Deterrence as a theory of punishment

History of Law
11 followers
4 Video Views·Oct 4, 2024
In this video I'll be discussing the second theory of punishment which is deterrence.
Deterrence as a theory of punishment aims to prevent criminal offenses by discouraging
individuals from engaging in criminal behavior. We can identify two forms of deterrence namely
individual or specific deterrence and general deterrence. Individual deterrence is where an
individual offender is punished in the expectation that he will not offend again.
For example prison sentences imposed for offenses such as theft will prevent the same offender
recommitting such offenses. General deterrence on the other hand is where the aim is not just
to prevent the individual offender from recommitting the offense but to discourage
the general public from committing such offenses by making an example of those who are punished.
For example higher fines imposed for road traffic offenses will not only prevent the same offender
recommitting the offense but will also generally discourage the public from committing road traffic
offenses. These are some of the examples for criminal sanctions that achieve deterrence.
Licensed suspension for drunk driving, corporate fines and penalties for environmental damage,
mandatory minimum sentences for drug offenses such as illegal trafficking of drugs. So deterrence as
a theory of punishment will aim to prevent these offenses being recommitted by the individual
offenders as well as by the general public at large. These are some of the advantages of deterrence.
It forms a preventative approach which means the aim of deterrence is to prevent recidivism.
So this will help to reduce the crimes in the society and as a result there is public protection
provided by deterrence and also it will crack down crimes that society wishes to condone.
However there are some disadvantages of deterrence as well. Deterrence does not follow the rule of
law because when an offender is given a serious punishment to set an example to others we can
look at it as an unequal punishment. So therefore deterrence does not follow equality which is
required under the rule of law. Also deterrence relies heavily on publicity. As long as the public
is not aware about the offenses happening or the relevant punishments given to the offenders
there will not be any deterrent effect. Therefore deterrence is relying heavily on publicity.
Also it doesn't work for impulse crimes, crimes that are committed out of pressure or at the
spur of the moment. For these crimes the offenders will not stop and think about the consequences
or the punishments that they will get. Therefore there is no real deterrent effect.
Let us see how deterrence has been applied in some cases. In R against Healy in 2002 the defendant
was sentenced to four years imprisonment for stealing a mobile phone from 17 year old.
We can see the judge has made a statement referring to deterrence where he says the sentence I pass
is to keep the public protected from you and as a deterrent to show that this type of offense
will not be tolerated. So we can see clearly how the judges have used this theory of deterrence
when avoiding criminal sanctions. In R against Crispin in 2007 court of appeal in an appeal
against a sentence of eight years was dismissed for possession of a substantial arsenal of weapons
where the court of appeal judge expressly held that gun crime was a contemporary curse.
The unexplained unlawful possession of such weapons even if not used must attract severe
deterrent sentences. So these two cases show how deterrence will be applied as a theory of
punishments by judges when deciding cases. Thank you for watching the video. I have already discussed
retribution in my previous video. If you haven't watched it yet you can use the below link to watch
that video and I will further discuss rehabilitation, reparation and restoration in my future videos.
Thank you.
