening or keeping hogs and feeding his
horses and fattening his bullocks,
he has made one of the greatest acquisitions that can be desired since he can do
all of this upon land, much too stiff and wet for turnips.
This was a staple for the homestead.
This kept the homestead going through winter.
Not only is the potato keeping the homestead or the farm functioning during the
wintertime,
but it is actually keeping the city going as well because this is poor people
food. If you look through cookbooks of the time period,
potato is the number one thing that people are going to when they're poor and
they can't afford nicer ingredients because you can take a potato and it's
basically just the starchy mush if you boil it and you can flavor that however
you want to.
So you're seeing everything from mock apple pies to mock cheesecakes.
They're just having a dish of butter and potato,
which we would call mashed potatoes now, but that was just, that was dinner.
It was, here's a potato, here's some butter, mush it together. There you go.
One of the things that you see at the poor house or even from street vendors
that is very affordable and easy to come by is potato soup.
There are so many recipes for potato soup in this time period,
but they are all in the context of poor food.
I have not found a single one that wasn't a meager soup.
Here's a reading from a country housewives family companion by William Ellis
says several of our prudent housewives foresee the great conveniency of having
broad beans, peas, carrots, turnips, potatoes, cabbages, onions,
parsley and other kitchenware ready for use against one of them and harvest
time. So they're planning ahead. They're already thinking, okay,
we're going to have all these harvesters in here. We need to feed them.
We're going to store these things back and then what's not used that just goes
right into winter storage.
So when I first had the idea to do this winter survival food series,
I knew, okay, I knew I wanted to do something with onion and that was easy.
So I did that first and then potato was kind of like the pinnacle,
but I didn't know which direction to go with it because you can go so many
different ways. So I started on potato bread.
We've had a really popular video with potato bread in the past.
So I decided not to do that and I wanted to think about, okay,
what is the easiest way that people can incorporate potatoes into their diet,
but it's not just a potato, like a baked potato or something like that.
Potato soup is it.
And as you keep going and looking for potatoes with poor people,
because let's face it, if your rule in the time period,
you're not necessarily poor, but the idea of winter survival food,
we're talking about people that don't just have the pick of everything.
They have to deal with what they have. That's what I want to focus on.
And potato soup is something that you see over and over and over again.
This recipe in particular has been rehashed in so many different books for
different quantities of soup that they want in the end result and used in
different people's dialects or in their own words,
but it's the same recipe and they're just copying it and they're just copying it
for their own personal use and for their own soup kitchen or their own just
cause when they're trying to feed the poor people. Let's talk about it.
Let's dig into this recipe for potato soup. Just a little bit. It's,
like I said, it's rehashed a lot. There are different versions.
Some people give a lot of explanation as to why you're using these ingredients
for some people. It's short and sweet and they're just like, just do it.
It's cheap and people will like it. Potato soup,
still five pounds courses parts of beef or mutton and 10 quarts of water till
half done at a quantity of potatoes skinned and some onions,
pepper and salt. Stir frequently and boil enough.
Bones of beef added would increase the soup and richness or quantity.
Now what's interesting about this is that they've broken it down so that you
know how much it's going to cost and they've estimated the cost at 50 cents for
the entire pot of soup and it says it gives 10 quarts of soup,
meat and potatoes and dines 10 men for just 5 cents. So there it is.
It is that simple. Beef broth with potatoes, onions and seasoning.
They go on to explain why this is such a great solution to the problem of poor
food. All these people need to eat,
but they don't have time to make bread and they don't have time to be in the
kitchen all day. You put all of this into a pot, let it boil and it's good to go.
We're going to cut this recipe in half.
We don't need a potato soup that is 10 quarts.
The first thing that you need to do is get five quarts of water on the stove.
Start a boil and you're going to take two and a half pounds of meat and you're
going to cut it up.
Now if you can't find something that's coarse and you can't find something
that's got bones in it, that's fine.
Just take some beef and cut it up and put it in the water to start cooking.
In the meantime, you're going to be pairing these potatoes.
Now it calls for 11 to 12 pounds of potatoes if you cut this in half.
So that's a lot of potatoes.
Give yourself some time to get the pairing done after they're paired slice and
put them in the water to start boiling with a couple of onions and some salt and
pepper. All right. So this is an interesting point.
I'm going to try to make here and it's a stretch.
So come along with me and the Christmas Carol Scrooge gets a bowl of something
to eat.
Now Dickens leaves us some evidence of what might be here in a popular culture.
You will see mainly the idea that he is eating gruel because the point that
Dickens is trying to make is that Scrooge is so cheap,
such a miser that he will not even spring for a good meal.
Now I know that popular culture says gruel.
I've even seen some people say it's split pea soup,
but Scrooge says in the context of the story that he has eaten something bad.
And that is why he is seeing spirits.
And he gives us two hints and a list of foods that it could be was potato and
beef. And I think, and John thinks as well, that he was eating potato soup.
It's finished. Here's our potato soup. As you can see,
it looks a lot different than what we would come to expect as a potato soup.
Now it's not a loaded baked potato soup with cheese and sour cream and all
sorts of chives and that kind of thing.
But it is the most common potato soup that you will find in the period.
Most everything started with some beef broth.
This has potatoes that are just starting to break down from the reading.
It looks like maybe they intend for potatoes to really break down.
You can just cook it longer if you'd like that to happen.
But I wanted to have some chunks of potatoes left in it and we're going to give
it a try. I'm expecting the beef to really be the flavor that comes forward.
The onions are going to come and get a little sweet, savory thing.
And the potatoes, I think they're just going to be a nice mouthfeel and filler.
Let's see what's going on. That is really, really good.
It's like when your pot roast and your pot roast potatoes kind of come together
on your plate. It's fantastic. You'll love it.
