Dave Argues With a Whole Life Insurance Salesman

The Ramsey Show Highlights
1.8K followers
442 Video Views·Oct 1, 2024
[Music]
brought to you by the every dooll app
start budgeting for free today you know
my name is Elliot I graduated from a top
20 you know business school and college
after college I sold triple net
investment sales for about two years and
then for the last years of for the last
year I've been a whole life agent uh
that you know in Louisville we partner
with many different workingclass
companies um for discussion purposes um
you know the average American retires
with about $55,000
in their bank account um personally I
tell my friends and family you know to
cash out their Whole Life policies and
the way I pitch whole life it's it's not
necessarily as an investment vehicle but
more so as a savings or a savings
account but simply as insurance that
accumulates cash value and a paid up
coverage over time in my eyes I believe
I'm leaving my members better off than
before they talk to me but why am I
doing something so horrible in your eyes
well because the product is crap not
because you're a bad guy but the product
that you're selling you're you're trying
to do a good thing Elliot and thank you
for doing that and I appreciate I
appreciate your heart but basically I
mean it's a math problem so if you take
a $200 whole life premium per month I
can buy the same amount of term
insurance on that 30-year-old for about
$10 so the the other 190 would go
towards cash
value in the typical policy the top 10
stock companies out there okay that's
the actual data that's out there in
today's market and so if I'm paying
$190 extra for the life insurance in
order to create a savings account that's
not the end of the world but it's the
rules of the savings account that are
the cash value we'll call it savings you
said we're using it as a savings vehicle
that are the problem the typical whole
life policy accumulates zero cash value
in the first three years have you
noticed
that yeah I know that okay so it's
called what we would what you and I
people in the financial industry like
you me and George we would call that
front loaded commission
agreed yes so so I have a savings
account that I'm putting $190 in my
example in per month and the first three
years I get zero it 100% goes to the
bank goes to the life insurance company
okay after that the typical whole life
policy accumulates at a
1.2% rate some of them go as high as 3
or 4% some of the universal policies
will go as high as 4 to 7% some of the
indexed universal policies that are
indexed to a like an S&P after fees will
go as high as seven or 8% rate of return
yeah okay but the typical basic whole
life policy not a not a universal policy
is accumulating at under 2% so I have a
savings account that for the first three
years I put money in it they keep my
money after that when I finally start
saving it accumulates at one to
2% and here's the thing okay now what
would be you say Elliott in your case
the typical size face value of policy
that you sell is what's a normal policy
for you you know it's going to vary from
someone who's 18 to you know 70 okay so
but I mean you're out there selling
who's your typical customer let's say
you had a
30-year-old would the typical customer
is Joe he works construction and uh so
he's probably not doing a $200 a month
premium like I'm using as an example
then no no for me I've never sold a $200
a month premium policy so probably more
like a
100 on average it' be more like between
50 and 70 say these are
$50,000 face value policies
right yeah or less I would say okay so
they're small policies would you agree
with me that a guy that makes $40,000 a
year and dies 50,000 is not enough to
take care of his
family it correct it's not enough to
take care of it his family if you wanted
to replace a $40,000 a year income you
would need north of 400,000 invested at
10%
correct and but I would say it's better
than nothing it's better than nothing
but for the same money he's spending he
could have bought the right amount of
insurance if he bought term right and
and the funny thing about term too is I
talked to these people when they hit the
age of retirement and they're like yeah
I paid in this life insurance my whole
life but then I never used it and
they're so upset with me about it yeah
and no they're not upset with you you
haven't been selling long enough to meet
anybody that kept it till retirement you
just started but that that they were
could could be upset with the industry
maybe but that I haven't had that
problem U because here's the thing if
you take the $10 a month and you bought
in our let's drop it to $5 a month and
call it a $70,000 policy yeah after
let's go back to our savings account I
was using 190 a while ago now I've got
to drop it down to about 95 because I'm
$100 a month policy okay now if we're
going to do that the $5 is covering the
insurance 95 is going into the Savings
Program zero for the first 3 years after
that it's accumulating at 2% and after
that uh if it builds up a cash value of
5 or $10,000 after 10 15 20 years right
yeah okay right they die with a $660,000
whole life policy with a $155,000 cash
value that they've paid extra to build
the cash value with a $60,000 whole life
policy would you agree with me that the
insurance company's going to send them a
check for $60,000
only the 60,000 exactly corre so you
paid for a savings program and when you
die they keep your
money yes y nice Parting
Gift that's why we think it sucks man
it's zero 100% is kept for the first
three years after that it's accumulating
at a lousy rate and when you when I die
you keep my money I paid extra Beyond
term to get whole life to get a whole
life policy that has a savings program
in it and my savings program when I die
doesn't go to my family it goes to the
insurance
company if I opened a bank with those
terms the bank would go broke no one
would put Savings in there so it's not
enough to actually cover and replace
income and you don't actually get the
cash value when you die I'm
confused the the only thing that I will
say I think a problem that it is it is
helping is that people do only retire
with about $5,000 in their bank account
well that's because they bought this
crap they didn't have any money to
invest because they gave it to you if
you put the $95 in a Roth IRA they would
retire
millionaires yeah but I don't think I'm
putting a policy in place where it's
like that uncomfortable where they
didn't have enough money to invest on
top of that like why don't they use the
money to invest wisely and if I showed
them an investment calculator and I put
the same amount in there they would be
flabbergasted and they would be running
far away from this prodct if I bought
term life insurance and wasted all that
money money for my whole life and ended
up a multi-millionaire as opposed to a
insurance company keeping my savings
that I paid for I don't think anybody's
going to be mad about that Elliot it's
like telling someone Dave the show this
show is great in season 12 it gets good
you can get through the first 12 seasons
of the show I promise it'll be mediocre
at best I'm not binging that no thank
you Elliot I think you're probably a
good guy but I think you're probably if
you keep doing the math on this you're
going to probably end up doing a
different type of financial planning
that's more beneficial to the folks
you're trying to serve this is the
Ramsey Show so if you look in the
skyline of the typical midsized City the
towers in the skylines particularly 20
years ago uh and before would be two
things
Banks and life insurance
companies Santa Claus did not build
those buildings
you
did you did your money went to them you
chose for it to go to them they didn't
steal it from you but their
products are so profitable to
them not to
you that they own the skylines don't you
just wish you had the bank
furniture they got the best furniture
so when we talk to a young man like
Elliott who's selling whole life life
insurance or an old man or an old woman
that's selling life insurance whole life
life insurance we find the only people
that believe that rhetoric that line
that he was that we just covered with
him and honestly I to his credit I think
he truly believes he's doing good
there's two types of whole life life
insurance agents as far as I'm concerned
the ones that understand they're
screwing people and the ones that don't
and he's one he doesn't he really thinks
he's doing a good thing and so but I
have done a lot of enthusiastically
stupid things
too uh by the way folks I'll help you
with this you get screwed way more often
by enthusiastic
ignoramuses than you do actual
conment there's not that many actual
Psychopaths out there like a Bernie maid
off there's a few of them but your
friend who's trying to talk you into
Bitcoin is an enthusiastic
ignoramus they're not con people they're
just even probably even the little fried
kid that is going to jail or whatever
Sam bankman free he might not even be a
real crook I don't know I haven't really
looked at the details of that he might
just be a massively enthusiastic
ignoramus you know what I'm saying and
so really what you've got to do is you
have to follow the money
and and you know be a fruit inspector
what's the fruit of the products when we
talk
to uh multi-millionaires and
millionaires we don't find them
using payday
lenders rent to
own whole life life
insurance we don't find them using
ripoff Finance products Financial
products they have avoided those things
and it's one of the secrets that causes
them to be wealthy and that's really
where you know this stuff breaks down
and and so um I mean I have really good
friends that used to sell whole life
life insurance and at and once they
actually because I just pound the crap
out of them but I mean they they finally
just like I get it and I can't sell it
anymore because I have a conscience I
you know if you have a good friend that
is a Payday lender and is ripping off
poor people at 800%
interest that's called oppressing the
poor you do not want to read in the
Bible what God does to people who
oppress the poor when you mess with the
poor on purpose screwing them and you
mess with widows and orphans you don't
want to be on that list in the Bible
it's not a good list to be
on a and so you don't want to be on the
wrong side of a financial product and be
justifying it well it's better than
nothing no it's actually not you'd be
better I'll put your money in a fruit
jar create your free every dollar budget
today the simplest way to budget for
your life
