Dix ans après le génocide des Yézidis par le groupe État islamique, la mission de l’ONU, UNITAD, chargée d'enquêter sur les crimes de guerre en Irak, s'est achevée, laissant un profond sentiment d'abandon chez cette communauté. Dans cet épisode, nous échangeons avec Marie-Charlotte Roupie, correspondante de RFI à Bagdad, de retour de reportage dans le Sinjar. Elle nous parle des défis persistants des Yézidis, de l'absence de justice et de réconciliation, et partage son expérience sur le terrain. #irak#yezidi#daesh
I knew it would be difficult, but I didn't expect such an intense report.
Me neither, I didn't expect these words from Marie-Charlotte Roupy,
who is the correspondent of RFI in Baghdad, and who you will hear in this episode.
I wanted to know how the Iraqi population,
which lived under the yoke of the Islamic State group between 2014 and 2019,
experienced the end of the UN mission, which was in charge of investigating Daesh crimes in Iraq.
The concern of a community in particular, that of the Yezidis.
In northwestern Iraq, the families of the victims of the Yezidi genocide and the missing
have been waiting for answers and justice to be served for ten years.
Khairi Ibrahim, director of a local NGO for the defense of human rights,
takes us to the exit of the city of Sinjar.
In this area, the Islamic State killed many Yezidis and put them in cemeteries.
There, we will go behind this goal, and we will see the cemeteries.
The Yezidis are a religious, Kurdish minority, most persecuted by the IAEA,
and who, despite the defeat of the jihadists,
continue to experience the tragic consequences of the genocide perpetrated in 2014.
All this happened largely on August 3 of this year.
Daesh men invaded the Sinjar region.
200,000 Yezidis were forced into exile.
Thousands of them were killed or captured, women and children reduced to slavery.
In this episode, which I recorded with Marie-Charlotte Roupy on September 25,
we talk about the challenges that Yezidis face today.
She explains to me why, ten years after the genocide,
justice and reconciliation seem far away,
and she shares her experience on the ground.
Hello Marie-Charlotte.
Hello Alexandra.
The Yezidis live in the Sinjar region,
but for those who don't know, can you give me a little more detail about this region in Iraq?
Sinjar is a province located northwest of Iraq,
which is limited to the west by the Syrian border.
It is a district within the province of Nineveh,
where the city of Mosul is located.
It is also close to the province of Dohuk,
which is part of the semi-autonomous province of Iraqi Kurdistan.
In fact, it is very, very west of these regions,
which are regions of strong activity such as Mosul or Dohuk.
Here we are really in a province that is rather agricultural.
It must be understood that even before 2014,
it is not a province that is very economically active compared to other provinces in Iraq.
It is mostly farmers or small traders.
There is a mountain range on which farmers raise their herds,
but overall we are not in a province that has a lot of job offers, for example.
It was important to remind you before talking about the situation today,
because today the province is still in this situation.
But finally, with the reconstruction,
and this is what marked me this time when I went there this year,
because I had already made a trip last year to Sinjar,
is that today there is a little more trade, more variety.
There are different activities that are actually born from the fact
that the population has left this province,
has discovered other things and is trying to bring back new ideas in the province of Sinjar now.
Going there, since you live in Baghdad,
going there, is it already complicated for anyone
and even more so when you are a journalist?
So, from Baghdad, you have to go north of the country anyway.
So, generally what we do is take the plane to Erbil.
We pass through the city of Mosul and from there we have several kilometers,
almost in a straight line, with 7-8 checkpoints to cross.
And then we finally arrive in the city of Sinjar.
So, it's a pretty long journey.
It's a province that is really very far from the big poles.
There are big roads to get there, but there are a lot of checkpoints.
As you go through these different checkpoints, you have to show them the different authorizations.
And as journalists, we have several authorizations to show.
We have, to circulate in Iraq, an authorization from the media commission
and an authorization from the National Operations Command,
which are the security forces that control who crosses the checkpoints.
We submit these requests by giving the date of departure and normally it works.
But in Sinjar, there are reinforced controls for the entry of journalists in this province,
which are exercised by different armed forces.
There is the Federal Army, but there are also several branches of the Popular Mobilization Front,
and for several months, the army has decided that the journalists must be escorted
once we really arrive in the province of Sinjar.
And that is something that obviously does not apply to the inhabitants of Sinjar,
but which is not very acceptable for journalists,
especially when we come to talk to people who are already very suspicious,
who felt abandoned by the Iraqi army and by the Kurdish fighters of the Peshmerga 10 years ago,
and who had left, according to them, the passage so that Daesh could perpetrate these massacres.
As this is their point of view, us being escorted by the army is very complicated.
But we still had a problem because the checkpoint through which we entered,
they had not transmitted this information to all the checkpoints.
And so while we were in the middle of recording a sequence,
the army landed and stopped us for a few minutes,
saying that we had lied when entering, etc., that we had not given the right information.
We ended up solving the problem, but it obviously had an impact on the people we were meeting,
because it immediately created a climate of suspicion.
It is already very intrusive, our work, to go and ask a lot of very personal questions to people,
and there are a lot of things that they do not necessarily want to discuss,
while soldiers stand by, can hear what they say.
The Yezidi population does not necessarily trust this army, which abandoned it, according to them, in 2014.
So coming with this army on our side is still problematic for people to feel confident with us.
That's for sure.
It is true that this is something that the listeners are not necessarily aware of.
It is all the journalistic work that must be done upstream to be able to address these populations.
When I called you to prepare this episode, you told me that I have been living with the Yezidis for six months.
So it's true that you didn't stay six months in place this time.
Six months because you have to do all this preparatory work, right?
Yes, a little more than that, because it really started in January.
In fact, what I meant by that is that I live with them in my head.
That is to say, overall, I spent a lot of time discussing with a lot of Yezidis.
Part of our work as journalists abroad is to anticipate different significant events
and to find the best way to deal with this event.
And so, of course, when we approached the 10th anniversary of the genocide,
I had anticipated the fact of covering this anniversary in one way or another.
And I had already gone to Sinjar the year before.
And so, what I had followed from afar was that the situation had changed a lot.
There were still a lot more people who had returned.
And so, we started with the idea of making a report on the return of life to Sinjar.
And the question is, does it really come back? And in what form?
And for that, we had to meet a lot of people who came back.
Also people who did not come back and to know the reasons why they did not come back.
And all these discussions took months and months.
Because you really have to get into the intimacy of people and the psychology of people.
One of the main reasons why the return to life is not really possible
is precisely because there is a psychological trauma.
And so, it requires being really confident with the people you're going to meet.
And so, it started in January, at the time of an official ceremony
of the return of identified bodies, whose bodies had been recovered in common graves.
And there, we met a young woman who collapsed into tears
by explaining that that day was as if it were the first day, the day of the massacre,
on August 3, 2014.
She relived all the events as if it had happened the same day.
And so, we already understood from there.
And I say we, because I obviously worked with fixers.
And we really realized at that time that the report was going to be
particularly centered on this psychological aspect of the ongoing trauma.
And so, we really had to create a link with the people we were going to meet.
Because the idea was not to do voyeurism, to make people cry,
but on the contrary, to really, deeply understand
what blocks this return to life in this province 10 years after the genocide.
How is your work going at that time, with this community?
So, it's simple and complicated at the same time.
That is to say that, in fact, we meet people with whom we had decided
beforehand that we would do part of the work, interviews.
But in fact, we realize that once we are in front of them with a microphone,
the discourses change a little.
And in fact, we gradually understand that they are afraid.
They are afraid that these discourses will be misunderstood.
They are afraid that these discourses will have consequences on them.
And then they are eternally afraid that a new genocide will occur
and that it will once again be the target of the anger of another population.
And what do they tell?
They tell the daily life, the weight of the genocide constantly in their daily life.
They tell the trauma.
They don't hide it from the fact that they are a traumatized population.
They claim to be victims of genocide.
For them, it is even important to use this word,
even if they are tired of being perceived like that.
Many tell us that they want to be understood as victims
because they don't feel completely recognized as victims.
And they tell a lot of things, but not necessarily in detail.
There are things that we don't tell anymore.
And even between them.
They understand each other.
They know what happened to them.
But they don't go into the details anymore.
It's not necessary.
They say it themselves.
They say it's not necessary for us to understand each other.
And so we don't talk about it anymore.
We also understand that in your voice.
You slowed down the way you spoke to me.
We understand that all this was also extremely loud to hear.
Yes.
They are survivors of a genocide.
That is to say that all testimonies are emotionally charged.
And it's not a simple emotion.
It's not a simple grief.
There is anger.
There is sometimes a desire for revenge.
A huge feeling of injustice.
There is a lot of sadness, of course.
And in fact, it's a lot.
All the testimonies are a kind of mixture of a lot of emotions.
And even if we, as journalists, tell their story,
we cannot be completely impermeable to all these mixed emotions
and to the violence of certain testimonies.
And sometimes it's simple little things that make the experience very intense.
That is to say, we will have discourses on the extreme violence of what they went through.
And then there is the child of this family who was born after this genocide,
who will arrive in the room and who will completely shake the person we are interviewing.
And who will suddenly start smiling and who will explain,
here, life, it continues anyway.
And so it's this kind of mixture between extreme violence and everyday life
which is also extremely destabilizing.
When you dive with them for several days in these interviews.
Marie-Charlotte, identify the bodies, understand what happened.
It is also the work of the UN mission that has just ended.
This work has been decisive in collecting evidence of Daesh crimes.
All this, it lasted more than six years, right?
Why does it take so long?
So yes, UNITA's mission was to collect evidence.
Indeed, it is very, very long because it goes through many stages.
It started with the collection of propaganda videos of the Islamic State
which were dissected, analyzed.
There is a collection of documents, papers from the Islamic State.
Because it is necessary to understand that the Islamic State was a proto-state
with a large administrative organization.
So there are a lot of written documents
which served to understand the functioning of the self-proclaimed caliphate
and which also provided evidence of the executions
which were carried out against the Iraqi population,
whether Yezidis or even Shiites, Sunnis, Qaqqai and other populations in the country.
Then it was also necessary to collect many testimonies,
eyewitnesses, reported testimonies.
They had to be corroborated with each other,
the information had to be verified.
And then, of course, there was a collection of information
during the excavation of the common pits.
And that can take months.
We don't always think about that,
but in fact there are a lot of factors to take into account
when we open a common pit like that.
There are possibly explosives to be removed around the area.
There are possibly chemical products that have been put in it.
In fact, these are really pits
in which we don't always know what we're going to find.
So there are a lot of precautions,
especially before the opening.
And then, opening these common pits,
you have to do it carefully
because you don't want to damage the evidence.
And the evidence can be a lot, a lot, a lot of different things.
It's going to be holes.
And then, of course, the bodies, the clothes,
the documents that can still be found in the ground.
All of this takes a lot, a lot of time.
And all of this is therefore consigned
in the UNITAD reports on the Yezidis.
I think there are nine.
You made me reach the last one.
I must say that it is quite chilling to read that.
This work also allowed to qualify
what happened as a genocide.
Yes, UNITAD cannot definitively affirm
that it is a genocide.
However, the report specifies that the collected evidence
could serve to qualify what happened
against the Yezidis of genocide
in judicial proceedings that could follow.
And one of its main reasons
is that Daesh called
in official documents
to eradicate this population
considered by the Islamic State
as heretic.
And this is globally the definition of the notion of genocide.
It is an intentional act
to eliminate a group of people
for their national, religious or ethnic identity.
I understand Marie-Charlotte
the pain, the trauma
of everything that happened to the Yezidis.
But we see that through this mission
there is still a work being done
so that all this is highlighted.
So, why does this community
always feel forgotten
even after this work?
The UNITAD mission
only collected information.
The question after
is to know globally
what will happen to this information.
This mission did not last long
to continue to support
the opening of all the communes.
And the Yezidis fear
that the rest of these communes
will be forgotten by the Iraqi authorities.
There was a figure highlighted
by many organizations
which was that of more than 90 identified
32 have not been opened
and that's just in Sinjar.
And we are not sure that there are no others elsewhere.
And so there is a feeling
of the Yezidi population
which has often been forgotten in Iraq
that without the presence
of a UN mission
it is again forgotten.
After, the second element
is also that there is a judicial work
which is expected
on the part of the Yezidi community.
They ask that the legislative authorities
recognize the genocide
and that the people responsible
be judged in front of the Iraqi courts
for genocide.
And that, the population
thinks that it will never happen
because the term genocide
does not exist in the Iraqi law
and that no legislation
is really in discussion
at the moment.
Except that this recognition for them
would already allow them
not to feel forgotten
and above all to potentially ask
for a financial compensation
which would also allow them to rise up
in the province to revive
life in the province.
This feeling of abandonment,
Marie-Charlotte,
is it also true for the entire Iraqi population?
In any case,
for all those who have suffered the Daesh assaults?
So, abandonment
for the entirety of the Iraqi population,
I cannot speak on behalf of
the entire Iraqi population.
On the other hand, what is certain
is that there is a general feeling of slowness.
We met several families
who are not only Yezidi families.
There are Shiite families too
who came to recover the remains
of their loved ones who have been identified.
These are loved ones who disappeared
in 2014.
All these families kept hope for a long time.
Finally, in 2017, they brought
their DNA to the Medical Institute
of Baghdad, saying that
there may have been hope, at least,
to know what happened to their loved ones.
And it is finally in 2024,
so ten years later, that they have the answer.
So there is a general feeling of slowness
and in any case a global feeling
of reliving
the trauma of the death of their loved ones
when they recover the remains
of the bodies.
The end of the UNITAD mission,
what does it mean concretely
for all these investigations,
since we understand that all this is very long.
Investigations that for some are still in progress.
Are the Iraqi authorities
ready to continue
the work on their own
since it is they, these authorities,
who asked for the creation
of this mission,
but also its departure?
Yes, so the work anyway
will continue in terms of
the excavation and identification of the bodies.
This is a job that had already
started before because Iraq
has a real problem
of false communes.
In its country, there are
dozens and dozens and dozens of sites
where we know that there are false communes.
These sites can contain
one, two, three, even ten
false communes in the same place.
And that, it sometimes dates
from the Iran-Iraq war,
massacres orchestrated by the old regime.
And then on top of that,
those of Daesh were added.
And we sometimes find false communes
a little by accident
during the renovation of certain places.
So this work, which had already started
before the UNITAD mission for the false communes
which dates from before Daesh,
it continues.
The people who collaborated with UNITAD
told us that they had learned a lot.
They had benefited from UNITAD's support
and that they would continue
to do things as they were done
knowing that UNITAD
has mainly acted on the last two
years of its mandate
from the point of view of concrete action on the ground.
The other question is
after this investigation,
what will happen at the judicial level?
And this is where, globally,
the answer may not be
much, since
we mentioned it a little earlier,
the term genocide does not exist
in the Iraqi law.
So there will not necessarily be a sequel
in these terms
from a judicial point of view.
And most of the suspects
arrested for participating
and joining the ranks of Daesh
have been judged as terrorists
and often already sentenced to death.
So there will not necessarily be other
organized procedures. But that is much more
vague because the legislators
do not necessarily want to discuss this subject.
Thank you Marie-Charlotte
for being in Témoin d'Actu for the first time.
Thank you Alexandra.
And thank you
for listening to this episode
and do not hesitate to subscribe
to Témoin d'Actu. See you soon.