Les hommes peuvent-ils être féministes ? Comment certains hommes remettent en question la masculinité patriarcale ? Cet épisode tente de répondre à ces questions en donnant la parole à deux jeunes hommes en Côte d’Ivoire et qui ont bien accepté de parler de leur engagement. Gloire Wanief est activiste, écrivain et éditeur. Elie Akadia est sociologue et photographe, surtout la photographie de nu. Ils ont tous les deux, décidé de mettre leur savoir-faire au service de la lutte pour l’égalité des droits entre les femmes et les hommes. Ils se sont ouverts à moi sur comment ils l’expriment dans leur travail. Mais en retour, ils sont parfois rabaissés et leur masculinité mise en doute par d’autres hommes, parce qu’ils refusent de perpétuer la domination masculine.
You are listening to Balépate season 2, episode 6.
No to toxic masculinity, yes to feminist masculinity.
In this episode, I decided to take an interest in the initiatives to deconstruct
the male behaviors that feed patriarchal society.
The wind changes direction and some will have to deal with it.
Women have become aware of their power.
It is no longer a question of submitting everywhere and all the time to male injunctions.
Among men, there are those who have chosen to resist in the age of time.
But there are others who have understood the fight of feminists
and some have even rallied by questioning their male identity.
I went to meet two young men in Abidjan, Ivory Coast.
I am Eli Akadia.
I am a photographer with a training in sociology and political science.
I am Gloire Waniyef, a writer and editor in La Presse Écrite Jeunesse.
I am a web activist.
It is mainly on social networks, especially on Facebook,
that I often share my opinions, my opinions,
sometimes in a slightly virulent way to tease the world a bit.
They both decided to put their know-how and their profession
at the service of the fight for equal rights between women and men.
They opened up to me about this commitment that motivates them
and how they express it in their work.
This is the story I had to write.
The story is Friends Forever.
I wrote this story.
What is this story about?
It is a story of friendship between a little girl and a little boy.
The little girl has to move because her parents have a job in another city.
The little boy is a bit sad about this and he organizes a party for his friend.
In this particular story, what I tried to highlight in terms of positive masculinity
is that the little boy is a boy who is very sensitive.
He cries several times in the story.
These are the elements that I purposely highlighted
to show a slightly different little boy.
Because even in our stories,
even in general, little boys are always adventurous.
I really wanted to highlight a sensitive little boy.
It is in this subtle way that I try to fight my fight.
I would even say that this is one of the reasons why I was chosen.
Motivation is something that I put forward,
the fact that I have this particular look on the world.
Photography, as I do it now,
I would say that I officially started it in 2016 and 2017.
It is a bit like when I entered my third year of sociology
where I really started to get into the subjects of social order,
the systemic problems of gender and race,
that I myself started to want to couple.
And as I became interested in my studies on the subject,
I also wanted to represent what I was doing visually in photography.
So when I have the opportunity,
I work on questions like forced marriage,
or violence against women in general,
or the look that we have most of the time on the modesty of women,
on how we try to make the police on the body of the woman,
or it is she who has to hide her body, it is she who has to cover herself.
So that's when I started to focus a lot more on the naked,
to precisely desexualize the look we have on women.
Or a naked woman is not necessarily synonymous with sexualization.
So that's where I wanted to use my art as a channel to talk about that,
and also contribute to a better education of young boys
to change their vision of femininity and maximunity,
already on themselves, but also how they see others,
how they see the world around them.
And working on the naked, especially on the body of women,
is it something that is easy to highlight in a country like the Ivory Coast?
Did you receive any criticism? How did you manage to instill that?
It is true that it is difficult for some to link nudity to anything
other than sexuality and pornography.
So it is quite well received.
I can't say that it is badly received or that it is well received,
but I really manage to convey the message.
But it is often the questions that I am asked,
because often the work, we understand it,
we can read it because it is often followed by a long text
to facilitate interpretation.
But it is often the questions that come to me,
where I am asked, ah, but Jean, the model after you did nothing,
how do you do to keep her?
Well, Jean, they still don't understand these questions,
because they imagine themselves.
I already have a web page called Akem Photography,
A-K-E-M Photography, with Y.com,
where I expose most of my work,
which I can't expose, especially on social networks,
because of the different restrictions in relation to nudity.
For example, I have the work of a black woman,
who is naked, who literally just has her hair to cover herself.
And what I wanted to emphasize, especially on this work,
was feminine pilosity,
because often we associate pilosity only with masculinity,
or when a woman has the audacity to keep her hair,
it is criticized, we say, ah no, it's dirty,
why does she keep it, why does she maintain it,
it is unclean.
But when it's on a weird man, we say, it's virile,
it does this, it does that.
So it is to remind that it is time to humanize the woman,
that the woman is a human being,
she is part of the biodiversity, of nature,
and that in this biodiversity, there are women who keep their pilosity.
Whether it is the hair of the dishes, the polyp,
or even the chest, which is not in the marketing standards,
which is bombed, all that,
which I wanted to emphasize, precisely,
on the part where she resists the fact that a man wants to
force her to impose his vision
of how a woman should present herself in society,
how a woman should be,
what she can keep or remove from her body.
It is good to hear Elie Akadia explain to us,
as a man, the look he puts on his model
in nude photography.
Because the person photographing, man or woman,
reveals his nudity in front of the lens.
This practice is generally associated with eroticism
and sexuality.
However, it is a photographic genre as a whole,
just like the portrait or the fact of photographing nature.
But nudity, especially that of women,
is hyper-sexualized and badly seen,
to the point that it is used as the unit of measurement
of a good morality or not.
That is why it made me feel good to hear,
on the part of a man, another sound of the bell
on nude photography.
I was also curious to know how these women
who pose naked feel in front of a male gaze.
One of Elie Akadia's models wanted to tell me
about her experience.
I am Marie-Lyne Tano.
I am an aesthetician, masotherapist,
and I am also a nude photography model.
What I like the most about Elie Akadia
is that he is really respectful.
He tries to understand the model in front of him,
the expectations of the model,
what the model would like to do or not do.
He does not have a perverse mind,
he does not have disrespectful speech, no.
He is someone who really works in transparency.
He puts you at ease.
He tries to listen to you.
He tries to share his ideas,
to see his ideas too.
He does not have wandering hands.
He does not allow himself to be touched without your opinion.
It was purely professional.
During the photo shoots,
I really did not feel that.
A look other than that of the photographer
in front of his model, no.
There was no such thing.
I'll give you an example.
Sometimes we work according to the themes.
With Elie, the most recent photo shoot
was based on pilosity.
You see a little when we talk about pilosity.
We were focused on that only.
There was no other look than that.
He made me love even more the nude photograph.
Because he taught me to love,
to love my imperfections.
That a man puts another look on the nudity of a woman,
a look other than sexual,
is almost unimaginable for some people
who do not conceive the female body
other than by the prism of sexuality.
Hence, reflections such as
a woman should not show her body
or a woman who dresses in such a way
incites sexual aggression.
To better understand,
I refer you to episode 2 of season 1 of Ballet Pats.
These moralizing criticisms
would never be made to men.
They are clearly part of the culture
of toxic masculinity.
I must explain to you this notion
that brings together all male behaviors
and societal norms
that would like a man to be virile,
that a man is superior to the woman,
that he has the right to be violent,
that the woman must submit to him,
or the injunction to be a real man.
In short, the obligation
of a masculine domination on the woman.
Activist Beninois Djeri Azilinon
talked about it in episode 9
of season 1 of Ballet Pats.
Positive masculinity is to take all these things,
that is, all that is masculine ego,
patriarchy, all these negative terms
that are around masculinity
and to make it something more positive.
Because masculinity is nothing bad.
It's just that over time
we have made it something negative.
It contains a lot more negative things
than positive things.
When today you are told to be a man,
that is, everything that has as meaning behind it
is only negative.
And we want that when you are told
to be a man, that it is something positive.
Respect women, treat women well,
consider women as they are,
that it is really all these positive things
that are behind being a man today.
In addition, it was obvious
that men who reject patriarchal masculinity
would be put aside by their peers
who consider them as less virile men,
because they refuse to perpetuate masculine domination.
They are most of the time
belittled and their masculinity questioned.
For example, men who dare
let their emotions express themselves
by crying are labeled as weak.
Those who support feminism
are almost always treated as homosexual.
Let's find the young Congolese writer
Gloire Waniyef.
Categorizing men who will defend
this idea that men and women are equal,
categorizing these people as homosexual
is a way of belittling them.
Because socially,
we consider homosexuals,
especially homosexual men,
because it is really precise,
it is really much more
homosexual men who are socially
considered as being less than men.
Because society considers that
it is men who have the power,
who are in front of things,
and who must have respect naturally.
Because if you are a man, you will be respected.
So when you are a man,
and in your behavior,
in your attitude,
in your clothing,
in the ideas you defend,
in what you share,
you feel a touch of femininity in you,
a touch of feminization.
Directly, you no longer deserve
the respect you are given.
Because socially,
people who are considered inferior
are women.
So we will identify you as a woman,
so at least we have the possibility
to walk on you.
Because if we consider you as a man,
we will have to talk to you
with all the respect you are supposed to have.
So I think it's a mechanism
to have this ability to walk on the other.
It's a way they found,
a rhetorical, ideological way
to be able to invalidate
someone's words.
Photographer Elia Kadia
makes the same observation.
They associate homosexuality
with femininity.
Because they don't imagine that there are homosexuals
who are very masculine, very robust,
who respond to their norms of hegemonic masculinity.
But it is the fact that in their minds
they have associated the fact of being homosexual
with being feminine.
Because when we tell them to draw a homosexual,
they imagine someone who is feminized,
who dresses in pink,
who wears a jacket.
So it's this version.
It's like they didn't find social examples
for what is not a man.
They place you either as a woman
or as something else
other than a man.
So it's a bit in this logic,
what they take for a logic,
to necessarily tax
homosexual feminists
without knowing that there are misogynistic homosexuals.
It's just a shortcut for them
to simply say
you're just not a man.
You can be what you want, but you're not a man.
In the end,
as you have understood,
toxic masculinity does not only target women.
Men are also victims of it.
Because toxic masculinity
opposes another masculinity
called positive.
And the men who claim it
can also be the object of humiliation
on the pretext that they do not respond
to the secular standards of masculinity.
At first,
the idea behind this notion of positive masculinity
is that men question
the patriarchal education
they have always received.
But also that they wonder
about behaviors they may have had
in the past.
Unfortunately, this concept of positive masculinity
has gradually been
emptied of its substance
to be born as a simple expression.
Let's take the example of the
IFORCHI world campaign
meant by Lui Pour Elle.
Carried by the UN Women since 2014,
it consists of selecting
men, IFORCHI ambassadors
who will show their
solidarity for gender equality
and commit to adopting
behaviors in this direction.
Except that there have apparently
been casting errors.
Some of them were illustrated
by sexist and misogynistic
positions on social networks
and, we imagine, in their daily lives.
Let's go back to Glore Waniyev,
this living Congolese
in Abidjan who questions his masculinity.
Before getting to
a personal awareness crisis,
he asked himself a whole bunch of questions,
especially on subjects
that are often not easy to address
and which he spontaneously
spoke about during our discussion.
He explains that it's all part
of a childhood memory.
I was a victim of sexual abuse
when I was a kid,
when I was 5 or 6 years old.
I was a victim of sexual abuse,
which changed
my perception of sexuality
and masculinity.
Because when I experienced
this abuse, I didn't really hide it.
I didn't really hide it,
especially because I was a kid,
I didn't understand what it was,
and it was presented to me as a game.
From a woman's point of view,
I think she was a teenager,
the memories are a bit vague,
but she was a lot older than me.
When I experienced this,
I didn't hide it,
it was presented as a game.
I talked about it to other boys and girls
who were a lot older than me,
except that it was seen as something normal,
it was seen as something good for me,
to have experienced this.
You're now a boy,
when I was a kid.
This particular element
had made me
internalize a certain misogyny.
Because, as I said,
I was educated by my mom,
but she taught me to be a man
like all other men should be.
A man is the boss,
a man is this, a man is that.
You don't touch domestic things,
you focus on school,
because you'll have money,
and when you have money,
you can have all the women you want.
This is the general education
that I received.
Because of this,
I had a very virilist conception
of masculinity.
As a man, if you want something,
you take it.
When I was younger,
I had abusive relationships,
retrospectively.
When I analyze my relationships
with women before,
they were quite abusive,
or I was the abuser.
I didn't take into account
other people's opinions.
So I had a very toxic
conception of masculinity.
As a man, I didn't take the time
to look at myself,
to analyze myself, to question
my condition, my person.
Because it's not something you say,
but socially, it's as if
it's something you admit.
As a man, as a boss,
we didn't show our weakness.
And to question
a behavior that society
finds normal, when you're a man,
it's not well seen, it's not tolerated
that you question yourself.
For example, speaking of being a boss,
of having an abusive relationship,
I remember when I was
much younger, maybe I was a teenager,
I had a little friend, and we found ourselves
in a situation where we had to have
a sexual relationship, and she didn't want it.
I wanted it.
At first, I wanted to force her,
but it didn't happen because she was
a little stronger than me, so she made sure
that nothing happened. And I blamed her
because I knew that I had acted badly.
But when I went to talk to others,
to friends, to older men,
they were like, but you're not normal,
why are you blaming her, it's normal
that you do it, it's her who behaved badly
because you're a man, you wanted it,
she should have let it go.
So that meant that there was no question
of all these different behaviors.
And in fact, these are female friends,
I think her name was Marie-Emilienne
Adjiko, on social media,
I don't remember what conversation
it was, but it was just a conversation
that had nothing to do with sexuality,
where we talked about things like that,
about consent and other things,
there was a lot of debate, and that's when
I understood, in 2018, that when I was
younger, I had been a victim of abuse,
and it allowed me to really question
all these different behaviors that I had.
It's not normal that we can
normalize the fact that men are
predators, it's not normal at all.
So we have to question that,
we really have to question that,
and especially on the relationships
that men have with masculinity.
In my Facebook walks,
I spotted in 2022 a man
who talks about the sexual health
of men and women.
I was first intrigued by his pseudonym,
Tonton Sagefemme.
He is Ivorian and lives abroad.
So I contacted him.
So I am Jean-Charles Wénien,
I am a Sagefemme man,
known on social media
as Tonton Sagefemme.
And on social media,
I present Sagefemme's job,
I give health advice
and sexual health advice.
I wanted to know
why he became Sagefemme,
if it had an impact on his
perception of masculinity,
and how he uses social media
so that men are interested
in intimate subjects like sexual health.
So let's say
it wasn't something planned
at the beginning,
because when I entered
medical school in Montpellier,
the idea was to do medicine,
more precisely cardiology,
because let's say
I had an emotional motivation
because my grandfather was a cardiologist.
And for me,
doing that to be the cardiologist
of his grandfather,
it was a childhood dream.
And unfortunately,
I was not able to be classified
in the very, very high
to have medicine.
So my ranking allowed me
to have other branches
affiliated to the first year
of health studies,
but not medicine,
and I had to make a choice.
And Sagefemme was not
part of my initial choices
because it is true that
in my imagination,
although being in a health study,
I did not imagine a man doing this job.
So I talked to my mother
and my mother told me,
listen, try to see the other branches.
I start like that, look,
I come across Sagefemme.
And in fact, it is now that I do research
on this job.
I read online testimonials
from Sagefemme and all,
and it spoke to me.
And I said, well, I'm going to try that.
And so I went to register.
And in fact,
we started with a first internship
in general care,
and then the second internship I did
was directly in maternity.
And the first day I arrive,
so I arrive to make a night shift,
and I'm told like that,
go ahead, follow the intern in medicine
and the gynecologist,
you go on a cesarean.
So I followed them,
entered an operating room
that I had never been to.
It's a real sanctuary.
I told you.
And the birth of the child,
the first cry,
it was very, very, very, very, very strong
for me, both symbolically
and emotionally.
And after a few hours
of watch, a few minutes
of watch, I said, no, this is my place.
This is what I want to do.
We have always assimilated
women to the job of care,
to take care of others,
to think of others.
We said to ourselves that they naturally have
these skills, and so when a man does it,
it raises questions.
I don't know what are really the social determinants
that make
that there are more women in these jobs.
I don't master all these contours,
but I think it can be explained scientifically
beyond the purely
naturalist aspect,
which will tell you that, in essence, a woman is made
to take care of others.
But at the level, for example,
of the job of care,
I realized in practice
that it has nothing to do
with the gender identity
of the person, but above all,
it has to do with personality,
because it is a job that requires
a certain dose of empathy,
of social intelligence,
like all medical and care
So that's what's going to dominate
the gender, quite simply.
To practice a so-called feminine job,
does it make a man less masculine
than the others?
Jean-Charles Ouignan's example shows us
that the answer is no.
It also shows us that by their choice,
their attitude, their commitment
in their field of activity,
men can contribute to their scale
to normalize gender equality,
whatever the discipline,
and therefore promote
a healthy masculinity.
In the next episode,
it will be a question of the battle
between masculinists and feminists
on social networks.
Do not hesitate to share this podcast,
talk about it around you,
especially to the men around you,
because the question of masculinity
is just as important as feminism.
Did you like this episode?
I invite you to share it
on social networks and talk about it
around you. Do not hesitate
to subscribe to the podcast
and give it five stars
on the listening platform of your choice.
See you soon!