History is in the details: The transformation of cultural areas in central Africa

Africa’s civilizations
4 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 10, 2024
I will talk a lot about pottery today, mainly African pottery, because that's my core business
as they say today.
So I will ask of you a little leap of imagination as to how it relates to your different detailed
archaeological fieldwork.
History is in the details.
So indeed, I think that the principles of this conference
are very good ones.
And as we have seen, I want to say that everything
I'm going to see today basically is a way
to add something, a layer to our thinking.
I'm going to explain that.
But I still think, I'm an archaeologist at heart,
there is nothing that beats a very detailed and very
thorough archaeological analysis.
There is nothing in the ethnographic world
that will give you a ready-made answer
for the interpretation of the past.
That comes with thorough archaeological investigation.
What we're doing is just providing a testing ground
and a playground for thinking about these things.
So why am I talking today with my colleagues, Olivier Gosselin
and Agnès Vaucard?
Basically, it comes from a feeling of frustration.
Working in the field of African pottery,
meeting with Olivier regularly, who's a friend,
who's also working on Africa.
But I'm more an archaeologist, he's more an anthropologist,
let's say, even though he's truly an archaeologist.
And Agnès Vaucard is working in the Middle East
on antique cooking wares.
And basically, the common thing was always to say,
wow, your stuff is really neat, but it doesn't quite
fit with what we have.
It doesn't quite work in Africa.
Oh, but your stuff is really nice,
but it doesn't work with antiquity.
This feeling was basically that we
lack an overall framework of comparative work.
Yes, we have had the Chez l'Opératoire approach
that came in the game of pottery studies a few years back.
And that was really helpful, because it provided
a sort of framework, simply, of comparing what is comparable.
After that, on the whole, unfortunately,
once you were finished with all the details analysis
of pottery techniques, we were left
with something of a lack in terms
of interpretive overall framework as well.
Yet, we had the feeling, all three together,
that everything was there.
When you think about it, there is nothing new to invent.
There's been a lot of work that has been done.
And in detail, many problems have been solved.
So the gist of that was, and how to relate
to the common topic of this conference,
is that we were left with something of a problem when
it comes to interpret technical variation.
We can show it exists.
We can analyze it.
We can show wonderful things about that.
But when it comes to the end of it,
it's difficult to say exactly why things are the way they are.
And Pottery Chez l'Opératoire doesn't solve that.
So what I'm going to present today
is really something of a toolbox approach.
We put in the toolbox everything that's
been done by other people.
There's nothing new.
Just a few things.
But nice details.
But mainly, everything has been done.
And we have this starting from the present approach, which
is typical of our work in Africa.
Because really, these days, I try
to erase the boundary between the present and the past.
And I think we do that because we
use a common analytical grid for the present and the past.
And that analytical grid is interesting for everyone,
I think, in this room.
So to explain things a little bit,
setting the context of this, I think
this is a classical view for archaeologists.
You have one type of vessel.
In this case, it's a water vessel.
And you can map its distribution area.
Now, when you look at neighboring areas,
you're going to see appearing other kinds of water jars
appearing.
And they are different stylistically, obviously,
just from the kind of visible style point of view.
So how can you explain that?
Well, if you follow the Chez Repertoire approach
and you split up these maps according to techniques,
you end up with a series of maps,
which I'm not going to describe in details now.
But you can see that the patterns are
completely different.
And the trouble is, of course, how do we move on from there?
Well, there's one good thing in there
is that we know that this is the result of history.
Previous maps and all these individual maps
are the result of history.
There is something to be told about them.
There's another good point.
It's that we know that these maps result
from putter's networks.
And that's interesting, because there
is a very good concept that has been appearing
in our toolbox, the concept of communities of practice.
And although Olivier stresses the fact
that it's very often misused, it is a very good, valid,
analytical unit in archaeology.
We will see that, in the end, we will not need it.
But it's a stepping stone.
So what is important when you deal
with communities of practice, and why is it useful for us,
is that the definition of Wenger says
that you need a common enterprise
to have a community of practice.
And that's easy.
In this case, we have puttering.
Second, you need mutual engagement, he says.
In this case, I will say physical engagement,
because it's easier to follow that in that way.
And then, in that respect, the physical engagement
is in the practice settings, where the craft is performed.
And then the other element of the definition,
the share of repertoire, is the last bit
of the definition, which is extremely important.
So common enterprise, it's done.
We know it's pottery, interest in pottery making.
The second point is physical engagement
in practice settings.
That's why I was asking this question of Valentin,
because about where do the potters meet.
That's a very important thing that we
saw in all over Africa.
It's that discussions, comparisons, relationships
happen in places where potters meet.
So clay sources will be a very important place.
Workshops, of course, and that's the relation
between the master and apprentice, for instance.
Firing structures are also places
where people share and exchange information.
And of course, markets are very important in that respect.
Now there's the notion of shared repertoire,
or you could say tradition.
But a repertoire is not a tradition.
It is a more narrow definition.
Here, I wanted to keep in mind that we're dealing,
I'm following the idea, all this is following a single type.
The one I showed you at the beginning, a jar, a water jar,
and you can very easily line up all the different ways
of making that type of water jar.
And that will give you several repertoires.
These repertoires are like the method, I would say,
or Valentin maybe will agree with that,
except it includes other elements which are not
completely the fashioning process.
You could add to that repertoire any archaeological information
you want.
You will see that after that, we will
need to map these repertoires.
That's how you start unfolding things.
This is the strict definition of the ways
of making a single type.
Now we have to keep in mind that there's
a certain degree of latitude in such a thing.
Everything that I say is trends and tendencies,
but potters are not like this.
So for instance, here you have the fact
that these repertoires, they're just
like a set of collective rules with a degree of change
possible.
And here you have the example of a water jar
from Mali, where the decoration changes only,
personal expression happens only in that small band just here.
And you see here a sort of set of all the possible variants
that are personal expression for that potter.
A student of us followed a training
with a potter from that village.
And when all the process was extremely rigorous,
she was holding her hand forcibly.
She said it was like having a hand in a vise.
You were really held tight to do this, this.
The shaping was strict, et cetera.
And when she arrived at decoration like this,
she did nothing.
And the student at that stage said, I knew my drill.
I did nothing until she told me so.
And then she said, you can go, you can go.
Now it's personal expression.
Express yourself.
And so she took the brush and the paint,
and she was about to stop when the potter stopped her again.
Said, you can express yourself, but don't do n'importe quoi.
So there again, there was the structure
and there was the variation.
Now in that artisan's perspective, of course,
this is where you see that it's important to compare
things which are comparable.
And that's why we were focusing on a single water jar.
Because for potters of this village,
this is the style of market pottery.
That's not including household, domestic things,
which are made slightly differently for the house.
But this is for the market.
And although the style is unmistakable,
there are degrees of variations, et cetera.
When you build repertoires, you have
to focus on a single type so as to make sure
that you're not going to make some undue comparisons.
Then in the latitude that is also that of artisans,
there are some changes, technical changes,
which are acceptable.
We will come back to that very important notion later.
But for instance, there's a place in Cameroon
where the most typical rocking bracelet that
was the way of doing a specific kind of decoration
on the shoulder of the vessel was replaced
by the twisted string roulette, which
filled the same space in a handsome manner.
And that change was acceptable for potters.
Now there's also a very important thing
is that repertoires constitute a reference framework, which
is very important for potters as a way
to relate, to compare themselves to their neighbors, et cetera.
And here you have the example of clay recipes in a village.
And what you can see here, this is
coming from Olivier Gosselin's work in Niger.
That's the way blacksmiths and weavers
prepare the clay for the same kind of vessels sold
in the same market changes.
And that's because they do not want to be mistaken.
They want to keep their specificity somewhere.
So again, history is in the details.
Identity, borders and frontiers can
be hidden in very small details of the repertoire.
Now, how are these communities of practice changing?
How are things changing in the technologies
that they are performing?
Well, according to Wenger, again,
studying communities of practice in the modern world,
he suggested two major mechanisms.
And for the moment, we have not been
able to prove him wrong for pottery in Africa.
So it always fits with these two mechanisms.
You have two basic mechanisms.
The one is alignment.
And that is coordination of action.
You will simply do as the other one is doing.
And the classic example of that is the relationship
between master and apprentice in the workshop.
The second mechanism at work is imagination.
He calls it travail d'imagination.
And this is simply that the technology has to make sense.
Things have to make sense.
If they don't, refusal is on making sense.
Here you have the example, the classic example,
of this vessel in this water jar I was discussing earlier,
coming from the region of Nyame in Niger.
They are considered in a very big region
as the most beautiful wedding jars you can offer someone.
But they are made only in one quarter.
And no one will copy them, because they
are made by slaves.
They're not known as slaves, but everyone
knows they are slaves, let's say.
And no potter wants to be mistaken for a Tuareg slave.
So these guys hold a monopoly in practice.
Now you're going to tell me, oof, very nice idea.
The definition is clear.
And we can see that in archaeology
and this community of practicing.
But how are we going to identify that?
Is there any chance of identifying that really?
Well, as always, nothing is perfect.
But C14 doesn't work everywhere either.
But there are contexts in which you could, I think,
identify communities of practice.
But that needs to be mapped.
You need mapping.
This is a crucial thing about talking about technology.
So you need to map the repertoires
that you have identified.
And with this sort of very simple repertoires
I was showing you earlier, you can
see that you have here two distinct repertoires.
Let's say the black one and the orange one.
And then the question, the classic question in archaeology
will be, how can we explain these repertoires?
What is the connection between these points?
I think that in the end, whatever
I say all the way down from here,
there are really three rules, absolute rules.
For once, Valentin, I agree with you.
It's an absolute rule.
Not for once.
There are many things.
But I remember disagreeing on something else.
That's why I'm coming back to it.
But the real thing is this separation, difference,
variations like this are due to one.
Let's say we're in archaeology.
So the first one would be chronological distance.
These people don't live in the same time frame.
They're not doing the same.
And there's all sorts of reasons why.
You couldn't have special distance
that people do differently because they live
far away from each other.
And now if you manage to prove that people
live in the same time frame and in the same geographic frame,
there is social distance.
And those three things rule everything.
Now this is, of course, very nice.
But can we explain that in a practical manner?
Well, there's a way of getting to these communities
of practice because you remember that one
of the most important elements of the definition
of the communities of practice was physical engagement,
being together, clinging places that you can actually
discuss together.
So I grant you that identifying the markets where
potters may have met is very difficult.
But as Valentin's work in the Levin showed,
you can do very detailed petrographic analysis
and gain a very detailed understanding
of the process in terms of raw material selection and recipes.
And if you can get to sources, clay sources,
then you can actually distinguish practice settings,
saying, well, in this case, we can split out this map
because here we have all these vessels were
made with the same clay.
This one too, actually, is way out.
But those ones, even though the repertoire
is the same all the way through, the actual clay
is slightly different.
Here, there might be something which is a bit blurry.
But clay sources may be selected on purposes which are similar.
Let's say we can say that these guys calculate this clay.
Those ones will use the clay.
See the common mind.
You can still see that there are different clay sources.
Now, this can be reinforced at the lower level
if we identify artisans, because you can actually
identify artisans in archaeology if you do detailed work
and you're mad like me.
You can count comb teeth to comb tooth and see the separation
and identify, actually, hands of potters,
particularly in the Neolithic or everywhere
where they use visible tools.
So you can actually identify the communities of practice
and you can identify individuals.
But most of you could say right now, OK, that's really neat.
Again, we see what you're saying,
but it doesn't fit with archaeology.
The maps we see in archaeology are
much bigger than the practice settings you're talking about.
Well, there is a unit of analysis
that was suggested by Wenger to go above the community
of practice.
And that is really what we're talking about in archaeology.
So in fact, you can forget about the rest,
but this constellation thing is the thing.
Basically, he says, when you are seeing convergences which
are much beyond the scale of practice settings,
but clearly involving different practice settings,
but showing common repertoires, then
you are dealing with a constellation.
A constellation is basically a constellation
of communities of practice.
It's not a single community of practice.
People engage every day in the work of pottery,
but they share something.
So these constellations, they can
come from sharing practice settings.
Like occasionally, you can meet up at a place or at a market,
and that will spread ideas to other communities of practice.
You can have movement of people.
People will marry in another community.
Or you can have the movement of objects,
typically through middlemen, as Valentin
was explaining earlier.
And that's very important.
That was not in Wenger's definition,
but I think this is more classic archaeology
or classic human geography.
You come back to also the fact that these constellations may
be structured geographically by geographic or human landmarks.
That's obvious that if there's a range of mountain,
or if you're living next to a river, that will impact.
It's everything that impacts on the circulation of people.
Clearly, as regards cultural factors,
you could say that trade routes, warfare between nations,
and things like that will have an impact
on the development, the spatial development
of these constellations of communities of practice.
I'm not going too fast.
Are you still bearing with me?
This is the difficult part of the paper.
Now, if you want to analyze that, basically,
that's what we're doing in archaeology.
You either have full concordance,
and I will leave that on the side,
because this is not very funny, when
you have a perfect match between repertoires.
And if we're dealing with situations of crisis,
it'll be more like partial concordance.
You can see variations at certain stages, et cetera.
Now, there are ways to explain this convergence
between the different repertoires.
You have three main categories of interaction.
What you need to do is to share.
You need to organize the repertoires
depending on the relationship underlying
the reproduction of the practice.
And this is where we are at the nut of things.
In the past, with the chain of our approach,
there was this idea that Arnold came up
with, saying that all this stuff about pottery and tradition
was a mechanical reproduction of things through time, et cetera.
The, comment s'il appelait ça?
L'enracinement psychomoteur, aussi, et cetera.
But basically, what we see when you talk with potters,
things change differently, because they
happen with different people in different places.
It's not mechanical.
So you have to look at things in this way.
And for instance, when you have direct and sustained
interaction, we can call it a shared learning history.
And that will be for the deep structures of technology,
like shaping methods, ornamental grammars, et cetera.
Now, if you go to a more casual interaction,
that could be categories and location of material,
types of tools, et cetera.
That could be a shared practice.
That could be when you go to the market
and you see that a potter is selling very well
this type of vessels.
You will see a decoration or something.
Sometimes you will invent, or we'll ask her,
and then you will adopt it.
And then things, and that's more in the last,
because for this you need, I'm sorry, I mismatched two steps.
The one I was talking is more about clay recipes and things
like this.
Now, when you go to the mediated interaction
and the consumption interaction, that's
something that can move pretty just by eyesight.
You see something, you copy it.
So if I go back to our little hypothetical example,
you can see that we can look at things
here and say that, in fact, all the orange dots,
they have a shared learning history
as compared to the other one.
Here, areas will match with shaping techniques,
as I mentioned earlier, painting techniques,
ornamental grammars, more or less.
And that will distinguish, if I come back to my example,
that will clearly distinguish the black tradition,
the repertoire, which is completely
different from the orange one.
Now, if you can split up things by considering shared practices
and seeing that, in fact, the clay source being different
here and here and here, you actually
have people who are not interacting on a daily basis.
The practice settings are not exactly the same.
And then that will happen mostly that
will have an effect on the type of tools that people use.
It will have an effect on the categories of material
that they use.
They may refer to, even though it
may be obvious for archaeologists
that the clay sources are different,
the way artisans look at them will be that,
like, we need to use gluey clay or sandy clay.
That's the way.
So even if you find that it's a different, altogether
different geological material for the potters,
the matching thing will be that it's a sandy thing.
And then you can see that people can
share the same idea of what needs to be a good clay,
even though they don't share the same clay source.
And finally, you can find a relationship of consumption
that will also be illustrated in our little example.
And typically, you will see that these areas of consumption,
they're basically where you use the same.
This is the upper layer of archaeological observation.
When you see similar types of vessels
with similar shapes and decoration,
they're fashion, let's say, areas
of where people share the same idea of how a water
jar should look like.
Now, in all these processes, we were
looking at processes of alignment
in different settings.
But the work of imagination is what's
going to limit things by saying what is acceptable
and what is not.
And in this case, from Niger, again from Olivier's work,
I was mentioning earlier that this water jar here
was being made by slaves.
In fact, in the area of Niamey here,
there's a borderline that you can see.
And on the other side here, some simple water jars,
they are real potters.
They could make that.
But they don't want to be mistaken for slaves.
So here, the boundary will be really clear.
On the other side, far away from Niamey on the eastern zone
here, people don't know who makes these pots.
They don't know it's made by slaves.
And actually, here, there's an area
where people make vessels like this very poorly,
because they only imitate them.
But they don't know that these vessels are made by slaves.
So they don't care.
But on the other side of the border
here, there's a new aesthetic that's coming up.
And it's the aesthetic of, let's say, Chinese animal wear.
It's the fact that things which are smooth and polished
are more beautiful.
And so the rough surface of these painted vessels
is not so much to the taste of people.
Now you're going to say, OK, this is all very well.
This mad rambling, is it true?
Does it work?
And how does it fit with the theme of the conference?
Well, the trick is, for me, this thing about crisis
is just that it's always the same thing.
It's interpreting variability.
And to do so, I think that what I'm trying to show today
is that if you map repertoires, if you build repertoires,
and if you map them in space, then you
will see things appear.
In this case, I want to show you what
happens when you look at an area which is most definitely
in crisis.
And it's in Katanga, in the Democratic Republic of Congo.
Basically, this is, you don't need to read it.
It's there just to know that it exists.
This is the repertoire with all the locations
where patterns, there's two pages like this,
where all the patterns were interviewed.
And when you map them, you can build repertoires by,
basically, this is shaping methods and ornamental methods
and tools, basically.
So you can build.
I don't call it a tradition, because there's just
two aspects of the Chez Repertoire.
But it already allows you to map things.
And you can put an A, B, C, D tradition,
much as you would do in archaeology, I guess.
And if you look at the, I don't have the time here
to detail this map.
So I'm just showing it like this to discuss it with you.
But if you look at, at first glance,
if you look at every step of the manufacturing process,
and even if you look at these repertoires, it's a mess.
It's a mess.
There are things everywhere.
You can see tendencies.
But basically, there are traditions a bit everywhere.
And it makes no sense.
It makes no sense unless, until you actually
look at the life of potters and their ancestors.
And then you can start drawing arrows in the landscape.
So now, if I look at these different, let's say,
repertoires and the movement of people,
things become much clearer.
In the north, you have the domain of tradition A.
The only A's that are down there have moved,
or their parents have moved.
And they are simply reproducing what their parents would do.
In the middle here, you have a sort of buffer zone
with B and C traditions.
Then you have something here, which is white.
And this is because it's a crisis area.
Now, today, the Mai-Mai militia have overrun the area
down to Lubumbashi here.
But when I was there, they were here, just north of the D.
And these guys are really very nasty.
They cut you in body parts, and they hang you in the villages
to show you where they're in power.
And in fact, these guys also show
are a parameter of the crisis.
Because a lot of the arrows going down,
mainly those guys here, a whole village
has moved down here in this area.
The only B here that you can see is actually
coming from there.
It's a whole village that moved because of the Mai-Mai.
They went and settled here.
On the other side here, D is a single potter.
She moved from this area also because of troubles
related to the war.
So interesting here is that you can
see this part of Katanga as a sort of either permanent crisis
or transition brewing with a lot of crisis.
But the two parameters which are very clear
is that, in fact, if I look at the past,
if I look at many things, because in fact, you
can make a sort of territory in the south,
mainly where I put the green, and a territory in the north
with a buffer zone in between.
I have not completely explained the buffer zone, honestly.
But tradition A is really related
to an old kingdom, the Luba Kingdom, who
ruled this area mainly towards the beginning
of the 19th century.
They entered internal strife for the succession of a king
just before the arrival of the Belgians.
In the south here, you had another empire,
which was the empire of the Kazembe of the Lualaba.
And it was strong there in the 18th century.
In the 19th century, some other guys
came in and took over this area.
But basically, what you see in the distribution
of tradition A and D when it is clean,
it's areas which we can call social spaces.
We call them social spaces until now,
which you could call also constellations.
They are constellations of communities of practice.
And the trick is, you can see that in a single time,
you have one ancient form of social space or constellation
which will linger in the landscape.
And I call it the remnants of social spaces.
And then you see all sorts of movements
that always lead to this area here.
Well, this area here, all the anomalies in the map,
they're not anomalies.
They are not random.
They are related to history, recent history of the Congo
since the 1960s.
1960, with the independence, people
were allowed to move in the country.
So hence, several of the movements.
And then following up on that and on the history of Congo
in recent times, wars, strife, et cetera,
have played their part.
But two factors lead to the appearance of people here
and the appearance of a mess of technology in this area.
The border with Zambia.
Zambia is cool.
Zambia works very well, incredibly well.
It's another universe.
Then you cross the border and you fall in hell here.
And the other thing is, here you have copper.
That's why I made the thing green.
It's the copper arc.
It's incredibly rich.
Even though Congo is a cesspit of hell,
because there you have copper, you have a semblance of order.
Potters are coming from everywhere to this zone
because this is where they can more or less survive.
And the trick is, it's true that today pottery, a bit
like you were saying, Valentin, pottery is not really trendy.
Congolese people in that area, they
think pottery is for peasants.
It's not modern.
So the potters who are there, they're
basically producing things as their mother did
and maintaining things.
But they're not the core of the fashion.
That's why also people can come in from other parts
and bring new technologies, new repertoires in the area.
Hence, B and D, and even the three Es here,
are coming from Zambia.
All these people are coming here because it's safe.
And the fact is, the technology is becoming extremely confused.
We're in a transition, maybe, period,
as you were putting it, Valentin.
But there you are.
You can see that finally, what I was seeing at the beginning
as a mess with things which are difficult to understand
all make sense if you take into account these repertoires,
if you map them.
And in terms of archaeology, there's
something very important to be picked up there.
It's that you can imagine that this is a synchronic map.
The fieldwork was done in a few years.
And so now it's impossible to access.
So basically, this could be, if you imagine the best of sites
where you're absolutely sure of all the dates,
you can see things like this happening.
And that's, I guess, what you were discussing this morning,
Valentin.
That in a single time period, you
can see things brewing up in a transitional period, rhythm
by crisis.
So by way of conclusions, I hope this,
I forgot to say at the beginning, is really
work in progress.
We're trying to build up something
with that, something that would match our different fieldwork
and where we could have a common ground of discussion
and a common ground of interpretation.
Of course, it's not finished, so we welcome any comments.
But by way of conclusions, as I told you at the beginning,
there's nothing new.
Nothing new, I think, with respect to good archaeology.
First, you need to choose a single type of vessel
when you work on something.
If you start mixing up the types,
then it's another kind of discussion.
You need to set a special scale, and that
will need to include variation.
So you need to build up your frame.
If it doesn't change in your field of work area,
then increase the scale until you see variation.
Then, of course, there's a chronological scale.
You have to narrow it down as much as possible.
And then we have to consider the structuring factors.
But we can even do that without the archaeology.
We can start with that by putting
in the frame the geographic landmark
and the cultural landmarks.
And I think that, particularly for antiquity or when you're
not working in Africa, you can already
put a lot of things on the map.
Then there's the question, for me,
of the analytical units that was really crucial.
And I hope to have shown you that we have the potter.
We have the community of practice,
which are valid archaeological units, in my opinion.
And then you have this constellation,
which is a good word because it relies on the rest.
It's not like culture areas.
It's not like social spaces, which I use myself,
which are, in fact, black boxes because you don't know exactly
what you're talking about.
And then there's the question of interpreting variations.
And I think that, although it's not finished in that respect,
I'm sure Valentin will have plenty of things to say,
there's something about defining the relationships where things
take place and who is involved in the chain.
And that would, I hope, bring some clarity
to the interpretation of Patricia Navarro's
and the variation in crisis or not.
Thank you for your attention.
Thank you.
