Mona Lisa (Full Length): Great Art Explained

Art Exhibitions
6 followers
7 Video Views·Oct 3, 2024
Who is Mona Lisa? Is it a self-portrait? Why doesn't she have eyebrows? Is she only famous because she was stolen? How do we know what Leonardo was thinking?#Artexhibitions
Some people are disappointed when they first see the most famous painting in the world.
At first glance it doesn't have the wow factor that other paintings in the Louvre have.
It lacks drama. But if we can ignore the hundreds of people that surround her,
if we can turn down the volume and just push the off button for a second, what we actually see
is a quiet contemplative painting. The greatest psychological portrait ever painted.
A portrait so ahead of its time that centuries later we are still trying to figure it out.
The Mona Lisa, however, is not just the most famous painting in the world.
It is also the source of innumerable myths, legends and supposition. In 1516 the 22-year-old
French king, Francis I, offered Leonardo a job. Court painter, engineer and architect to the king.
Leonardo, now in his 60s, moved to the Chateau d'Amboise in France and never went back to Italy.
The young king and Leonardo would form a deep friendship and the artist was given the king's
royal summer home, Clos Lucey, where he lived for the last three years of his life.
Doing what he loved best, learning and creating. He worked on architectural plans for a royal
residence in central France and one of his masterpieces of this period is the double helix
stairway at Chambord. He brought dozens of notebooks like these with him to France,
but he also brought the Mona Lisa. Leonardo knew how important it was. He knew it was a masterpiece
and he would continue to work on the painting until his death in 1519.
Mona Lisa is the end product of the greatest inquisitive mind in history.
Leonardo anticipated theories by both Galileo and Newton. His anatomical drawings are unparalleled,
as are his botanical studies. His treatise on painting explored radical new ideas, as we shall
see. He designed war machines, he used fossils to disprove biblical accounts of the flood
and he had the skill to open the still beating heart of a pig to explain how ventricles work.
He was a man for whom science and art are complementary rather than distinct disciplines.
He believed that ideas formulated in one realm could and should inform the other.
He would take all his scientific knowledge and apply it to the Mona Lisa,
a portrait of an ordinary woman that he would transform into a myth.
Often called the first art historian, Giorgio Vasari published his book about the Renaissance
artist in 1550 and in it he wrote the very first account of the painting. Leonardo undertook to
execute for Francesco del Giocondo the portrait of Mona Lisa, his wife. There has always been a
dispute about Mona Lisa's true identity, but in 2005 a German scholar found a handwritten comment
in the margins of a 15th century book in Heidelberg University's library. It was dated October 1503
and was by Agostini Vespucci, the secretary of Niccolò Machiavelli, the writer of The Prince
and a good friend of Leonardo. Vespucci notes that Leonardo was painting a portrait of Lisa
del Giocondo. This is an eyewitness account that firmly establishes not only the identity of Mona
Lisa but also the date when Leonardo was working on the portrait. Lisa Ghirardini married Francesco
del Giocondo in 1495. She was 15 and he was 30. Francesco was a nouveau riche silk merchant
and Lisa was from an old noble family with no money. She had five children with him and lived
a long and it seems happy life. One of the great mysteries is why Leonardo, who was used to painting
for royalty and popes, painted the wife of a bourgeois merchant. Family connections. Leonardo's
father, Sir Piero da Vinci, was Francesco's lawyer and it was probably pressure from his father
that made Leonardo take on such a small commission. But I think Leonardo painted her because he wanted
to paint a relatively ordinary woman, to try out new ideas without the fear of interference.
It gave him the unusual opportunity to put all he knew about science and the poetry of painting
into the commission. Mona Lisa would become a vehicle for all that he knew. This high resolution
scan taken by art technician Pascal Cotte in 2004 revealed that there is a similar sketch underneath
reconstructed here as to how it might look. The pose looks the same and it is quite possible
that this is the face of the real Mona Lisa. Leonardo worked on the painting for 16 years.
Knowing that it is Lisa del Giocondo gives us more information to work with. One example is,
because we have Francesco's will, we know that Lisa owned a large amount of jewellery
that is not shown in the painting and that, as we shall see, is significant.
We can be sure that the Mona Lisa is Lisa del Giocondo from Florence.
To say that aspects of the Mona Lisa are just happy accidents, that he just painted and hoped
for the best, is to deny all the evidence of a lifetime spent experimenting with techniques,
dissecting human bodies and collecting scientific and geological data.
For a painting with such a huge impact, it is surprisingly small
at 77 by 53 centimetres or 30 inches by 21.
For Mona Lisa, Leonardo used a thin grain of poplar tree and applied an undercoat of
lead white rather than just a mix of chalk and pigment. He wanted a reflective base.
Leonardo painted with semi-transparent glazes that had a very small amount of pigment mixed
with the oil. So how dark you wanted your glaze to be depends on how much pigment you use.
He used more like a wash, which he applied thin, layer by layer. Here you can see two colours of
contrast, light and dark. When you apply thin glaze over both of them, you can see it starts
to unify the contrast but also brings depth and luminosity. The lead white undercoat reflects the
light back through the glazes, giving the picture more depth and in essence, lighting Mona Lisa
from within. As we move around the painting, that light shifts around. This microscopic cross-section
is taken from another Leonardo painting. The first layer is the lead white ground.
Layer two is known as imprimatura. This layer gives the painting a transparent toned ground,
which will allow light falling onto the painting to reflect through the paint layers. The imprimatura
became widely used during the Renaissance. Then we have a dark glaze and that is followed by various
layers of different coloured glazes. Scientific analysis shows us that Leonardo used up to 30
different layers of painted glaze on the Mona Lisa, applied so thinly that it only totals 40
micrometers of paint. That's half the width of a human hair. All of these layers, applied differently
with varying amounts of pigments, refract the light in unique ways. He used tiny, almost invisible
brushstrokes, applied super slowly over months, or in Mona Lisa's case, years. By contrast, on her skin,
the brushstrokes were applied in an irregular way and that makes the grain of the skin look more
lifelike. He also used the verdaccio technique. We see it here on one of his unfinished works.
He would use green as a base colour to produce nuanced flesh tones. If you look down at your own
hands, there is a surprising amount of green showing through the skin. This infrared image,
taken in 2004 by the Louvre, tells us a lot about his techniques and use of paint. We know the Mona
Lisa was meticulously created. Nothing was accidental. A technique he pioneered is chiaroscuro,
where he contrasts prominent shades of light and dark to create the illusion of three-dimensional
forms. Along with this, Leonardo used the sfumato technique, which he is credited as inventing.
Sfumato means smoky and it is a blending technique for softening the transition between colours,
to make sure there are no sharp, unnatural lines. The soft blending creates an ambiguous mood,
particularly around the corners of the mouth and the corners of the eyes.
This means there are no hard edges anywhere on the Mona Lisa. They are all blended in to form
an ambiguous image. You can see how the smile ends at each corner. It simply tails away,
unresolved and open-ended. We can demonstrate this with an x-ray. If we put Raphael and Leonardo
side by side, an x-ray shows us that Raphael used clearly defined edges, whereas Leonardo's figure
disappears as he uses none. As Leonardo wrote, the eye never knows the edge of anybody.
This makes her facial expression blurry or fuzzy, so that when we look at her,
we perceive the expression in different ways. This brings her to life. Leonardo understood
light as well as optics. The man who had worked out the reflection of light from the earth to
the moon, had also studied how ratios of light and shade hit the face, according to the angle
of impact. And this knowledge, combined with the sfumato, the chiaroscuro and the glazes which
affect light refraction, means she constantly changes through optical and perceptual illusion.
In essence, these techniques take painting one stage further. It allows us to look at a painting
the way our eyes work. It allows depth of field never seen in a painting before. The best way to
see how incredibly skilled Leonardo was, is by looking at Mona Lisa's gossamer thin veil.
Look at it for a bit. On her forehead, we can see the dark edges of the silk veil, but the light of
her skin shines through the translucent material. But where the veil crosses the sky, it becomes
darker and more visible. He would have painted the background first and then used a transparent
glaze to paint the veil over it. His representational skill is spectacular, but his powers of observation
are uncanny. Actually, let's start with what she's not wearing. When was the last time you
employed a professional photographer? The answer is usually a wedding or a prom. What were you
wearing in your prom photo? Your best clothes? Your best jewelry? Of course! Being painted by one of
the most celebrated and in-demand painters of the day is your chance to really show off, and yet
Mona Lisa is stripped of all the usual high status symbols. Her clothes are nothing special.
They tell us nothing. Instead of the usual flamboyant expensive outfits we see in commission
portraits, hers are pretty simple for a wealthy woman. Along with the complete lack of jewelry
and the simple hair, they serve one purpose and one purpose only.
Leonardo made sure we would not be distracted from the face of Mona Lisa.
Let's talk about her eyebrows, or lack thereof. It's not down to fashion, she almost certainly
once had them, but over time, with cleaning and restoration, the most delicate parts of the
painting, her eyebrows and eyelashes, have disappeared. Copies of the painting produced by
Leonardo's own studio are a good source of information on how she looked in 1503, and here's why.
Leonardo had a team of about six assistants and apprentices. Workshops were training grounds for
young artists to learn their craft over several years, and they begin by copying the master's works.
It's how Leonardo, Michelangelo and other great artists learnt, by copying masters. Then they
developed their own style. Multispectral analysis in 2004 by art technician Pascal Cotte revealed
that Leonardo used a preparatory sketch or a cartoon to create the Mona Lisa, using the Spolvero
technique, a similar idea to tracing. It is a technique that Renaissance artists would use to
make lucrative copies of their paintings from an original drawing, as well as copies for their
students to work on. Leonardo used the Spolvero technique to transfer his sketches of the Mona Lisa
to a wooden panel, more than once. With this technique, holes are pricked along the outline
of an original drawing, known as a cartoon, and then dusted with charcoal to produce an outline
ready for painting. The analysis shows faint traces of the charcoal drawing. It is most obvious on her
hands, where the scan shows us the charcoal pinpricks used to trace the drawing onto the wood.
The same sketch would have been used as a base for his apprentice's copies.
From these scans, we also know that as Leonardo made changes to his painting,
the pupil made the same changes to his copy. The logical conclusion is that the Prado Mona Lisa
was painted by an apprentice side by side with Leonardo, using the same pigments and the same
adjustments. This copy was not really considered important until it was restored in 2012 and the
original background was revealed. Scientific examination tells us it was painted by someone
working in Leonardo's studio as an apprentice, and therefore under Leonardo's supervision.
By use of infrared radiography, we know it is likely that it was created simultaneously
in the same studio. The Prado copy doesn't have the mystery of Leonardo's achingly beautiful
painting. This is something that cannot be copied, but the excellent state of conservation
of the copy gives us unique insights into the original painting, which has become cracked and
yellowed with age. If we take the copy and overlay the two, we get some idea of what the Mona Lisa
might look like if it were possible to restore her. Now we see the rosy lips described by Vasari
in 1550, and the thin eyebrows and eyelashes he wrote about, suggesting that indeed the Mona Lisa
once had eyebrows. Leonardo uses the classic pyramid shape composition that was introduced
during the Renaissance. It is an important change from the paintings of the 15th century.
The structure provides stability, but more importantly, it provides a clear central focus
and directs your gaze. In Mona Lisa's case, it is pulling us into her face.
Leonardo pioneered the use of the three-quarter length pose, rather than producing a full-length
portrait, or the standard profile used at the time. But why? Because he completely fills the
frame with his subject, making the painting more intimate and cutting down on distractions.
This three-quarter length pose becomes the norm in Italy for 400 years. Today we look at Mona
Lisa's pose, and it seems fairly normal, but for its day, it was groundbreaking. Previously,
subjects were stiff and upright, aristocratic. But Mona Lisa is relaxed. Her hands are resting
gently on the arm of her chair, as she turns towards us, almost as if it's a snapshot.
Mona Lisa is also rather content and self-assured, which was more how aristocratic men were portrayed,
not women. The standard Renaissance portraits of women were in profile, and they didn't smile.
We are looking directly into her eyes, and she is looking directly at us.
Women in paintings just didn't do that. They didn't look boldly and directly at the viewer.
The entire painting deviated from the traditional way women were painted in Italy.
Portraits were usually drawn with an open sky as the background, a monotone background,
or a simple room. Mona Lisa is in front of a complicated landscape that only existed in
Leonardo's imagination. Paintings in this period had both the subject and the background in sharp
focus, whereas the background of the Mona Lisa is hyper-realistic and is created using an illusion
of depth or recession. This is aerial perspective. Leonardo was the first to write about it,
and if he didn't invent it, then he certainly perfected it. Behind Mona Lisa, the vast landscape
proceeds to distant icy mountains. A path and a bridge are the only indication of human presence.
The curves of her hair and clothing reflect the rolling valleys and rivers behind her,
connecting humanity and nature. Microcosm and macrocosm, a favorite theme of Leonardo's.
He used his pioneering studies of hydrodynamics not only to explain how an aortic valve closed,
but also to explain the weight, volume, and direction of the curls of hair. The twist of
the earth parallels her torso. Look at the river on the right. It flows into the scarf over her left
shoulder, and we see that she is connected with the earth. Even the background is informed by science.
This time of sedimentary layers he studied in the Apennines. Centuries before Darwin, Leonardo
guessed through his studies of rocks and fossils that the world is far older than Genesis claims.
His knowledge of geology ensures that there are no accidents in his plotting of the background.
And yet, the horizon of the landscape does not quite line up behind the figure. It is very
slightly skewed, while her shoulders are painted level. This is a typical Leonardo visual trick
that gives an illusion of movement. Leonardo knew that our brains would struggle with this
conflicting visual information. We know that the horizon should line up, so we read it as level.
This causes us to interpret the shoulders as being on a slant, which they are not. As our brain
corrects this, it creates an illusion of movement, as if the figure shuffles a bit in its frame.
Lisa's eyes are in fact looking to her left, but step back and she is looking directly at us.
If your screen is big enough, move to the right and left. Her eyes follow you. This effect only
works with two-dimensional images, since the elements of perspective and light and shadow
are fixed and don't change. They look the same no matter from what angle you are standing.
It is a real phenomenon, but not unique to this painting.
Then there is the smile that pulls everything together. Before, during and long after the
Renaissance, artists did not paint their subjects smiling. When you think about it, portraits are
generally very serious. It's easy enough to smile for a few minutes, but not for the weeks,
if not months, it takes to paint a portrait. And yet, despite the scarcity of a smile in paintings,
Leonardo almost makes it his signature.
It is said that Leonardo kept Lisa happy by employing musicians and jesters.
Look at her for a while. Really look into her eyes. First she is smiling and then she is not.
The smile comes and goes as we scan around the face. When we look away, the smile lingers.
When Leonardo was perfecting Lisa's smile, he was spending his nights in the morgue,
peeling the flesh off cadavers and exposing the muscles and nerves underneath.
He became fascinated by how a smile works and analysed every possible movement of each part
of the face, working out the origins of every nerve which controls the facial muscles.
Here we see two partially dissected faces in profile. They show the muscles which control
the lips and other elements of expression. In the one on the left, Leonardo has removed part
of the jawbone to expose the muscle, which pulls back the angle of the mouth and flattens the cheek
as a smile begins to form. Leonardo reveals the actual mechanisms that transmit emotions
into facial expressions. Extraordinary. Here are puckered lips, pouting lips,
the muscles that move the mouth. Then almost forgotten at the top of this page is a simple
drawing of a gentle smile, sketched lightly in black chalk. Even though the fine lines at the
end of the mouth turn down slightly, the feeling is that the lips are smiling. This simple
anatomical drawing is the beginning of Mona Lisa's smile. Astonishingly, Leonardo had studied the
whose pioneering theories on the psychology of visual perception inspired his own work on optics.
Leonardo knew from his optic studies that light rays do not come to a single point in the eye,
but instead hit the whole area of the retina, and this is the key to her enigmatic smile.
Her expression changes as you look at this painting. In the year 2000, Dr Margaret Livingston,
a Harvard neuroscientist, discovered that Mona Lisa's smile changes because of how the human
visual system is designed. She explains that the human eye has two distinct regions for seeing the
world. A central area called the fovea is where people see colors, read fine print, and pick out
details. And the peripheral area surrounding the fovea is where people see black and white,
motion and shadows. When we look at a face, we spend most of the time focused on the other
person's eyes, using central vision. So when a person's center of gaze is on Mona Lisa's eyes,
the less accurate peripheral vision is on her mouth. And because peripheral vision is not
interested in specific details, it also picks up shadows from Mona Lisa's cheekbones.
This is where both his sfumato and chiaroscuro techniques come into their own. Keep looking
directly into her eyes. The shadows and tones suggest the curvature of a smile.
But when your eyes go directly to Mona Lisa's mouth, your central vision doesn't see the shadows,
and she isn't smiling. Smirking at best. You can prove this theory quite simply by scanning
back and forth between her eyes and her lips, and her expression changes. That is not your
imagination. It is all to do with how we see, not how we think. The genius of Leonardo is that he
understood this 500 years ago. Some claim that the Mona Lisa is only well known because she was
once stolen. This is nonsense. As previously noted, Mona Lisa was seen as a great painting
right from the start. In 1797 she was moved to the Louvre, where Napoleon saw her and decided he
had to have her. So in 1800 he had her moved to his private bedroom in the Tuileries. Already
the Mona Lisa was a masterpiece fit for Europe's greatest leader. In 1825 the first engravings of
Mona Lisa were made and sold, adding to her popularity. And in 1854 the first photograph
was taken of her. Charles Baudelaire, George Sand and Jules Verne were amongst many to write about
her. And in 1867 the art critic Theophile Gautier published a popular article praising her mysterious
smile and her eyes that hid secrets. While Badeker guidebooks told tourists as early as the 1870s
that she was the most celebrated work of Leonardo in the Louvre. She was being mass-produced and
written about extensively. Mona Lisa was already on her way to becoming known worldwide. And then
On the 21st of August 1911 Vincenzo Perugia, a petty criminal, stole the Mona Lisa and took her
to Italy. It was not until the next afternoon that anyone realised the painting had been stolen,
fuelling the idea that nobody cared. But the truth as always was simpler. The Louvre was
cataloguing its collection and museum staff believed that she had been removed to be
photographed. Suspects, including Picasso who was living in Paris at the time, were rounded up but
no answers were found. In fact the Mona Lisa was missing for over two years, during which people
lined up around the block to look at the empty space where she once was. Perugia was eventually
arrested and the Mona Lisa was recovered. But why did he steal the Mona Lisa rather than any of the
other paintings? The answer again is simple. Because it was the most well-known. So for sure
her fame grew enormously after she was stolen. But it did not begin in 1911. Something else to consider
is that it was only by this time that photography was becoming commonplace. Suddenly, thanks to the
press, millions of people who might not have seen it in person, might never have even heard of it,
soon became experts on Leonardo's stolen painting.
What really cemented her fame was her 1963 visit to the US. This made global headlines
and television brought the Mona Lisa into the living room of billions.
In the same year, Andy Warhol reflected on her transformation from a painting into a celebrity
icon. So yes, the theft made her more well-known and the US tour made her a global celebrity.
But regardless of all this, the Mona Lisa was always considered a masterpiece and would have
become famous in the same way the birth of Venus or the girl with the pearl earring did.
The Mona Lisa is an image that is so familiar that it has been stripped of meaning. Her celebrity
status is a distraction from what a masterpiece she really is. In an era in which we are bombarded
with images, it is more important than ever to stop and look again. Whether she is Mona Lisa,
La Gioconda or La Joconde, she is the face of a revolution in art. The Mona Lisa embodies
Leonardo da Vinci's belief that everything is connected. He had the ability to combine
intellect with imagination. Art and science are perfectly blended in a single work,
that may have started as a simple portrait of a bourgeois woman but has become something much
more poetic, something universal. Leonardo once said that art is never finished, just abandoned,
and it would seem apt that a painting created by a man who never stopped learning
still manages to teach us something 500 years after he created it. Despite all the myths and
legends surrounding her, we are learning more and more about her through science and studies.
Who knows, one day we may see the Mona Lisa exactly the way Leonardo saw her.
