En Géorgie, l'influence de Moscou se fait de plus en plus sentir. Après l'adoption en mai et septembre 2024 de lois inspirées de la législation russe, notamment sur l'influence étrangère et les 'valeurs familiales', la Russie semble vouloir façonner l'avenir de ce pays du Caucase. À l'approche des élections parlementaires, nous discutons de cette stratégie avec Régis Genté, le correspondant de RFI à Tbilissi. #russie#georgie#tbilissi
It's really difficult, you know?
Let's say one step back.
It forces NGOs and media
that receive more than 20% of funding
from other countries
to declare themselves to the authorities.
Despite the presidential veto,
this law is now in force.
September 2024,
same parliament, same context.
A series of laws
on the protection of family values
which target in particular the LGBT community
and vote.
Again, it is inspired by Russia.
How do these laws translate
the growing influence of Moscow in Georgia
and what does this turn mean
for the future of the country?
I'm talking to Regis Janté,
RFI correspondent in Tbilisi.
Georgia is located on the border
of the Black Sea.
It is surrounded by Russia, Azerbaijan,
Armenia and Turkey.
In 2023, it obtained the status
of candidate to the European Union.
But the party in power,
the Georgian dream,
which is said to be favorable
to the rapprochement with the West,
has taken a sharp pro-Russian turn
The next parliamentary elections
at the end of October
will therefore be crucial
for the future of the country.
Hello Regis.
Hello to you, hello to everyone.
Teona, you are the young woman
we hear in this introduction.
You interviewed her
in front of the Parliament
when the deputies examined the veto
to the law on foreign influence
which had been submitted by the President.
All this concluded
months of opposition demonstrations.
Can you remind me
first of what this law is
and why it has aroused
such opposition
from the population?
It is a law that looks like
a copy-paste of the law
adopted in 2012 in Russia
on foreign agents
and which turned out to be
extremely liberticidal.
In Georgia, we already have a dozen laws
that frame the sector of non-governmental
organizations, NGOs, civil society.
And it is already perfectly transparent.
In 50 seconds, if you go
to any NGO site in Georgia,
you know who finances it,
why, in which program, etc.
So it consists first
simply to label, to stigmatize
these organizations
which are financed by the West
as foreign agents,
that is to say, as traitors.
The translation in Georgian
sounds like in French.
It is really a way to break
the reins of the pro-Western civil society
financed by the West,
be it the United States or Europe.
And this is already what a good part
of the street and a good part of society
feared in April and May.
We had two months of daily demonstrations
sometimes up to 80,000
I think, demonstrators.
So it's a lot for this very small country
of 3.7 million inhabitants,
afraid of the tightening of the law.
But above all, this law has been
renamed the Russian law.
And so it is a Russian law in the sense
that it is a law that was inspired by Russia,
but also where Russia exports
in a way its political model
and which means that Georgia
would return to the geopolitical orbit.
And geopolitics is very concrete,
you know, for people's daily lives.
So it would return to the orbit
of the former colonial power, which is Russia,
which we absolutely want to emancipate from
for at least 30 years in Georgia.
And it is also a law
that has really been written precisely
to break ties with the West.
To simplify, but in the context
of the war in Ukraine, the Europeans,
notably under the impetus of the President
of the Ursula von der Leyen Commission,
accelerated the processes
of adhesion to Europe for Ukraine,
Moldova and Georgia.
The government had to follow
because 80% or more of the population
said they wanted Europe.
But Moscow,
through the pro-Russian government,
which is led by an oligarch
who is completely in Moscow's hands here in Georgia,
tried to stop this march.
And this law is a real
sense of prohibition to go to Europe
since it contradicts
all the values and all the requirements
of Europe to be able to adhere.
If you label each organization
of civil society as an agent of the foreign,
it is obviously the best way not to associate it
since everyone must be wary of it
and it is done for.
This law, Regis, you just said it,
it was adopted despite months of demonstrations,
also of repression,
of intimidation.
Is all this still being pursued today?
Well, it calmed down a little bit
because once the law was adopted,
there were still a few demonstrations
in May and then the summer
arrived and then the energy,
of course, after two months
of daily demonstrations,
it calmed down a bit.
Now it is starting again,
we feel that there is agitation in society
because on October 26th,
we have parliamentary elections
which will be, in a way,
the realization in the urns
of these demonstrations
that we could observe in the streets.
It will be, in a way,
the final point of this big geopolitical turn
that the oligarch, the strong man of Georgia,
whose name is Litvitsina Ivanishvili,
who made all his fortune in Russia.
With this election, it is a way,
in a way, to finish this cycle
and to complete the return of Georgia
in the orbit, in the sphere of Russian influence
in case of victory of the party in power
which is highly probable
even if it lost in popular support
because of these demonstrations
but by force of propaganda,
by force of propaganda, for example,
on the fact that Europe was decadent,
on the fact that Europe wanted to import
the Ukrainian war, to import it
in the Caucasus, in Georgia,
still managed to keep a part
of the population's support
so it will be a rather disputed election
but above all, the party in power
has what we call the administrative resources
it has huge means
apart from the fact that the strong man of the country
is a billionaire whose only fortune
represents about a third of the country's GDP
and so we fear
an election that is not quite clean
and that somehow steals their future
The man you are talking about, if I understand correctly
is the leader of the party in power
whose name is Rev Georgien
he exercises a more and more
important control
Yes, he is really the man
who completely controls the country
I work a lot in the entire
old Soviet space, in many
dictatorships and authoritarian regimes
we realize that these are much more complex regimes
it is never simply the dictator who dictates
things, he is often obliged to
seduce a part of the population,
to buy it, to create clientelism
but indeed, he is the man
who truly dominates the entire
Georgian political scene
his party, the Rev Georgien
the party in power
since 2012
has no political figure
that is independent of Mr. Ivani Jveli
for example, if we take
all the ministers, all the personalities
who have been ministers for 10-12 years
none of them, when they left the government
had a truly political existence
except one, maybe, otherwise all the others
have completely disappeared
so it shows how much this man has
an ascendancy over the entire political spectrum
especially from the party in power
Regis,
it's a bit the same scheme
that operates with the recent
so-called family values laws
they were voted a few days before
our recording
this also participates in establishing
a very conservative climate in Georgia
Yes, that's it, in fact, we feel the Russian dough
because, what is this law
on family values, on the protection
of family values and minors
basically, it is nicknamed
the law against propaganda
or the so-called LGBT propaganda
it aims to paint the West
Europe and America
as decadence
while Russia
and the surrounding countries would be
trees of conservative peace
respectful of traditional values
etc. It is obviously completely
false, but it is the way
that Russia, for two centuries
presents itself on the international scene
and the government
supports itself, exactly like
Mr. Putin did, since 2012
in particular, it supports itself on a segment
of the society a little more traditionalist
than the rest, by saying, look, there is a huge risk
we want to destroy our traditional culture
by promoting
homosexuality
What I don't understand, Regis,
is that while preparing this episode
I read that this party,
Rêve Géorgien, was at the beginning
rather pro-Western
What happened?
How did this
reversal happen?
And how, as a result,
does the population continue
to vote for it?
Indeed, this is an absolutely fundamental question
Originally, 12 years ago
you always had a population
that believed in its independence
in its national destiny
and in this case, for Georgia
it means being on the side of Europe
being on the side of the Christian world
and so
that's how we end up with 80% of the Georgians
who say they want to become
a member, that their country becomes a member
of the European Union
So the government, even if it has a purely pro-Russian agenda
it is obliged to hide
and to make believe that it is the one
who carries the real European values
but not the liberal values, the conservative values
For example, the great friend
of the Georgian government
is the Hungarian government of Viktor Orban
because precisely
it allows them to have
a political vision
which is officially called European
but which actually goes in the opposite direction
So in fact, this government
constantly plays on this ambiguity
For example, at the moment, if we went out
in my street, we would see posters of the party
in power, which are almost the only ones
we can see, because it has financial means
compared to the other parties
and you have in fact
the logo of the party
mixed with a part of the European flag
to make believe that it is them
who are the real bearers of European values
and of the European project
when they did everything to sabotage it
But if they went too fast
if they said, giving up Europe
let's go to Russia, well we would have exactly
what happened in Ukraine at the end of 2013
which we called the Maidan
with the result that we know
the revolution, the fall of the president
and the annexation of Crimea
and the war in Donbass
and so the government is very careful
to defend itself as a European
while going against the European project
and then we could see over the years
and especially from 2021
Russia really exerts
a lot more pressure on this friendly government
the one of this oligarch
who made a fortune at home
and who owes his fortune to Russia
We really saw a strategy of rupture
with the West, whereas before
we had at the same time a government
who played the pro-European card
in appearance at least
and who seemed to manage the interests of Russia
but since 2021
it has really reversed
Regis, since the beginning of this episode
you talk to me a lot about Ukraine
if I understand correctly
in the geopolitical strategy of Russia
there are several methods, the war
the one we see in Ukraine since 2022
and then the more severe war
with attempts of destabilization
this is what is happening for Georgia
Indeed, I tend to think that these events
especially this law on foreign agents
in fact we have to look at it
as a fact of the war in Ukraine
I think that in a hundred years
when we will look at these wars, these events
we will put them all under the same banner
and we will probably call it the wars of decolonization
of the former Soviet space
or something like that
Indeed, we must always remember that the war
in current Ukraine
that we see every day in our newspapers
that we listen to every day on RFI
this war started in Georgia
in 2008
it was exactly the same war
for exactly the same reasons
for Russia, it is about defending what it calls its neighbor
to make sure that the countries
that it had colonized before
which are around its borders
remain under its watch
under its control
in its geopolitical orientation
and if possible with the same type of power
of the same type of regime
and I think that laws
like the law on foreign agents
which was also adopted in Kyrgyzstan
for example, in Central Asia
at the same time, it is a way for Russia
to put all these countries
in some way in its hands
so indeed it is a kind of episode of the war
but not a military episode
as you just said
you are right, but rather as a political episode
of this war
I was asking you earlier about the Georgian population
and its reactions to all this
we haven't answered yet
is there a certain
fatalism or fear
how does it happen?
in fact
we have to see how an authoritarian regime
works, in this case
we have the establishment of an authoritarian regime
which is not yet really
because the Georgian society is quite free
it is a society where we demonstrate a lot
I think I had to cover 150 demonstrations
in this country in 20 years
of coverage for RFI for example
so it is happening little by little
but indeed, an authoritarian regime
which is establishing itself
a kind of autocracy of an oligarch
which has no official function
it is a very curious regime
which we see establishing itself
it uses a lot of means
it is like a piano with a lot of different keys
so sometimes it can be the carrot
but sometimes it is the stick
so we have seen repression in the demonstrations
we have seen people passing out
it was about instilling fear in the population
to the point that the people who did it
were able to do it in a face-to-face way
so it really showed a lot of audacity
and assurance
we also use clientelism
we buy people
for example
we passed a law in the spring
to say that 600,000 people
in a country of 3.7 million inhabitants
it's huge
well, deserved to hold now all of a sudden
while the election is approaching
and we were also going to pass these laws
which were so controversial
well, they were entitled to a social assistance
of a little more than 100 euros per month
for example
so you can imagine that all these people
even if they hate the government
before going to vote
they will think twice
if they should still vote for this government
and whatever it costs for the European future
or not for the country
because in a poor country
where the average income is around 300 euros per month
obviously it is something fundamental
so there is clientelism
we buy people
we scare them
a lot of propaganda
telling them that Europe is resuming
to make propaganda for homosexuals
or that Europe wants to open a second front
of war in Ukraine
and therefore import war in Georgia
and a whole bunch of methods like that
that in the end
we still manage to have support
for this government
without having to cheat
on the one hand they are surfing
on a real electorate
that is honest
that says that we should not confront Russia
but we can see that it goes beyond that
but it is also part of its electoral background
which is legitimate
How does the opposition organize itself
in the approach of these parliamentary elections?
Is it able to rival
with Reef Georgien?
It is very difficult because they deal
not only with a billionaire
I was saying that his fortune
represents about a third of the GDP
so imagine that as soon as he puts
a little money in the country
for example on the occasion of an election
he immediately changes the donation
so that is very important
but it is also someone, this billionaire
who knows perfectly the political functioning
of all the instruments
he knows perfectly the mentalities
how the units work, etc.
He comes from the very heart
of Russian politics
in the late 90s
and so he is indeed very powerful
and the opposition against this
is quite disunited, it has a little funding
but from people who do not represent
the hundredth of the financial power
of Mr. Ivanishvili for example
so it is difficult
it is also divided partly
because of its own mistakes
we are in a young country
partly also because sometimes it is a little helped
by the party in power
which can arouse divisions within
and so it advances masked
it advances divided
and so it is an opposition that struggles to unite
to the point that for example the president
Mrs. Zohrabi-Juilli
who does not have a lot of power
but who can have a kind of moral authority
to propose to the opposition
to make a charter for those who want
Europe in a way
which allows everyone to stay in their own party
to keep the diversity
of these opposition parties
while still having a goal, a common ground
which is to want to join Europe
but even that is still quite difficult
we witness discussions these days
which show that it is still
a difficult ambition but which could succeed
You Regis, you have been
correspondent for a very long time
in Tbilisi and throughout the Caucasus region
how do you see these evolutions
and I also wanted to know if you
you feel particular obstacles
also in your work as a journalist
Not really obstacles
we felt a little pressure
that could put itself on us
but not really for the moment
on the other hand we feel a population
and elites that can tend sometimes
so it can be more difficult to speak
to some people
the party in power generally refuses
interview proposals
there are only two or three people
who are allowed to speak
in this very particular context
and often they speak by making statements
but do not really respond to interviews
forcibly from the foreign press
but for the moment we manage to cover
these events because it is a country
which is animated by a lot of freedom
a lot of demonstrations
and that it is difficult for the party in power
even if it had the ambition
to establish a kind of authoritarian regime
and that's part of the questions
we ask ourselves for the future
are we really going to make it?
is imposing dictatorship
or authoritarianism on a population
that has manifested so much for 30 years
and who was among the pioneers
to want to leave the USSR
from the 1970s
will it happen?
so for the moment we manage to work
the atmosphere is a little tense
we see on the other hand
that's the advantage of living in countries
it really allows us to take the pulse
of the populations or the countries
in which we work
and there we see that there are a lot of concerns
I have seen people who have always fought
for 20 years that I have been there
and who today really take blows
and we are sometimes afraid
and wonder if we should not leave
Thank you very much Regis
for coming back to Témoin d'Actu
it is always a pleasure to understand
this part of the world
Thank you very much, thank you
and thank you for listening to this episode
it is available on all podcast platforms
on our application
Pure Radio
see you soon