Not allowing any automation at U.S. ports is foolish, says Zuoz Industrial's Urs Dur

Financial Freedom
10 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 5, 2024
Urs Dur, Zuoz Industrial principal, joins 'Squawk Box' to discuss the latest developments on the U.S. port strike, why he believes both sides may see value in holding firm on their positions for the time being, the economic impact of the strike, and more.
The strike by 45,000 dock workers on the east and gulf coast entering its third day. CNBC sources
said yesterday that there were no signs of progress at bringing workers and port owners
even back to the negotiating table. Our next guest says that both sides may see value in
holding firm on their positions for the time being. Joining us right now is Urs Durr,
ZUOT's industrial principal. And let's talk a little bit about this. You think both sides
benefit from staying out? Why is that? Yeah, I don't know if they necessarily fully benefit
from being out. I mean, people could lose some some work here and nobody wants wants pain on
people. But, you know, it's an election season and it's not like either political party is going to
make much hay by using pressure on unions right now. So that's probably not helpful. And as well,
the dock workers have some some time to hold out here and they seem to have a very strong
leadership position that is going to hold them there. The interesting thing that other people
haven't really thought about is that container shipping, while everyone on the dock worker side
is complaining that they're very, very profitable, isn't as profitable as people might think. But
they've benefited from the Red Sea being, you know, 40 percent capacity than it was before
because of safety issues in the Houthis. And that's added eight percent on on ton miles.
So freight rates have benefited from that, as well as they've benefited from the Panama Canal
having drought earlier in the season. So they had a pretty good year. And if you cause disruption
on the U.S. East Coast, ships have to go somewhere and they're going to go somewhere and it's going
to cause disruption and congestion and freight rates will go higher. So they can sit for a
bit on this, as well as, you know, not allowing any automation is is foolish, in my opinion,
and we're the least efficient ports in the world. And the container shipping companies can sit and
hold on that. Oh, sorry. I don't think that in the short term, perhaps the union benefits by
staying out. But because of the fiery rhetoric and really harsh commentary coming from the leader of
the longshoremen, and because this is something that is going to start impacting consumers maybe
over the not too distant future, over the next few weeks where they see higher prices or shortages
when it comes to things they're used to seeing on on store shelves. I mean, they really run the risk
of overplaying their hand if they haven't already and losing the public opinion war.
I agree with that. You know, Daggett is very charismatic. As he said yesterday, he doesn't
have a crystal ball between his legs and he doesn't know necessarily how long it's going to
go. This is a major impact. We're already talking about least efficient major ports in the world
on the U.S. East Coast, largely because of a lack of automation and obstinance by union leadership.
And as such, they don't seem to have much constituency in regards to them being an
inflationary impact on the United States. And so I think eventually it dissipates. But again,
you know, I don't see the Republicans or Democrats not taking sides here, although I'm pretty
conservative, pressuring unions on this issue. So it could be a number of weeks here where they
can hold firm and that will cause an impact on everybody's on everybody's dinner table, for sure.
