BEETHOVEN PIANO CONCERTO NO. 5 (“THE EMPEROR”) PIANO TUTORIAL // How To Practice The 3rd Movement

Learning Piano
22 followers
Hi everybody, this is Danae and today I will be talking about Beethoven's 5th Piano Concerto.
I will be talking about the beginning of the 3rd movement specifically because it has a
pretty famous opening and it is also not that easy to play, there are some tricky passages.
Today I will tell you what I look out for, how I practice it, and how I make sure to feel
comfortable when playing this passage on stage. If you are interested in that, then keep on watching.
So the first tricky thing about this passage are the jumps in the left hand. The left hand is
continually jumping and you need to make sure that you're going to press the right bass note.
So I use a pretty interesting or maybe unusual fingering, I'm not sure if so many people play
like that. I play the bass notes with my thumb, not with my pinky like I usually would, and I do
this because I find that they have to have some weight and gravitas and I find that I can really
do this with my thumb safely. And also I must say that I do feel safer when using my thumb because
I place it on the black key in a way that it really builds across basically with the key,
not like this like I usually would, but I do it like this. Of course I practice
my left hand separately in order to secure those jumps.
An exercise that I do in order to make sure that those jumps are secure
is that I play one group of three and then before the next bass comes, which is the next jump,
I go until the key and then hover on top of it without pressing it.
I also like to turn around the pattern, so instead of playing
one, two, three, I play two, three, one, two, three, one.
Another thing that I find very important with this passage is that the first note really has to
wake you up and shock you because it comes right after the second movement. It is an
attacca movement, this beginning of the third movement, and in the second movement you are
playing the theme but in a pianissimo, dreamy, almost not audible way. And then you have the
fermata on the B flat and the next note is the bass with the right hand. I find that it really
has to be a shock that wakes you up. So I really put a lot of strength and power onto that first
bass and I almost think of it as a very strong accent because I feel like it really needs that
character-wise. And I don't necessarily want to put that accent onto my right hand because in my
right hand I want to keep the phrase going upwards. So my right hand is playing the phrase upwards
while my left hand is really accentuating the bass.
So I think it's important to add that I don't accentuate every bass in the same way. The first
one is really strong and then the other ones kind of come within that sound that the first one
created because I'm also using the pedal. I like to imagine a big bell in which the sound unfolds
and that first bass really fills that bell and then the other notes are within the sound bell
that the first bass created. Now after those first two bars we suddenly have a subito piano and a
different type of character all together and I think it's very important to get that subito
immediately. So once the harmony changes to the Bb major we have to be in piano. I immediately
take out the pedal. I play it in a much drier way with much less pedal than the first two bars
and more non-legato and I really try to emphasize that the character is different,
lighter, more playful than the first two bars.
Another difficulty is the trill in the right hand.
You are playing a Bb major chord and then the upper note has to trill
and what I do there is I simply lift the lower two fingers. So I press the chord
but then I lift the fingers and just trill on top. There's no need in my opinion to keep those
fingers on the keyboard and then trill on top which is very uncomfortable. Just
press it and then quickly lift them and play the trill separately.
Now we're getting into that octave section and there I also immediately change my mindset and
my attitude towards the character of the piece and here I think of holding back. I kind of think of
sticky fingers to the keys because I find that the danger is to kind of run and go a little bit
too quickly when that passage comes. So I think of sticky fingers, something holding me back.
I kind of imagine that it's a little bit hard to move forward because I think that these octaves
with the chromatic scale that they are playing around with are really a symbol of it's a little
bit harder to get to the end of the phrase as opposed to just Eb major chords that go upwards
in such a majestic way. Also important to add is that this chromatic octave scale
is interrupted by two bars that remind us of that majestic beginning. Those two bars are in Bb major
again and I think there we can get back to the more pedal, more majestic character and then
back to those sticky octaves that are having a bit of a harder time to move forward.
And then if you're performing this with orchestra then of course you are aware that this passage
ends where the orchestra comes in. So be aware of the fact that you are not ending this phrase
on the piano. You are ending in the middle of the phrase and the orchestra is coming in and picking
up that phrase exactly where you left off. So when you end this passage you have to have in mind
that you're not ending the phrase, you're ending it in the middle. So end it with kind of an open
end and feel as if you were about to continue playing it. That way the conductor and the
orchestra have a chance to pick up right where you left off and bring it to the end.
So I ended at a not fully developed crescendo, at a not fully developed tension. I ended right
in the middle in order to give the orchestra the possibility to continue. So this is my
interpretation of the opening of the third movement of Beethoven's Fifth Piano Concerto.
I hope that you found this interesting and helpful. Let me know in the comments down below.
Let me know if this is similar to your interpretation or if you have a completely
different take on it. I would also be interested to hear that because of course there are so many
different ways to play this concerto and it has been played in so many different ways.
So let me know what you think about that. I also want to wish you a happy new year.
In a couple of days we're going to start the new year 2022. I am very excited about this.
The past year has been very hard in some ways for everyone because of different reasons but also
very exciting for me. Many new exciting things happened and I am so grateful for this channel.
I'm so grateful that this community grew so much more and I'm really looking forward to many new
exciting videos in the new year and to listening and well more reading your opinions and all your
comments. They make me so happy and I wish you all the best. Have a great rest of the year and
a great start and I will see you again in the next video in the new year. Bye!
