An Atheist Debates with Dr Zakir

Your Faith
11 followers
Morning Mr. Zakir Naik. My name is Jay Mishtamani.
First of all I want to thank you for what you're doing here. I've really taken a lot away from me
I'm sure. My question is on your point number three. Actually I have three questions if you
could be so kind. But on point number three, first of all I felt that it was very evasive
your answer but what I'm going to ask you is very simple. When you talk about terrorism,
when you talk about Islam. Now this is a very simple straightforward question. I hope I can
get a straightforward answer. With what's happening in Pakistan, Iraq, Afghanistan,
just to name a few. I'm not stereotyping. I hope no one takes offense. But when you hear on the
news that a woman is cooking food for her kids and then a suicide bomber comes and kills them.
I want to ask you a simple question. What is that? Is that Islam or is that people who don't
understand what Islam is and they have their own perception of Islam? And please let me ask you
one more thing. Can you give me an answer that is not in world war one or something there were more
people that died or this is all propaganda and these are Americans killing people and that's not
the answer. Hear my answer then you can pass your comment. The brother has the question
that years in Afghanistan and Pakistan a woman cooking food a suicide bomber comes and blows up
and kills. As far as Islam what the media is saying forget about it. I'll give you ruling of
Islam whether what the media says right or wrong. Quran says in Surah Maida chapter number five
verse number 32. If anyone kills any other human being unless it be for murder or for spreading
corruption in the land it is as though he has killed the whole of humanity. Any person kills
any other human being whether Muslim or non-Muslim unless it be for murder or for spreading
corruption in the land it is as though he has killed the whole of humanity and if any human
being saves other human being it is as though he has saved the whole nation. So according to the
Quran killing any single innocent human being is prohibited. If a suicide bomber comes
and kills a woman who's cooking she's innocent it is 100% prohibited whether done in Pakistan
or Afghanistan or America or Dubai. Is the answer clear? 100% wrong. Whoever's doing it
whether namesake Muslim or American or propaganda whoever's doing it it is totally prohibited.
Fine so is it clear answer? That is clear. 100% clear. Whether you do anyone does. 100%
wrong. It is as though he has killed the whole of humanity. There is no other scripture that
I know of today. There is no other scripture that I know of today that gives the statement
that if you kill one human being it is as though you killed the whole humanity except the Quran.
There's no other scripture that I know which says that if you say one human being you have saved
the whole of humanity. No other scripture. Perfect now can I ask you something? Yes. You've told me
this is wrong yeah? 100% wrong. Fine fine fine. Now why are you here? The way I look at it all
of these are innocent loving people here. Why isn't this convention somewhere like Afghanistan
and Pakistan trying to teach people that what they are doing is not Islam and is just some
brainwashed chaos and that they're going to go to hell and they're not going to go to heaven for
killing innocent people for the 9-1-1 attacks for the London bombings. Innocent people died. If I
don't like you and I kill you it's more justified than if I don't like somebody. If I don't like
Jews and I go and kill innocent Americans with families why don't you go and educate these people
and have a better cause rather than converting four or five people here and save thousands of lives.
Brother has asked a very good question. He's telling me why don't I go to Pakistan to Afghanistan and
spread this message and prevent this. Brother I go every day even now I'm going there. I'm on the
satellite. We have Peace TV reaching 100 million people. This is how much? This is 20-30 thousand
people. The audience here will be 20-30 thousand people not more than that. You see the recording.
Why do the recording? So that I can go to Pakistan. I can go to Afghanistan. I can go to
even America. And my lectures on jihad and terrorism the maximum viewership it has got
more than 100 million people and it is meant for the full world. I'm giving here it is being
recorded being telecast. The thing is I cannot force anyone the point of those who accept my
message. Can I force you? Am I forcing you? Am I forcing you to accept my message? How can I
force the people of Pakistan? How can I force the people of Afghanistan? At the same time, at the
same time, at the same time I also tell the innocent people being killed I agree with you.
What's the numbers? You said you know four five people converting here is better than telling that
my job is to deliver the message.
Mentioned in the Quran surah Ghasha chapter 88 verse number 21-22. Our job is to deliver the
message. We can't convert hearts. Allah told the prophet you are not the manager of affairs. It is
Allah who gives the hidayah. I can talk. I cannot convert. It is almighty God who converts. I can
talk whether they understand or not in Pakistan. It is almighty God. Coming to a basic question.
According to me, you should see my cassette. Is terrorism Muslim monopoly? Is terrorism Muslim
monopoly? If you see that cassette, your mind, your vision of terrorism will improve. Time does
not permit me to give a talk here again and I'll tell you for sure. According to me, the terrorists
are mainly the politicians. It is they who create this. You go anywhere you know in India
all the riots that took place indirectly or directly. It's the politician. Babri Masjid.
Why did Babri Masjid riot take place? Why? Because of the politicians. Gujarat riot. Politicians.
What happened about 9-11? See my cassette. It was inside job. According to 72 scientists of America,
they say 9-11 cannot be done by 19 Arabs. It's impossible. It was inside job. 72 scientists
of America. Not Zakir Naik. Inside job. Who did it? George Bush. Afghanistan. Wait. Let me go a
bit mad. Afghanistan. Thousands of people being killed. They are sending cluster bombs. Cowards
there. Thousands of people. You're talking about suicide bomb? That is haram. I'm not condoning it.
I'm condemning it. But the bigger thing to be condemned is the Americans sending the fighters
in Afghanistan killing thousands of people. In Iraq killing thousands of people.
Saddam Hussein. I'm not a fan of Saddam Hussein. He has done mistakes. The people of Iraq,
they were fed up of Saddam Hussein. But after America came there,
they are more fed up of the Americans than Saddam Hussein. That does not justify. Just
because Saddam Hussein was bad, that does not justify America to come and take over Iraq.
Why are they doing it? For the money. For the oil. What is the main interest? Is the oil.
Who created Taliban? When Russia came, the Americans supported the Afghans created Taliban.
Now they want to take over the fighting back. Who is the creation? Americans.
The biggest stars according to me in this history, George Bush. Now he's no longer there. George
Bush number one. I'm with you on that. Sorry? I'm with you on that. You're with me on that. So I'm
also going to America. I'm even going to America live and on satellite, giving the message to
Americans. I was the first person that I know of in the public after 9-11 in Australia. I said,
I'm a fundamentalist and I consider George Bush to be the biggest terrorist. It came at headlines.
In December, in December 2001, when I gave a talk in Australia, when the consul general asked me
that, what do you consider? Who's a terrorist? I said, George Bush number one. It came as headline.
Dr. Zakir Naik calls himself a fundamentalist and consider George Bush to be terrorist number one.
Now, every Tom, Dick and Harry is calling him a terrorist. At that time, no one had the guts.
What we realized, we are speaking the truth. Now, whether George Bush, you know, many people say,
when I gave a talk in London on terrorism, very good talk, people enjoyed. A youngster come and
tell, death to George Bush, death to George Bush. Full talk of mine gone. Our beloved prophet
Muhammad Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam, there were two staunchest enemy of Islam. Both were called
Umar. The prophet prayed to Allah that give Hidayah to one of these two Umar and Umar bin Khattab.
May Allah be pleased with him, who was the second kind of Islam. Allah gave Hidayah,
who was the staunchest enemy of Islam, became the staunchest supporter. Therefore, I said,
may Allah give Hidayah to George Bush. I cannot. I can speak. I cannot give Hidayah. I can tell
him what he's doing is wrong. I don't want to kill him. I want him to accept Islam. Killing is
useless. What's the use of killing? Accepting is better. So, that's the reason we are giving
the message. Those whose hearts are opening, they're accepting. Inshallah, God will open your
heart also one day. When God opens your heart one day, I cannot do it. I can give the message. I
can't force you. Unless God gives you, unless you strive. If you strive, God will help you. If you
don't strive, your heart will not be opened. Some people ask question only for questioning.
But the true gentleman, when he gets the answer, he accepts it. You know, people just ask for
questioning. You spoke very loudly. I'm asking. I gave a speech. I said so many things. Do you
agree with it or not? Yes, I agree with it. Are you a Hindu? I'm actually your favorite. I'm an
atheist. Atheist. MashaAllah. That's what I heard you enjoy. You're atheist. You're my favorite.
No, I'm not your friend. But I was told that you like having debates with such. Yes, yes.
Okay, brother. You're an atheist. Fine. I would like to congratulate you.
You'd like to what? I'd like to congratulate you. You know why? Why? The reason I congratulate you
because all the others, all the human beings, they're blindly following. Father is a Christian.
The son is a Christian. His parents are Hindu. He's a Hindu. Many of the Muslim parents are
Muslims. You are thinking. I know their father was an atheist. Father was an atheist. No. Good.
So you're thinking. These are the people, they worship this almighty God who falls down and
breaks. So you are thinking. And the reason I congratulate you is because you have said
the first part of the Islamic shahada, la ilaha, there is no God. You have already said half the
They have said the full kalima. You are half Muslim now. Atheist means half kalima, you know.
La ilaha. Only thing I have to do is illallah but Allah which I shall do inshallah.
I'm congratulating you because you have agreed to the other people who believe in wrong gods.
First I have to spend half my time in trying to convince them the God you're worshiping is wrong.
You have already agreed there's no God. Only thing I have to do is prove to you about
Allah which I shall do inshallah. Brother, suppose there's equipment which is bought.
Equipment is bought in front of you. No one in the world has ever seen.
No human being has seen. It's bought in front of you. And if I ask you the question,
who is the first person who will be able to tell you the mechanism of that equipment?
I heard this speech and it's the creator. It's the creator. So the creator of that
equipment will be the first person who will be able to tell you the mechanism of that object.
You may say creator, you may say manufacturer, you may say inventor, you may say maker,
whatever it is somewhat similar. Now I'm asking you a question. How did this universe come into
existence? How did this universe come into existence? You're going to now mention the
big bang and all that. No, I'm asking you. Don't tell me what I'm going to mention. I want to know
what is the... No, you are... I'm asking you according to your knowledge. No, the thing is
I've actually heard this speech before. I'm actually a good fan of yours. You know that.
Mashallah, you're a good fan. Good fan, theoretical or practical? If you're a practical
fan, you will follow. If I'm wrong, you correct me. If I'm right, you join me. No, I only learned
about you about two weeks back actually. Fine. So in two weeks, you became a great fan. Mashallah,
I'm very happy about it. In two weeks, you learn about me. That means you know. You know about the
creation, the big bang, which we came to know recently. Quran mentioned 14 years ago in Surah
I don't know the verses, but... Fine, but you know that. Similarly, we did not know that the
earth was spherical. We came to know recently. Quran mentioned 14 years ago in Surah Nazia,
chapter 17, verse number 30, it is spherical. We thought first the light of the moon is its own
light. Quran mentions 14 years ago the light of the moon is not its own light, reflected light,
which we came to know recently. Who could have mentioned this? There's biology, there is water
cycle, which you learned in school. There is embryology, there is genetics. My question is,
who could have mentioned all these things in the Quran? So if you have heard this,
you also know the answer. Who could have mentioned in the Quran? Same answer.
The creator. The creator. This creator, who has mentioned in the Quran, we call as Allah.
So that means you believe in the creator. Who could have mentioned this in the Quran? The
creator who created the human beings, the person who created all this universe. It can't be a human
being who writes all this. So now do you believe in a creator? Well, there are different perspectives,
you see, a person has. You can think about science or you can think about God. Now the debate is
which to follow. We can follow both. I believe in both. As I said... I'm a student of science also.
Also, I'm a believer in God. As my opening question stated, what I asked about terrorism,
I believe you also know those are certain facts that... Brother, we'll come to terrorism later on.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. We're talking about that. Why I don't believe. Brother, wait. You asked me direct
question. Suicide bombing, killing innocent, wrong. I gave direct answer. Now I'm asking you direct
question, you give me direct answer. You asked me, you are happy with my answer. No beating around
the bush. I'm asking you directly, when you believe in the creator, why don't you accept
the creator? I'm asking you directly. You asked me direct question in front of 30,000 people.
I gave a direct answer. I'm asking you direct question. You didn't believe in God, I congratulate
you. Now I prove to you that the creator wrote the Quran. Now I'm asking the question, why don't
you believe in the creator? I didn't say that I believe in the creator. I was just mimicking your
speech, which I watched. Brother, I didn't ask you to come here to mimic me, please. Did I ask you to
come and mimic me? I asked you, who wrote, you said creator. I didn't say, did I say that?
No. Even in my speech I don't say. That's what you said. Even I didn't say, the questioner said.
That means you haven't seen my speech correctly. Like how you are telling, when I ask an atheist,
he gives the reply creator, not I. Not I. That means I haven't seen my speech correctly.
It is a person like you, who I might have asked the question to, he gave the reply. Like how you
gave the reply now? Did I ask you to mimic or did I ask you to give answer from your heart?
So that means you are not a very truthful person. You ask me a question brother, I give answer
directly, from my heart. Correct? I'm asking a question, you gave the answer, now you are saying
that I'm mimicking. Okay, if I say the creator is what you want to hear, now. Not what I want to
hear. No, no, no. Listen, hypothetically here. Not hypothetically. If we say that I agree to the
creator. Now, what if I say that I agree to the creator of what was written, but I don't believe
what was written justifies everything. You're giving me six facts. Correct, correct, correct.
Very good, very good. You're telling me six things, but there's a lot in life that's not
written there. Fine, fine. There's nothing about gravity or, you're just telling me about light.
Correct. Very good, very good, very good. The brother says he believes in the creator,
but everything is not there. Brother, this book, the Quran, is not a book of signs. S-C-I-E-N-C-E.
It's a book of signs. S-I-G-N-S. It's a book of ayats. There are more than 6,000 signs,
6,000 ayats in the Quran, out of which more than a thousand speak about science. It's not a book
of science. Two plus two is equal to four, that's not written there. But the beauty of it is,
what is written, we did not know. You mean me didn't ask me? The creator wrote. If it had
everything of science, it would be a voluminous book, as big as the World Trade Center, or maybe
it's Burj Dubai tallest building now. It is not a book of science, brother. Please don't misunderstand.
It is to prove to the scientist that this is the word of God, this is the word of creator. What do
you have to tell me to disprove it? You have to take out a mistake in the Quran. Quran says in
Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse number 82.
Do they not consider the Quran with care? Had it been from anyone besides Allah,
there would have been contradictions in it, there would have been mistakes in it. So for you to
disprove the Quran to be the word of Allah, you have to take out mistakes. That is the reason I
said, please come up and take out mistakes in the Quran. Why? If it's wrong, I will leave it.
If it's right, you join me. It's a two-way, not one-way.
But how old is the Quran? I don't exactly know. The Quran is approximately 1400 years old.
Okay, and how long have human beings existed in this planet? Human beings in millions of years.
Millions of years. I'm not challenging you, don't get this wrong. No, I like people challenging me.
I like people challenging me. Okay, if you want to challenge, then I'll take that step then. Okay,
what is the reason that, first of all, I believe Christianity is older than Islam? No, no, you're
wrong. You're wrong. Christianity is not older than Islam. What's the difference? Islam is there
since time immemorial, since man set foot on the earth. Okay. From the first human being,
it's already there. Prophet Muhammad is the last and final messenger. He came 1400 years ago,
he was the last messenger. Quran is the last revelation, not the first revelation.
This is the last testament. Otherwise, Islam is there since time immemorial.
Jesus Christ was a Muslim according to the Quran. Abraham was a Muslim according to the Quran.
Peace be upon them all. So Islam means peace acquired by submitting our will to Almighty God.
It is there since time immemorial. Okay, so getting to the point, I asked you the
time scale that the Quran has existed and the time scale of human beings.
Not time scale of Quran, Islam is there since time immemorial. No, no, of the Quran, the book,
the holy book. Not Islam, we can say Islam existed forever, but why was the Quran placed on earth
afterwards? Very good, very good question. And I also wanted to ask you something I always wanted
to know about, that is the Darwin's theory of evolution. I know there's a lot of controversy
on that, but why do you believe in evolution or you believe man was placed directly? And
the whole thing of apes, the science that has proved that human beings emanated from apes,
do you agree with that? Two questions. Sorry about that. No problem. Two questions. Do you
believe in Darwin's theory? Science has proved that human beings have been emanated from apes.
Do you believe in it? Do you believe that human beings are placed? And second question, why was
Quran revealed 48 years back? Why not before? Two questions. Regarding a correction in your
question, science hasn't proved that human beings have been made from apes. It is Darwin's theory,
not Darwin's fact. It's a theory. There is no book today, there is no book today on the face
of the earth which says the fact of evolution. It's theory. The fact of the origin of human
beings, no. It's theory. And for your information, Darwin himself said that there were missing links
in his theory. If you read his book on the origin of species, he writes in this on a ship by the
name of HMS Beagle. He goes to an island by the name of Calatropis and there he sees birds were
pecking in niches, in holes. Based on the holes they pecked, the beak of the birds became short
and long. Based on that observation, he propounded the theory of natural selection. He wrote a letter
to his friend Thomas Thompson in 1861 that I have no proof for my theory of evolution,
but because it helps me in giving replies to embryology, to genetics, that's the reason I'm
propounding. He had no proof on it. That's the reason in our school, you know, to joke around,
we used to say, if you were present at Darwin's time, Darwin would have been proved right.
Trying to insinuate, I'm telling my colleague he's a monkey. There were missing links. Furthermore,
all the three stages today, science in advance, we have come to know that the first stage,
the Australopithecus and the Iceman. The next stage that we have, Neanderthal man, Cro-Magnon.
All these stages that we have today of the human being that we found, there's no link between them.
Certain things what Darwin said that life is evolved from water, I agree with it. Quran says
that we have created every living thing from water. I believe in that. But saying that we
have evolved from one species to the other is a hypothesis. According to molecular biologist,
Hanses Craig, he said it is letting imagination run too wide to say that we have been evolved from
apes. If that was true, today we'll find someone in between man and human being. You only find in
mythology. You don't find anywhere in the world a monkey man. Do you find? So what, do you think
evolution has stopped now? It is a hypothesis and most of the scientists today disagree with it.
There is only a small negligible percentage which yet believe in Darwin's theory. Majority
of the scientists have already disproved Darwin's theory. I feel your knowledge of science is not
up to date, brother. But Dr. Naik. Not but, wait. You're asking me a question, I'm replying.
Then we have to give chance to others. You've already asked five, six questions.
No, I thought you were just having fun, that's all. Sorry? I thought you were being entertained.
Having fun? Besides entertaining you, I want to entertain the other non-Muslim brothers.
If all non-Muslims get up, I'll come back to you. So what we realize, Darwin's theory, brother,
your knowledge on science is weak. We say Adam and Eve were the first human beings. That's what
the Quran says. Furthermore, regarding your second question. Okay. I have to answer your question?
I have not answered second question, you want to put the third question. That means you're not
listening to me or you've forgotten you've asked two questions. No, no, I've asked you the first
one. That means you're a good questioner, huh? Now you ask me the question, why was Quran revealed
1400 years back? Why not before? You know my son, he wants to become a doctor. He's telling me,
father, Abba, why do you put me in school and college? Why don't you put me in medical college
directly? I said, son, first go to nursery, then go to primary, then go to secondary school,
then go to college, then go to medical college. I can't put him in medical college directly. Why?
He should know the basics. Similarly, Almighty God is our creator. He kept on sending other
revelations. Almighty God, our creator, thought 1400 years back was the right time that human
beings could absorb this message. He revealed it. He's our creator. He knows better than you and me.
1400 years back, he revealed his last message, the Quran, to the last and final message of Muhammad
sallallahu alaihi wasallam. And it's mentioned in the Quran in Surah Maida, chapter number five,
verse number three. On this day, have I perfected my religion for you, the perfect form, and have
has chosen for you Islam. After this, nothing new can be added into the basics of Islam,
nothing can be subtracted. That's it. So Almighty God knows when we can imbibe the message of the
Quran. And this is the last testament, last messenger, Prophet Muhammad. No other messenger
will come after this. Hope this answers your question. And I hope that you will accept,
besides being my fan, you also accept my teachings inshallah. Maybe next time when you come here.
Maybe next time. You tell me I'll come again tomorrow. I'm flying tomorrow.
I'll come back fast for you alone.
