What Do We Know About Alexander The Great?

Ancient Europe: History, culture and Humans
93 followers
Was Alexander the Great a god? Well, he certainly liked to think so but he absolutely was not.
And they go on to have a sex marathon of 13 days.
There's that saying, isn't there? Alexander the Great conquered the world. No, he did
not conquer the world.
Why did Alexander the Great cry?
Um...
Hello, I'm Tristan Hughes, the host of the Ancients podcast and today the History Hit
YouTube team have dragged me in here to answer the most Googled questions about Alexander
the Great.
I mean, look at, they've even got a bus there for me. I mean, fair play to them, fair play
to them.
So let's get going.
But here's the first one. Was Alexander the Great a real person?
Short answer, yes.
You have so many depictions of him surviving in statues and coinage, so much literature
about his escapades, about his life that had survived and what happened next, ultimately
the world that his conquests create, the Hellenistic world.
Then again, trying to find the story of the real Alexander is quite difficult because
so many parts of his life are later fiction.
All of these stories, these anecdotes that are linked to Alexander's life, most of them
almost certainly never happened.
So yes, he was a real person, but sorting truth from myth is very difficult for all
Alexander historians today.
Was Alexander the Great Greek or Macedonian?
Okay, throw me in the deep end right at the beginning, why don't you?
Because I know this is one that I might get in some hot water for.
There's a big debate at the moment in Greece and the Republic of Macedonia about the ownership
of the figure of Alexander.
In my opinion, he was Greek, he was Hellenic, he spoke Greek.
The Kingdom of Macedon was considered a part of the Greek world, although it was seen on
the periphery.
And where the differences come in is really in regards to things like dialect of Greek.
So if you're an Athenian or a Theban or let's say a Corinthian and you thought you were
right at the heart of the Hellenic civilised world, you would look out to places like the
Kingdom of Macedon in the north, or maybe the Kingdom of Molossia in the northwest.
You see that they're bordered by the barbarians like Illyrians and Thracians.
And so they almost deride the Macedonians and the Molossians for being a bit less Greek
and a bit more barbaric because of their proximity to the barbarians.
And that's why people from places like Athens and Corinth and Thebes look down on people
like the Macedonians.
But at the end of the day, the Macedonians, they were considered part of the Greek world,
they were considered Hellenic, their kings took part in the Olympic Games, they were
Greek.
Who were Alexander the Great's parents?
So non-mythologically, non-fantastical here, his father was King Philip II of Macedon and
he really lays the foundations in the kingdom, in the military, in the economy, in allowing
Alexander to go on and conquer the Persian Empire.
Philip II of Macedon transforms his kingdom from one on the brink of ruin into becoming
the dominant power in the central Mediterranean in his just over 20 year reign.
Alexander's mother is one of Philip's many wives and the wife that he married for diplomatic
purposes because she wasn't a Macedonian.
She belonged to a nearby Greek kingdom, the Kingdom of Molossia.
To gain an alliance with that kingdom, Philip married Olympias, who was a princess of the
royal line of that kingdom, the Aeacids, who claimed descent from Achilles.
Philip's line, the Argeads, claimed descent from Heracles.
So on either side of his mum and his dad, Alexander claimed descent from mythical heroes
of Greek mythology.
The complication to that story is that later Alexander claims he's the son of Zeus, that
he's the son of a god.
Maybe Olympias forwarded this to when her relationship with Philip becomes really strained.
But that's the mythological story of Alexander's father being Zeus rather than Philip.
Was Alexander the Great Christian?
No, he absolutely was not.
However, I will add here a quick story, which is a later addition to it, where there is
a romance, the Alexander Romance.
There are various versions of this romance, including Arthurian tales of Alexander going
to the edges of the known world and further fighting mythical beasts and visiting these
places.
One version of this Alexander Romance, I believe it is the Jewish version or the Syriac version,
Alexander visits Jerusalem and converts to Judaism.
There's even one story that says that he was circumcised on his visit to Jerusalem.
That however is certainly a later addition.
Maybe he visited Jerusalem, but he certainly didn't convert to Judaism.
Alexander's religion was the polytheistic pantheon of ancient Greece, Zeus, Hera, Aphrodite,
demigods like Hercules, mythological figures like Achilles and so on.
Was Alexander the Great blonde?
Well, that's how Plutarch describes him in his description of Alexander's appearance
in having this flowing hair, this blonde look.
So to the best of our knowledge, yes.
However, having said that, in arguably the most famous depiction of Alexander, which
is the Alexander Mosaic from the House of the Thorn at Pompeii, Alexander is portrayed
leading a cavalry charge and his hair colour is brown.
So the jury's out on that one.
And I would leave that to the better experts who know about the hair colour of Alexander
the Great.
That's not me.
Was Alexander the Great taught by Aristotle?
Yes, although the amount of influence that Aristotle ultimately had over Alexander the
Great is debated.
Certainly he introduced Alexander to literary works like Homer's Iliad and Odyssey.
And certainly Aristotle was the most renowned great philosopher of Alexander's teachers.
But although Aristotle gets the limelight, he wasn't the only of Alexander the Great's
teachers as he was growing up.
He had a number of different teachers which also had an influence over Alexander.
Did Alexander the Great tame Bucephalus?
And Bucephalus being the horse, the famous Thessalian steed that accompanies Alexander
for most of his life.
Well, the popular story goes in Plutarch that he does, and it's a great story.
It is whilst Alexander as a young lad, he's with his father and I think his mother might
be there as well.
They're in Thessaly.
And Thessaly is this region in central Greece and it's renowned as being the land of horses.
The horsemen who fought from Thessaly were renowned as being some of the greatest cavalry
in the known world.
And then there is a horse owner who tries to sell this stallion to Philip.
However, neither Philip nor any of his adjutants are able to tame the horse.
Then Alexander, who's still a young boy at this time, he steps forward and says,
let me try, father.
Plutarch includes some lines of dialogue as well and Philip's almost like, all right,
you give it a go.
And what Alexander supposedly realises in this story is that why Bucephalus is so wild,
why the others can't tame him, is Bucephalus is scared of his shadow.
Alexander realises that and those other figures who tried to tame Bucephalus, they hadn't
realised it.
And because of that, Alexander is able to tame Bucephalus and he becomes one of the
closest animal friends of Alexander throughout his entire life.
With Philip supposedly remarking, as Alexander tames the horse, this boy needs more than
just the kingdom of Macedonia, he is destined for great things.
So something along those lines, that's the kind of gist of it.
So once again, that's kind of a later addition, almost certainly.
So this is an amazing story.
It's right at the start of Alexander's reign.
It's also a very brutal story, which shows Alexander's brutal streak too, right from
early on in his rulership.
The Greek city-state of Thebes, following the assassination of Alexander's father, Philip,
they see that there's a new king in Macedon.
It's Alexander.
He's only 19 or 20 or 21 years old, so he's very young.
And the Thebans think, as Alexander's trying to consolidate his rule over Macedon, that
this is the perfect time to rebel, to cast out the shackles of Macedonian overlordship.
And so they rebel and they try to get other Greek city-states to rebel too.
But the Athenians, who they thought that they would be able to count on in this, they refuse
to send help to the Thebans.
And what happens is Alexander, when he hears of this revolt, he marches down to southern
Greece, to central Greece, to Thebes, and he lays siege to the city-state.
It's a long and it's a bloody siege, but he ultimately wins.
And to show the other Greek city-states, the Athenians, the Corinthians, to show them who's
boss, that he's not going to take any prisoners and that they should not consider revolting
or they would experience a similar treatment, he does something really brutal.
He raises the entire city-state of Thebes to the ground.
This is a city-state that had been active during the Persian Wars.
It's one of the most prestigious city-states in the mainland Greek world.
Alexander doesn't care about that.
They are the people who are going to demonstrate why you don't get on the wrong side of Alexander.
The only house he spares is the house of a popular poet called Pindar, who Alexander
revered.
Everything else is raised to the ground.
But the reason why he does that is because the Thebans had revolted after they heard
that Alexander had ascended the throne of Macedon.
Why did Alexander the Great invade Persia?
So there are multiple parts to this story.
The first part is that the foundations had been laid by his father, Philip II, who had
already sent an advanced force into the Persian Empire, which is the other side of the Dardanelles
Empire, stretched from Anatolia all the way to the Hindu Kush.
Philip was preparing for this war already, and Alexander kind of jumps on that and does
the actual campaign against the Persian Empire.
There are other stories too that they use, that Alexander and his team, very PR-wise,
they use as further incentives, as further reasons for why they're doing this.
The first is a story that King Darius supposedly paid the assassins who murdered Alexander's
father, King Philip II of Macedon.
There's no proof of that, but it's used as a pretext to get more Macedonians to want
to do this campaign.
The second pretext is revenge.
Vengeance for the Persian invasions of Greece that had occurred 150 years earlier when they
had sacked Athens to the ground.
This is to get the Greek city-states and those soldiers on side, why they should join Alexander
in his war against the Persians.
And this had also been in the thinking of Greek philosophers like Isocrates in the decades before.
Isocrates basically saying how they needed unification in mainland Greece to finally
be able to defeat the superpower that is the Persian Empire.
So what Alexander does is he's able to use all of these pretexts to then launch this
campaign against the Persian Empire which begins in 334 BC.
Was Alexander the Great a good general?
Well, people popularly say that he never lost a battle, and arguably he never really did,
although he did suffer some really big setbacks during his campaigns against the Persians
and then against various Indian kings and Scythians and so on.
But yes, he was a remarkable general and people still look at his generalship today.
They admire it, whether it's the big battle of Galgamela, his final clash against the
Persian king Darius III, or it's his being able to navigate to get across the fast-flowing
River Hydaspes in the Indus River Valley, or if it's sieges of isolated rock fortresses
in what is now modern-day Uzbekistan.
So yes, Alexander was a very good general.
Was Alexander the Great a pharaoh?
Once again, yes.
And this is really cool because Alexander conquers Egypt in 332 BC.
He doesn't have to fight a battle in Egypt.
The Egyptians welcome him.
The Persian governor of Egypt doesn't decide to fight, so they welcome him in.
And the Egyptians see him as, in some ways, a liberator.
And what they do is they proclaim him as the new pharaoh.
And what I love the most is that you can go to some Egyptian temples today
and you can see depictions of Alexander the Great as an Egyptian pharaoh,
looking no different to those like Tutankhamun or Ramesses II.
He is depicted by the Egyptians as a pharaoh.
He has a cartouche with his name as the pharaoh right next to it as well.
You can see that today.
So you can see an amazing afterlife of Alexander the Great in Egypt.
Was Alexander the Great a god?
Well, he certainly liked to think so, but he absolutely was not.
And I say that as a Christian, so I'm not worshipping the polytheistic Greek pantheon.
But Alexander believed that he was a god, that he was the son of Zeus.
Some others believe that too.
It's very much a popular PR and very much this idea
that they descended from these divine, mythical heroes too.
But yes, Alexander believed he was a god.
In fact, he was very much mortal.
He died at the age of 32. He died from illness.
He suffered wounds like everyone else did.
He was a mortal figure, even though he believed that he was the son of a god.
Why did Alexander the Great invade India?
Well, I think there are two ways to look at this.
If you look at it in regards to the Persian Empire,
at its height, theoretically, the Persian Empire
also included territories in the Indus River Valley,
which was part of ancient India, modern-day Pakistan, that area.
But when you look at Alexander's own motives,
Alexander wanted to go as far as he could.
He wanted to surpass all those who had been before him.
And he grew up learning myths of figures like Heracles and Dionysus
and stories that they ultimately went to India.
So, for Alexander, he always wanted to get beyond the Hindu Kush,
that mountain range, and to campaign into India.
On one hand, to kind of conquer all of the Persian Empire,
but on the other hand, to try and surpass these mythological idols of his
and get as far as he could.
Why did Alexander the Great cry?
Um, okay.
I mean, he cried sometimes.
As all we did.
I guess the biggest time of mourning for Alexander
that I'll just talk about now, because it's come straight to my mind.
Well, there are two cases.
There are two really big times when Alexander mourns
that I know of, and there are probably more,
but I'm going to say these ones at the moment.
The first is when he murders one of his close companions
during a drinking party when they're in north-eastern reaches
of the Persian Empire, modern-day Uzbekistan, in Samarkand.
When Cleitus the Black, one of his senior adjutants,
berates Alexander for his arrogant attitude,
for him trying to say that he's not actually the son of Philip II,
for him trying to smear Philip's reputation,
and also for his Persianization in ways that Cleitus didn't really like.
Also, Cleitus had been named the new governor of that region.
So he wasn't happy, and he berates Alexander,
and Alexander, as a result, he finds a spear from nearby
and he skewers and kills Cleitus.
And then he immediately regrets it.
He mourns for three days about that time,
and he really regrets his actions because Cleitus' sister
had been his wet nurse when he was just an infant child.
So that's one big instance of Alexander crying.
It's mourning the killing of one of his close companions.
But then the other big one is when he loses his closest companion.
Arguably, for parts of his reign at least, his lover, Hephaistion,
who dies in 324 BC of illness.
And Alexander, he is so bereft.
He is so consumed by grief.
He orders a massive funeral pyre for Hephaistion,
and arguably this great grief is another cause of his early death the next year.
So Alexander did cry. I mean, why he cried?
I mean, there are probably many different reasons why he cries at many different times,
but those occasions are mourning the deaths of close friends on his companions.
Did Alexander the Great conquer the whole world?
There's that saying, isn't there?
Alexander the Great conquered the world.
No, he did not conquer the world,
and especially the world that we know today.
He conquered not much of it at all, when you look at it in that perspective.
But when you look at it in the ancient lens,
the boundaries of Greek geographic knowledge,
sometimes we underestimate how much they knew.
We knew of Greek explorers who'd gone as far as Orkney,
maybe even a Shetland, the figure of Pythias,
who's around the time of Alexander.
We know of Phoenician sailors, and maybe Egyptians too,
who have actually circumnavigated the African continent,
which is also really, really interesting.
So even with that knowledge,
Alexander absolutely did not conquer the whole world.
But he conquered a part of it that the Greeks were focusing in on at that time.
They weren't interested in the Western Mediterranean as much with Italy.
They were focused on the Persian Empire.
And I guess maybe another stem for this
is the fact that Mesopotamian kings in the past,
like Cyrus, like Nebuchadnezzar,
by ruling Babylon, they called themselves the king of the world.
And so by Alexander conquering these places
and becoming the new rulers of what was the Persian Empire,
that might also be a stem for why they were then saying that they were the kings of the world.
But actually, Alexander called himself Lord of Asia,
so not the world.
This is a later addition that he also conquers the whole world, which he doesn't.
Who was Alexander the Great's lover?
Well, he had several.
He had male lovers and he had female lovers, men and women.
So let's have a look at the women first of all.
There are several women who have sexual relationships with Alexander the Great.
We can talk about, first of all, for instance,
a beautiful courtesan from Thessaly called Calixana.
And the story goes, in a couple of the sources,
that a young Alexander, Philip and Olympias,
are worried that Alexander isn't showing much interest towards women.
And so they fear that he may never have a son, that he may never marry.
And so supposedly, they bring Calixana to the royal court
and they present her to Alexander
and they basically beg Alexander to have sex with Calixana,
which he ultimately does.
Then on his campaigns, when he's king,
we know that Alexander marries two women.
They're both Asian.
One is Roxana, who's a Sogdian princess.
Sogdian is a modern region of Uzbekistan
and that was done for diplomatic reasons.
And the other woman he marries was the Persian princess Datira,
who is the daughter of his great enemy,
the great king of Persia, Darius III.
But he also has some mythological lovers too.
And perhaps the best one is the story of the Amazonian queen,
the Amazon Velestrus.
Now in this story, supposedly,
when Alexander and his army are near the Caspian Sea,
they're visited by Velestrus, the queen of the Amazons.
And she approaches Alexander and basically says,
Alexander, you are evidently the greatest man alive through your achievements.
And I am the queen of the Amazons,
so I am obviously the greatest woman alive.
We must have sex and we should have a child
because our child will be the best child in the world
because he's got the greatest traits of the best man
and the best woman in the world.
And they go on to have a sex marathon of 13 days
before Velestrus decides,
okay, that's enough, I should be pregnant by now,
and I go back off and join the Amazons.
We never hear what happens if they do have a child,
but then again, this is a fictional story.
So those are some of the women that his sex life is linked to.
In regards to men,
we know of at least one for certain male lover of Alexander
and this is a Persian eunuch called Begois.
Begois, who had been a lover of Darius III
and then becomes Alexander's lover after he enters Babylon.
But we don't actually hear that much about Begois
apart from an explicit reference that he is the lover of Alexander.
And then there's the figure of Hephaestion,
who is Alexander's closest companion
and it's almost certain that they were lovers too,
at least in some parts in their life story,
although it's never explicitly said.
However, the stories of them together,
like being Patroclus to Alexander as Achilles
and Alexander saying Hephaestion is just as much me
than myself in another case.
Time and time again, we get these illusions
that the relationship of Alexander and Hephaestion
is a bit more than just a platonic relationship
and that there was a sexual element to it too.
Did Alexander the Great have a son?
Yes, he had two.
One legitimate, one illegitimate that we know of.
The illegitimate son was a figure called Heracles
who was the son of Alexander
and a Greco-Persian noblewoman called Barcene.
But he's never really looked in to be a successor of Alexander
and is ultimately murdered by one of Alexander's successors
in Macedonia, a man called Cassander.
The other son of Alexander is born after Alexander's death
and he's also called Alexander.
He is actually proclaimed King, King Alexander IV.
Now, Alexander IV's mother was that Sogdian noblewoman Roxane
who Alexander the Great had married a few years earlier
as part of a diplomatic agreement.
And so Alexander IV is not fully Macedonian.
He is part Asian.
And so he's not as accepted.
He's not fully accepted.
There are some who don't really support his kingship.
However, he never becomes king officially.
He is a minor king.
He is named king, but before he is 18,
before he is an adult,
rulership is given to a regent.
So he holds no official power really.
And before he is an adult, when he's just 13,
he is also murdered along with Roxane.
So Alexander has two sons,
but both of them are killed before they reach adulthood.
Who killed Alexander the Great?
Well, I would argue illness killed Alexander the Great.
There was probably a combination of factors
that influenced his early death in Babylon,
aged just 32, in June 323 BC.
That might have included an illness.
We don't know what illness, but maybe typhoid,
maybe malaria, maybe pneumonia.
The jury's out.
But there might have been the addition of all the wounds
he had suffered over the course of his campaigns.
That may well have influenced his early demise.
The great grief he'd had for Hephaestion's death recently too.
All of these factors may well have combined
for his early death.
There is, of course, the other theory that he was poisoned,
although I believe that theory of him being poisoned
by certain generals and governors
who were getting disillusioned
with Alexander and his great plans.
I believe that that's the nature of fiction.
Was Alexander the Great buried alive?
No, he certainly was not buried alive.
But I'm guessing what this is kind of asking
is there is one line of thought
that Alexander didn't die on the 11th of June 323 BC,
but had actually entered a coma
and was in a catatonic state.
And so when they thought he was dead,
he actually wasn't dead.
It's likely that this theory is wrong
because it's only mentioned in one source
and the rest of the sources make it quite clear
that he died on the 11th of June.
And anyway, the Egyptian priests
go to Alexander's body the next week
and they embalm him.
They take out all his organs.
So even if he was alive for an extra week,
he certainly wasn't alive for very long.
But he certainly wasn't buried alive.
He was very, very much dead when he was finally buried.
And Alexander was only properly buried
over two years after his death in 323 BC
when his body is brought to Egypt.
Most likely, most probably
to the necropolis at Saqqara
near the Egyptian capital of Memphis
because that is where Ptolemy
initially brings the body of Alexander the Great.
And there's some interesting
Hellenic Greek architectural hints
at Saqqara that hint
that that was the first burial location
of Alexander's body.
He is then moved at a later date
to the new centre of Ptolemy's Egypt
which is the city that Alexander had founded
the city of Alexandria
on the coastline of the Mediterranean.
And there he has a lavish burial
and then he's reburied
a few generations later
in a great tomb which was known as the Soma.
And this became a place
of pilgrimage.
Alexander, following his death, he becomes a god.
He becomes divine.
And so you see many of these massive names
of ancient history
of the Greco-Roman world
Caesar, Augustus, Hadrian
Herod probably as well
Cleopatra
They all visit Alexander's tomb
and pay their respects to Alexander
at Alexandria.
I guess I should also mention before we go on
where is he buried today?
We don't know because his tomb
vanishes by the end
of the 4th century AD.
It was more likely than not
destroyed by early Christians
at that time.
However, there are various theories
as to where his body might be today.
There's one that it's actually in the tomb of St. Mark
at the church of St. Mark in Venice.
There are others still searching for it in Alexandria.
There are others who believe it's at the Oracle
of Zeus Ammon in Libya
at the Siwa Oasis.
But at the end of the day, we don't know
where Alexander the Great's
body is, where he's buried now
because his tomb has been lost.
If that gets discovered, it'd be one of the greatest
archaeological discoveries ever.
Why didn't Alexander the Great conquer Rome?
Well, because he headed east rather than west.
Actually, there's a great
story because when he went east
to conquer the Persian Empire,
there is another king called Alexander
who is the king of the neighbouring region of Molossia
and was actually Alexander's
brother-in-law, Alexander the Great's brother-in-law.
He sees Alexander the Great
heading east to conquer the Persian Empire
and this Alexander of Molossia
wants to get his own glory
and he looks west to southern Italy.
And so he invades
southern Italy, he fights various Italian
tribes. This is before Rome has become
dominant in Italy and he gains
some success there before he is ultimately defeated
and is killed.
That was the closest that an Alexander
came to fighting
the Romans, to interacting with the
Romans at that time. We do hear
that Alexander of Molossia does meet
the Romans and they have a diplomatic
meeting. But he never fights
the Romans, although the Romans did like
to think of a scenario
where what if Alexander
the Great had headed west
rather than east? And this is
done by Roman historians like Livy
and unsurprisingly in Livy's
deductions, he believes
that the Romans would have defeated
Alexander the Great and that we wouldn't know
anyone called Alexander today if he decided
to go west rather
than east.
Why was Alexander the Great
Great? Well, it depends on
your meaning of great. Many people don't think he was that
great at all. And let's
be honest, he was a megalomaniac
by the end of his rule.
But he's great because of course
of the extent of his conquest
this idea that he never lost a battle
and of course I think what also
adds to his mythologising
as the Great. There are many
people who call themselves the Great but arguably
Alexander is the one who really monopolises
who owns that title.
It's also because he dies young.
He doesn't have the chance to lose
all the territory that he's gained.
He dies young
and it's his successors that are the ones
who ultimately cause his empire
to fragment. It's also kind of that achievement
isn't it? The story of
a boy
whose kingdom
barely decades earlier had been
on the brink of complete ruin
thanks largely to his father
that he's able to conquer
the Persian Empire
and create a kingdom unlike anything
the Greek world had seen before.
Was Alexander the Great a good person?
Absolutely not. He was a horrific
figure. He murdered. It was a
genocide in India in particular.
He killed hundreds of thousands, I mean tens of thousands
probably hundreds of thousands of people
in his campaigns. He murdered
his friends. He was happy
to murder relatives as well to secure
his throne when he succeeded his
father. So was Alexander the Great
a good person? Absolutely not.
And I believe that is it.
So there you go. There was
me answering some of the most Googled
questions about Alexander the
Great. I think I need to go and find out
where else he did cry. But anyway
I hope you enjoyed today's episode. If you did
please like and subscribe. Follow
the History Hit YouTube channel. We have
certainly got more content like this coming your way
in the near future. And if you want
even more ancient history content then check out
my podcast The Ancients.
