The exercise secret for longevity: Martin Gibala, PhD

Health Longevity
19 followers
26 Video Views·Oct 7, 2024
A few minutes of daily vigorous physical activity, getting out of your comfort zone,
maybe huffing and puffing a little bit, is a very effective health strategy.
And look for ways to get uncomfortable once in a while throughout the day.
Your body will thank you for it.
Your mind will thank you for it.
You'll be a lot happier and healthier 20, 30, 40 years from now.
So how do you define high-intensity interval training?
Repeated bouts of hard work interspersed with recovery periods.
Now, the key question is probably how do we define hard?
You know, I think people get this notion that, okay, the exercise is intermittent.
I do something.
I take a bit of a break.
I go hard again.
So how we define hard is it depends on the context.
And so hopefully that's a freeing message for a lot of people that you don't need to
magically meet this single percentage of your maximum heart rate, however you would measure that.
So let me break that down.
In a health or an exercise prescription context, hard means vigorous.
And vigorous is well-defined in public health guidelines, in guidelines from various agencies.
And so it's around 77% of your maximum heart rate.
It's about a seven or eight on a 10-point scale.
So if 10 is sprint from danger pace, save your child from an oncoming car.
One is laying in bed.
You know, moderate exercise is a five or a six.
Vigorous is a seven or eight on that scale.
You couldn't have a conversation with your workout partner,
but you could spit out a couple of words and phrases.
So squarely between the 70 and 80% of max heart rate if you're wearing a wearable that tracks that.
Yeah.
And on the upper end of that, as I say, that 80% guideline is pretty good.
And so if people want to aim for that, but it's not the only one that they can measure,
because of course lots of things can affect your heart rate.
But on the higher end of that 70 to 80% would be if you could think of it as
the minimum effective dose of high-intensity interval training.
And what's the minimum effective duration?
That would be the other key question.
Work that we've done, and where the name of my book, The One Minute Workout, came from was
we've done studies looking at three 22nd bursts of hard effort.
Now that doesn't mean just getting to that minimum vigorous pace.
There you're working much harder than that.
And so effectively when it comes to HIIT, there's an intensity duration trade-off.
If you're willing and able to sprint or work very, very hard,
you can get away with a surprisingly small dose of exercise and it can still be beneficial.
Now, if you're the other end of that scale, you know, you're just getting into the HIIT range,
77% or so, we're not going to suggest that you could do three 22nd efforts like that.
And it's going to provide you with robust health benefits.
Of course, anything is better than nothing,
but think of it as that intensity duration trade-off.
So, okay, I think you sold a lot of people on the one minute workout.
Assume we're somewhat trained because you don't want to encourage someone who's
never done anything to get off the couch and try to go to a 100% max heart rate.
But assuming we are trained, tell me more, how can one have that one minute workout?
Yeah.
So the studies, the classic studies that we did were three 22nd bursts
within a total time commitment of 10 minutes.
So you can imagine, you get on your workout bike, you warm up for two or three minutes,
you do a 22nd sprint, rest or recover for two minutes, do a second sprint,
another two minutes of recovery, do a third sprint and a short cool down.
So start to finish 10 minutes, but within that 10 minutes, you've only done one minute
of very hard work, these three 22nd sprints.
And what we've seen is the improvements that you can see over several months,
the improvements in your VO2 max, the improvements in other health-related markers
is very similar to what we associate with a much larger dose of the more traditional
moderate intensity continuous training.
So we're not saying that HIIT is the only way or it's the best,
but it's an option for a lot of people and especially those who cite time as a major barrier.
It's always time and money, right?
Those are the major barriers.
And so how often, how many days per week do we need to do this?
Yeah.
And so our classic studies have been three times a week.
So the vast majority of HIIT studies are three times a week.
And so, you know, I can confidently say here,
if reasonably trained people would do that three by 20 workout three times a week,
they're going to improve their VO2 max.
They're going to improve their cardiorespiratory fitness.
Now, there's no free lunch.
That type of training is very demanding.
It's extremely uncomfortable for a lot of people.
Now, some people will say, you know what, that's okay.
I'm willing to work very, very hard if I can get away with a very small amount of time.
Other people try it and say, that sucked.
I absolutely hate that workout.
I'm never going to do that again.
And so now what we're trying to do is say, okay, well,
if it's not all out, how high do you have to get in order to make it beneficial?
And so we've started to, you know, do some work with what we call vigorous stair climbing.
So people, you know, ascend the stairs at a challenging pace.
They're not sprinting up the stairs.
It's not safe.
And so that's where some of our research is going now is sort of this idea of,
okay, how hard you have to work and how little a dose can still provide some benefits.
I love that question.
And before we touch on benefits and VO2 max,
I want to talk about something I struggle with and it's RPE.
So the rate of perceived exhaustion.
And I think that's defined as this feeling like I can't go anymore.
I'm out of breath.
I'm done versus heart rate zone.
Zones one through five, five being 90 to 100% of your max heart rate.
And something I've personally found, and I'm not alone,
is sometimes the two are not correlated.
And so, for example, I don't run.
I hate running.
But if I joke, if I run, that means I'm being chased.
Call the police.
I'm in danger.
So I row and I'll do the ski machine.
And I'll find when I do the ski machine at my local gym,
and if I go hard, I hit RPE fast, much faster than I would rowing.
But my heart rate can't get to the 90 to 100%.
I ended up running out of steam at like zone three to 70, 80%.
And I'm like gassed.
I'm done.
Whereas rowing, I can just hold zone three, zone four.
And sometimes I just have trouble getting to zone five to like get winded,
but I don't feel it.
And so I just walk away confused.
I say, here I am working my butt off on the ski machine,
and I run out of gas quickly.
And I'm at zone three.
Whereas I can hold zone three or zone four rowing, and I'm okay.
And get to zone five, and I just have trouble holding it.
But it's not because of I'm running out of gas, so to speak.
So I just left.
I don't know what to do.
It's a classic conundrum.
I feel your pain.
And it's actually, to make a serious point, it's one of the things that makes the
challenge of translating high-intensity interval training,
especially when you're working at these very high intensities, so difficult.
And so a quick minor correction, it's rating of perceived exertion, RPE.
So not rating of perceived exhaustion.
And so those are different.
But you can think of it as, it's basically how hard are you working, right?
And a 10 on either exhaustion or effort.
If you're working at a 10, you're working really hard.
So in some ways it doesn't matter there, but that's what RPE is.
And to your point, the higher the intensity, the greater the disconnect
between that feeling of effort and your heart rate.
So the heart rate response lags.
And so there's a classic test in exercise physiology called the Wingate test.
It's on a specialized bike.
It's 30 seconds of all out, as hard as you can go effort.
It's one of the most demanding tests you could imagine, you know, where it's,
you're 10 minutes in and you're just gassed, you're dying on it.
But at the end of the 30 seconds, you've worked extremely hard and you're just exhausted,
but your heart rate might be 70% of maximum because of that lag.
And so this is where I think RPE has value,
especially when it comes to prescribing high intensity interval training,
because we all have this subjective scale and RPE is influenced by many different things.
And so your relationship between your heart rate and perceived effort
can differ depending on the day.
Did you have a good sleep or not?
Are you under a lot of stress?
Did you drink last night?
All of these things can affect your heart rate response to exercise.
And so I think effort-based training can be exceptionally valuable.
So what should we pay more attention to,
the effort and the exhaustion or the zone, or is it a little bit of both?
So I think the nice thing about using different metrics to define high intensity interval training
is you can use the one that appeals to you most.
So for example, some people absolutely love wearables and their phone
and they, or they wear a heart rate monitor religiously
because they absolutely want that objective feedback.
Where am I?
You know, I don't want to go too high.
I don't want to go too low.
Other people are, but you know, others can feel,
I don't want to be a slave to that, right?
I just want to go with how I'm feeling.
And so, you know, if I'm going for a run
and my heart rate says you're getting into your highest zones, but you feel great.
Some people say, I just want to go for it.
And so I think that's the way people should look at it is
either metric can be an effective indicator of how hard you're working
and choose the one that works for you,
or at least be okay to go out of your comfort zone once in a while,
in terms of whatever metric you like.
You know, now, if you're an athlete, sometimes coaches are going to say,
no, we do heart rate based training.
Others are going to say,
obviously there's a lot of lactate based training now,
but some people are fine to go with perceived effort.
And so I like that idea of using different metrics,
choose the one that works for you.
And don't feel that HIIT is singularly defined by any single one of those.
Fair point.
And if we assume that the one minute workout, if you will,
three times a week, a total of 10 minutes is the minimum effective dose.
When do we see diminished returns?
What's too much for most people if they're just looking for longevity benefits?
And these are where, you know, you don't like to have the guess on,
especially the cautious scientists who every answer is, well, it depends, right?
But it does depend a little bit.
And probably the biggest reason why it depends is we're all so variable.
So there's huge inter-individual variability in responses.
You know, I could take a hundred of your listeners,
put them on the exact same interval training program.
Some are going to thrive.
Some are going to wither.
Some are going to really enjoy it.
And some are going to burn out or overtrain very, very quickly.
And so there isn't a, you know, you'll read on the internet
or read in the latest health magazine.
Well, you know, if you're doing HIIT more than twice a week, it's too much.
And others will say, you know, you can do HIIT five times a week.
It's fine.
And so I think that's what it is, is we're all a little bit different.
And so I think for an individual, there's a little bit of, you know,
you got to try it out a little bit and see what works for you
as unsatisfying an answer as that is.
But generally speaking, we can, you know, we can see people do well
with three times a week of interval training.
That doesn't mean they have to do it.
And, you know, I, you know, you've had some guests on recently.
I listened to Andy Galvin's interview with you.
And, you know, I think you hit on some very good points there.
Like you got to push it once in a while.
Right.
And so even touching into that zone once a week is fine.
But ideally you're also doing something that lasts an hour every week.
That's, that's moderate.
So the best approach is a variable one to try and, you know,
hit on all of these areas.
The other analogy that I'll use, it's a bit like the stock market, right?
And so probably the best approach for most people is to invest in some
boring mutual funds or to spread out your risk.
You know, you might get rich with a single stock pick.
You might find that singular workout that really just happens to work for you.
But for most people, doing a variety of things is going to be best for them over the long term.
Yeah.
I'm glad you brought up that point and mentioned Andy's interview, which I love,
but I also left with a lot more questions.
And so I think you bring up a good point.
If you're doing the traditional VO2 max workout, which is the once a week,
and it is all out in the interview with Andy, we described, you know, the sprint,
you know, you sprint for a quarter mile, then walk and then sprint and so forth for a mile.
It's probably going to take you 20 minutes, 30 minutes,
maybe a little less if you're a really seasoned athlete, but it's a lot of weight on one day.
What if you have an off day?
It's a time commitment that I think, well, let me take a step back.
In terms of pounding on the body, there's going to be a lot more
pounding, if you will, or exertion in that one day,
because you're going for a longer period of time versus like this all out one minute.
And you're doing it three days a week.
You're kind of stepping into it.
You're building a base and at the same time building the peak versus
I'm just like going for the peak and I'm going hard once a week.
And for a guy who's turning 50, who doesn't want to get injured?
That scares me.
Lots in there, but number one would be, you mentioned you're not a runner.
I'm not a runner either anymore because I can't be.
I'm the classic mid fifties guy who has knee osteoarthritis,
but I do a lot of hit and I do a lot of hit on the bike.
And there's minimal impact forces on the bike or if you're using a rolling erg.
So you can, depending on the mode of exercise,
hit per se, or working hard does not have to ramp up the potential risk for injury.
Again, you hit on this with your interview with Andy running hit is extremely demanding
or, you know, running at VO two max space is extremely demanding and potentially injurious,
but, you know, get doing the same thing on the bike.
You can have the same cardiovascular stress, but, but not,
not the same stress on, on your joints in that.
So that's, that's point number one.
Point number two, you're talking about the pyramid.
You know, there's, there's lots of ways to build that pyramid, right?
And, and so we'll often take cues from elite endurance athletes.
And so I think that's where the classic 80, 20 split or 80,
20 mix that's often bantied around comes from.
And that's, if you're a high level endurance athlete,
they tend to center around training, which is.
80% is low to moderate intensity, continuous type training and 20% high intensity intervals.
And it's a very popular and effective formula for enhancing performance.
Now, where I would quibble with some of the other, you know,
other commentators out there is just because elite athletes do an 80, 20 split.
That doesn't mean that that's optimal for, for everyone.
You know, if you're training 25, 30 hours a week, 20% hit is a lot of hit.
If you're training an hour a week, 20% high intensity intervals.
It's really, it's not that much.
So I think it depends how much time are you
wanting to invest in your physical activity and exercise pursuits?
And importantly, what's your goals are?
Are you just looking to maintain health and general fitness?
Are you trying to train for a 5k race or important event?
Are you trying to improve or just maintain?
And so all of these things impact on what you quote unquote should be doing.
So let's say I'm training for longevity.
I want to, you know, feel good and look good as I age and I'm limited on time.
I work, maybe I have a family.
How should I structure my week?
If I say, if I've got like maybe a half hour a day and we're going to allocate,
say at least two to three days to strength training, got a half hour a day.
How can we allocate days specific to hit or zone two or just to say cardio in general?
And how can I maybe layer it on to my resistance training?
So I would suggest that doing more hit would provide more bang for your buck.
And you know, when you come back to that idea, your goal is longevity and general health.
Again, you talked about this with Andy,
but probably the single best predictor is your cardiorespiratory fitness,
which you measure objectively as VO2 max.
And so getting your VO2 max and maintaining it as high as you can over the course of your life
is probably the best insurance that you have.
There's no guarantees, but it's probably one of the best insurance markers
that you're going to live, have a high likelihood of living long and living healthy.
And I think especially when time is limited,
there's good evidence to suggest that more intense, more vigorous exercise
is going to provide greater bang for your buck in terms of improving your VO2 max,
as well as things like improving your mitochondrial capacity and your metabolic health.
So to answer your question, if you work out 30 minutes a day, six times a week, say,
and three of those are allocated to resistance exercise,
and three of those days then are going to be aerobic based,
I would suggest that for two of those three days, do intermittent work.
You know, that doesn't mean you have to be sprinting, but get into that vigorous range.
So do some alternating bouts, getting into that vigorous range
for 10, 15, 20 minutes of those 30 minute periods.
So vary up the rest intervals, vary up the recovery intervals,
but get into that vigorous range as much as you're willing to do,
because I think it will pay the greatest benefit
in terms of boosting your fitness in limited time.
Well, let me rephrase that.
I should have asked the question in a better way.
I think we're all sold on your one minute workout.
It's happening, and we're doing that three days a week.
What I should have asked more specifically is,
can we do, is it zone two, is it some specific type of training,
assuming we're doing this three days a week,
that's going to benefit that three day a week VO2 max ultra efficient HIIT workout?
Is it a certain thing?
For example, resistance training.
I have no patience, I don't have time.
I don't really wait between sets.
So my heart rate is always like, I'm always at zone two at the gym.
It's just happening.
That, for example, or is it walking?
We're all sold.
How can we use our time effectively to make sure we're getting extra benefits
or extra gains, if you will, with your one minute workout?
I think the mode of exercise doesn't matter.
So if we're talking broadly aerobic exercise,
the type of exercise that you do, it doesn't really matter.
There's an old saying that your heart doesn't know what your muscles are doing.
And so again, an empowering message, right?
So you don't have to run, you don't have to get on the bike,
you don't have to do stairs.
You don't have to do the elliptical.
You don't have to do the rower.
Pick one of those that you like.
And you're more likely to stick with it over the long term.
So if you're that person who, I only like the rower.
Okay, only do the rower.
I like to vary it up.
Okay, that's fine.
Vary it up, right?
So it's more about the relative effort than the specific exercise.
Obviously you have to do some resistance exercise in there
and body weight stuff is, or not recovering very much in between sets.
That's fine.
So I'm really not trying to hedge on the question, but I would say, you know,
I ideally then if you are sold on these one minute workouts,
I think you want to do something, you know, sometimes for a half hour,
do it continuous in nature for, you know,
try and maintain a high intensity for as long as you can.
But it's absolutely okay to do the so-called zone two stuff.
Again, the more vigorous workouts,
the more perceptually challenging it is.
And so it's absolutely fine.
There's nothing wrong with doing moderate intensity, continuous work,
whether that's, you know, in the trails or walking your dog
or walking with your partner, like that's all fine.
So I just don't want my message here to be,
Hey, it's only about HIIT.
HIIT is the greatest thing.
It's the only thing that people should do.
Traditional cardio sucks.
And, you know, scrap the public health guidelines.
That is not the messaging that's going out today.
Jason Walkup here, founder and co-CEO of MindBodyGreen
and the host of the MindBodyGreen podcast.
Please subscribe.
You'll never miss a show and you won't regret it.
I understood on that note,
I do want to double click on HIIT benefits because there are many
and it goes beyond cardiovascular health
and respiratory fitness, if you will.
Can you walk through some of the benefits
as they relate to longevity for HIIT,
whether it's metabolic flexibility,
body comp, brain health, it's a long list.
So I do want to talk about that.
And so, you know, we've definitely done work
in the area of metabolic health
or this idea of metabolic flexibility,
which, you know, that's just the idea.
Whatever fuels you want to give to the body,
it's able to utilize it, right?
You want to give it fats, fine.
It'll take the fats and burn them for energy.
You want to give a carbohydrate, fine.
It'll take those sugars and burn them for energy.
So that's this idea of metabolic flexibility.
And that's largely related to your mitochondrial capacity,
your mitochondrial content.
So mitochondria are these specialized organelles,
you know, they're referred to as the powerhouses of the cell.
But what mitochondria do,
mitochondria are the part of the cell
that takes oxygen to burn sugars and fats
to produce cellular energy in a very efficient manner.
So they produce energy aerobically.
And so HIT is definitely a stimulus for your mitochondria
to grow new, to grow more mitochondria,
to remodel your mitochondria.
So effectively, the mitochondrial health gets better
and that translates into better metabolic health.
And that translates into better things
like insulin sensitivity,
which we know is largely related to your risk
for developing type 2 diabetes.
So if you have better insulin sensitivity,
your risk for type 2 diabetes or prediabetes goes down.
So, you know, that's something that we've really been focused on.
There's definitely good work out there.
Again, the traditional approach can do it,
but HIT probably can do it
in a little more time efficient nature.
In terms of body composition, as you would well know,
you know, it's primarily about diet,
absolutely exercise and HIT specifically can assist
with weight loss efforts and encourage weight management.
But again, there, you know, you'll read on the internet,
oh, you do a HIT workout,
you have this massive afterburn effect
and, you know, the calories are just going to melt away.
Absolutely not, right?
Is there some time savings there with HIT
in terms of calorie burning?
Yeah, probably, right?
And so you can have a little greater afterburn
or your metabolism or your rate of calorie burning
in recovery is a little higher
for transiently longer period of time.
And so if you do that repeatedly over time,
that's going to help you.
But there's no compelling data right now,
at least to my mind, that HIT is magically better
for weight loss or weight management.
And of course, the primary driver there is nutrition.
I think the whole area of brain health is fascinating.
I'm not an expert on that,
you know, we're watching this work around BDNF,
potential relationships with lactate,
you know, clearly exercise generally is going to promote
cognition, brain health, neurogenesis, things like that.
And there's definitely some interesting studies.
You know, you can cherry pick a few right now
to say a high intensity exercise is maybe better for that.
But I think that work is still relatively at its infancy.
And there's a lot more that we need to know around there.
And probably there, just exercise and physical activity
is good for brain health.
Maybe there's some subtle differences,
but I don't think there's as compelling a data right now
as there are around, for example, cardiorespiratory fitness.
You know, intuitively on that one,
and again, I caveat, I don't like running,
but running, I have run and you can kind of zone out.
It's meditative.
Whereas with HIT, there's intense focus.
Which intuitively feels a little bit better for cognition.
This intense focus versus, you know,
kind of zoning out, running, enjoying life.
Yeah, absolutely.
You know, maybe one of the best activities
you can do is orienteering, right?
Whether it's winter or summer,
which is, that basically combines running,
trail running with map reading.
And the winner, you know, gets to the goal
or gets to the place fastest,
but it's not just who can run there faster.
It's who can figure out the map to get there.
And there's been some work done here at McMaster.
My colleague, Dr. Jennifer Heiss,
she's a cognitive psychologist,
but a student of hers, Emma Waddington was an orienteer
and did some really cool studies around that.
So, you know, that speaks to both sides, if you will,
the physical health, as well as the mental challenge.
Love Jennifer.
I didn't put the two together.
We had her on when her book came out
and her work in terms of mental health
and the implications, you know, unbelievable.
Absolutely. Absolutely.
And so you mentioned stairs earlier.
My view is stairs are so underrated.
And if you think about time, very effective.
If you think about that, I have a rule
under five flights, I'm taking the stairs.
So if I get to wait for an elevator
and maybe take the elevator up five flights,
maybe the elevator comes at like, it's five, 10 seconds.
Maybe I have to wait another 10 seconds.
How long does it really take you?
If you're in shape to take five flights of stairs,
not much longer.
So I'm like bang for your buck.
I'm doing stairs all day long.
I'm with you.
I have the same rule in terms of taking the stairs.
You know, this feeds into some of the work
that we're currently doing right now,
which is the notion of exercise snacking.
And so what an exercise snack is,
an activity, it lasts less than a minute,
but stair climbing is a perfect example, right?
You're walking to the subway, you're walking to the bus,
you're coming home to your apartment,
you're walking into your office tower
and you got the option, right?
You can take the elevator or you can take the stairs.
Built-in exercise snack opportunity right there.
The other classic example for me
is getting off a long flight, right?
You know, you get off the plane
and you have the option,
you've just sat for four or five, six, seven hours.
Of course, many people choose the escalator option,
but there's a built-in exercise snack opportunity right there.
You know, if you have carry-on luggage,
it turns into a strength exercise as well.
Up the stairs, 20, 30 seconds,
massively beneficial for your skeletal muscles
and your cardiovascular capacity.
And so if you can build those in through your day,
you're setting yourself up well.
Yeah, I love exercise snacking.
And if you think of the big objections
to the health category, if you will,
again, it's time and money.
A lot of these exercise snacks don't cost anything
and they're so efficient.
It's this idea of editing your day versus adding
and, oh, I gotta get up early or I don't have an hour.
Because you know what?
People don't, but you have these mini breaks.
So let's talk more about this.
100%.
And so I think, you know,
like there's definitely a pendulum with HIIT, right?
And I've been in doing this research now
for almost 20 years.
And, you know, I think there was a lot of promise with HIIT,
even though a lot of the things that we were researching
with HIIT, they weren't brand new concepts.
You know, athletes have known this for a long time.
A HIIT as a health promoting activity
has been advanced for decades,
including high intensity interval training
in patients with cardiovascular disease.
It goes back to the 70s and 80s.
But, you know, then there was a bit of a backlash,
I think, against HIIT in part because of overstatement.
I'd like to think that we didn't,
we weren't, you know, advancing all of that overstatement.
But I think now it's starting to settle in.
And related to that then, I think was growing awareness
of very small bursts of physical activity
can be beneficial.
You know, until recently, the public health guidelines
stated that unless a bout of activity
was 10 minutes or more in duration,
basically it didn't count.
And there wasn't a lot of evidence for that.
But, you know, the most recent physical activity guidelines
are now suggesting, hey, every little bit counts.
In part, I think, because of the recognition
of some of the HIIT research that's out there.
I also think HIIT is beneficial
because it's empowering to people who otherwise think,
okay, exercise is this thing that I do
in a special place after I change into special equipment
and it takes me an hour and I don't have that.
And so we can break down these barriers by saying,
no, no, one, it's physical activity, right?
It doesn't have to be structured exercise.
Two, you don't have to change into anything.
You can do it anywhere.
Look for these activities of daily living
that you can incorporate that are beneficial.
And three, it doesn't take a lot of time.
What do you got, 20 seconds, a minute?
Okay, we'll take that.
You know, if you think about this,
if you're a mom or a dad of a young kid
and you've got a 30 pounder,
if you're holding a 20 to 30 pounder in your arm
and say like you're vacuuming and walking around the house,
like you're essentially got your weighted vest on
and your heart rate is up because you're moving,
you're moving your arms, you're vacuuming.
And like, there's so many ways to get creative here.
And I do think that's empowering.
Absolutely, right? Ballroom dancing.
People like to, you know, people don't like to exercise
or they never think of themselves as an exerciser,
but they love to dance, right?
So there's so many ways.
Again, basically it comes back to,
what are we talking about?
Physical activity, which is just moving your muscles
and getting your heart rate up a little bit,
getting a bit of a cardiovascular challenge.
So what else is underrated or if you will,
that maybe something we're doing,
which we don't realize can be classified as hit
if maybe we added a little bit to it?
I'd say body weight exercise would be the classic one for me.
And so you say body weight exercise,
some people's minds go directly to burpees
and they're like, I hate burpees.
A lot of people hate burpees,
but there's so many different things,
ascending out of a chair, right?
So I think those opportunities to engage in activity
that doesn't require space, specialized equipment,
anything else.
And so for some people, again,
they have bad memories of high school gym class, right?
Push-ups were a punishment, right?
Or in sports, if you played sports
and you got into trouble
or you weren't following the play or the drill,
you were told to run sprints, right?
And so I think people,
there's some negative connotations there,
but again, we got to flip the script.
We're just talking about basic calisthenics,
things that don't require much space,
equipment, time,
and all of these things can be beneficial.
So, you mentioned playing with your children,
ascending the stairs with a heavy backpack,
carrying groceries out to your car,
park the car, don't hunt around.
And these are not novel ideas,
we hear these all the time,
but they matter, right?
Park in the farthest spot,
carry your groceries out to the car,
do it with a bit of a step in your walk.
It's a built-in workout right there.
Talk while you walk.
For sure, absolutely, right?
And so people can,
they can look for these simple,
easy ways to basically make their day
a little bit more harder, right?
Like look for ways to make your day harder,
simple ways, because as a society,
of course, we've done such a great job
of engineering physical activity out of our lives.
So you said ascending out of a chair,
how can we make that harder?
Yeah, you know, so,
well, for a lot of people, first of all,
you know, even doing a series of air squats,
like if you were going to do a series of,
you know, do air squats for one minute, right?
Chair ascends for a minute.
Challenging for some folks, right?
Do a wall sit for a minute, right?
Or you're sitting against a wall.
So, and again, you know, you're,
not everyone loves these, right?
So.
It's bringing back bad memories for me from.
Exactly, right?
But you know, how could you do it?
You could hold a book close to your vest.
You could hold your child, right?
If you're, you got that young baby in the sling,
do a series of air squats there.
Now, of course, be safe.
Make sure someone's around you.
Don't choose to exercise with your child.
I'm not suggesting that.
Many different ways to add resistance.
But you know, I think the fundamental point here is
there's just so many types of these activities,
and we just hit on a number there
that can be used and built in effectively.
If you'll indulge me, let me give you one more stat.
And that's, you know,
I've been involved with some research.
It's led by an individual named Emmanuel Stamatakis
out of the University of Sydney.
But it's this idea,
I'm going to introduce another acronym here,
VILPA.
And what VILPA means is
Vigorous Intermittent Lifestyle Physical Activity.
And so it's basically hit that's not structured exercise.
It's vigorous in nature.
It's intermittent,
but it's part of your lifestyle
and it's physical activity, not structured exercise.
So a lot of these things that we just talked about,
carrying groceries,
carrying a heavy shopping bag out to your car.
Those are examples of VILPA.
Well, I'll give a nod to my friend Dan Buettner,
Blue Zones.
It's very Blue Zones
where these people are moving all day
and longevity is equated with the,
you know,
in some communities is the incline
in the neighborhood.
Is there a hill?
And so the critical stat there
that I wanted to drop in was
I've been involved with some work
led by Professor Stamatakis
that's trying to quantify
the amount of VILPA
that's associated with improved health outcomes.
And in one of the studies,
it relied on data from what's known as the UK Biobank
where a large number of individuals
are followed over a long period of time.
But what that work showed was
in individuals who did three to four minutes a day,
three to four minutes a day
of this type of activity,
they had marked reductions,
25, 30% reduction
in their risk of dying from all causes,
in their risk of cardiovascular disease, mortality.
And so it just is more compelling data
that brief, vigorous hard work
can be very, very beneficial for your health.
And three to four,
essentially that's walking up
a very steep incline with groceries.
Exactly.
And three to four minutes a day of that,
you know, the more you do the better,
but again, it's this idea,
we're not suggesting that's all that people should do,
but it's more evidence
that brief, vigorous physical activity,
as we've been talking about,
can be very, very beneficial.
And that's probably the big takeaway here
for folks, hopefully.
And are there differences between men and women here?
Maybe.
Again, the cautious scientist answer,
I, and we've shown it in some of our studies.
So for example,
sometimes when we've done relatively small scale,
but these are very carefully controlled
and very invasive studies,
we've seen some subtle differences
between biological males and biological females
in terms of some other glucose responses.
But I think it's more related
to the large inter-individual differences
in responsiveness,
because sometimes we followed up those studies
where we then try to more carefully control
or match our groups of males and females
in terms of their fitness levels and that.
And we don't always,
we're not able to reproduce those findings.
And so what that tells me is,
clearly males and females are not exactly the same.
There might be some subtle biological differences,
absolutely.
But I think there,
for a lot of these things,
they're relatively subtle.
Both men and women,
males and females can benefit
from interval-based approaches to fitness.
And I don't think right now we can definitely say
this is an attenuated response in biological females
compared to males.
In terms of studies,
you mentioned the VILPA study.
Are there any others that come to mind
that you're excited about
or would love to do
if you could wave a magic wand and get funding?
Yeah.
So the exercise snacking stuff,
we're big on that right now.
So right now we're running
a number of randomized clinical trials.
These are multi-center,
two-site right now,
clinical trials.
This is with my collaborator,
Dr. John Little at the University of British Columbia,
looking at exercise snacks
in various groups of individuals.
So right now we're running a trial
in individuals who have type 2 diabetes
and asking the question,
if they do 20 snacks a week,
so that's four or five snacks,
four or five days of the week.
And all these snacks are one minute in duration.
So at most it's 20 minutes of vigorous exercise a week
for three months.
Is that enough to move the needle
in things like their glycemic control?
So these individuals are wearing
continuous glucose monitors
and we're trying to ascertain that.
We have some other work planned
in individuals who have overweight and obesity.
And so trying to really
apply these concepts in the real world.
And so all of these studies are not,
people come into our laboratory
under a very carefully controlled environment
three or four times a week.
People are doing this in their real lives.
And so how the intervention is being delivered is
it's on their smartphone.
So we partnered with a company
that has basically,
they get a message or reminder that says,
hey, it's time for your exercise snack.
They click on a link.
It takes them to their video.
It shows them a little YouTube video of,
you know what?
You're doing air squats for a minute.
You're doing lunges.
And they were able to pre-select
or give us, the research team,
this is what I like to do
and what I don't like to do.
So we're trying to meet people where they are,
certainly in their homes,
at their work environments.
And then the only time they come into our laboratory
is before and after to get their testing done.
I am very excited about this.
You said, meet people where they are.
Typically, we don't do that.
No, we don't.
And we can be very preachy.
And, you know, there's,
we've been accused of that.
Clearly, some people can see
the public health guidelines as being preachy.
You know, and I think there's been this notion of,
well, if you're not meeting the guidelines,
you're a failure, right?
And we know that most people aren't, right?
So rather than, you know,
berate people for that,
it's like saying, hey, you know,
when you're starting to see the messaging change, right?
Every little bit counts.
So the role that we're trying to play
is show some of the evidence
for some of the biological,
the physiological changes that can take place
when people do these very small doses of exercise
and how do those relate to health-related metrics, right?
We're not going to answer all the questions,
you know, and we're trying to collaborate
with behavioral experts
because some people just discount hit out of hand, right?
No one's going to do it.
If exercise is vigorous, it's aversive,
people deem it uncomfortable.
It's a public health failure.
It's never going to work.
Well, number one, it's like,
well, what we've been telling people to do
largely for 40 or 50 years
isn't working that well either.
So I think we need to explore some options.
I love just the rebranding of it, of exercise.
You know, we do have an eating problem here
in America and Canada.
We're reframing this as exercise snacking,
just from a branding.
It's just a lot more attractive to say,
let's do an exercise snack versus HIT or VO2 Max
or, you know, whatever it might be,
like exercise snack.
Yeah, I like snacks.
We like snacks here.
On that theme is the other thing we'll talk about,
and again, not novel to us, we didn't coin it,
is expanding the movement menu, right?
And so just like people,
no one wants to eat the same thing every day
or a few people do, you know, when we say,
okay, this is what a healthy diet looks like.
We're not telling you,
you can only eat this food or can't eat that food.
You know, here's the things you should do
to make your diet healthy.
Well, if we apply that to physical activity,
it's, hey, here's the things you should do.
Here's your physical activity menu.
You pick what you like.
And not everyone likes the same thing on the same day.
You might go through a period of time
where I don't like that food.
I don't like that exercise.
That's okay.
Vary it up, right?
And so we're trying to, you know, give, allow people,
enable people to expand that movement menu
and choose what they like and enjoy.
Well, I think it's very empowering
if there's anything we can do to support here.
We're all for it.
In closing, is there anything we didn't touch on
that you would like to discuss
before we leave for today?
No, I've appreciated the opportunity to chat with you.
I think we really hit on the big ones, right?
And so in closing, actually,
let me just finish that thought
around the behavioral side of things.
And so there is emerging and compelling research
showing that, you know what?
Some people like and enjoy this type of exercise.
Some people like and enjoy the more vigorous stuff.
And when you look at, you know,
there's now systematic reviews, meta-analyses,
which are trying to pull all these studies together.
Depending on your view, it's either,
the news is either, well, it's just as good as moderate
or just as bad in that some people will choose to do it
and others won't.
And so that's why this idea of, you know,
choose what you like and feel free to vary it up is best.
And so, you know, in closing,
I think my take-home message would be a few minutes
of daily vigorous physical activity,
getting out of your comfort zone,
maybe huffing and puffing a little bit
is a very effective health strategy
and look for ways to get uncomfortable
once in a while throughout the day.
You know, your body will thank you for it.
Your mind will thank you for it.
And I think you'll be a lot happier and healthier,
you know, 20, 30, 40 years from now.
Well, I am 100% in for the one minute hit,
three days a week.
I will report back.
And where can people find you online?
Yeah, so I am on Twitter at Gabala M
or at my website martingabala.com
where I keep information on podcast interviews like this
and some of our scientific research outputs.
Awesome.
Thank you so much, Martin.
Thank you.
