Which DRUGSTORE CONCEALER is the BEST for Dark Circles & Wrinkles? | I Tested Each One...

Cosmetics and Makeup tricks
241 followers
Finding the perfect concealer that covers up dark circles and yet
does not emphasize fine lines and wrinkles is the bane.
It is the bane of my existence, okay? It is
the biggest challenge ever and I am, I am on it.
Challenge accepted. I bought and tried every drugstore concealer that I could
find and I'm going to show them to you today.
In order to keep this fair, I blended out every single concealer using the exact
same clean concealer brush and then I showed
you the results in studio lighting and in natural day lighting, which is how
you would likely see it on yourself. As always, no filters or skin
softening of any kind has been used in this video.
Let's go. So let's start with Rimmel Kind & Free.
On the website, they say that this has a fresh, dewy
finish. So it's a hydrating, light coverage concealer
that's buildable. It's also considered a thoughtful choice at Shoppers Drug Mart.
So a thoughtful choice product is one that has no animal testing.
It's formulated without parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde, formaldehyde
releasing agents, hydroquinone, all of those things. I will leave a list
of the things that it's formulated without, okay? So if you're
looking for thoughtful choices, this does sit in that category. My
thoughts about this is that it has very light coverage. The
creasing and the separation of this was not terrible by any means,
but that's because it is such a light coverage formula. Typically, light
coverage formulas don't sit in fine lines as much. If you struggle
with very dark circles like I do, if you have blue or purple undertones under the
eyes, I can pretty much guarantee that this
just won't be enough for you. If you don't,
right, and if you just want to brighten without too much
density and you're looking for something that is
vegan or cruelty-free, all of that stuff, then this may be a really great option
for you. On my other eye, I use this one. This is
the NYX Bear With Me Concealer Serum. So this was rated the best drugstore
concealer that won't settle into fine lines by InStyle. I was very intrigued
when I read that. So this has medium coverage with a
natural finish that's not too dewy or too matte. This is also considered a
skincare treatment and makeup product hybrid. I love when brands put skincare
and makeup together. So this hydrates the skin for up to 24
hours, and because it's a serum, it has this really silky light texture,
which is really easy to blend and buff out. It also doesn't
exaggerate dehydrated skin, which can be a bigger concern with age. So that
crepiness under the eyes, this really doesn't exaggerate that. It
says that it doesn't on the website, and I agree. I don't think it does.
So my thoughts for this right away, I didn't love
that it doesn't have a doe foot applicator. The formula itself
is actually really beautiful. I loved it right away.
Does not crease a lot, does not get super cakey. It is
more coverage, way more coverage than the Rimmel Kind & Free.
The finish is luminous, but it's not too shiny.
It's really beautiful. I just hate that you have to pump it on your hand and
then, you know, pop it on the eyes. That's being
really picky. If this had a sponge tip or a doe foot applicator,
it would probably be like a perfect concealer. I'm very impressed. Really,
really like this. If you try it, let me know if you like it too.
Okay, let's move on to this guy. So this is the L'Oreal
Super Blendable Crayon Concealer. As soon as I saw this, I thought
I need this. I want this in my life so badly.
I was really, I don't know, intrigued by the crayon
shape of it. So the tip of this crayon allows for really precise
application. So if you have a teeny little pimple, you can use the
tip of this crayon, but you can also turn it on its side
and then you can cover more area with it. They say that this has
sheer to full coverage, so buildable as well, and they also say that it blends
easily and doesn't look cakey. So my thoughts for this, honestly,
it's great because it's really portable, it has pretty good coverage,
it blends perfectly, it has a really nice creamy consistency.
Although I like this and I think this could be a great
concealer even to use as a foundation. Like if you are having a natural makeup
day, you apply your sunscreen, you could pop
this on your forehead, the bridge of your nose, under your eyes,
maybe around here a little bit in the chin,
blend it all out. I think this would be lovely for that, like almost to stretch
out as a spot correcting foundation style
product. It's great, but I don't think it's full, full coverage. Like if
you have very dark circles, very dark blue, and you want
impactful coverage, this isn't gonna give it to you. Is this still great? Is it
still blendable and creamy and smooth? Absolutely. I love this product, I love it,
although it doesn't live up to what it says it does on the website.
Regardless of it, I'm really happy I have it in my, you know, concealer wardrobe
because I know I'll be reaching for that a lot, especially in the summer months.
Now, I compared it to this guy, okay? This is the True Match
Serum Corrector. This is also a hybrid skincare and makeup product.
It corrects like a concealer, hydrates like a serum, and provides
this instant dark circle coverage. It also says that it visibly de-puffs the
look of eye bags and helps iron out fine lines. Now, I don't
believe that really. I don't think that if you use this on
your eye bags, your eye bags are going to miraculously go away.
Puffiness under the eyes is a big challenge. I'm currently working on a
video where I'm testing a bunch of products on my husband who
has under eye puffiness because it's not as easy as you think.
Do I think if you buy this concealer, if you have puffiness, your puffiness is
gonna go away? Absolutely not. Like the marketing, they
just, they go so over the top with the marketing. But again, regardless of that,
it's still really good. This is a medium coverage,
radiant finish, and it really does leave the under eyes looking instantly brighter.
I got more coverage from it than from the L'Oreal crayons for sure. So if
you're looking specifically for under eye darkness, I think between the two of
them, this is the one I would go for. This one
is the Revlon Colorstay Skin Awaken 5-in-1 Concealer. On the website, they
say that this has light coverage, so natural looking coverage.
It's transfer resistant for up to 24 hours of wear.
My thoughts on this, I really like the sponge tip applicator.
This does dry down fairly quickly, which I actually don't mind because
if you have a lot of fine lines and wrinkles, when you have a formula
that's too emollient, like too wet and shiny that doesn't dry down,
it can really settle in those fine lines and wrinkles quite quickly. I'm sure a lot
of you guys have noticed that. So I do find this one to be a really
nice one for fine lines because it minimizes creasing significantly because
it does dry down. I'm not overly excited about this. I do
find that it has a lighter coverage, so it doesn't cover extreme dark
circles very very well. It was just okay. The next one is
this Revlon Flexwear Full Cover. These are actually pretty
different. They're both Revlon, but they're very different.
This one's 100% full coverage, so this is supposed to conceal imperfections,
redness, dark circles. It also has something called an Adapti
Flex technology, which basically claims to give you this
comfortable, breathable feel that moves and flexes with you,
and it's transfer resistant, fade resistant, 24-hour wear.
This is fantastic for those people that need full coverage. It really is. It has
an elasticity to it that's very unique. I could see this one
being a little bit thick for mature skin.
Almost too much coverage for most people. See, this is the crazy thing with
products. It's never black and white, right? I bet you guys wanted me to be
like, this one's garbage, this one's good, get this one, don't get this one.
There's so many factors, and those factors will determine what you need,
what you want, and what you like. For me, this one
is better because I have a lot of darkness,
and I want more coverage. But for someone that has less darkness,
maybe more lines, someone who's older than me, I really think you're gonna like
this one better. Okay, they're both good. I wasn't super
mind-blown impressed with this one just because
this isn't the type of formula that I typically gravitate towards,
but if I had a client, for example, in their 60s or 70s with not a lot of
darkness but a lot of lines, I'd definitely reach for this before I
would reach for that. So I hope that's helpful.
Let's move on to a concealer that I'm sure you guys have seen on the channel
before. Okay, this is the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser. This
concealer has been on social media for a while. You guys
can see I've used up, this is I think my second or third bottle of it.
The really nice thing about this, and what they say on the website actually, is
it has a really buttery formula and it glides on very easily.
There's a little click dispenser here so you just rotate it
and the concealer comes out and then of course you have your
sponge tip applicator. One of the cool things about this is that
a lot of people online, and it's actually marketed
to be really good for highlighting and contouring as well because you can like
pop it on really, really easily. You can grab a
shade that's quite a bit darker than your skin tone,
maybe grab a shade that's lighter, use it to highlight, contour, and conceal.
And because it has such a buttery formula, it does that
really, really well. It does have medium to lighter coverage though, okay? It's not
a super full coverage, which again, you don't
always want it to be, right? Because you want it to blend
and brighten and lift and sculpt, you might not want something that's too
tacky, too, too dense. This isn't tacky or dense,
it is light to medium, but it's great. Okay,
let's compare this to the Maybelline Superstay
Active Wear. This one's a bit different. So this is up to 30 hours wear,
plus it has a really unique applicator. They call it the Comfort Curve Flex
applicator. It makes it easy to apply. At the end of the day, it's a tiny
doe foot. Let's be real, it's a tiny doe foot. Do I
think this applicator is like mind-blowing? No, I think it's
fine, but I don't like rave about it, you know what I'm saying?
My thoughts on this, honestly, it's not bad. The creasing was not bad, especially
for full coverage, but I did still find, like between these
two, I still found the Instant Age Rewind one
to be much more brightening. Even though Instant Age Rewind isn't
supposed to be as full of a coverage, honestly, I found it to be more
brightening. This one is definitely more on the matte
side. Maybe that's why I found this to be more
brightening, because it doesn't lay as matte, but if I were to choose between
one of these, I would definitely reach for this one.
On to this guy. Oh, I had such high hopes for this.
All right, let me tell you what the website says about it first. So it's
infused with hyaluronic complex, vitamin C, and niacinamide.
It's supposed to give a bright, radiant finish with medium to full coverage,
and it's certified cruelty-free, which is great. Okay, this is what my thought is
on this. So this was the second time I bought it, because as soon as I saw
Simply Ageless, I always try those concealers, because I
do have a lot of fine lines around my eyes,
and I do have a big issue with creasing. Okay, you guys know if you've been here
for a while, that's my biggest issue for sure. So as soon as I
saw it, I bought this, and I was like 100%
invested in making this work for me, and within
three days, I literally threw it in the garbage. The formula itself
is really thin, yet creasy, which is so annoying. So it doesn't
cover up dark circles, and it creases. The worst thing about it, I would say, is
that it has a really weird applicator. This applicator
is so weird. It's supposed to be a cooling ceramic wand. Okay, that's what
they describe it, and it's supposed to be used to de-puff
without tugging. Like, listen, I get it. I get that it's
supposed to not tug, and we're not supposed to tug around the eyes,
but I just find that... How are you supposed to get the formula even out of here with
this, like, weird plasticky wand? I don't know. I don't get it. It would be
so much better if it was a doe foot applicator.
All right, I chose to compare it to this one, okay? CoverGirl Clean Fresh
Hydrating Concealer. So this one, again, claims to have a
glowy, buildable coverage. Vegan formula made without phthalates,
mineral oil, formaldehyde, talc, parabens, or sulfates. So the biggest
marketing thing with this concealer... Everyone always emphasizes one thing.
Like, this one's all about the wand being super cool. I'm like, it's not cool. It
sucks. But this one's all about, like, you can
highlight and contour with it, right? Every single one of these has, like, its
star thing. The selling feature of this one is
that it's the whole clean makeup thing, okay? It's called Clean Fresh.
Vegan, right on the bottle. It's all about clean makeup.
I might get, you know, roasted in the comment section below for this.
I don't buy the whole clean makeup thing, you guys.
I think slash know it's a total scam. I have a science background. I've gone
down that rabbit hole so many times looking
deeply into it, trying to, like, fully understand it.
I've watched a lot of videos about it. I talked to my dad about it, who's,
you know, quite a well-known scientist. And clean makeup
is just marketing, okay? It's just BS. There I said it. I know I
used that as a point in some of the other
concealers because I know a lot of you guys are looking for that because I see
that in my comments a lot. Like, please do a
whole look of clean makeup. And I'm like, oh, it's hard for me,
you know, because I respect that you want that. And I'm giving you options. That's
why I mentioned it in the other concealers. But I also think it's, like,
just, like, BS. Like, I just, I really think it's
BS. Regardless of that, though, putting the clean makeup thing aside,
this has very little coverage. I would never buy it again. It's probably the
worst one of the lot, in my opinion. Let's get into the highest coverage
concealers now. These ones are full, full coverage. Okay, so let's
start with this one. The E.L.F. Hydrating Camel Concealer. E.L.F.
is known to be cruelty-free, and a lot of people gravitate towards it because it
is cruelty-free. So that is actually amazing.
And I really do love so many, so many E.L.F. products. They say it's crease
resistant. We're going to get into that in a second.
And it's 16-hour wear. So this is the thing with this.
I loved this concealer at first. When I first bought it,
I was 10 out of 10 impressed with it. It's made its appearance in so many
videos. I've used it on so many models. I use it on myself forever, for months,
every single day. On camera, you will see that it looks like a dream. When you
put this on on camera, it's like almost shockingly impressive. When I use this
on my mature models on camera, it's like, whoa, because it's so luminous and
creamy, but so full coverage that, like, boom, the dark circles are wiped away
immediately. But off camera, there's a little issue with it that's actually a
big issue. It makes me so sad to say this because I loved this concealer, and I
still really want to love it. But it does separate quite a bit, and it can look
patchy and very dry. I don't know why, and I was so bummed. It didn't do that at
first, and I loved it. I used it on my models, and we, like, loved it. And then
after I used it for a few months, I'm like, why is it doing this? I recently
saw that Marlena Stel made a video, and she said the same thing about it. And
Marlena's a friend of mine, so I've talked to her a little bit about it as
well. And she said it's because it has kaolin in it, which is actually used in,
like, clay masks to draw out impurities in the skin. So it's known to be very
drying, which is bizarre because it's a hydrating satin finish concealer, but it
which is so strange. Like, it makes me wonder why they formulated it like that,
you know? So overall, I mean, if you are gonna be on camera like me, yeah, this is
gorgeous. But if you aren't, and if you have a lot of fine lines and wrinkles,
and you're gonna be a natural light with a lot of people, it wouldn't be my first
choice anymore. And that brings me to another one that's very full wear, okay?
This is L'Oreal Infallible Full Wear. This is an OG of mine. I've had this in my
pro kit forever. Actually, this one is pretty much empty. I should throw this
one out. I've used it on a lot of people, and I've used it on myself. I used it on
myself exclusively as my under eye concealer for probably at least a year.
This is the most pigmented and full coverage concealer of L'Oreal's concealer
bunch. It's waterproof. They say it's non-greasy, and it won't transfer, fade,
or flake. And it dries down to a thin, natural finish that lasts up to 24 hours,
okay? That's what the website says. So my thoughts about this after using this
for a very, very long time is that it's definitely the most full coverage
concealer at the drugstore. This is amazing for covering up hyperpigmentation,
red marks, or anything. The only thing is that this is very thick for under the
eyes. You know, the website says it dries down to this really thin consistency. I
don't agree. It doesn't. It doesn't. It's very thick for under the eyes. If you
have aging under eyes, mark my words. I'm telling you right now, I can almost
guarantee that this is going to be too much for you. It will cover your dark
circles 100%. It will, but it's also going to significantly emphasize your
lines. You guys have seen me do those before and afters where I use these
really thick concealers on one side and a lighter, more radiant concealer on the
other. And my one side looks so old and wrinkly and dragged down, and the other
side looks so lifted. This is the type of concealer that I think if you are
more mature and you have circles and lines, it's going to actually cover your
circles but age you. Again, makes me sad because this is a really excellent, very
full coverage concealer, but it's not great for a mature skin. If you are
younger though and you have pigmentation issues, but you don't have issues with
fine lines and wrinkles and creasing, then I think this would be a fantastic
option for you. Thank you guys so much for watching. I'm going to summarize all
of these into some really cool graphics, and I'm going to pop those all up on my
Instagram. So definitely follow me at GlamGirlGabby over there if you want a
place where you can see summaries of everything that I talk about in the
videos. We make really cool graphics over here so that it's a lot easier for you
to shop when you're actually headed out to the store. This video's over!
