Economy will see ripple effects of strike 'within hours', says U.S. Chamber of Commerce's Bradley

Financial Freedom
10 followers
Oct 1, 2024
Neil Bradley, U.S. Chamber of Commerce chief policy officer, joins 'Closing Bell Overtime' to talk the looming port strike and how it could impact U.S. businesses, consumers and the economy.
Well, joining us now is U.S.
Chamber of Commerce Chief Policy
Officer Neil Bradley.
The chamber out with a new poll
about the potential strike, saying
a majority of Americans want the
government to step in and stop it.
And it just sent a letter to
President Biden urging him
to intervene.
Neil, it's great to have you on.
I've seen numbers as high from J.P.
Morgan as five billion dollars
a day in economic impact.
But we also know that
a lot of the shipping companies,
a lot of the shippers who have
their goods on those ships that
would normally be coming into
east and Gulf Coast ports, have
been diverting them and making
other plans.
So at what point could
this truly become
harmful and detrimental to the
economy and impact
start impacting consumers and
businesses?
Well, Morgan, thanks for having me
on. If we have a strike at
twelve oh one tonight, which it
does look like that's where we're
heading within hours, you
will start to see some of the
ripple effects.
So if you have
just a one day strike, for
example, that creates a backlog
within these affected ports
that takes on average six
days to clear.
The strike goes on for two days.
You're talking about two weeks just
to clear up the mess that's been
created.
So it's not hard to imagine a
situation where even a strike that
only lasted one week
actually disrupts the economy well
into November.
And if you're a small business
who's counting on goods coming in
over the next two weeks, for
example, for your holiday sales
season, you may miss out on
the entire season if the strike
actually occurs.
And we just mentioned that you
sent a letter to President Biden.
He has the power as the president
to potentially invoke the 1947
Taft-Hartley Act.
That gives the federal government
authority to step in and labor
disputes. But he's also been pretty
vocal in saying he's not going to
do that.
So what is your message to him
today and why do you think you can
change his mind if it does involve
invoking that act?
Well, taking the invocation of
Taft-Hartley off the table is just
a mistake.
This is not like it's a new idea,
as you pointed out, it's been in the
law since 1947.
And on 37 different
occasions, President Biden's
predecessors have used this
act to ensure that
striking workers
can't bring our economy to a
complete halt.
And so our message
to the president is
that this is much bigger
than one union and these
ports. This is really a question
for our entire economy.
He has the responsibility and the
authority to use the powers
under the law to protect
our economy.
And by the way, it happens to be
what the American people want.
We just released a poll today.
Fifty seven percent of Americans
say the president should use
this authority to protect our
economy and keep the ports
open and operating.
You know how many days you think
before this becomes a sort of
redline event for the economy?
How many days of striking?
Yeah, as I mentioned earlier,
John, you know, it really only
takes one day of strike to have
these types of things.
But how bad is that is what
I'm asking.
Sure, you have the ripple effects.
You end up potentially with
companies pursuing air freight
instead, which costs a lot more.
And I imagine those costs get
passed along to the consumer
affecting inflation.
But but how many days if you've
calculated that before it becomes
a really serious problem?
Yeah, I think it's just a few days
because, as you point out, this is
a compounding effect.
Look, look right now.
Look at spot shipping prices.
Look at what's happened over the
last few weeks as importers
and exporters have tried to get
ahead of this strike.
They've actually driven up the
cost of shipping goods into
and out of the United States
just by the threat of a strike.
And so if we actually cross the
threshold, if we actually end up
in a strike, I think that is
going to send shockwaves through
the economy.
Remember, we haven't had a strike
on our east and Gulf Coast ports
since 1977.
That strike lasted for 44
days.
It is a much bigger, much more
trade reliant economy today.
If we even come close to that,
you're talking about economic
devastation for the United
States.
I mean, we've seen labor take a
much more aggressive approach and
and have the leverage to do it in
recent years because
it's been a tight labor market.
And obviously we've got Boeing
and its striking machinists right
now and reports that those talks
have broken down as well.
You've got the possibility that
UAW workers at Stellantis
factories are actually going to
start going on strike as well for
what they see as violations to
their labor agreement.
It all raises the question,
is this labor's last
stand if we do have a cooling job
market or does this unrest
continue?
Yeah, I think we've entered a
situation in which the demands
that are being put forward by many
labor leaders just are
out of touch with kind of economic
reality, even in this situation.
You know, the port operators want
to provide a big raise to workers,
but the seventy seven percent raise
that the union is demanding,
that there's just no way that the
economics can accommodate that.
By the way, all of us who
buy things would end up paying that
that that price.
And so I think we have a situation
today where you're right,
the unions are feeling more
emboldened, the union leadership,
but their tactics have real
collateral damage from small
businesses who can't get goods
in. So think about the restaurants
around some of these factories that
have been shuttered by recent
strikes. There's no strike fund
for the restaurant owner who loses
all their business.
There's no strike fund for the
manufacturer who sells goods
into these manufacturing plants.
And so we're starting to see that
this aggressive posture by labor
leaders is really beginning
to drag on our economy.
