Mid-cap stocks are a better hedge in the near term than small caps, says BofA's Jill Carey Hall

Financial Freedom
10 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 10, 2024
Jill Carey Hall, Bank of America Global Research head of U.S. small and mid-cap strategy and senior U.S. equity strategist, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss the latest market trends, why she likes mid-cap stocks in the near term, the Fed's inflation fight, interest rate outlook, and more.
Our next guest likes mid-caps in the near term.
Joining us right now is Jill Carey-Hall.
She's the head of U.S. small and mid-cap strategy
and senior U.S. equity strategist
for Bank of America Global Research.
Why mid-caps?
So I think when you think about Fed cutting,
obviously this is supposed to be a positive for small caps.
They've actually underperformed
since the 50 basis point cut.
And I think the reason is a lot of investors
are now looking at the fundamentals
for smaller companies
and they've still been stuck in an earnings recession.
We haven't seen that recovery to positive growth
the way that we've seen for larger stocks.
So I think mid-caps could be a better hedge
for the near term.
They've seen better earnings and guidance trends
and they've historically still done well
and oftentimes better than small caps
following the initial Fed rate cuts historically.
So I think for those that want to tilt down the cap spectrum,
that's a better area than small caps right now.
We had somebody tell us yesterday
that small businesses still have to pay
about 10% interest on average to get a loan,
even though the Fed has cut rates at this point.
Is that part of the thesis
that for small business it still takes a while
even after the Fed starts cutting rates
for that to trickle down?
Well, I think, you know,
certainly for some small businesses
and others may be more tied immediately
to the Fed funds rate.
I think overall, you know,
one rate cut is not going to solve the refinancing risk
that small caps face.
You know, you still have about half of their debt
that's that short-term or floating rate.
So, you know, the more rate cuts we get,
the more that helps to mitigate the refinancing risk
that a lot of these companies face.
But, you know, there's also some sector specifics.
There are sectors like real estate
and tech within small caps
that even if we get a handful of rate cuts,
they still do face a lot of refinancing risk.
Are there sectors you like within the mid-caps too?
I think overall, I mean, within both small and mid-caps,
I think this is an environment where,
you know, you want to focus on themes or styles,
even more so than sectors,
because, you know, within small caps,
even though we've still been tactically cautious,
just given the fundamental backdrop,
obviously if we're in a soft landing,
which is our base case,
and if we're in an environment where the data holds up,
the Fed's cutting rates,
you know, if we start to see revision trends
and corporate commentary turn around,
then maybe later this year,
once we get past the election,
it could be a better environment for small caps
usually volatility,
which small caps are negatively correlated with
stays high ahead of that.
So I think for now,
just focusing on stocks that have positive
rather than negative revisions,
those have been rewarded,
higher quality stocks,
and, you know, even stocks that have dividend yields,
because as the Fed's cutting rates,
that should drive money out of shorter duration assets
and into equity income.
Are there issues that you see with,
I guess, the economy coming on?
We've had a lot of discussions this morning
about whether the economy is starting to turn down,
whether it's more complicated.
What does it look like from your perspective?
Yeah, I mean, I think overall,
you know, we've certainly been
in a weak macro environment recently,
which is, you know, one of the reasons
why overall corporate earnings,
you know, may see a bit of a dip this quarter.
We think we'll see a re-acceleration
after this quarter.
And I think when you look at the balance of data,
we're still expecting the US to stay out of recession.
Obviously, the recent data,
in terms of GDP revisions and jobs data recently,
has been encouraging.
So, you know, we'll see if that continues.
We track a regime indicator on our team,
and that, after being in a more positive phase
for much of the year,
had turned down into more of a downturn phase
for the last two months,
which tends to be a phase
where you don't want to own small caps and risky stocks.
You want to tilt up the cap spectrum
and stick with quality.
But it's also been volatile
in terms of some of the underlying components.
Did you see Mark Rowan of Apollo
saying that he did not think
that there should be additional cuts on interest rates
because he thought the economy was doing so well,
so well that it was actually a mistake
to cut interest rates?
Shocking from a person
who's in the private equity business, in large part,
who you would think would want rates
to be as low as humanly possible.
Yeah, I mean, I think, you know,
the rate cuts for the overall market,
corporates have been able to adapt to higher rates.
And, you know, especially for large cap stocks,
they've been able to do well in this environment.
And, you know, we've been in an environment
where the economy has held up.
You know, a year ago, many were expecting recession.
We've managed to stay out of that.
I still think for small caps,
you know, that was the biggest focus.
And one of the biggest reasons
we saw that big rally in July in the Russell
is because investors have become so focused on the Fed
as a catalyst for smaller companies,
given how much investors have become focused
on the refinancing risk that these companies face.
So, you know, I think for smaller companies,
that's really where the issue lies,
since large caps have been able to adapt,
and particularly for some sectors.
If the labor market really is the slightest bit
indicating some weakness, I can understand it.
But if it's just to keep the,
if the default move is to keep the punch bowl going,
because people love easy money,
or because you're worried about that,
then I don't think-
Mark Rowan's point, I'm just looking at it now,
the risk is that we accelerate the economy
and have to go in the other direction,
and that would not be a good day.
That's why I was thinking the Fed knew
something about the labor market.
And then the labor market has that report.
It's like, what was the 50 all about?
It's not the stock market.
And the last 20 years, we have become addicted.
We just love the party, Wall Street traders.
We love the, oh my God, low interest rates.
Oh, it's a great.
But if you don't need them, I don't,
I think you should save it.
Save it for when you need it.
But it also suggests that things then are very good.
That to me was sort of the underlying piece of it,
which given the number of people-
But the Fed seems to be thinking that it's,
I don't know, like illusory that it's so good.
I don't know.
It's a unique backdrop.
I mean, the Fed's cutting into
an accelerating corporate profit cycle,
which isn't something that frequently happens.
So maybe reflationary.
So within our overall equity market outlook
and within the S&P as well,
we've had some overweights
on some of the cyclical sectors
that could benefit in this backdrop.
