A Tribute to Richard Brettell by Gloria Groom

Classical Artwork Conservation
262 followers
#classical art#art#art conservation#What Is Art Conservation #Arts
My close relationship with Dr. Britell goes back many years to the University of Texas at Austin,
where he was my professor, to the Art Institute of Chicago, where I was a research assistant,
and over the decades in our many reunions in Europe, but mostly in Chicago, which I think
was his second home after Dallas. In 1979, Rick became department head of European Painting at
the Art Institute of Chicago, and about six years later, I was hired to work on the exhibition
A Day in the Country, Impressionism in the French Landscape, which was based really on the classes
that I attended at UT, which I should say were standing room only, and we had to hire a note
taker because he was such a Jiminy Cricket kind of bouncing around that it was impossible to look
at him to listen and take notes at the same time. Once I was a member of the Art Institute family,
I was thrilled to be involved with Rick's 1988 exhibition The Art of Paul Gauguin. For the first
time ever, Gauguin was presented not only as a painter who exhibited with the Impressionists,
who left his wife and children to go to Brittany and finally ended up in Tahiti, but as a remarkable
maker of objects, as a variety of media, one of the most innovative potters, sculptures,
and printmakers of the 19th century. Together with his co-curator, Charles Stuckey, who at that time
was at the National Gallery, Rick traveled to Tahiti and to the Marquesas to look closely at
the shorelines, the trees, the flowers, the beautiful golden-skinned citizens wearing
colorful perillos, as well as the dogs, the pigs, from which, as Gauguin had done decades earlier,
he, to make his documents of the people, Rick drew his inspiration to reinvigorate
the artist's story and to also make the amazing installations that you see here.
After the exhibition's success in Chicago, in Washington, D.C., and in Paris at the Grand Palais,
Rick became a committed Gauguinista. In many ways, Gauguin was a closer fit to his own
outgoing personality and his extreme curiosity, even more so than his main man, Camille Pissarro,
with whom he had done his dissertation and a book. Like Gauguin, Rick had overlapping professional
lives, and he somehow managed to be successful in all of them as an academic, as a curator,
as a museum director, as an art critic, journalist, entrepreneur, and above all,
a people magnet, always on the lookout for the next exciting project and challenge. Like Gauguin,
he was a fearless world traveler whose worst nightmare was to be caught in a situation
or a conversation that he considered boring. The 1988 exhibition was a game-changer
to Gauguin's studies. It enlarged our understanding of the artist's achievement,
and it gave Rick the credentials to take on his next major role as the author for the Catalogue
Résumé of Gauguin, being undertaken by the Wildenstein-Plattner Institute, for which he
worked many years. But Rick could never resist the next challenge. Long before it was trendy to do so,
he embraced technical art history, the scientific examination of works of art to be used as tools
to enrich what we know, and many times leading to new discoveries that challenged and changed
our interpretation. Working closely with scientists, conservators, curators, and other art historians,
he quickly absorbed the results of these examinations, and he could see how the canvas
weaves, the underdrawings, the pigments, the signatures could be put to the service of identifying
and dating Gauguin's paintings. And this was no small accomplishment, for until recently,
dating Gauguin's paintings, especially those from his years in Tahiti, have been a kind of
a guessing game since the artist traced and copied, reused his canvases, and really copied
full some of his composition. And this was certainly the case with the wonderful painting
that has been in the Dallas Museum of Art since 1963, Under the Pandanus, one of many canvases
that Gauguin made of daily life during his first trip to Tahiti in 1891. And the painting is even
more compelling now that the darkened varnish has been removed, which you can see in this
mid-treatment image. The work was rolled and brought back from Tahiti and exhibited in Paris
in 1893, and again in 1895, as with the Tahitian title, Eurary O'Viry, in French, Sous le Pandanus.
In Paris, it would have been hung on the bright yellow walls of Gauguin's studio and gallery,
where he directly inspired, as we now know, another painting with the same title in the
Minneapolis Institute of Art, the MIA. Around 2012-2013, the DMA and MIA began research for a
project which would delve further into Gauguin's pairs. And in October 2014, a group of conservators,
curators, and art historians met at the Midwest Art Conservation Center located in the MIA for
Scholars Day, focusing on his pairing, especially this one. And here you see Rick conferring with
former conservator at the MIA, David Marquis. Behind them, both paintings, Dallas on the left
and the slightly larger Minneapolis, are shown unframed side by side for a purely visual analysis
that was informed by the full scientific inquiry of the materials that had been done prior to this.
Common to both paintings are the specific yet unusual medley of branches, roots, and vegetation
in the foreground. Pandanus trees, with their thick entwined roots, can thrive in a sandy soil
than like those found in marshes or along the shoreline, as you can see in this painting. And
anyone who has studied Gauguin knows that he is absolutely rigorous in keeping the approach to
art as topographically specific but not photographically precise, with the overall idea
that it would be about the harmony and the decorative quality of the whole. From the day
and a half study day in Minneapolis, it became clearer in what ways the Dallas picture had to
have been painted before the slightly larger Minneapolis version. In the larger canvas, we
see that the lines of branches in foreground are more simplified, more flowing, with their colors
more carefully considered, as would be expected for the second go-round, when the artist is less
tentative and he knows more confidently in which direction he's going. In the Dallas cognate, by
contrast, the brushwork of the leaves hanging down between the two heads is more exploratory,
with a number that have been painted out or shortened, while in the Minneapolis version, the
strokes are concise, more predetermined. Likewise, in the earlier Dallas canvas, there seems to have
been changes made to the shape of the dog's head, where a rough reserve has been left after the dog
was filled in, and it's kind of hard to see on the left, but there's a halo around the dog's muzzle.
The Dallas composition is what we refer to then as the prime version of the matrix, completed
the first trip to Tahiti in 1891, when Gauguin was making these documents, these sketches that
would eventually make their way into his paintings. Gauguin seems to have been particularly fond of
the pole-carrying figure and his companion, and this reappears in a number of works in different
media. As I mentioned, it is likely that the Minneapolis painting, which I show you here,
was conceived in Paris between 1893 and 1895, when he had the paintings from the first trip
on his walls, and he was rethinking and reconceiving them. During this period, he was
also hard at work on a semi-autobiographical account of his first sojourn in Tahiti, known as
Noah Noah, and he chose to incorporate these same two central figures into the frontispiece of the
illustrated version, which was never completed, but the woodblock was used again and again,
and provided the basis for many experimentations, such as the four that are in the Art Institute's
collection I show you here. Additionally, he recycled the same two figures in a watercolor
or monotype print, which he made before leaving to go back to Tahiti. From the technical study day
in Minneapolis, we were able to build on what we had learned, and when we looked at another
Gauguin painting, this time in our collection at the Art Institute of Chicago, The Big Tree,
which was close in date to the Dallas paintings. You can see also that they have in common those
decorative foliage in the foreground, and we know that ours was painted on a canvas similar to that
of the Dallas painting. This examination was the beginning of a larger project that we undertook
at this time to study our nine Gauguin paintings at the Art Institute and our hundreds of works on
paper in an online scholarly interactive and completely free catalog, and for this, we asked
Rick to be the prime author, and we had to lure him back to Chicago, but I have to say he did this
without much resistance, and he became part of the study team, and here you see.
That's right, yeah, and we were, you know, I, my sixth sense was that it was wrong,
and then it arrived, and we all decided it wasn't, because you know, it's right there,
and he does this in almost every medium. He does it in ceramic, he does it in wood,
he does it in printmaking, I mean, it's everywhere.
And as you can see, and we were there in December, just a couple of months after the Minneapolis
session, and as you see, Rick is in his element. He's teaching, he's asking questions, and above all,
he's having fun. The research that we conducted over a year and a half was a groundbreaking,
led to the groundbreaking exhibition that we organized with the Musee d'Orsay, Gauguin,
Artists as Alchemists, and it was really a project that completed the circle that Rick had begun
decades earlier with his 1988 retrospective, in the sense that it, again, presented Gauguin,
not just as a painter, but a risk-taking maker of objects, but now we could enrich the story
by the knowledge that we had acquired through these in-depth technical studies that have fed
into so many discoveries, including that aha moment that confirmed the chronological precedence
of the Dallas painting over the Minneapolis version. As I mentioned earlier, and as anyone who
knows Rick well, he's a people magnet and a kind of a yenta, kind of a matchmaker for putting
together creative individuals from all walks of life, and I'll never forget when, in the course
of working on this exhibition for 2017, Rick said, I had to meet Richard Kelton, a hugely intelligent
and eccentric collector of all things Gauguin, and he said, no, you have to get yourself invited to
his Marina del Rey home, so I did, and it was the beginning of many visits, and not only did it lead
to loans to the exhibition, but also to the acquisition of two of Gauguin's most important
early sculptures, La Parisienne, and this weird box carved with Degas dancers and a mummified
figure inside that were part of the Kelton collection. So once again, this coup was made
possible from Rick, always the rainmaker, always making things happen. I really cannot imagine
a world without the unstoppable Rick. One of his last performances, and as anyone who has
heard Dr. Patel in a lecture, you know that they are performances and more, was scheduled for April
2020 at the Art Institute, where he and I were going to be in dialogue about his recently published
book on modern beauty. Of course, that did not happen, but I'm sure that had we been able to be
together on the stage, Monsieur Gauguin would have been, if not the prime focus, a great focus, and
I'm even sure that I would have learned a lot, and that, as always with Rick, I would have had a fun time. Thank you.
