⚡Lightning Lap 2024 ⚡| The Ultimate Performance Car Test | Car and Driver

Cars Arena
18 followers
Welcome to Car and Driver.
This is Lightning Lap.
For the 17th year, we return to Virginia International Raceway,
where our team of professional test drivers
run the latest and most exciting performance vehicles
around the 4.1 miles and 24 turns that
make the grand course.
Think of it like an American Nurburgring.
Each vehicle is configured in its highest performing
or track-ready setup, and the only modifications permitted
are things like durability-enhancing brake fluid,
which we see as more of a safety modification.
There were exceptions this year, of course, three of them.
But we'll get to those later.
Yeah, playing it safe.
I said, let's get it.
You say that's a good move for a kid out the way.
Got no time to waste.
Can't be with me if you're not in my race.
You're not in my level.
You're not in my race.
One foot on the gas, I'm catching the pace.
We categorize vehicles based on price
and order them here from slowest to quickest.
You can watch each vehicle's individual lap
on its corresponding page in the links below.
Remember, though, that a lap time is just that.
So we also aim to explore the overall picture
of a vehicle's character.
The Honda Civic Si has always been an incredible low-buck
enthusiast car.
And though this 11th generation version
is more agreeable all around, as we
learned during our 40,000 mile long-term test,
a few of its changes slowed it down versus the Si Coupe
we tested in 2017.
That Coupe no longer exists.
And this Si sedan is not only bigger and heavier,
but it's slightly less powerful too.
The sweet shifting six-speed manual carries over,
but it has a shorter final drive ratio
that's doubtless a boon at the autocross,
but not ideal for the wide open spaces of VIR.
In corners where the old Si could dip into second,
this Si had to stay in third.
Add the extra mass, and the result
is a slightly slower approach to the climbing S's
and a slower top speed down the back straight.
Still, the Si remains well-coordinated
through the medium speed direction changes,
despite the Goodyear Eagle F1s that are now out of production.
As of now, Honda does not offer factory fitment summer tires.
Nevertheless, the Si carries so much more speed
through the second part of Hogpen
that it can get a higher top speed at the finish line.
The Honda Civic Si is still a great driver's car,
but it's probably better suited to a tighter racetrack
or an autocross course more than it is VIR.
The 10 best winning Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86
were fantastic at Lightning Lap 15,
but the fun usually ended after a lap
when the brake pedal turned mushy.
With the BRZ TS unavailable at the time of this year's test,
we brought down the BRZ we're currently
running through our 40,000 mile long-term test.
And with it, we tried creating a cost-effective track day
upgrade package.
It only takes a handful of hot laps
to find the upgrades are transformational.
The setup dropped the lap time by 3.1 seconds,
and it didn't alter the playful handling balance.
Similarly, the brakes withstood multiple hot laps
at a time during roughly 19-minute sessions.
They delivered consistent stopping power.
Pedal feel softened only a touch.
We also put on a couple thousand street miles
and found the setup livable, though obviously, you
want to remove the pads and tires
once track day season ends.
The pads squeal terribly outside of their operating temperature
range, and the tires don't like cold weather.
If you're set on taking your BRZ or GR86 to the track,
consider our setup as a good starting point
to improve lap times and reduce your anxiety level every time
you mash the middle pedal.
Quick laps are as much about driver confidence
as they are of vehicle's capabilities,
and ours shattered after the EV6 GT
had a huge turn and oversteer in the middle of the climbing
S's on our first out lap.
After that, we no longer dared keeping the stability control
off.
The EV6 wanted to go rear first everywhere.
It would carry drifts through multiple corners,
including in a terror-filled moment,
the back end stepping out through the kink
on the front straight at 130 plus miles per hour.
Each hot lap used roughly 20% of the battery,
but the EV6 never cut power.
And its superior straight line acceleration
allowed it to keep pace with the much better driving BMW i4 M50
from last year.
Despite having a power to weight ratio fractionally better
than the latest M2, the EV6's G average through turn one
was the second worst of this year's group.
And while the brakes never went away,
braking over curbing sometime caused the ABS
to jump in too strongly.
The EV6 GT is simply not a track car, and that's OK.
We now fully understand why Hyundai
would choose to take a couple additional years to develop
its version of this car, the 2025 IONIQ 5N.
Simply, the changes that make the Acura Integra
Type S a better daily than the Civic Type R
hold it back on the racetrack.
Of course, that shouldn't be too surprising.
The lack of a track mode for stability control
was unfortunate, though there is a process
to disable the system entirely.
It's called a pedal dance for reasons that
become obvious after doing it.
Then there's the bucket seats that
aren't as deeply contoured and the adaptive dampers that
have a bit less rebound.
But there's one big difference, tires.
The best available for the Type S
is the Michelin Pilot Sport 4S, a fine tire,
but a far cry from the Pilot Sport Cup 2s on the Type R
that we lapped here previously.
This slowed the Integra considerably.
Slower exits onto straights lead to slower peak velocities,
so a cornering deficit earns you compound interest.
The Integra Type S is still highly enjoyable.
It dances through the tight stuff
and the engine pulls hard out of corners.
The brakes are powerful and supremely heat resistant.
And the dual-axis strut suspension
can make you forget it's front-wheel drive.
Would a set of tires make all the difference?
Well, if Acura won't offer them, there's
nothing stopping you from hitting up a tire rack.
Pull up to a track day in an X5M,
and most will assume it's your tow vehicle.
But BMW's most ferocious X5 can earn more than a few surprise
point buys.
The latest X5M is 130 pounds heavier than before,
in part from a revised engine that
adds a 48-volt hybrid system.
Yet it was slightly quicker through the uphill S's
than this year's M2 and Z Nismo.
And it hung right with those two in the back half of the infield
and while sliding through Hogpen onto the front straight.
We ran 2.4 seconds quicker than the last X5M we tested here,
making this the third quickest SUV we've run.
That's behind only the Cayenne Turbo GT and Lamborghini Urus,
both of which had far racier tires.
The lap time's also fractionally quicker
than a C6 Corvette Z06 and a current 718 Cayman S.
The X5M is amazingly balanced and competent.
It loves to rotate and claw through corners neutrally,
and it devours curves.
The brakes held up phenomenally, too.
In fact, it took a while for us to build up
to braking so late in something this big and heavy
and with this high of a vantage point.
Simply, X5M owners who don't explore this SUV's capabilities,
they're missing out.
With 453 of the most well-muscled horses
this side of the Bavarian Alps, our first laps in the M2
felt like driving on a slip and slide.
The power slides were easy to catch and modulate,
but they kill lap time.
Just how powerful is this M2?
Enough to make up for its moderate grip.
It was slower through turn one than the previous generation
M2 competition, but exited most corners going a touch faster.
On the front straight, it was 4.9 miles an hour faster
than the M2 competition.
That kind of power requires patience on corner exit.
And once we got the tail to behave,
this M2 went 2.8 seconds quicker than that M2 competition,
beating it through four of the track's five sectors.
Sharp, precise steering helped place the M2,
though its muted feedback masked what
the front tires were doing.
There's surely more time in it, too.
Our car lacked the optional lightweight carbon fiber
roof and bucket seats, and it carried
the added weight of a sunroof.
Still, the M2 proved it can slither around all you want,
but tame those wild horses, and it'll
lay down some impressively quick, tidy laps.
We approached the Nissan Z NISMO with caution,
remembering very well the 2009 370Z NISMO's brake failure
that sent one of our drivers into the wall at turn one.
But as the laps piled on, our confidence grew,
and the braking zones shortened.
The brake pedal stayed positively firm
after three days of lapping, though the front rotors
were grooved enough to look like an LP made of chrome.
The Z NISMO is a joy on track.
The twin-turbo V6 asked for patience
when exiting the slower turns, but respect the torque
and the tires getting the power to the ground.
Even the nine-speed automatic, the sole transmission option,
it had crisp shifts.
The steering even shows signs of life,
especially under full load in hogpen,
where the duress of the front tires
is fed back through the thin-rimmed wheel.
While most other cars at this level have adaptive dampers,
the NISMO has passive units.
Still, this Z gets around VIR unfazed
by various grades of curving.
Well, mostly unfazed.
That one was our fault.
Our only concern is the rear differential, whose fluid
approached 400 degrees, or enough
to push the fluid out of the vent tube and coat the exhaust,
leading to a very unpleasant smell.
If you plan to track the NISMO, investigate some cooling
options.
At just 43 pounds lighter than the supercharged Shelby GT500,
it sure seems like the Ford Mustang Dark Horse
has spent too much time grazing.
But hey, you wouldn't call a sumo wrestler fat.
Some of the heft is from the 15.4-inch two-piece rotors
up front and the 14-inchers in the rear.
And this brake package is the real deal,
hauling this 500-horsepower Mustang down
from 145.9 miles per hour before turn one.
That's two miles per hour faster than the 349-pound lighter
Z NISMO, yet the Mustang got to the brakes roughly 60 feet
shorter.
Shortening the brake zone by roughly 10% is significant.
As we saw during our 0 to 150 to 0 test,
the Pirelli P Zero Trofeo RS tires
do a fantastic job applying braking forces to the tarmac.
But when it comes to lateral Gs, the Dark Horse
doesn't match the Mustang Mach 1 we tested in 2021.
Cornering grip is down everywhere versus that car,
but carrying around an additional 213 pounds
will do that.
On the upside, the Pirelli's offered consistent grip lap
after lap.
The bigger letdown is the 10-speed automatic,
which doesn't take many laps before warning you
of rising fluid temps.
And with the heat comes indecisiveness and untimely
downshifts.
It's very likely the 6-speed manual
might knock a little time off, but nevertheless,
the Dark Horse's lap is good enough
to dethrone the Mach 1 as the Mustang king.
With 40 more horsepower, specific chassis tuning,
and a nearly $30,000 higher price,
the M3 CS easily outpaced the M3 competition
we tested here two years ago.
Problem is, the 3 and 1 half second difference
should have been much bigger.
In fact, we thought it might be closer to the M4 CSL
we tested last year, as it's essentially
a continuation of that model, but with two more doors,
a backseat, and all-wheel drive.
Sadly, a tire snafu ruined its chances.
There are four available tire models for the CS, two Michelins
and two Pirellis.
Our CS showed up on the Pirelli PZ4s
and with a backup set of Michelin Cup 2s.
We used the PZ4s to sort the car and planned
to switch to the Michelins for the fast lap,
only to find the fronts were the wrong size.
And in the frenzy to get a new pair overnight,
we wound up with Cup 2Rs, which aren't available on the CS.
That means the lap time on the Pirellis
doesn't fully represent the CS's impressive capabilities.
We hope to have it back next year on the correct tire.
The E-Ray is no stranger to VIR.
During its development, Chevy engineers
brought it here several times to learn how to extract
the quickest lap time.
We were glad they were on site to share that knowledge.
The 1.1 kilowatt hour battery can't provide full boost
for the entire lap, and the power
from the electric motor driving the front wheels
trails off after 120 miles per hour.
The solution?
The driver has to parse out the electrical energy over a lap
using the car's Charge Plus mode, which
allows the battery to deploy some of its juice
while holding some in reserve.
Luckily, the eight-speed automatic
shifts smartly on its own, which allows
you to focus on fumbling with the awkward Charge Plus
button on the side of the center console.
That annoyance aside, the E-Ray's track performance
confirmed its middle position in the C8 lineup
with a lap time between the Stingray Z51 and the Z06.
The E-Ray felt slightly bigger and less precise
than the lighter Stingray, but still well-balanced
with virtually no high speed understeer.
It muscled through the slow turn one,
and its all-wheel drive system yanked it out
of that corner 0.6 miles per hour faster than the Z06.
The carbon ceramic stoppers felt like they
could arrest a runaway train, but the propulsion system's
limitations showed on the front straight
where the E-Ray topped out 2.4 miles per hour slower
than the less powerful Stingray.
That speed deficit in no way diminishes the E-Ray's prowess.
It's a big bruiser that can dance
in a multi-talented middle child of the C8 family.
Considering the Lucid Air Sapphire's four-digit peak
horsepower figure and 5,300-pound weight,
we admit to suppressing some intimidation on our first lap.
It wasn't warranted.
The Sapphire is so approachable that our tentative first lap
was already five seconds quicker than the existing EV record.
And that was in the 767-horsepower Endurance
Mode, one of the three sub-choices for Track Mode
that allows for longer sessions.
Hot Lap Mode has 1,003 horsepower,
and that meant the fourth-highest speed
on the front straight that we've ever recorded.
There's no getting around physics,
so stopping for turn one required
anticipating braking markers that don't exist.
The speed is remarkable, but the Sapphire is about way more.
When you get it right, it can really
flow through the back half of the infield,
with the rear end just perfectly settling as the next curving
comes into view.
Consider that its second time equaled the 911 GT3
Manti through the uphill S's and the slow spiral
corner in the infield.
It's amazing what's going on behind the scenes
to make the Sapphire drive naturally.
There is no limited slip differential in back,
so it's all software tuning.
Powering out of turn one, it can be
overdriving the outside tire while dragging the inside motor
with slight regenerative braking.
Add in the subtle aero tweaks, and the Sum
is a car that feels totally stable at big speeds,
including steering through the kink on the front straight
at 160 miles per hour.
How might the Tesla Model S Plaid compare?
We haven't been able to source one with a track pack
for lightning lap, but a pro driver
ran a two-minute 50.7-second lap in a Plaid
at one of our track days.
That makes this result a monumentally impressive
first outing for Lucid.
The Sapphire isn't just the fastest EV,
it's also the fastest four-door.
On the all-time leaderboard, it's
between the 2016 Viper ACR and 2020 Mustang Shelby GT500.
Good company.
Porsche owns a majority stake in man-tire racing
and has designated it its motorsports partner.
What that means to well-to-do Porsche owners
is aftermarket parts that carry a factory warranty,
and thus the GT3 man-tire racing's entry
into lightning lap.
We do mean well-to-do, as the GT3 package costs about as much
as a new 718 Boxster, consisting of suspension, brake, wheel,
and aerodynamic changes.
These changes make small gains versus the GT3 we ran in 2021.
The added downforce helps in corners
but hurts on the straights.
After exiting hogpen 0.4 miles per hour more quickly
than the stock GT3, the man-tire racing version
has a 0.5 miles per hour lower top speed.
This GT3 shines in linking the corners climbing
the hill towards roller coaster, gaining a lead over the stock GT3
it never gives back.
One big advantage that seems tiny on paper
is that the new dampers allow for an extra half
degree of negative camber, resulting in crisper turn-in.
The steering rack hasn't changed,
but on center feel is tighter, leading to confidence
in fast corners, where it's as if an already planted car just
put down additional roots.
The lap time amounts to a 8 tenth of a second lead
over the regular GT3, and that may not seem like much,
but for a modification package that
doesn't change the engine output or tire compound, it's a lot.
If you're in the business of winning track days,
the GT3 RS will send your stock skyward.
What's arguably Porsche's most extreme road-going model ever
has active aerodynamics and seemingly endless supply
of settings.
You could spend all day tinkering
with the four knobs that control all the settings.
Fortunately, Porsche Pro Patrick Long
was on hand with a recommendation.
Maximum rebound front and rear and a bit of extra diff lock
when coasting.
We don't have a historical braking stat from VIR,
but if we did, the GT3 RS would likely be the king of it.
While the GT3 RS hit 157.3 miles per hour
at the end of the front straight,
it feels even faster because you can brake well
past the number 5 marker.
If you're too early on the stoppers and need to modulate,
the hydraulics translate tire communication so cleverly
that it's as if you woke up to discover
you could speak a new language.
Fun is everywhere, but finding time on track
took longer than normal because of this GT3's cornering speed
capability.
Pick a speed, decide on a spot to go flat, and you're wrong.
Faster and earlier is always the answer.
We haven't even mentioned the glorious 9,000 RPM 4 liter
flat-six.
Its sounds and vibrations make every lap a hair-raising event.
And while the engine is one of the greatest of all time,
the GT3 RS's true magic lies in how
it makes something as light as air
have seriously heavy impact.
In addition to lap time, we log 24 on-track data points.
Remarkably, this GT3 RS tops our all-time charts in 12 of them.
Here's its full lap with a few of those highlights.
Lightning Lap is limited to stock cars driven
by our team of test drivers, but this year
had a few exceptions.
Not one, but three professionals showed up
ready to challenge the grand course.
A configuration of VIR that none of them had tried before.
For years, we've wondered where a sport bike would land
on the Lightning Lap leaderboard.
This year, we found out.
BMW racer and test rider Nate Kern
showed up with the 205 horsepower BMW M1000RR
that was fitted with race slicks in an aftermarket exhaust
system.
As he explains it, the onboard electronics
and gyroscopic sensors, along with adjustable settings
for throttle response, engine control, and traction,
and wheelie control, give him incredible confidence.
Consider that he short shifts into sixth gear
before the kink on the front straight to minimize wheel spin.
Yeah, it breaks traction above 165 miles per hour.
And Nate left a tire mark in the same spot on every fast lap.
The resulting lap time was only 2 tenths
behind the $216,000 Porsche 911 Turbo S we ran in 2021.
And comparing the laps illustrates just how quickly
the BMW accelerates.
On the front straight, it has a 5 miles per hour advantage.
On the back straight, 10 and 1 half miles per hour.
But the higher speeds and the fact
that the bike sends most of the stopping force
through a single tire is a recipe
for longer braking zones, seeding that gain back
to the 911 Turbo.
Kern exits spiral at 93.7 miles per hour,
the fastest we've ever recorded.
But the Turbo S pulls ahead in the tight, twisty back half
of the infield and maintains the small gap.
Running this kind of time for under $40,000
is impressive, to say the least.
And if you're looking to improve your skill set,
check out Kern track days.
We'll probably stick to sitting on leather
instead of wearing it.
The full name is NASCAR Next Gen Garage 56 Chevrolet Camaro
ZL1, or G56 Camaro for short.
Yes, this is the development twin to the same car that
raced at Le Mans this past year.
It's all natural 5.8 liter V8 winning the hearts of the crowd
and showcasing the uniquely American motorsport discipline
on the world's biggest stage.
Hendrick Motorsports manufactured and managed
the project.
We never really thought they would
agree to bring the car out, but they did.
Driver Jordan Taylor didn't race in France,
but the 10-year IMSA vet did a lot of the development.
While he calls VIR one of his favorite tracks in the world,
he's never lapped the Grand configuration on anything
other than a simulator.
On track, the G56 is simply rad in the most American way.
It's loud, it's fast, and it's big,
almost as wide as a pickup and some 10 inches longer
than a Corvette.
Taylor locked the rears going into turn one,
hence the low 1.19 Gs of lateral acceleration there.
The rest of his lap was clean, particularly
when he was on the full course where he's most familiar.
He sends the G56 through the climbing S's
at an average of 158 miles per hour.
That's more than 20 miles per hour
than any other street car we've lapped here
and nearly 6 miles per hour faster than the Subaru Air
Slayer.
The Camaro also trumps the Subaru
in the difficult turn three, off camber turn 10,
and in hogpen.
Given another shot, we bet this Camaro
could match the Subaru's faster lap.
We also hope the effort to make a stock car run fast for 24
hours doesn't stop.
An all NASCAR endurance race might
be more fun than the 24-hour race in France.
You probably remember seeing the Subaru Air Slayer flying
over a speedboat in Gymkhana 2020.
When the Subaru team showed up at VIR
with racing vet Scott Speed, they
had another target to clear.
The track record.
Built by Subaru Motorsports partner Vermont Sports Car,
the Air Slayer is essentially an uncorked WRX STI rally
cross car.
Sans the engine restrictor required by regulations,
the custom 2.3 liter flat four makes 862 horsepower.
Not only that, it runs on fuel so corrosive
it'll eat through your shoes.
Seeing the aerodynamics, the radiator
sitting in the backseat like a kid's car seat,
the flames shooting out of the hood,
you get a real No Rules Can Am vibe.
The Air Slayer is fast everywhere, obviously.
Sticking at 1.32 G's in turn one, for example.
But it's more shocking how it accelerates.
It exits Hogpen at 125.9 miles per hour.
And the next closest street car in Lightning Lap history
is the McLaren Senna at 121.6 miles per hour.
A Corvette Z06 is doing 114.
With Scott Speed at the wheel, the Air Slayer
lapped VIR in 2 minutes 25.6 seconds,
putting it 1.1 seconds ahead of the Garage 56 Camaro.
The advantage was almost entirely generated
after turning off the back straight.
In the tighter and more technical part of the track,
the Air Slayer takes full advantage of its rally routes,
including some lines that would raise Stewart's brow.
Whatever car eventually beats its time
should wear the moniker Speed Slayer.
