The race to solve solar energy's recycling problem

Industrial electrical equipment
1 follower
29 Video Views·Oct 6, 2024
We might have a teeny tiny problem with solar.
And it's not that they don't produce energy at night.
What started delivering clean energy in the 1950s and took off in the late 2000s
is now ready for the dumpster.
Not because the technology is trash,
but because solar panels are built to last 20 to 30 years.
Soon we could be looking at 27 million tons of out-of-date solar waste.
And only a tiny fraction gets recycled.
Around 80% of all panels are landfilled.
Big problem.
One, plastics end up in the environment.
Two, precious metals would just go to waste.
And three, recycling saves emissions.
So I'm here in the French Alps to find a fix.
And what this has to do with baking and bathing now.
We're at the French company ROSI.
Founded in 2017, they are one of the pioneers in solar recycling.
This is Antoine Chalot.
He has been working here for the past four years.
So what are the main process steps in your recycling process?
So the first step is to get rid of the polymers.
So we do it with a thermal treatment.
It's a pyrolysis process in a furnace that eliminates the polymers.
And then we separate the material with mechanical sortation.
And then you have a last step because the photovoltaic cells contain different metals.
And these metals, we want to separate them from each other.
So we have a chemical treatment,
small mild chemical treatment that we do that detaches the silicon from the silver.
And this way, at the end, we recover all the materials inside the PV panels.
Basically, a solar panel is made of a few main ingredients
that need to be separated during the recycling process.
You've got tempered glass, thermoplastic glue,
the cells with silicon, silver and copper,
a plastic backsheet and an aluminum frame that holds everything together.
Of course, the precise mix of components varies by manufacturer.
Why is it so hard to recycle these panels?
So the good thing with solar panels is that they are made to last very long.
20, 30 years outside, any weather conditions,
they can last because of the construction.
This construction with a strong glass sheet in the front,
with polymers gluing everything together,
it's very water resistant.
The problem is now we need to recycle them
and we need to separate all these materials to put them back in the economy.
And they are all glued together with polymer.
So the most challenging first step is to separate the materials from the polymers.
This is not possible if you crush it,
because if you crush it, you create small particles
all glued together with this polymer.
And the plastic is literally everywhere.
So even when you now remove this,
you still can't access the cells, right?
You have different types of polymers, different layers.
There's even more.
Oh, wow.
This is difficult, huh?
Yeah.
So the first step is to get rid of the plastics.
The panels get put into this big gray furnace.
And because Rosi is still in the patenting process,
everything today is pretty much top secret.
The mastermind behind this process is Gui Xixi Niu,
CTO and co-founder of Rosi.
Come with me.
I mean, you can really feel the heat.
You can really feel the heat.
Wow.
Really feel the heat.
How hot does it get in there?
400 degrees.
400 degrees?
That's really hot.
So we don't stay too close for long.
The panels bake for between one and a half and six hours,
turning the plastics inside into gas.
What is really important when you look at this process?
Does it depend on the temperature?
How the panels are stacked up?
What makes the difference?
What makes the difference and what is our knowledge
and our protection, IP protection,
is, of course, it's not a standard pyrolysis process.
It's customized and optimized for the treatment
of these solar panels.
So meaning that what we managed to do
is to improve the general regulation of the oven,
depending on the source material.
So actually, the modules, they contribute to the process.
It's not an oven with a payload.
It's a combination of the two.
It's coupled, meaning we use the energy from the modules
to heat up the oven so we can save energy.
So it's a combination, the coupling between the machine,
the equipment, the oven and the payload.
So the combination of the two makes it more efficient.
ROSI sends hazardous gases and exhaust fumes
through a five-stage filtering system.
They say only CO2 and water vapor are released in the end.
But despite the CO2, recycling still saves emissions
compared to mining fresh silicon.
Creating the base silicon from quartz
and wood chips releases between 8 to 12 tons of CO2
per ton of silicon.
ROSI says their recycling process only releases three tons,
a reduction of at least five tons of CO2 per ton of silicon.
The company wouldn't let us show you the solar panels
going into the furnace.
But this is what the solar panels look like
after being baked in the oven.
This batch is about 20 kilos
and represents the content of one solar panel.
You can see the glass, you can see the silicon wafers,
which are like super thin.
And you can just break them into pieces.
And then you've got the copper connectors.
Now, this mass goes into the next range of machines
that take on the sorting job.
When you look at a typical solar panel
from the weight perspective,
it's about 76% glass, 10% plastic, 8% aluminum,
5% silicon, 1% copper and 0.1% silver.
And it's that really valuable silver
that's the main goal of this whole process.
Though first, we need to extract the copper and glass.
But this whole process isn't the only way
to recycle solar panels.
Other companies are trying it
with mechanical recycling, for example.
It's less energy intensive, it costs less,
and you don't need to deal with chemics afterwards.
However, the recovery rates can be lower.
Firms like Solar Materials in Germany
are using heat like rosy at the start of their process,
but no chemical baths.
In Japan, there's even one called the hot blade method.
And like the name suggests,
a really hot and sharp knife is used
to separate the glass from the rest.
Another German company is putting it very, very simply,
hitting the solar panels with lightning.
This bursts them into several components,
which are then sortable.
I don't think I can pick a clear favorite right now.
Marius Ian Peters has been researching photovoltaics
for more than 20 years
and is concerned about how to deal
with all the plastics in solar panels.
I'm not exactly happy, for example,
with a thermal process
in which the polymers are incinerated,
because we would lose those polymers.
They go into a state for which the elements are still there.
Now, that being said,
it is very hard currently to take a polymer
that's inside the solar panel,
get it out of the solar panel,
and treat it in a way that we can reuse it as a polymer.
It's very energy intensive to do that,
and it doesn't really compete
both energetically or economically or ecologically
with making a new polymer.
So plastics are going to stay a pain to deal with.
But what about the remaining materials
after the mechanical sortation?
Now, most of the materials are separated,
but we still need to get out the most valuable one
that is still in this photovoltaic cells
connected to the silicon.
It's the silver.
The thousands of pieces of photovoltaic cells
in these containers
go through a set of five to eight chemical wet baths
that are connected to each other.
Here, the silicon and the silver
are separated from one another.
It is these tiny, tiny silver lines
that we are talking about here.
Their job in a solar panel
is to make the electricity available for direct use
or storage in a battery, for example.
In case you're wondering,
this is as much of the process as we could show you.
Can you specify a bit what kind of chemicals you use?
Because chemistry is like a really wide term.
We avoid the use of organic solvents and strong acids
and we have specific conditions with different baths
to treat the photovoltaic cells.
That's as specific as they would get.
Because we can't really show you the inside of the process,
we set up a small experiment.
So you first have the photovoltaic cells as they enter
and every step you can see
the silver fingers detach a little more.
It's like really tiny, small fingers.
Yes, it is very, very thin.
Yeah, it almost looks like hair.
Yeah.
What's the purity on the silver
and on the silicon that comes out of this?
So our process is in general
unable to keep the same purity for the material
when they come in.
So we don't degrade the purity.
So for example, for the silver,
it comes from silver paste on the cells
and silver pastes are in general above 90 percent purity.
For the silicon, it's 99.99 percent.
Ah, okay.
That sounds quite pure.
The recovered purity is in line
with scientifically published papers.
But for the economics of the process,
another number is important.
How much of the materials is actually recovered.
With their combination of thermal
and chemical recycling steps,
Rosie says they are able to recover
99 percent of the glass, aluminum and copper,
90 percent of the silicon
and 95 percent of the silver.
Which means that they get about 10 US dollars
worth of silver out of each solar panel.
The other stuff, glass, aluminum, copper and silicon
is worth another 10 bucks.
But of course, the recovered materials
cost more than virgin materials.
Do you have the feeling that companies
are willing to pay these premiums
that you have for recycled materials?
Yeah, unfortunately they don't pay big premium.
But today, all the big companies,
all big industrial companies in Europe
have very strong targets on CO2 reduction.
And using recycled material is a very good way
for them to reduce their CO2 emission
from their raw materials.
So already with silicon, for instance,
the CO2 emissions of silicon production is very high.
So for our customer, it is crucial
that they use less CO2 intensive materials
and our silicon completely fulfills this target.
I would have loved to compare the prices
for recovered materials to actual market prices,
but Rosie wouldn't tell me their numbers.
Luckily for them, in France,
there is a so-called gate fee
that every solar importer or seller
must pay to recycling companies
to make sure the panels are rightfully taken care of
at their end of life.
Just to put this in perspective,
a study by the US National Renewable Energy Lab
put the cost of trashing a solar panel at under $5,
whereas recycling one would cost $15 to $45.
So how do you make recycling pay?
Rosie say they can process around 3,000 tons
of solar panels per year here.
Not really that much compared to the millions of tons
of trash expected in the upcoming years.
And it's not even enough for them to break even.
But they're already planning to build a facility
10 times bigger in Germany by the end of 2025,
which should be able to handle 30,000 tons per year.
However, upscaling such a process is a real challenge,
as their CEO told me.
For the very big scale recycling site,
we'll have to organize very well the operators,
engineers, technicians,
so all the traceability system
and also how to integrate the operators,
so human beings with the automation,
to reduce the cost,
to protect to a maximum the safety of the site.
Also, you cannot use this recycled silicon
straight away to form a new PV module.
One of the reasons being the technology moved on.
20, 30 years ago,
silicon of 99.999% purity was used.
Sounds pretty pure.
However, today,
silicon more than a thousand times purer is required.
So you'd need another purification process
after this to create new silicon ingots
and new wafers to put into new modules.
This has been done on the science side.
For example, by Germany's Fraunhofer Institute,
a research body that works closely with industry partners.
But ROSI is taking a different route
and is selling its recovered materials
to the automotive, building and electronics industries.
Another way to make this whole thing easier
and that wouldn't require engineering
the recycling process to perfection
is to redesign these solar panels
and make them easier to recycle.
The Netherlands Organization for Applied Scientific Research
has developed what they call a release encapsulant,
where a type of trigger is worked into the polymers
that make them easier to get rid of during recycling.
Like pressing a button and everything goes poof.
At the National Energy Lab in the US,
they are taking things up a notch
by getting rid of all the plastic.
And they are doing this by literally welding glass together.
That way you wouldn't need to deal with plastics
used for encapsulation at all.
But of course, this is all still happening in the lab.
Another promising tech could actually be perovskite solar cells,
which I already did a video on.
Because the different layers of perovskite solar panels
are created using chemicals,
they could also be taken apart easier afterwards
by using similar process steps.
But they would need to be mass produced first.
What I can say is that the recycling process for ROSI
is working at a pilot facility.
But I'm going to be honest with you,
I expected to get to know a lot more details about the process.
I don't even know what chemicals they are using.
And the upscaling is going to be difficult as well.
Not just from the process or technical side of things,
but they also need to get the financing right.
And everything at the same time, not easy.
Overall, bigger players with a lot deeper pockets
will have to get involved to make recycling solar panels
at a larger scale a reality.
If you did enjoy the video,
like it, comment on it, share it,
and don't forget to subscribe to our channel.
We post new videos on the environment every Friday.
Thanks!
