DEBT SLAVES': Economist gives the odds of recession pummeling the US
1 Video View·Sep 30, 2024
There was a whole lot of spending going on this morning.
Of course, that's because we got a lot of economic data,
so they had to give it the treatment.
Core inflation, remember, core inflation plateaued, right,
for here for a while,
and now it's actually edging a little bit higher.
But, I mean, who cares, right?
Because here's the headline,
the number was better than consensus.
Meanwhile, income and spending,
well, they grew less than expected.
That's another indication in my mind
that consumers are fatigued,
and it matches a whole lot of other signs of caution.
I'm gonna bring in Heritage Foundation
Public Economist, E.J. Antoni.
And E.J., you know, we're celebrating,
we're celebrating the third revision
that the Street did this week,
the third revision of the second quarter GDP,
and a lot of yawning over the day's data,
you know, which shows income and spending missing the mark.
Also, though, they're moving a little bit lower here.
Just your thoughts overall on what the data is telling you.
Well, Charles, one of the things
that's really concerning for me in this report is,
not only did we get revisions on the last couple of months,
but with the recent BEA revision of the last several years,
we can now see that government transfers
have been adding much more to consumer spending
than we previously believed, about $200 billion more.
That's roughly 5% of the total.
And we should remember that these transfer payments,
that includes things like welfare,
they are not actually included
in the GDP component we call government spending.
That's just direct purchases by government.
So you have to throw in
all of this additional taxpayer money on top of that
to see how much government is really juicing this economy.
Sadly, so much of what we consider consumer spending
or private spending really isn't.
Yeah, and people know that, right?
I mean, economists try to convince people
they're doing much better than they are.
And to your point,
it is even starting to show up in credit card data.
You know, we saw this lately,
the most recent stuff from Bank of America,
which I love their weekly data.
Overall, it was flat,
but the only reason it was flat,
iPhone orders through the roof,
and that kind of carried that one area,
but every other line on there, deep in the red.
And it just, again, it signals that American consumers
are really starting to tighten their belt,
maybe because they have no choice.
Charles, I think that's a really good read.
We are seeing right now a consumer that is increasingly,
at least when we look at the bottom 90% of them,
they're increasingly reliant on that credit card debt
that you just mentioned,
and on government transfer payments.
So we are seeing less and less of people's ability
to actually get by on their own.
And it really is that top 10% or so of consumers
of really high income earners
who have been carrying this market,
kind of in a very similar way, Charles,
to how the Magnificent Seven have really been holding up
the broader equity markets for much of this year.
Yeah, let's talk about a recession.
Bloomberg's chief economist saying now
there's a 70% chance the US economy is recession bound.
Where do you put the odds?
I'd say that's about right, Charles.
I mean, unfortunately, the odds are really higher than that,
just depending on how long you wanna stretch out
your time horizon.
The reason I give that caveat
is because you can put off a technical recession
for a very long time if the government is willing
to spend, borrow, and print enough money,
but you're really just kicking the can down the road.
And sadly, we're seeing the latest example
of that right now in terms of Congress
just passing yet another continuing resolution,
yet another case of business as usual
when it comes to spending too much money.
Again, this is kicking the can down the road.
It's not solving any of our underlying problems.
You know, I wonder about that, E.J.
I was thinking about that today.
What project out there
has taken the longest to complete, right?
Because Congress began kicking his can down the road
a long time ago, and I was thinking about this cathedral,
right, the Antonia Gaudi Cathedral.
I think they began it in the late 1800s,
still not finished, because it just feels
like they're never gonna do their job.
It really does, but I mean, when we say this,
why should people care
if it doesn't feel like it matters anymore?
Well, Charles, I think it's because
we have really glossed over what the effects
of this overspending actually is.
You know, if you're wondering,
where did government actually get the trillions of dollars
in excess spending that we've seen
over the last several years?
They have taken it out of your hide
through the hidden tax of inflation.
If you're wondering,
why are we in a cost-of-living crisis today?
Why is it that young people can never afford a home,
probably for the rest of their lives?
Why is it that so many young Americans today
have given up on the dream of retirement?
It's because you are paying
for all of this runaway government spending.
We have turned ourselves, at this point,
into a nation of debt slaves,
where somewhere around half of all personal income taxes
sent to the federal government
are effectively used just to pay interest on the debt.
And that's getting worse every single month, by the way.
So if you think that this doesn't affect you,
think again.
The problem is, I think, that the politicians, Charles,
have just gotten really good at hiding the effects.
Yeah, and Americans need to know
that trillion dollars in interest payments
are going to the richest people in this country
and the richest people in other countries.
We're taking hard-earned taxpayer money
and we're paying the wealthiest people in the world,
and it's a hell of a transfer of wealth,
and it really, really, at some point,
should spark some sort of a revolt
or pushback in this country.
E.J., thank you so much.
Always appreciate your analysis.
Thank you, Charles.

