Average property insurance payment up 52% for single-family homes from 2020, says ICE VP Andy Walden

Invest Insight
9 followers
5 Video Views·Oct 8, 2024
Andy Walden, ICE vice president of enterprise research, joins CNBC's 'The Exchange' to discuss how natural disasters have impacted insurance costs for Americans, where storm-impacted homeowners are relocating to, and more.
As she mentioned, it's not just borrowing rates that are climbing.
Property insurance is also on the rise.
Everyone's been seeing it, especially if you're in an area that's been hard hit by
natural disasters.
The average mortgage payment just hit a record two thousand and seventy dollars in
August. And with Hurricane Milton now a Category 5 storm barreling toward Florida
less than two weeks after Helene caused billions of dollars in damage.
It's unlikely these insurance costs will come down anytime soon.
Joining us to talk more about that, Andy Walden is vice president of Enterprise
Research at ICE.
Andy, it's good to see you.
How much is insurance up kind of from the trough?
Yeah, if you look from four and a half years ago, we kind of started the beginning of
the pandemic. The average property insurance payment for a single family homeowner in
the U.S. is up about 52 percent from where it was four and a half years ago, much more
significant than the average principal interest in tax rise of 15 to 17 percent among
folks. So it's three times the rise that you're seeing in property insurance versus
some of these other expenses.
So home insurance costs are basically up 50 percent since, as you said, maybe about
2020. I mean, that is a massive.
Do you know what the average property insurance cost is for homeowners these days?
If you look at the average monthly payments, about one hundred eighty one dollars per
month on average for the typical U.S.
homeowner. But it can vary significantly depending on where you live across the
country. And when you look at some of those hurricane prone areas, you look at New
Orleans, it's about five hundred dollars a month.
You look at Miami and you're talking close to five hundred dollars a month as well.
So for some of these folks, you're talking one out of every four dollars that you pay in
a month on principal interest taxes and insurance is just going to that monthly property
insurance payment. Is that cracking the market in certain areas?
I just saw data that in Tampa Bay, which we're all concerned about with with Milton
bearing down, that their listings are up, I forget the number, maybe 60 percent year on
year. But demand is down 10 percent.
And that could, of course, accelerate after whatever we see take place this week.
Is it going to have a longer term effect on on the housing markets in these areas?
Yeah, I think it will. And it's happening for two reasons.
You mentioned insurance there.
Certainly when you look at home prices as well and you look at, again, what's happened
over the last four and a half years, those are some of the areas where you've seen the
largest home price gains, putting pressure on just typical home affordability.
But then you tax 70, 80, 90 percent property insurance growth in some of those
specific areas that you just mentioned on top of that.
And absolutely, you're seeing pressure there.
And when you look at the areas that are back to, quote unquote, normal levels of home
affordability, it's those hurricane prone areas of Texas, hurricane prone areas of
Florida where you're starting to see that inventory rise and you're starting to see
some of the softer home prices across the U.S.
as well. Where are those people going, Andy, if they feel priced out or sort of don't
desire living in those areas anymore because of cost, because of reconstruction, what
have you? Do you know where they're relocating to?
It's a good question.
Part of that is, I mean, Florida is kind of a typical inflow from the New York area
heavily. And so you could see some folks that just simply aren't investing in second
homes down there in Florida.
If I'm looking at it from a buyer perspective, I'm certainly looking at some of those
more central areas where home affordability is much stronger, not only compared to what
you're seeing down in Florida, but compared to their own long run averages as well.
And so I think it's possible you could see some migration towards some of these central
areas that, one, have lower risk overall, but two, have more of a
broad sense of home affordability, even with rates kind of hanging in the six now up to
closer to six and a half percent range.
You're still seeing relative home affordability in those areas of the country as well.
I agree. I think that's I don't want to call it a problem, but it's kind of the
conundrum. It might still be cheaper to go to Florida with high insurance costs than to
live in the Northeast, for example.
You mentioned that there are a couple of markets nationally where we're already seeing
prices begin to fall. And I shouldn't say already because it's not an assumption that
they're going to fall on a national basis at all.
But where are the places where we are seeing some downward pressure?
Yeah, I mean, really, when you look across the Rust Belt, that's the area of the
country where inventory is returning.
And inventory has been that key component to price softness.
Anytime you've seen inventory get back to the levels that we typically expect to see in
those areas, I'm talking 2017, 18, 19 levels, prices have come down.
And it's really across the Rust Belt region centered around, again, Florida.
If you look at the softest home prices over the last couple of months, they've come in
the state of Florida. Almost all major markets there are seeing prices ease on a
seasonally adjusted basis.
Austin continues to see some softness.
And you're seeing it in some of those other Rust Belt areas, Nashville and in the sort
where we saw, again, migratory inflow, stronger than average home price growth.
Even for what we saw in the rest of the country during the pandemic, you're seeing a
little bit of reversal in course there just because, again, there's relative
unaffordability with how many folks moved in and how high home prices pushed in those
areas. Yes. So it sounds like those are more actually the Sun Belt kind of areas.
I would I anecdotally understand that the Midwest, Northeast, some of those markets
are actually holding up a little bit better.
Yeah, I mean, they're coming down from where they were, but those are still the
strongest areas of the country, the Midwest, because of relative home affordability,
the Northeast, because there simply isn't any supply up there and you're you're
bouncing subpar demand up against next to nothing in terms of supply and very little
improvement in supply in the Northeast.
And that's where you're seeing home prices remain sticky.
All right, Andy, thanks as always for your time today.
We appreciate it. Andy Walton with ICE.
