The Magic of FLOUR in FROSTING | Ermine Frosting Guide

Comida Cultural
568 followers
Today we're diving into the world of ermine buttercream, one of the most unique frostings.
Now I've studied a lot of buttercreams. This one stands out for its texture, stability,
and versatility. The science behind it is fascinating. It's because it uses a sweetened
flour paste which then gets combined with butter. This creates a frosting with the following
characteristics. It has a lighter texture. With a butterfat content at 20%, this frosting is
deceivingly light and some describe it as whipped cream-like with a delicate yet creamy texture.
It tastes less sweet. Coming in at 27% sugar content, this buttercream is one of the least
sweet. It is more heat-stable. Ermine buttercream is relatively more reliable than most buttercreams
as it can withstand slightly warmer temperatures. It is easy to modify. Ermine's simple ingredients
offers flexibility, making it easy to adjust and customize for different flavors. Now this
frosting has been around for probably a hundred years and there are many right ways to make it.
So I'm going to start with showing you my base recipe and along the way I'll explain how it
works so you can become an ermine frosting expert. The ingredients I'll need for this frosting are
all-purpose flour, sugar, whole milk, heavy cream, unsalted butter, and flavor enhancements such as
The first thing I have to do is make the flour paste. To prep I'll set aside a flat tray or plate
along with a strainer. So into a pan I'm going to add the flour and sugar and whisk in the milk
and heavy cream and I'm going to heat this on medium low until it thickens into a paste. The
secret to a super smooth texture with your ermine buttercream is evenly distributing the starch
granules from the flour within the milk. So to do this I'm going to whisk for this entire step.
Now once I see the bubbles pop in the center, the paste is near or at boiling temperatures,
I'm going to start my timer and whisk the entire time. And the formula is one minute for every cup
of liquid and here I'm using about two and a quarter cups of milk and heavy cream so that's
two minutes and 15 seconds. Cooking for this long ensures that I dissolve all the sugar and cook
all the flour thoroughly. It also dissolves some of the water so the end result is a thick and
smooth flour paste. Now I'm going to scrape this into my tray. If you're aiming for a silky smooth
texture it's a good idea to run this through a sieve to ensure that there are no lumps formed
during the whisking process. Now I have to let this cool to room temperature. If you leave it
uncovered evaporation will occur more quickly on the surface of the paste and that'll thicken
into a skin and that'll cause lumps in your frosting. So to prevent this I take a piece of
plastic wrap and I spray it with a bit of oil and cover the surface directly to prevent this
from happening. Now I'm going to aerate or lighten the texture of the butter a bit and to do this we
want to ensure that the butter is at around room temperature. So I add the butter to my mixing bowl
and whisk on high speed for about two minutes. The butter should be lighter in texture and color
but still ball up inside the whisk. Here you can see the before and after. So out of the box butter
does contain a tiny bit of aeration. It's about one to seven percent of the butter's total volume.
That's actually made of air. So it's very little and I find that when I add butter just straight up
into an ermine buttercream it makes it slightly denser. So I like to aerate my butter to give it
a lighter texture. Fat absorbs flavor very well so during this step I also like to add my vanilla
and salt. Now I'm going to combine the paste and the butter together. Here you can see how thick
my paste is. You can easily pick it up with a spatula and now I'm going to add the paste in
about four to five additions. I'm going to add the first amount then whisk on high speed for about
30 seconds before adding the next amount of paste. At the end of this step the frosting is going to
have these huge air pockets because I used the whisk. It's going to look uneven but it's okay
as long as I don't see any patches of flour paste streaked within the bowl. Now I'm going to switch
over to the paddle attachment to smooth out the buttercream. If you have the one with the silicone
edge that one's my favorite for smoothing out frostings but the metal one works really well
too and you're going to mix on low speed for at least two to three minutes. At the end of this
step the frosting will look smoother but it might still have a few air pockets. That's normal and
that's okay. Because this frosting has a lower ratio of butterfat and uses that kind of sticky
flour paste it doesn't get 100% smooth at this step so don't let this deter you. Once you use
a metal spatula over the surface it's going to smooth out a lot more. The final texture of ermine
buttercream might be a little bit softer than what you're used to particularly if you're coming from
another buttercream like American buttercream which is the butter and powdered sugar variety
or even something like Swiss meringue buttercream. The texture is often described as something
between a whipped cream and a buttercream and this texture proved to be a little bit problematic when
I was trying to smooth it onto my red velvet cake. There were times when this separation occurred
almost as if the emulsion had broken when I was trying to smooth out the size of the cake with
a scraper. I would have to go over small spots repeatedly to get it smooth. I would say that
it probably took 50% longer than it normally takes me to frost a cake. With piping it does
perfectly fine. It can pipe super intricate designs and tall swirls no problem. My takeaway for this
is that if you're a beginner I would suggest trying another buttercream if you're just learning
how to get that super smooth exterior on a cake. On the other hand if you're a veteran cake decorator
be sure to just give yourself a little bit of extra time or at least be okay with having the
cake look a little bit more rustic. Ermine buttercream has better heat stability than most
other buttercreams. I did a video a while back comparing the stabilities of various buttercreams
by placing them in a heated and humidified tank. Of all the eight that I tested ermine buttercream
was the top buttercream. It held its shape at temperatures up to 90 degrees fahrenheit and 74%
humidity. So I think the heat stability of this buttercream is due to a fundamental characteristic
and that is that there's a lower ratio of butter which leaves room for a higher ratio of that
sweetened flour paste. Now the sweetened flour paste is very well suited to endure warmer temperatures so
let me explain. The sweetened flour paste gets its thickened texture because of the flour. When the
flour is heated with water the starch granules in the flour absorb the water and swell and as the
heat increases the granules break open and some of the starches inside leak out. This process is
called gelatinization and as the mixture cools some of those starches can stick together and trap
water and this forms a gel. This process is called gelation. This flour paste gel is heat stable at
least around the ambient or even warmer room temperatures that cakes are typically served.
To put it in perspective butterfat starts to melt around 90 degrees fahrenheit. Starch based gels do
break down and it sometimes depends on the type of starch but generally they start to melt at 140
to 158 degrees fahrenheit. This is why you'll see butter heavy butter creams deflating before
ermine which has a good amount of that sturdy starch gel to hold it in place. Now the ability
for the sweetened flour paste to give us that heat stability hinges on another important interaction
and that is how well does the paste emulsify with the butter and what I found is that this is
dependent on the type of milk that you use in the paste. I conducted an experiment to test how
different milk fat contents affect ermine frosting texture. The control in the middle uses whole milk
to its left I tested two percent milk and then skim or non-fat milk. Towards the right I wanted
to see what happened when I increased the amount of milk fat. I tried a mix of whole milk and heavy
cream and lastly whole milk with added buttermilk powder. I apologize that it's hard to see in this
video but the differences are very clear in person. The emulsion loosens as the fat content decreases
making the frosting harder to smooth. There are large uneven pockets of liquid and tiny butter
fragments sliding around and I find that this issue becomes even more pronounced in larger
batches as mixers can struggle to emulsify them properly. So from this I gathered that it's better
to work with higher fat milks and you may be wondering why I didn't just test adding more
butter to stabilize the frosting. Butter is high fat but it's not the right kind and it typically
has the opposite effect and will make the buttercream looser. We need a specific kind of
emulsifying fat and these get drained off during the butter making process and into buttermilk which
is why sweet cream buttermilk is such a great emulsifier. That's why in my recipe in addition
to milk I add heavy cream which contains a good amount of those emulsifying fats and I like the
texture with one part heavy cream to two parts whole milk. Heavy cream is such a good concentrated
form of these fats that it allows us to easily make modifications to this recipe. Classic vanilla
is the traditional flavor for red velvet cake but this frosting can go in many different directions
and the idea is that if you keep a couple core ingredients constant you can modify the others
to come up with some really unique flavor combinations. To understand how to modify this
buttercream it's easier if we break down the composition into modifiable sections. So I have
the butter and then I have the sweetened flour paste which is heavy cream and the milk, the sugar
and the starch. The things that we don't want to touch here are the butter and the heavy cream,
the other components are more or less fair game. So I'm going to briefly cover starch substitutions
here but you can find a more detailed write-up on my blog. I tested various flours expecting
differences in the ermine buttercream stability as gluten in wheat flour is thought to contribute to
it. However, I found that gluten plays little to no role. Most flours I tested were gluten-free
and the frosting's stability remained consistent. I found that the more important factor is the
starch's gelatinization strength, its ability to gel and firm up a liquid. You can check my blog
for the current substitutions including how to use cocoa powder to make a chocolate version.
Now the milk substitution is where I had a little bit of fun with flavors. You can either use water
or whole milk ideally and steep things in it like teas and herbs and then use that in place of the
whole milk in the recipe. So to demonstrate the fun you can have here, I created a boba shop
frosting collection and first up is my Korean banana milk buttercream. For this one I'm going
to swap out just one thing, the whole milk for pre-made Korean banana milk and the process is
exactly the same. I'm going to heat the sugar, flour, banana milk and heavy cream until thickened
and allow that to cool and mix that into whipped butter. I'm not sure how they get this banana milk
to not taste very artificial but the end result is so delicious with just the right banana flavor.
When I was at the store there was also taro, melon, and strawberry milk. Those could all be easy
modifications. With my second flavor I went with a Thai green tea buttercream. This expands on the
idea that you can steep flavors into water and use that in place of whole milk. For this one I'm going
to swap out the whole milk for tea and to change things up I'm going to substitute the all-purpose
flour with tapioca starch. What I found worked best is to double the concentration of tea. This
will ensure that you get a strong enough flavor as it will get diluted with the other ingredients
in the buttercream like the butter and heavy cream. So for this recipe instead of using five
grams of tea leaves for 300 mils of water, I'm going to use 10. I'm going to steep that for
four minutes and then strain out the leaves. I also find that these steeped liquid ermine recipes
need a bit of sweetness above what's indicated in the base recipe. So what I do is sweeten the tea
concentrate with a bit of sugar. This is up to you. I liked about two tablespoons of white sugar
and because that usually creates more tea liquid than what you need for the recipe, you're going to
have to measure out the exact amount to replace the milk. So for a three cup recipe that's one
cup of sweetened tea. And then I'll just proceed with the same protocol. I'll make the flour paste,
let it cool, and then add it to whipped butter. And this one was so good. Thai green tea is
different than the one that you probably get at your local Thai restaurant that's made with black
tea. It's very floral, usually made with jasmine as well as other flavors like pandan and vanilla.
The moment I opened up this bag of tea, I was in heaven. It smells exactly like the Thai desserts
I grew up eating. I also did a Vietnamese coffee version which follows the exact same concept
and yielded one of the best and potent coffee buttercreams I've ever tasted. And for the last
version, I made a strawberries and cream buttercream using a puree from frozen strawberries
and a little bit of sugar. I pureed and strained the strawberries, then substituted the puree for
whole milk and cooked it as usual. An interesting observation is that I tried to make a version of
this using mochi flour to make a strawberries and cream mochi buttercream, but the texture was a
which reduced the water ratio and was unable to hydrate the rice flour properly. So for a fruity
ermine, I recommend using fruit juice because then you can use any type of starch. But if you
want to use a puree like I did here, make sure to only use all-purpose flour. I can try to develop
a more generalized fruity ermine recipe if there's enough interest. Speaking of developing recipes,
if you want to try any of these, they're linked down below. I even have a no-cook version of
ermine buttercream that uses instant pudding. I didn't have time to go over today, but my favorite
flavor of this modification is the cheesecake one. It yields a light and creamy frosting with a light
cream cheese flavor. You can make it in about 10 minutes with no cooking. So that's all for today!
Happy baking, everyone!
