Housing market recovery threatened by mortgage rate pop

Your Loan Toolbox
1 follower
7 Video Views·Oct 10, 2024
Home sales and home prices have been improving for several weeks.
Unfortunately this period could be fleeting because
we had strong economic news last week and ironically a really strong
employment situation in the country actually drives the bond market to
higher rates. So after the recent lows with mortgage
rates this week the 30-year fixed rate jumped back
up over six and a half percent. We can already hear that the few weeks of
September refinance boomlet has backed off.
The purchase market is slower to respond and the data
now is still showing the positive impact of
lower mortgage rates of recent weeks. Mortgage rates bounced back
up over the last couple days and it demonstrates how fragile this housing
market recovery could be. The fact is that mortgage rates fell
closer to as mortgage rates fell closer to six percent.
Home prices and home sales have been pretty obviously showing gains over last
year. The leading indicators like price
reductions have topped out. Even the withdrawal rate of frustrated
home sellers declined over the last month. Last year
was really low in terms of home sales. There were very few buyers in the fourth
quarter last year so having more sales now isn't like a big accomplishment
but it shows that consumers do in fact get a little more motivated
as the cost of money gets a little cheaper and conversely
if mortgages don't stay cheaper we've seen home buyers very willing to wait.
The conventional wisdom is that mortgages will
generally move lower but there's no reason that must be true
as evidenced in the last few days. That's why we do this work each week
and by the way this Thursday October 10 we'll have our weekly or monthly
webinar where we spend an hour with the data. In many ways we could
finally be at a transition point of sales recovery
but that's not guaranteed and so we want to dive into all the details. We're going
to really focus on two things. First the key indicators of what to watch
if this recovery has legs and which will turn first if home buyers
slow down again. So we'll cover also all the local
markets some of which are up some of which are looking very weak
still. These webinars are limited to a
thousand attendees but you can still reserve your spot now so
click the description there's a link in the description below
to reserve your spot if this Thursday 10 a.m pacific for the Altos
webinar. At Altos Research every week we track every home for sale
in the country. All the prices, all the supply and demand, all the sales, all the
changes in that data so that you can understand the changes
in the U.S housing market immediately as they happen. I might
Simonson. I'm the founder of Altos Research and it's now the fourth
quarter of 2024. Are the green shoots of sales recovery going to wither away
after only a few weeks? Let's look at this week's data.
Let's start this week with home sales. There were 61,000 new contracts pending
for single family home sales this week. That's
down a bit from last week but almost six percent more sales
than a year ago. There were another 12,000 condo sales that started this
week too. This is not the second week in a row
where home sales are coming in greater than either of the last two years.
Those two years were very slow in sales and and like I said
a little growth over last year isn't like a big accomplishment
but it does illustrate how consumers are reacting to cheaper money.
So in this chart of the newly pending home sales each week
see this year's dark line is now above each of the last two years
and in 2022 that light red line here you can see how quickly homebuyers
hit the brakes as mortgage rates surprised again in September of
and October of that year. This year we've had a great trend of declining mortgage
rates and but that strong economy data drove
rates higher in the last few days like really
spiked. So that's why I'm worried about the
durability of any sales recovery we've seen.
Homebuyers are not afraid to wait. Now at the same time home prices have
been holding up better than I expected for much of the
year and this week continued that trend.
Home prices have moved up for four weeks in a row
and I did not anticipate this strength. We're looking here at the prices for the
newly pending home sales each week so that
the home's going into contract see the dark red line here at the top of the
chart but this is the median price of the
homes that people are buying those that went into contract this week.
It's $395,000 now and like I said it surprised me that
four weeks in a row now this measure of home prices has ticked
up. In general one would expect home prices to ease
down in the fall but these are new pending prices they rose by one and a
quarter percent this week to $395,000. They are five percent greater than a
year ago. The new pending prices have been hovering
three to five percent greater than last year.
So this is now the upper end of the range after a month of
slightly improving homebuyer demand. In the last two years
when October had sharply higher mortgage rates home sales were
tanking and prices were dropping too and I've highlighted here in gray
the times in the last two years when home prices
plunged. Home prices dropped seven percent in October 2022.
The opposite is happening now and this it's pretty stark in this view here.
Now I don't expect this trend to continue home prices are not skyrocketing
through the winter it is after all autumn but this is a
stronger signal than I expected for the resilience of the homebuyer.
This is the price point that people are buying
and this recent trend implies that the yearly home price appreciation
has a little more room than I've been expecting all year. So
it's a reflection of the fact that as rates
fell finally closer to six percent home prices were supported but then
suddenly they jumped again. So we're going to see how quickly that
reverses this pricing trend. The median price of all the homes on the
market all the actives is now $440,000 that's
unchanged from last year zero percent gains.
So with the new pending prices up five percent
over last year the asking prices are unchanged.
That creates an overall picture of home prices with a zero to five percent
appreciation window. I've been assuming that the year
would finish close closer to the zero percent
appreciation over 2023 but now I'm leaning closer to three to five percent
because we could see this trend here. There's still a lot of
variables to play out before the end of the year though.
The available inventory of unsold homes on the market ticked
up to 734,000 single-family homes this week.
That's up half a percent for the week or just under half a percent for the week
and is 36.7 percent more homes on the market now
than a year ago. Inventory looks like it probably has three more weeks of growth
through the end of the month. Inventory grew by less than half a percent this
week right so nationally it seems to be
approaching a seasonal peak. If mortgage rates keep climbing from
like 6.1 to 6.5 to 6.6 where they are today
or closer to seven percent then that will slow demand
and it'll drive inventory higher for longer.
As the last two years have shown rising rates late in the year
can drive inventory higher all the way to the end of November.
Some of the sunbelt states like Arizona, Texas, Florida haven't topped out
inventory yet. Texas has 44 percent more homes on the market than last year
and 24 percent more unsold homes on the market
now than 2019. Texas is 24 percent more homes now than pre-pandemic. Arizona
has 70 percent more homes on the market now than a year ago.
Nationally we're up 36, 37 percent more homes unsold than a year ago
but we're still 23 percent fewer than 2019.
There are eight states with more inventory than 2019 but most of the
country is still fewer unsold homes on the
market right so this we're going to cover this in detail
on the Thursday webinar about which states and which trends
are moving. So in this chart you can see that inventory
is slowly reaching the pre-pandemic level
across the country and you can see how quickly inventory
can climb late in the year with spiking mortgage rates. See the
the red line from last year that started growing again in September and didn't
stop until the end of November when rates rose
inventory. There were 61,000
61,000 new listings unsold this week which is
down a few percent for the week and a few percent more than a year ago
with only 8,500 new listings immediate sales. The immediate sales was
actually slightly fewer total sellers than a year ago.
The immediate sales are at their lowest level since we started tracking during
the pandemic. So these are the you know the bidding
war homes and the homes that get offers immediately after listing.
These are the best homes the best locations that are properly priced and
well marketed. So there are always some immediate
sales but it's notable to me that while we're measuring a slight
pickup in total sales and demand the and the prices being paid are
holding firm the urgency of buyers is not increasing.
Home buyers are in a much stronger position than they have been
in many years and it shows in our immediate sales data.
Now I use this new listings data each week
to watch for any emerging imbalance between supply and demand.
There are a lot of potential home buyers out there who assume that a
flood of inventory is coming that home prices will tank as a result
and so if we are going to see a flood of sellers that dark line here is going to
have to climb. There's no sign of that happening yet
but that's what we're watching for each week.
So this week's 61,000 new listings is still 10 to 20 percent
fewer sellers than normal times pre-pandemic.
And let's close with price reductions today.
Just about 40 percent of the homes on the market have taken a price reduction
from the original list price. This percentage has been staying flat
for a couple of months now. One way to measure the slight
improvement in home buyer demand over the last month
is that price reductions haven't climbed at all.
In the late season there are a lot of withdrawals so
homes that haven't gotten their offer have two options. They can either take a
price cut or they can withdraw the listing. At the
end of August we were measuring withdrawals at the
highest level that we've seen in a long while.
But since then that ratio has declined a bit.
I mentioned at the top of the video as rates fell closer to six percent
the price cuts leveled off, withdrawals slowed, the new pending sales picked up
and prices ticked up. But now suddenly in the last few days
mortgage rates jumped again which could put a damper on all those
trends. Rates spiked remember in the autumn of
2022 and at that time the pace of withdrawals
accelerated, price cuts climbed too and you can see
that here in the red line. And in 2022 we
transitioned from that pandemic boom to the post-pandemic
boom. And so now it really illustrates for us
how fleeting any recovery can be. And it's wild
right how quickly this the sentiment can change in a week.
We were maybe at a transition point to get some home sales growth
and then suddenly we had this really big spike in mortgage rates. So
buyers could put the brakes on very quickly and it can be impactful
for smart decision making. Home buyers and sellers need to hear the data
directly from you so they know how to act.
You should join us at Altos Research. Go to altosresearch.com
to book a free consult with our team. We'll help you
know how to talk about the data and the market with your clients and prospects
today. There's a link in the description below
to join us. Click that and let's get started.
