The Truth About the Internet and Your Mental Health - MQ Open Mind

Mental Sharpness
237 followers
Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast, MQ's Open Mind. Again, Craig and I are delighted,
we've got two fantastic guests. We've got Mariana Volliver, and Mariana is known to
Craig and I very well, because obviously she works with MQ, but we'll hear more from Mariana
in a second. And also we've got another guest, Thomas Hackman, and Thomas is currently in the
Netherlands, I think, but we'll hear about his PhD work shortly at the University of Oxford. So
welcome, Mariana and Thomas, to the podcast. Thanks for having me, Rory. Great to be here.
Thank you. And so Mariana, let me kick off with you, because you're obviously known to us, but
maybe not known to all of our people who listen to the podcast. We always start the podcast,
the focus of this podcast, for those who are tuning in, is looking at really the relationship
between the internet and mental health more broadly. But before we get into the nuts and
bolts of the podcast, Mariana, can you tell us a bit about your journey into mental health research?
And obviously you've been with MQ now for a few years, so maybe tell us about your journey,
that'd be great. Yes, so I've been at MQ for four years now, which is a long time,
and my background has been in global health and international development and a little bit of
work with the applications of digital technologies in this field. And at MQ, my role has been focused
on driving lines of research that have to do with the wider determinants of our mental
health, how aspects in our society, in our economic systems, and now in our digital
environments, which is a part of our world now, how do those things affect our mental health,
and also how our mental health can in turn affect or influence all of these factors,
both from ourselves, our personal conditions, but also in the wider
society. And this is how this project of the internet and mental health came into place.
Yeah, thanks Mariana. And you just mentioned there that one of the reasons of the podcast,
or the impetus behind the podcast, is you've been working with Thomas, who you'll hear from
in a second, looking at the relationship between the internet, digital harms, and obviously mental
health, and particularly at, as we obviously in the UK have recently, through Parliament,
obviously, the Online Harms Bill and so on has moved forward. Thomas, same question to you,
though, before we get into the details, is tell us a bit about your background
and the work that you've been doing. All right, sure. Yeah, my background
originally comes from psychology. A funny fact is that both my parents are psychologists, so
I have been psychology from a very young age. My original interest was neuropsychology,
looking at the development of the brain, a particular focus on neurodegenerative diseases.
And then at some point, I started getting interested in more of a social psychology
subject, which was for me, what is the internet doing to us collectively and individually?
What is spending all this time mediated by technology, be it video games, social media,
what is it offering us in terms of risks and harms, but also benefits? And that brought me
to the Oxford Internet Institute, where I've now been for the last five years doing research in
this field, most recently looking at video games specifically. Great. And we'll hear a bit more
about your work, I assume, as we sort of dissect the research evidence. So Marianne, I'll come back
to you then. So tell us about the project. This is an MQ project. Where did the project come from?
What did you hope to achieve? And then we can go into the details about the specifics
in a second. Yes, of course. So it's an MQ project, which we started acknowledging,
as someone was saying, that the omnipresence of digital technologies in our lives. So we wanted
to understand this link with mental health. But furthermore, because there is so much debate
in conversation, in press, in different aspects of the harms of how is it good, how is it bad,
we wanted to know, based on good research and scientific evidence, what do we really know
about these links? And what we took, we took the ambitious scope of the whole internet. So that
includes social media, gaming, artificial intelligence, access to information, and so
forth. And besides compiling what do we know from that, we also wanted to imagine how things can be
better. And not just focusing on all of the harms and how it can be bad, but also how can we make
technology safe and healthy and empowered. Oh, sorry, and I forgot to mention, so we are working
in this project with the University of Melbourne, with Origin, that they conducted the literature
review of longitudinal studies, and they are experts in young people's mental health. And,
of course, as we started this conversation with Thomas, we saw that link, and yeah,
we are then collaborating in this. And who was leading the work in Origin?
Jo Robbins. Oh, it was Jo Robbins. Okay, great. Yeah, Jo was fantastic.
Okay, so then- I'm Bridget Kenney.
I'm sorry, who else? Sorry. Bridget Kenney, that she conducted the literature review.
Well, okay, great. Fantastic. So is this review, is that project finished, though?
Yes. So the project has three phases. One has been the literature review. Second, we conducted
some consultations, including young people, researchers, people from the private sector
and technology developers, to discuss these issues and how can we do that better. And then,
on the third phase, we really don't- didn't want to just make a report and publish it,
and that's it. We want it to be used. So we have been working with different actors at the global
and local sector to make it come to life, to understand what do they need. So right now,
we are in that process of finishing the report that is going to be published and starting to
analyse and use those learnings. Okay, fantastic. Fantastic. Then,
Thomas, back to you then, in terms of- so what do we find in terms of the top line question
we're often asked or we often hear discussed in the media is- the question is, well,
is the internet harmful to young people's mental health? What does the evidence tell us?
There's a small question for you there, Thomas. That's an incredibly huge question, as you can
tell. The internet is a very big, multifaceted space, right? Like commerce happens there,
socialising happens there, gaming happens there. So when we talk about what is the effect of the
internet, we will have to probably zoom in on people's individual experiences, like also what
does their usage look like? Then the other hand of that question, what is the effect on people's
mental health? Even that, especially also young people, takes many different forms and shapes.
The only way I could answer a question that is that big is probably by likening it to,
you know, a diet. Like what is the effect of calories on your health? And the answer would be,
well, that depends, you know? That depends on how are you- like what are your macronutrients like
and does that fit to your life or lifestyle that you desire? And so the same would be for internet.
You can over-consume on a lot of different things that happen, you know, in the digital world.
People can spend too much time on certain applications or people can experience harm
through certain usages of the internet, undeniably so. But on average, I would say the effect of
internet on mental health is probably not that harmful. There are very serious grave harms
perpetrated on the internet, but then you're looking into like specific, yeah, parts of that.
Okay, so let's zoom in, because that's a great answer to really get us going, is that,
okay, of course we have to. The internet is this massive, as you say, it spans all aspects of life.
But if we then zoom in to where we hear so much of the media coverage, and maybe,
Marianna, do you want to kick off on this bit on the role of social media? So we'll come back to
be interested in maybe two particular aspects. One is social media and mental health, and the
other maybe is looking at gaming and mental health, because obviously we could see the growth
in serious games and ways of not just, as we said at the outset, obviously you're looking not just,
Marianna, at the harms, but looking at how we can harness things for the good as well.
So Marianna, do you want to then just kick off maybe with what the evidence tells us on the
relationship between social media and youth mental health? Because I know the focus of the report,
I assume, is on youth given origins involvement. And then, Thomas, you can come back in and add
bits to that, and then we'll move on to the gaming stuff. So Marianna, do you want to kick off?
Yes, of course. And, well, one of the advantages of looking comprehensively at the internet
is that we could recognise that regardless, well, in different activities, the harms or
the potential harms and the benefits are similar. So regardless if it's, for instance, in all
internet activities, one of the potential harms is addiction-like behaviours and compulsive use.
Another one that is across activities is the cyberbullying and exposure to harmful content,
either if it's violence or inappropriately sexual or everything from human trafficking.
But in general, what we see of mechanisms of harm is this compulsive use, potential social comparison,
the algorithmic effects on our decision-making and our behaviours, and cyberbullying.
And in terms of mechanisms of benefit, what we have seen is, well, the access of information
in social media and in gaming and others is the access to social connections and peer support
and feeling empowered by the tools of the internet to explore curiosities, skills, even
leisure, because we have to understand that also for young people, like, play is an activity and
it can be a good activity. As Thomas was saying, it's just not, things are not good or just bad.
So that's a little bit of what we have learned in terms of potential harms and benefits and, well,
I've talked a lot, but maybe after I can give you a little bit of comment on what we have learned
from social media. I think that's good. That's good, Mariana, obviously highlighting the nuance,
obviously, in the debate. Maybe Thomas, then going into a bit more detail then on the,
so somebody said, my understanding of the literature is that the relationship between
social media and mental health, youth mental health, first of all, it's complicated. Secondly,
my understanding is that any effects that are evident are modest and that most of those effects,
of course, they'd be modest, but devastating on some individuals who are already vulnerable.
So is that a correct interpretation of literature or do you want to provide more? It would be great
if you could provide more detail. Yeah, you're right on the ball, Rory. That is where the
literature currently stands. So the big studies that have been done about the effects of social
media on mental health do consistently on a big population level find slight negative associations.
We have to be careful in interpreting that cautiously, like we have to be cautious in
interpreting that causally, but these effects are about the size of having an unhealthy diet
is on your mental health, wearing glasses is for your mental health. So we're speaking about things
that aren't determining, big determining factors in whether or not your mental health switches from
one state to the other. That being said, that is on a population level. Anecdotal evidence,
more qualitative research has certainly found that people can also experience big harms in
social media. And there are also particular vulnerable populations when it comes to social
media. One that the news often mentions is young girls. Here, the harms to mental health often are
related to social comparison or indeed kind of sexual exploitation or grooming practices at the
worst. What you have here, Dan, is that there is a part where people truly suffer, potentially even
because of social media or the interactions on there. But on average, most people manage to
balance it and are fine with it. Still doesn't mean that on self-report skills, they say that
they're happy with it because there is also this underlying thing of, is it useful time, time spent
on social media or on the internet more broadly. People might still rather be doing something else,
but it might not be negatively influencing their mental health, particularly if they're using it as
any other leisure activity. And the alternative would be watching Netflix, reading a book or
another hobby instead of, for example, exercise or sleep or things that the literature knows are
very beneficial for your mental health. That's really helpful. Do we have any idea though,
in terms of other populations that are vulnerable? I would say within every population,
of course, no one is immune for the dangers of the web. Other populations that are vulnerable
would be LGBTQ communities, although they also have, there are studies that have shown clear
benefits, particularly for these communities, because internet places, especially video games,
can operate as a safe space to explore with different identities, genders, or other kind
of like personalities that potentially you couldn't be do, you know, in your quote unquote,
like real life back at home. Of course, there are other communities as well. And then I'm thinking
about other minority communities, you know, different populations all across the globe
that are not kind of, yeah, the dominant, the dominant group. Yeah, no, because obviously
there's been competing narratives, obviously published recently in the popular science
literature in terms of the evidence for and against. And I suppose when I think the field
that we work in and I work in suicide prevention is for me, the issue is the debate, we've lost
all nuance in the debate. And although I firmly believe we need to be regulating social media
companies, we need to make sure safe material is presented and we don't have algorithms that
put you down this rabbit hole of despair and disaster. But there is a number of important
bodies that's often then used as a get out clause for governments. Obviously, I can understand why
the government is supported regulation, and I supported it as well. But often it's a get out
clause of we need to, if we're looking at mental health, the determinants of mental health, as we
well know, are multifaceted, cross life, cross generation. And I think too often social media
has been used as a scapegoat to explain declining mental health in young people. And it's so much
more complicated than that. And although, yes, so don't get me wrong, of course, we need to
regulate and keep places as safe as possible. That's only one small part of the complex puzzle
of understanding young people's mental health. Maybe on that note then, Mariana, and again,
on this positive note, and then I'm going to come back to Thomas when we ask about the evidence for
gaming, which there is obviously now growing evidence for some positive benefits. But Mariana,
in terms of your reading of literature and involvement in this project, then what does
the evidence tell us about the positive benefits of the internet, of social media in different
populations? So one of the, well, from the positive angle, as Thomas was saying, there's
this part of, especially in young ages, of exploring an identity, of developing curiosities,
but one, and this is like, I'm cautious to say this, because there's some evidence about it,
but we still really don't understand, but there is this hypothesis of the rich gets richer.
So essentially, when you have a fulfilling life offline, when you have a wide range of fulfilling
offline activities, social life, I don't know, hobbies, so your social media or your online
activities become an expansion of that fulfilling life. When you don't have that,
and, you know, particularly for young people from marginalised or underserved communities that have
less access to entertainment options, or, you know, that are not socially skillful, then
that starts to create vulnerabilities. And that goes to Thomas' point, that is not social media
causing something, but there are underlying things on the offline. And also just in terms
of social media, one aspect that was helpful to know is research can help, like, practically,
to put limits to those harms. And one example that we explore in the report, and I just wanted
to mention, particularly because it relates to young girls, is that after finding that there's
a link between the use of dieting products and the development of eating disorders, then
Instagram banned the advertising of dieting products to under-18s. So those are limits
based on evidence that we can put, and we can do more of that to understand what are the boundaries.
Yeah, no, that's good points. The earlier point there reminded me, your first point reminded me
a bit of when Craig and I interviewed Alistair Campbell, the podcaster and mental health
campaigner, is Alistair Campbell talked about, when he thinks about his own mental health,
he talks about having a jar, and basically, when you have lots of things in your jar,
it's a jam jar, right? So he was using it to explain the multifactorial nature of mental
health. And he said at the very bottom of the jar, you've maybe got your genetic influences,
then you've got all your lifestyle stuff, your diet, doing exercise, in this case,
going whatever, wild swimming, spend time with family and friends, having a project he's really
involved in. But the point he was making was, what you're trying to do is grow the jam jar,
is effectively what he was saying. And I suppose that sort of came to mind when you're
chatting about, if you already have awful stuff going on in your life, and then awful stuff then
also happens in the internet, or you don't have, you have the absence of more protective factors
potentially, then obviously the risk of the internet or social media grows. So that sort
of struck me as you were speaking there. Don't know how good a comparison that is, but anyway,
it came into my head. Thomas, back to you then, I'm going to ask you a couple of questions. One is
maybe on the gaming work, because you've been doing work on gaming. And so for those people
who are unfamiliar, how you go about studying, investigating that, can you tell us what you've
been doing or what the evidence has told us? And then how we can harness gaming for the good,
as well as always hearing about gaming being a link to internet addiction and so on.
You've already used the word scapegoat. And I think when it comes to digital technologies,
gaming often has become arguably the biggest scapegoat of them all. In America, in American
media at least, it has often been blamed for causing violence. School shooters always played
Call of Duty, for example, or any other kind of shooting game where they must have learned
how to be violent, but it's not true. The science has shown over and over again that being exposed
to violent video games or violent content does not make you yourself violent. Everyone in Japan
also plays Call of Duty, but there hasn't been a shooting ever, I think. So these, especially
video games, not just for violence, but also for addiction or other kind of negative things,
video games have often been blamed. That has kind of created a tricky situation for research,
where before, because games were shown in such a bad light, the gaming companies who hold the data
to study these phenomena also weren't that interested in participating in research.
And I think over the last 10 years, that has really changed. So in our research, we are working
together with all the big gaming companies right now, not just the publishers, but also the platforms.
So you'd be thinking about the Nintendos and Xboxes to study what real gameplay behavior and
actual objective playtime does to players' mental health. Before we started these collaborations,
we just had to ask people, how long do you play and how does it make you feel? And we have
we and others have found that people are not really good at accurately remembering how much
time they spend online, especially if they're in these immersive environments like video games,
where there's this whole concept about flow, but people lose track of time. And what we have found
is that on average, the amount of time you play does not seem to be a good predictor of your
mental health. The quality of your play seems to be that. So it depends again on people personally,
if someone has five hours available to play, they can play and be happy with that. If someone has
two hours to play, they can do that. If someone does not have time for play and therefore doesn't
play, they're probably less happy than someone who has time available to play and chooses play
as their leisure activity of preference. This is in contrast to what I have first said about
social media, where there is a consistent slight negative association. Here we find
either a null association or a positive association on average.
And what outcome measures do you tend to be using in those studies?
We're looking at life satisfaction, subjective well-being, measures of addiction and dysregulation
and a whole bunch of others. We're looking at sleep measures as well. We're looking at
time displacement measures, like what else would you be doing? And yeah, personality and depression
indexes as well. We try to go as wide as we can. And across all of those indicators,
there's either this positive effect or no effect at all. I mean, that's not for everyone.
That is on average. Yeah, that is the average result. Yeah. Of course, there are people who
struggle, of course, you know, with all those things, life satisfaction, well-being, depression.
But on average, on the population level, we see no clear negative effect at all.
Just to pivot slightly, so talking about gaming, so that's one of my main hobbies. So what I've
seen over the last decade is that there's been a rise in mechanisms that's been involved in the
game kind of landscape. So in terms of the rise of microtransactions, so if anybody doesn't realize,
but it's more of like spending small amounts of money on, well, I guess at first it started with
cosmetic items, and it started turning into actual things that you can use to kind of
get ahead in gaming. And also the rise of stuff like loot boxes, which is essentially like
gambling aimed at children. Has there been any research or anything that's been involved about
that aspect? Well, before you answer that, Thomas, what is that? Loot boxes, did you say?
Yeah, so I'll explain loot boxes. Loot boxes are the digital equivalent of what buying a pack of
trading cards was, you know, kind of offline. You buy the pack that has a chance of having a special
card in it, a special Pokemon card, or just more the kind of common ones. But the problem here is,
is that you do not know what you're paying for, but you know it could have a slight chance of
something pretty epic. This is pretty much akin to gambling. You're spending money on,
you do not know what. And especially for games that are played by young people,
this is incredibly problematic, because gambling is something you can only start doing as an adult,
even then, gambling research has also shown that gambling is not, on average, good for your mental
health. So then to have kind of these like similar practices in games, I think is problematic,
and the science has shown that too. And then go back then to the sort of evidence then, right? So
the take home thus far then, just as far as I understand what you've said then is, both of you,
is that the evidence for gaming and mental health is positive or no effect at all. And then with the
social media, although of course it can be devastating impacts on some individuals,
on average, the effects are small or modest and are similar in size to the impact of diets and
so on on your mental health or well-being. So if that's a correct understanding of the
broad literature on those two areas, I suppose my question to both of you then is, if you had
all the money in the world, right, what's the one question that you'd want to be addressed
in the sort of broad sphere or field of internet, stroke harms, benefits, mental health?
Right. Unlimited money. Like the actual social media companies of today have, I would want to get
a representative population. So all these questions we are studying on the ones we can reach
or on the ones who are on these platforms. And there are so many like under-marginalized
minority communities around the world that simply we haven't even studied yet.
And to get a good answer to any of the questions that we want to know, we need to not just study
the kind of convenience samples of the West. That's where I would take it.
Yeah, that's a good answer. Mariana, same question to you.
So first of all, I do share with Thomas that the point is that since we have found we need
longitudinal data and all of these platforms, what they have is longitudinal data from
huge samples in the world, but this data is not shared with independent research.
So that is one thing. And I would use that data to understand how we can build the algorithms
that are going to drive our digital future in a compassionate way, so that algorithms themselves
are compassionate in terms of having the capacity of recognizing suffering, try to avoid it,
do actions, and that technology is not just designed to trigger all of our vulnerabilities
for profit. So yes, I think that I would invest... That was a slightly longer answer.
No, that's not what I was thinking.
Incorporating compassion into algorithm intelligence, I think that would be the
short version. Yeah, no, I think that's really,
really important. But I suppose that leads me on to another interesting question, which is,
what else do we think social media should be doing to protect young people's mental health?
And I assume there's recommendations in the report around this. So
if you want to kick off on that.
I think the first step is what Mariana just said. The social media companies should
open up their databases to independent research. Before we can take action, we need to know what
is the real effect. And indeed, all this data, all this online behavior, all this time spent online
has been stored by these servers. And right now, this data is used to optimize algorithms to sell
more advertisements. But this data can also be used to study online behavior and its effects
thereof. So I think that's step one. Are we tiptoeing step one, step two, or should I just
take over, Mariana?
No, you continue.
Right. Well, and then if we have the tech industry opening up its data to independent
research, then independent research needs to look at that, but not alone. They need to do that with
practitioners, families, and youth themselves to start integrating the lived experience of then
how this is integrated in people's daily lives and the outcomes from that. And I think after that,
policy will need to listen to the evidence-based that's being formed to produce evidence-based
regulations for the technology industry. So it shouldn't be one based on stigma or kind of like
political waves of fear or anger. It should be a collaboration between all these parties.
And then these regulations, one example would be a duty of care for social media or like technology
companies in the sense that if they are the creators and moderators of these digital spaces
where youth and children spend their time, then they should have a duty of care to minimize the
harms that are perpetrated or created in these spaces. Other things that might be helpful are
a certification for developers who work on spaces for youth. Right now, these are made by
brilliant coders and developers that are given by a metric to optimize for by a business department
of one of these companies. And that metric will probably be user engagement or spending.
So they're creating spaces for youth where youth try to develop identities, where they try to
socialize, where they find access to information and try to navigate the world. But what they are
building these spaces for is not to further those causes. It's just to try to consume as much of
their time or money or data as possible. So I think the people developing these spaces should
probably kind of be certified like any other profession that works with children, be that
teachers or caregivers or something like that. I think that would be another great thing to
implement to start making these spaces safer for youth.
Yeah, that's a great answer and such an important answer. As you say, in any other setting,
there will be some requirement or some check that you're meeting some minimum standard.
Mariana, anything else to add to that?
Well, those responsibilities that social media companies or tech developers in general
have or the private sector have is soft responsibilities. So there's a responsibility
to promote and to try your best. But essentially, if you don't, nothing really happens. Or even when
fines are done or legal consequences are designed, they are so minimal for the power and the
resources that these companies have that it becomes really pointless because if you can pay
a fine and keep doing what you're doing, you're just going to do it anyway. So that is one thing
like I would work on the enforceability of that. But also we know that it cannot, you know,
by prohibitions and regulations, you can only do so much. We really need to explore ways to use
positive engagement strategies so that people are drawn to whatever activity came in,
not through their vulnerabilities, but more like feeding on a desire to be better people,
to connect genuinely with others, to learn to other things, you know, just to... We need to
tell also the private sector, what can you do instead? And make that enforceable.
Also another point that I wanted to make related to the enforceability is that most of the
recommendations about how to make the internet safer, they put the weight on carers, on parents,
on the individuals, on schools, when it's really we need to focus more on the systemic things,
the technology itself, the economic models of our digital world, and not just in small things like
the social media, the screen time, those are really not the right questions.
Yeah, I suppose we should be more focused on not just the economics, but the well-being economics,
I mean, in terms of trying to... That should be prioritised, because as you say, the big tech
companies aren't incentivised sufficiently. They're so vast that, as you say, a small fine
is such a drop in the ocean for them. Okay, so a couple of last questions,
can you try and squeeze in a couple of last questions before we bring it to a close?
Okay, the first one is trying to be more optimistic in terms of how we can take home
messages. So start with you this time again, Thomas. So can you tell us what can advice to
young people out there, families out there, how can people stay safe in the internet,
or what can they be doing to promote safety? Yes, I do think safety should not come from
the end user, but should be built into the system and built into society. But of course,
people should also be able to take measures into their own hands, and you're not powerless in this.
I think that one of the key take-home messages when it comes to digital use is quality, not
quantity, which means that you should think, what does this bring me? What am I doing,
and am I enjoying it? And that will probably also naturally then start limiting the time spending
if you repeat those questions. The second point would be, take a holistic approach.
Don't hyper-focus on digital media usage or screen time alone. See how this technology
fits into your life and what the behavioral trade-offs are. What else would you be doing
if you wouldn't be doing something online right now? And the third one also for especially young
people, but I think it applies to everyone, is that talk to those around you that you trust
when it comes to online experience. Talk to parents, talk to friends about anything that
looks odd, feels out of place, or you feel like you are losing control of.
Okay, great. That's really wise, practical advice. Marianne, same for you. What else would you add?
Well, I think Thomas just mentioned everything. The only thing that I would add to that,
for young people, for families, for schools, and everybody else, is just to really join advocacy
efforts to, well, Amnesty International, for instance, they have very important, very well
evidence-based advocacy campaigns for digital rights, and I would really encourage people to
join those advocacy efforts. Okay, great, great. There are also things you can do when it comes
specifically to the technology, right? There are apps. Basically, you can, in a way, fight
technology at their own game, where they are trying to make these apps as seamless and as
smooth as possible, as low friction as possible. They're on your phone, colorful notifications.
When you're in, it immediately tells you, like, this and this is happening.
You can kind of do the opposite. You can install certain apps that, for example, allow you to take
a deep breath before you open Instagram or something. I have found, if people want really
concrete little quick fixes, that something like that helps people, because by adding back in that
friction, it gives you a moment to think, do I want to be using this app now, or am I doing so
out of habit, or because the app told me, by means of a notification or something,
that they want my attention? If you kind of create that little bump again,
you are forced to just think for a minute, or not a minute, for the time of one deep breath,
am I in agreement with this, or actually, do I not want it? Things like that can help as well.
Excellent. That's a great way to sort of bring things almost to a close.
Let's see, Mariana's trying to come in again. Yeah, sorry. I was just going to mention one
thing, and it just went that we will show through the report, but also through the
conversations that we've had in this project with different people, what we have discovered.
It's really that there are very good examples, just as someone said, of how technology can be
good. Through the report, we are going to see examples of collaborations between the safety
children, and with PAI, that is an artificial intelligence assistant, with emotional
intelligence incorporated in it. We are going to see advocacy efforts, so we do want to show
that things can be given, that there is a way, that there are people and organisations trying to
do things right, to not give a very pessimistic scenario of the digital future.
Okay, that's an important point to almost bring it to an end. That's twice I've tried to end this
podcast, and twice both Thomas and Mariana had loads to say. That just illustrates how much
there is to talk on this topic. Okay, so just before we bring it to an end, I'll just ask one last
unrelated question, which we try and just end on a sort of upbeat note. But before I do, is there any
other key message that either of you would like to convey about the relationship between digital
harms, mental health, the benefits of the internet, or whatever it might be, before we bring it to
a close? Anything you'd hoped to have said, or been asked, but haven't had the opportunity?
I would say, think about your use like a digital diet. With your diet, you're always thinking,
how much fat do I need? Protein? Carbohydrates? And it depends, are you running a race the next
day? Are you trying to lose weight, gain weight? Are you exercising or not? Too much fat is bad.
Too much protein is bad. Too much carbohydrates is bad. Too much of anything in the digital world
is also bad. And you have to figure out, when does consumption on internet become over-consumption?
And when should I tone it down and find ways of doing that? That's my take-home.
Nice, a nice take-home that. Marianne, any final take-home from you? You don't have to have,
because there's one other question as well. Well, no, I would just emphasise on the point
that we need to, on the role of mental health research, of helping to design technology in a
healthy way. And so it's for humans and not only for consumers. Excellent, that's amazing.
If I can add to that. Am I ever going to get this podcast finished?
Sorry. Talk, Thomas, quickly. I'm running late for my next meeting, but you've got two minutes.
Sorry, because that one was for people, or for like the general population. The other
important take-home message is we cannot study this as scientists if we do not get access to
the data that companies hold. And if scientists cannot study these questions, policy cannot create
evidence-based policy that really improves mental health and tackles the harms. So it all starts by
the willingness of these private entities to start working with scientists and the people
to really study how we can improve this. Okay, brilliant. Such an important point,
right? I'm going to try again to bring the podcast to a close, right? So, okay,
so we have this unrelated question. So, Marianne, I'm going to ask you this question just to try and
it's a nice way to end. So the question is, if you had the opportunity to have dinner with
any historical figure, who would it be and why? Well, probably there's a more interesting
answer to this, but just because we have been talking about the integration of compassion
into algorithms, I would say Buddhas to understand how compassion works and how can we actually
implement it. So I think that would be my answer. Yeah, that's a great answer, Marianne.
And Thomas, say a few. I am shocked that was going to be my answer. I cannot believe that.
Okay. Are you being serious? That was going to be your answer? Yeah, yeah. All right. No,
you're not invited to my dinner. You just have to find your own. You know, maybe he would be
fasting anyway and he doesn't want to go on the dinner. Who's your second choice, then?
Your second choice, Thomas? Beethoven. And why? Someone who has made music so timeless. I wonder
what it was like, you know, in his time. Was that the pop music of today? Yeah, I do. That's what I
want to find out. Yeah, that's a question I've often wondered myself as well when I think about
Mozart and Beethoven and whatever. Yeah, I will invite you to my dinner, but if you also invite
me to your dinner, I would like to know that. On that note anyway, on that note, on behalf of
Craig and I, huge thanks, Thomas and Marianne. That was a really fascinating discussion. And
Marianne, the last question for you is if people want to know when's the report out and how can
people get access to it? I think so. We are publishing it in mid-September and we are going
to be disseminating it in social media and everybody who can use this work, understand
how is it applicable at MQ, open to start conversations with anybody who wants to
join our efforts. We are very fortunate to be working well with Thomas, with Amnesty International,
with BWC. So we are really trying to gather efforts and that we are aligned in this.
Okay. Okay. Well, thanks a million for that. And a huge thanks again to both of you.
So, and to our listeners, hope you enjoyed that really important lesson. And again,
keep an eye out for the report in September. Thanks a lot, Rory.
Thank you, Rory. Thank you, Craig. Thanks.
