The FBI has released its crime statistics showing that violent crime, including murders, are dropping across the United States. The release is being used to fact-check perceptions that crime has been growing in recent years. But other sources of data suggest that there is still some nuance in the reporting. We’ll discuss this issue and others, in this episode of Crossroads.
🔴 Stay informed. Stay Free. Join us: https://www.joshphilipp.com - - - - - - - - - Views expressed in this video are opinions of the host and guests, and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.
Welcome to Crossroads. The FBI has released new crime statistics showing that violent crime has
dropped across the United States. But the release is being used to fact check these perceptions that
crime has been growing in recent years and the problem with that is that while other sources
suggest that there's actually some some nuance to this. Now first let's look at the official data
from the FBI. This is released on September 23rd. This is the official FBI statement. It says this
the FBI's crime statistic estimates based on reported data from 2023 show that national
violent crime decreased an estimated 3% in 2023 compared to 2022 estimates. They note that murder
and non-negligent manslaughter recorded a 2023 estimate nationwide decrease of 11.6% compared to
previous year. Big drop they say. It notes that in 2023 the estimated number of offenses in the
revised rape category saw an estimated 9.4% decrease. They note that aggravated assault
figures decreased an estimated 2.8% 2023 and robbery showed an estimated decrease of 0.3%
nationally. Now look of course it's an election year this year so politics was going to be
part of the media's reporting on these statistics. And if you look at what the media is saying about
this, well again they're trying to fact check Trump again with the recent political debates
they had with him and Kamala Harris. And they're saying that he's lying about crime statistics
and so on. Now there's a bit of details to this because basically it ties into which set of data
you're looking at. But let me show you first what NBC said. NBC News said this. They said crime
including serious violent incidents like murder and rape dropped nationally from 2022 to 2023
according to new data released by the FBI. They say public perception of crime is often out of
step with the facts especially in the age of social media. Ease of digital communications
between neighbors and doorbell cameras when many Americans may be more aware of individual crimes
than they would have been in the past. Again you know the flood of information all of us are
watching Twitter and other things like that and we're seeing all these videos of crime and again
that's forming our perceptions but that's what they're suggesting. Now they note that during a
campaign stop in Kittending Pennsylvania on Monday evening former president Donald Trump had a
different take on the numbers claiming crime was through the roof. Now what's important here these
statistics are being reported in context of policies for the presidential election. Crime
has become a political issue. It's not just about crime itself. Donald Trump is saying hey you know
crime is through the roof. He's pointing to light on crime policies. You have a lot of these district
attorneys who are kind of not prosecuting a lot of crime. You have the concept now of equity when
it comes to the way laws are enforced and who faces punishment and you know you have issues
for example in some states and even some major cities where crimes are not being punished the
way they used to. Drugs are for the most part decriminalized in a lot of the country, at least
most drugs are, at least drug use. You have it for example in San Francisco where you can steal around
nine hundred dollars worth of goods and it's not really a major offense. You have of course you
know car theft happening now on a pretty large scale including a lot of the major cities and
there's very little people can do about this. When it comes to the crime statistics for the
experience of non-americans what they're seeing is that hey I don't feel protected anymore and
the argument here as well is that an actual fact? Are you less protected or is it something that you
believe only because you you know maybe follow social media too much? That's kind of where the
debate is. Now what's really going on is there's a bit of nuance with all of this. The real fact
and this is kind of where it gets complicated. The real fact is whether you believe that crime is
up or down kind of depends on which statistic you want to believe because there's actually
different data sets. Republicans are using one, Democrats are using another, and this is where a
lot of the kind of miscommunications are coming into play. It depends on which set of data you
want to go by. Crime and public safety have become big issues like especially again in light of these
policies and especially in major cities and because people are worried about this well
politics are using it. But look as with a lot of information these days again there's some really
important nuance. What it comes down to basically again is which set of data you want to go by.
Some news outlets for example noted that the FBI crime statistics, the one that a lot of the other
The FBI's crime statistics does not include necessarily complete data from some of the
most violent cities and towns across America. And the issue with this is there are different
sets of data that feed those statistics. The surface picture changes a lot depending on which
data set you go by. Now this is Sure News Network. They say for more than a hundred years the FBI's
relied on local law enforcement agencies to submit crime data through its uniform crime
reporting program. This system provided an annual snapshot of crime in America and was considered
the gold standard for national crime statistics. But what happened? Well that changed in 2021
when the FBI moved from the summary reporting system which focused on top line numbers like
well the total number of murders or car thefts to the more granular national incident based
reporting system that's the NIBRS. Now this system NIBRS was designed to modernize the way crime is
tracked providing richer details about each incident including specifics about the victim
the suspect and the circumstances surrounding the crime. However this switch caused significant
disruption in data collection. Notes that many police departments especially those in large
cities like New York City and Los Angeles were unprepared for the transition and failed to
submit their crime data. So how do you have you know crime is down and you don't even have
statistics from some of the biggest cities. Now notes this according to the Marshall Project over
representing nearly one third of the nation's total were missing from the FBI's national crime
data last year. And notes this data gap means that a quarter of the U.S. population was not
represented in the FBI's crime reports. Now look of course it's important to note that the missing
data is a big issue right now. The big question is whether that is still the issue. Well here's
the Marshall Project explains the discrepancy in data again after the FBI's recent report on crime
statistics. Now this is from the Marshall Project they say experts say the decline is real again the
crime dropped but that the interpretation of the numbers is likely exaggerated. And again so that's
the problem you have it's how you it's not just the numbers it's how you interpret the data and
that's where a lot of the discrepancy is. It says this zooming out to see the big picture the overall
trend in crime victimization suggests that by 2022 crime had returned to pre-pandemic norms.
This messy dispute on crime data points to a more serious problem. The national crime statistics
leaves yawning gaps and collection collecting better crime data should be a non-partisan issue.
But again it's become a partisan issue especially because of the elections. It says this the recent
White House statement about falling crime in 2024 cited the FBI's quarterly crime data which included
numbers from 11,000 police agencies around the country and trumpeted a 26 percent decrease in
homicides. Amazing. And this is what they said according to Biden Americans are safer today
than when I took office. That's again a statement from the White House. Now notice that nearly 8,000
police agencies were not included in the quarterly crime statistics report which is where the
discrepancy is. How do you have again a reflection of the actual state of the country when nearly
8,000 police agencies are not even included in the data. They note that is a relatively new
offering first issued in 2020. It was partly introduced because of the lag that was long
plaguing national crime reporting. And it's historically the agency has only released data
annually about 10 months after the end of the year. While the quarterly reports are more timely these
new ones they have they are also preliminary because crime data often changes with police
investigations and fewer agencies submit information to the quarterly report than to
the annual one. And that's one of the problems right? How do you say there's an increase in
crime when you're not sure crime was committed? That's where the big issue is. They say as a
result they sometimes contain errors according to criminologists. Further it states for example
the FBI's quarterly data recorded 46 homicides from the New York Police Department but the
department's own data showed 82 murders from the first quarter of this year. It notes that in
Dallas where the FBI's data documented 33 murders Texas's crime data dashboard showed 50 such
incidents. And so if you have like such a huge discrepancy right that the FBI says 33 murders
the actual data says 50. Or for example in New York we have 46 homicides reported from the FBI
and you have again you know the departments themselves saying there were 82. And that's the
big problem here. Which set of data do you go by? One set of data shows crime dropped the other set
of data shows crime increased. Which do you trust? Now look the issue here seems to be the way the
is collected and reported. And also on some of the missing pieces again of the overall picture.
But it does seem that some of this is kind of changing right. One of the big problems they
have is that because the shift happened in 2021 a lot of agencies had to adjust in terms of how
they collect data and how they report it. Now it does note that while only a third of the local
police departments reported the same homicide figures as the FBI. The Marshall Project actually
did look into it and they found in the overall picture that when you look at the updated local
statistics compared to these ones by the FBI it's actually become kind of close when you look at it
at like a national level. Now the Marshall Project said this of the largest cities where the Marshall
Project compared FBI statistics with the local statistics most of the numbers are spot on or
show small differences. They note this Trump is right that the National Crime Victimization Survey
is considered a more robust data source than the preliminary quarterly numbers from the FBI.
And again that's the difference on Republicans or Democrats depending which one looking at.
But it says however the most recent data on this the NCVs is nearly 18 months out of date and says
nothing about what crime rates look like right now. Now note that Trump also left out that the
same year's FBI crime data the other national gold standard showed a slight decrease in 2022
right. And so what it seems is that a lot of the problem is in these statistics from a few years
ago was that reports were measuring two different sets of data. The FBI crime data what did it go by
well that went by incidents reports to the police. The other set of data the big one the one being
cited by a lot of Republicans was from the victimization surveys on how people were experiencing
crime. And it seems these two sets of statistics right these are creating the very starkly
different views on crime right now. And the big question is well which side do you believe? Do you
believe the officially reported data is more trustworthy? Again given that some of it is not
being reported from different agencies and there's differences in data depending on the time it takes
to investigate. Or do you believe the victimization surveys on this other side of it which is again
more from the ground level and reporting that they've been victims of crime. Which do you think
is more accurate? And so the issue for America right now is that well there's different views
on the state of the country when it comes to crime. Do you believe that things are getting better?
Do you believe it's getting worse? It's really based on this difference in data. Now look in
other news there's a legal battle starting up over the use of AI technology to make election
memes. And this started with new anti-deepfake laws that were recently passed in California
by Governor Gavin Newsom last week. We'll be talking more about this we'll come back from a quick break.
Experts agree one of the best ways to protect against financial uncertainty is to diversify
your portfolio. Learn how physical gold and silver can secure your retirement funds from today's
economic challenges with a gold IRA from American Hartford Gold. You can safeguard your wealth with
no penalties or taxes when you transfer your current qualifying retirement accounts. Call now
and our precious metals specialists will send you a free information kit no cost or obligation.
American Hartford Gold a trusted industry leader with an A-plus from the Better Business Bureau
has a five-star rating from thousands of happy clients. Whether you are getting physical precious
metals in a gold IRA or delivered to your doorstep we offer only the highest quality
gold and silver. For your peace of mind we also offer a no fee buyback commitment a low price
guarantee along with free shipping and free insurance. So don't wait call the number on
your screen today and secure your financial future. Welcome back. There's a new legal battle starting
up over the use of memes when it comes to elections. Now this started with these new
anti-deepfake laws that were recently passed in California by Governor Gavin Newsom last week.
You know deepfakes are the ability to maybe mimic a person's face or voice and have it look like
they said or did something they did not do. Some people are using this to make funny videos some
people are doing it in ways that are more deceptive and this is kind of where the debate is right now.
Now Newsom signed three bills to quote combat deepfake election content and what these bills
do in a nutshell is it requires disclosure or the removal of AI generated deepfake content
related to elections during a certain time frame on social media or election advertising.
Although the law does not apply to parody or satire content there are some concerns this scope
could actually change and that often happens right. They introduce a law they find the law
is maybe not broad enough and so they expand it. That oftentimes happens and there's also concerns
that other states could actually follow suit with California and pass similar laws. Now one of these
bills that Newsom signed is AB 2839 and that it says it quote expands the scope of existing law
to prohibit materially deceptive content of elected officials candidates elections officials
and others authorizing them to file a civil action to enjoin the distribution of such material.
And again when it comes to law that can be interpreted in many different ways.
Basically what it means at least on the surface politicians and others can now sue over election
deepfakes in California if companies do not enforce these new regulations. Now look this all
started after a deepfake parody campaign video of vice president Kamala Harris made rounds on social
media. Now Elon Musk he then shared this deepfake on X and then Gavin Newsom used that and the video
as an example when he pushed for new laws and he stated quote manipulating a voice in a quote ad
like this one should be illegal and he said I'll be signing a bill in a matter of weeks to make
sure it is. Now all this focus on the deepfake ad sparked the creator of this meme it wasn't really
an ad to take some actions because you know part of his argument is this is satire it's comedy and
you can't restrict a person's free speech. That's where the nuance is right? Politico said this
The creator of a video that used artificial intelligence to imitate Kamala Harris
is suing the state of California after governor Gavin Newsom signed laws restricting the use of
digitally altered political deepfakes alleging first and 14th amendment violations. Now the
individual Christopher Coles who goes by the name Mr Reagan on X has been at the center of the debate
over the use of AI generated material in elections since he posted the video in July
calling it a parody of a Harris campaign ad and it features AI generated clips mimicking
Harris's voice and saying she's the quote ultimate diversity hire and now what's happening well
Coles is suing and he's arguing that governor Gavin Newsom is trying to make computer generated
parody illegal and asserting that political satire is a fundamental first amendment right
now the lawsuit filed Thursday in federal court seeks permanent injunctions against the laws
now again this is going to be an interesting legal battle because you know when it comes
to parody historically you're allowed to dress up like an individual and mock them
you're allowed to create cartoons and newspapers and otherwise that maybe make parodies of political
issues this is something that goes back to like the origin of newspapers something was even part
of the political debates going back to the founding of the United States and so the protection of free
speech even when it includes parody and comedy and things like this tends to protect that as well
the problem we have now is that when it comes to deepfake technology you can't really immediately
discern that it's fake or real and the problem we're having with that is that if you publish
a video online and it looks like Kamala Harris or President Donald Trump is saying something
well how do you discern whether they actually said it or not how do you discern whether it's
real or not and so the argument is well maybe we should label it maybe we should require some kind
of you know writing somewhere to make sure people don't take it out of context because we do see
that happening and that's where the debate is where does let's say parody and comedy end and
where does actual manipulation and falsifying somebody's voice or whatever come into play
because again you know the the nuance here is that if somebody tried to say that I said something I
did not say and it damaged my reputation I could sue them for libel I could sue them for it and so
if somebody for example made a video using AI of me and used my likeness used my voice and did it
in such a way that it made me say things I would never say well could I sue them well yeah you
probably could at least based on the way that normal libel laws work and defamation laws work
the question is how does that tie in with AI and the problem we have as a country in a world right
now is we're kind of dealing with the emergence of these new technologies that are bringing about
complications like this issues that weren't really issues before now that being said the
battle against memes right funny images and so on is becoming a global phenomenon this really started
after the 2016 elections now you might remember what happened back in 2016 Donald Trump was running
against Hillary Clinton and you had a lot of funny images and people taking videos and putting
people's faces on cartoons and so on and those videos because they were funny were being shared
and going viral all over the internet and those videos and funny pictures kind of became the
campaign ads for the 2016 election after Donald Trump won the election in 2016 a lot of different
bodies that looked for example at let's say misinformation and disinformation as they
framed it they started looking at how do you restrict quote-unquote false information from
circulating online and what they began doing was deplatforming a lot of individuals who they
deemed as being extremists or spreading false information or rumors or whatever else and that
included a lot of actions not just to the platform a lot of youtubers and even closed down a lot of
Facebook groups and so on that were kind of becoming the the hubs of communication and kind
of maybe an alternate political worldview they shut those down and then they started going after
the ability to create memes now those laws more focused in Europe and a lot of for example the
anti-meme laws were made in different countries Europe Canada and elsewhere but in America where
you know we have the constitution and deeper protections on free speech those haven't really
come here yet AI is now changing that and again with these legal challenges we'll have to see
well where does parody end and where does defamation begin that's going to be the argument
very likely now an argument would be that this will stop things like foreign disinformation
which actually is becoming an issue although it's become politicized as well this is the problem
things that are not foreign disinformation are being labeled as foreign disinformation and so a
lot of people have kind of the the boy who cried wolf phenomenon going on where they told us that
everything is foreign disinformation so you don't believe it anymore there actually is some
for example the FBI is now warning that the Iranian regime is trying to both assassinate
Donald Trump including warning Trump about this and they're also noting that Iran is trying to
alter the outcome of the elections the Trump campaign itself noted this when they were
breached recently by Iranian hackers and information on their campaign was even leaked to US media
we know for example the Chinese Communist Party is starting up domestic news outlets
and even for example using its spies to collect data and feeding that to other news outlets
disinformation is taking place the problem is because it's become politicized people don't
know what's true and what's not but the issue you have with anti-deepfake laws again is where do you
where do you begin restricting freedom of speech in order to fight back against actual existing
threats and you know social media is kind of becoming the big focus of this because while
Americans can have a platform of free speech other countries including spies and other regimes can
use that open platform in order to undermine our country this is the very delicate balance they're
facing right now how do you approach that right that's the challenge now in other news American
troops are now heading back to the Middle East this is raising concerns the United States could
get pulled into yet again another war as Israel is expanding its attacks against Hezbollah I'll
be talking about this more only on EpicTV.com so if you're watching on YouTube, Facebook,
Xrumble there's a link in the description below click on that you'll get access to the rest of
this episode as well as our whole library of shows and our hard-hitting documentaries and
issues that matter like the Chinese Communist Party's 100-year plan to defeat the United States
the CCP is one of the biggest threats to America they're using things like propaganda video games
entertainment movies culture to subvert and influence the next generation if you want to
find out more about the CCP's plotting against America watch my documentary the final war the
100-year plot to defeat America you can find the link to that in the description below and I'll
show you all the trailer before we go exclusively to EpicTV.com for the rest of this episode I'll
see you there. The greatest threat facing the United States is the CCP. The Epoch Times investigation
team had studied the CCP for years but what we uncovered was yielding evidence beyond our
imagination. With Chairman Mao, with the Prime Minister, our talks have been characterized by
the Clinton administration said oh don't worry about it this will be a poison pill for China.
China's strategic goal is to make sure that the U.S. has four enemies and one of them must be
a terrorist group. We are giving of our life's blood so that the Chinese Communist Party can
survive and thrive.